Printable version of thread

Posted by: Calum Nov 10 2019, 06:19 PM

Welcome to the Icarus Falls rate! We haven't had a rate in the 1D forum for a while, and what better way to pick back up than to go with the best solo album by a 1D member? (Bal, back me up before everyone comes charging xx) Let's find out your favourites from Zayn's whopping 27-track sophomore album!

Like other rates, you may give one 11 to your favourite song, but no -1s allowed in this rate - not that you'd need it anyway. If you decide to include a -1 in your rate, it'll be counted as a 0 when the results are calculated! Otherwise, you can score every song between 0 and 10, and half marks are allowed too!

Please listen to ALL SONGS (I've included a Spotify embed to the album below), so no excuses for leaving anything blank.

I'll leave this open for roughly a couple of weeks to allow any rates besides mine and Bal's to trickle in - so we'll go with a closing date of Sunday 24th November at 23:59!

xx.x Let Me
xx.x Natural
xx.x Back to Life
xx.x Common
xx.x Imprint
xx.x Stand Still
xx.x Tonight
xx.x Flight of the Stars
xx.x If I Got You
xx.x Talk to Me
xx.x There You Are
xx.x I Don't Mind
xx.x Icarus Interlude
xx.x Good Guy
xx.x You Wish You Knew
xx.x Sour Diesel
xx.x Satisfaction
xx.x Scripted
xx.x Entertainer
xx.x All That
xx.x Good Years
xx.x Fresh Air
xx.x Rainberry
xx.x Insomnia
xx.x No Candle No Light (feat. Nicki Minaj)
xx.x Fingers
xx.x Too Much (feat. Timbaland)

Posted by: Calum Nov 10 2019, 06:26 PM

Posted by: HauntedHaus Nov 10 2019, 08:50 PM

SO here for this. Such a good album and while long, it's a brilliant listen. He's my favourite member musically in terms of their solo material and this contains some of his best *.* We have no choice but to stan.

Hopefully the rate means a few others give the album a chance!

Posted by: ...ready for it Nov 15 2019, 06:33 AM

11 Let Me
09 Natural
09 Back to Life
08 Common
07 Imprint
07 Stand Still
09 Tonight
08 Flight of the Stars
08 If I Got You
09 Talk to Me
08 There You Are
09 I Don't Mind
07 Icarus Interlude
07 Good Guy
09 You Wish You Knew
10 Sour Diesel
07 Satisfaction
08 Scripted
07 Entertainer
07 All That
07 Good Years
06 Fresh Air
10 Rainberry
08 Insomnia
08 No Candle No Light (feat. Nicki Minaj)
08 Fingers
07 Too Much (feat. Timbaland)

Posted by: George.keh Nov 15 2019, 03:51 PM

10 Let Me
07 Natural
08 Back to Life
07 Common
08 Imprint
08 Stand Still
06 Tonight
06 Flight of the Stars
06 If I Got You
05 Talk to Me
10 There You Are
09 I Don't Mind
05 Icarus Interlude
05 Good Guy
05 You Wish You Knew
10 Sour Diesel
07 Satisfaction
08 Scripted
08 Entertainer
06 All That
10 Good Years
06 Fresh Air
10 Rainberry
08 Insomnia
10 No Candle No Light (feat. Nicki Minaj)
11 Fingers -this was done dirty
07 Too Much (feat. Timbaland)

Posted by: George.keh Nov 15 2019, 03:53 PM

10 Let Me
07 Natural
08 Back to Life
07 Common
08 Imprint
08 Stand Still
06 Tonight
06 Flight of the Stars
06 If I Got You
05 Talk to Me
10 There You Are
09 I Don't Mind
05 Icarus Interlude
05 Good Guy
05 You Wish You Knew
10 Sour Diesel
07 Satisfaction
08 Scripted
08 Entertainer
06 All That
10 Good Years
06 Fresh Air
10 Rainberry
08 Insomnia
10 No Candle No Light (feat. Nicki Minaj)
11 Fingers -this was done dirty
07 Too Much (feat. Timbaland)

Posted by: Calum Dec 3 2019, 08:07 PM

Will leave this open for another week or so, Bal get your rate in!!

Posted by: HauntedHaus Dec 3 2019, 08:18 PM

Omg, I got halfway through a listen last week and then stopped and haven't returned. I have most of my scores done just need to do last few and then submit!

Posted by: HauntedHaus Dec 4 2019, 07:07 PM

10.0 Let Me
07.0 Natural
10.0 Back to Life
08.0 Common
05.0 Imprint
05.5 Stand Still
06.0 Tonight
05.5 Flight of the Stars
06.0 If I Got You
08.0 Talk to Me
11.0 There You Are
07.0 I Don't Mind
03.0 Icarus Interlude
04.0 Good Guy
06.5 You Wish You Knew
06.0 Sour Diesel
10.0 Satisfaction
06.5 Scripted
09.0 Entertainer
08.0 All That
08.5 Good Years
06.0 Fresh Air
07.0 Rainberry
06.0 Insomnia
10.0 No Candle No Light (feat. Nicki Minaj)
08.5 Fingers
07.5 Too Much (feat. Timbaland)

Posted by: Calum Dec 4 2019, 07:23 PM

King of TASTE *.*

Posted by: HauntedHaus Dec 4 2019, 07:25 PM

This is easily my favourite 1D related album! I have been a little harsh on some of the moments that don't wow me as much but there is so much here that I absolutely love. It's a brilliant album, I just wish it was a bit shorter with some of the filler removed.

Posted by: Calum Dec 4 2019, 07:45 PM

10.0 Let Me
07.5 Natural
10.0 Back to Life
08.0 Common
07.0 Imprint
04.5 Stand Still
08.5 Tonight
06.0 Flight of the Stars
09.0 If I Got You
05.5 Talk to Me
11.0 There You Are
10.0 I Don’t Mind
03.0 Icarus Interlude
04.0 Good Guy
06.5 You Wish You Knew
07.5 Sour Diesel
10.0 Satisfaction
09.0 Scripted
08.5 Entertainer
10.0 All That
10.0 Good Years
05.5 Fresh Air
07.5 Rainberry
07.0 Insomnia
09.0 No Candle No Light (feat. Nicki Minaj)
08.0 Fingers
07.5 Too Much (feat. Timbaland)

Honestly echo everything Bal says - this is by far and away the best 1D-related album There is a bit of filler, but the highs really outweigh those. An absolute gem <3