Printable version of thread

Posted by: UltraReputation 10th March 2019, 11:12 PM

The last rate for Rep was at the end of 2017 so let's see how your opinions have changed since! <3

Usual rules apply:
- Rate every song from 1-10, I won't be accepting partial rates as it's an album rate.
- You may use ONE optional 11 and ONE optinal -1, no limits on other scores.
- I'll set the deadline as the 29th, just under three weeks should be more than long enough!
- Edits are fine as long as you say because I'll probably add up in batches as I go along so obviously if I put it in and if you edit without saying I'm not gonna know lmao

xx ...Ready For It?
xx End Game
xx I Did Something Bad
xx Don't Blame Me
xx Delicate
xx Look What You Made Me Do
xx So It Goes
xx Gorgeous
xx Getaway Car
xx King Of My Heart
xx Dancing With Our Hands Tied
xx Dress
xx This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
xx Call It What You Want
xx New Year's Day

Posted by: UltraReputation 10th March 2019, 11:14 PM

These were the results last time:
1) Ready For It 9.18
2) Delicate 8.83
3) Call It What You Want 8.48
4) Look What You Made Me Do 8.45
5) Gorgeous 8.35
6) Getaway Car 8.28
7) I Did Something Bad 8.23
8) End Game 8.18
9) Don't Blame Me 8.13
10) Dancing With Our Hands Tied 7.70
11) King Of My Heart 7.28
12) Dress 7.28
13) New Year's Day 6.73
14) So It Goes... 6.53
15) This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things 6.48

Yep I see a lot of change happening from last time DBM better be WAY higher than 9th this time wtaf how did that even happen

Posted by: ...ready for it 10th March 2019, 11:15 PM

10 ...Ready For It?
09 End Game
09 I Did Something Bad
09 Don't Blame Me
10 Delicate
10 Look What You Made Me Do
11 So It Goes
09 Gorgeous
08 Getaway Car
08 King Of My Heart
09 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
09 Dress
09 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
08 Call It What You Want
08 New Year's Day

Posted by: SamJudd 11th March 2019, 12:20 AM

Posted by: Jonjo 16th March 2019, 11:40 AM

09.0 ...Ready For It?
08.0 End Game
08.5 I Did Something Bad
07.5 Don't Blame Me
10.0 Delicate
06.0 Look What You Made Me Do
06.5 So It Goes
06.0 Gorgeous
11.0 Getaway Car
09.0 King Of My Heart
08.5 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
08.0 Dress
10.0 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
07.5 Call It What You Want
07.5 New Year's Day

Posted by: Calum 17th March 2019, 05:05 PM

09.0 ...Ready For It?
06.5 End Game
09.0 I Did Something Bad
10.0 Don't Blame Me
07.0 Delicate
08.5 Look What You Made Me Do
07.0 So It Goes...
08.0 Gorgeous
11.0 Getaway Car
09.5 King of My Heart
08.0 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
09.0 Dress
10.0 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
06.0 Call It What You Want
05.0 New Year's Day

This album has been such a revelation for me since deciding to watch the tour when it got put on Netflix! I didn't listen much / wasn't that keen when it was first released, but there's so much to love on it! Getaway Car is by far and away the best thing on the album, but (alongside 1989) I actually enjoy pretty much everything and not just the singles as well as one or two more.

Posted by: blacksquare 17th March 2019, 07:13 PM

06 ...Ready For It?
04 End Game
03 I Did Something Bad
06 Don't Blame Me
09 Delicate
06 Look What You Made Me Do
05 So It Goes
03 Gorgeous
08 Getaway Car
07 King Of My Heart
07 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
08 Dress
-1 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
10 Call It What You Want
05 New Year's Day

Posted by: Doug 18th March 2019, 12:11 AM

11 // ...Ready For It?
09 // End Game
10 // I Did Something Bad
09 // Don't Blame Me
10 // Delicate
10 // Look What You Made Me Do
08 // So It Goes
06 // Gorgeous
06 // Getaway Car
06 // King Of My Heart
07 // Dancing With Our Hands Tied
05 // Dress
09 // This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
09 // Call It What You Want
08 // New Year's Day

Posted by: Liаm 19th March 2019, 08:27 PM

11 ...Ready For It?
09 End Game
10 I Did Something Bad
10 Don't Blame Me
04 Delicate
10 Look What You Made Me Do
07 So It Goes
09 Gorgeous
08.5 Getaway Car
07 King Of My Heart
08 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
06.5 Dress
09 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
09.5 Call It What You Want
09 New Year's Day

Posted by: LMLou 19th March 2019, 11:01 PM

09.0...Ready For It?
09.5 End Game
10.0 I Did Something Bad
11.0 Don't Blame Me
8.5 Delicate
9.0 Look What You Made Me Do
08.5 So It Goes
04.5 Gorgeous
07.5 Getaway Car
09.5 King Of My Heart
07.5 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
06.5 Dress
10.0 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
03.0 Call It What You Want
03.5 New Year's Day

I think this has become my fave Taylor album over time, DBM is definitely my favourite ever song of hers

Posted by: John-James 21st March 2019, 10:09 AM

I'll post my rates at some point, I'm just being lazy atm

Posted by: JosephAvery 25th March 2019, 09:37 PM

08.5 ...Ready For It?
09.0 End Game
09.0 I Did Something Bad
10.0 Don't Blame Me
10.0 Delicate
09.5 Look What You Made Me Do
07.0 So It Goes
07.5 Gorgeous
10.0 Getaway Car
07.5 King Of My Heart
08.0 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
08.5 Dress
11.0 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
10.0 Call It What You Want
09.0 New Year's Day

Posted by: HausofTove 25th March 2019, 09:53 PM

09 ...Ready For It?
08 End Game
06 I Did Something Bad
08 Don't Blame Me
11 Delicate
08 Look What You Made Me Do
05 So It Goes
07 Gorgeous
08 Getaway Car
07 King Of My Heart
06 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
10 Dress
06 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
09 Call It What You Want
07 New Year's Day

Posted by: Dexton 26th March 2019, 01:59 AM

11.0 ..Ready For It?
08.0 End Game
09.0 I Did Something Bad
10.0 Don't Blame Me
9.5 Delicate
9.0 Look What You Made Me Do
07.5 So It Goes
07.5 Gorgeous
07.5 Getaway Car
07.0 King Of My Heart
06.0 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
06.5 Dress
06.5 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
07.0 Call It What You Want
05.5 New Year's Day

Posted by: Bangtan Cody 26th March 2019, 02:56 AM

10.0 ...Ready For It?
10.0 End Game
11.0 I Did Something Bad
09.5 Don't Blame Me
09.0 Delicate
10.0 Look What You Made Me Do
06.0 So It Goes
07.0 Gorgeous
09.5 Getaway Car
09.0 King Of My Heart
10.0 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
08.0 Dress
05.5 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
08.0 Call It What You Want
08.0 New Year's Day

One year on and most of my feelings for the songs have not changed. I nearly dropped to the floor the first time she performed I Did Something Bad bc I thought it would become the next single. It didn’t and I’m still sad about that.

TIWWCHNT still encapsulates everything I hate about Taylor but I couldn’t dock it down to less than what I gave because it fits the album’s Progression nicely. It’s Taylor going dark and saying “f*ck you all, you’re all gonna pay for turning me into a monster” then by the second half of the album she comes back to her senses. Somewhere in the middle, something sets her off, and she has one last temper tantrum. The last two songs are her finally cooling down and realizing that she’s relinquished all that anger and resentment from her body. The job was finished. It was time for the next chapter of her story. Stuff like that is why I respect Taylor as an artist.

Posted by: UltraReputation 2nd April 2019, 11:12 PM

You have a week longer as I'm having a lot of coursework due in this week so I don't have time to devote to this rn. (And for anyone interested in the pop/movie forums, the pop awards & buzzjack movie awards will finally happen next weekend/the week after!

Posted by: UltraReputation 13th April 2019, 10:55 PM

10 ...Ready For It?
10 End Game
09.5 I Did Something Bad
10 Don't Blame Me
10 Delicate
11 Look What You Made Me Do
06 So It Goes
09 Gorgeous
10 Getaway Car
09.5 King Of My Heart
08.5 Dancing With Our Hands Tied
06 Dress
08.5 This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things
10 Call It What You Want
08.5 New Year's Day

Posted by: Doug 16th April 2019, 09:10 PM

Edited my scores, can’t believe I ever gave I Did Something Bad less than a 10 before! I must have been feeling harsh lol.

Posted by: UltraReputation 20th April 2019, 09:50 PM

Last chance, results starting tomorrow x