Tweedy accuses All Saints of copying

BuzzJack - Entertainment Discussion _ Artist Forums _ View All Artists _ Girls Aloud

Latest Artist News

Go To Work with Nadine

Sarah wins Celebrity Big Brother!

Listen to Sarah's debut single Threads!

4 Pages

« < 2 3 4

Tweedy accuses All Saints of copying, She thinks All Saints new single is a ripoff of GA...

Display modes

Track this thread - Email this thread - Print this thread - Download this thread - Subscribe to this forum

Tim View member profile	13th October 2006, 04:08 PM Post #61
BuzzJack Platinum Member Joined: 7 March 2006 Posts: 5,504 User: 61	QUOTE(Davidyay @ Oct 12 2006, 10:46 PM) I named bands because I dont think and never said it it sounds like any other song - you said that. A sound is a sound, doesn't have to be narrowed down to a song if it was then it'd be saying "this is a rip of that song". Which is exactly what "looking at what works at the minute and going with it" means. As for Cheryl being humble, she comes across that way in the documentry and interviews. She doesn't owe All Saints anything & thats what I like about any band is if they speak their minds. She didn't come out and say "All Saints are c*p, they're stupid girls who know fcking nothing" that would be not worth defending. If the All Saints are going for what's popular explain how. Sound is vague and the fact that you could only name other girl bands did not help your case. You can't name another other popular song this year that 'Rock Steady' is similar to (which was my challenge, I never claimed that you said it was ripping off another song directly). If it's going for what's popular now, surely that would be easy. You can't explain what is it about the song which is popular - it's a pop song sung by girls without a live band - that's not a sound and if it is it was not invented by Girls Aloud.


Mushymanrob View member profile	13th October 2006, 04:18 PM Post #62
im all clares! Joined: 7 March 2006 Posts: 16,421 User: 5	....... but the new all saints track is very uninspiring, its not a patch on their earlier material and it does sound very much like any other girlband..... that isnt a good thing.


Davidyay View member profile	13th October 2006, 06:27 PM Post #63
BuzzJack Enthusiast Joined: 13 March 2006 Posts: 783 User: 208	QUOTE(mushymanrob @ Oct 13 2006, 05:36 PM) ....... but the new all saints track is very uninspiring, its not a patch on their earlier material and it does sound very much like any other girlband..... that isnt a good thing. Exactly what I'm saying. Tim, you can go round the houses with words all you like. You're trying to make me say Rock Steady sounds like another song, it's not my opinion - I dont think that. Why should I say it is! I thought I'd at least try and answer your question. I dont even care if All Saints sound like another band, they obviously need to sell and appeal...but they dont sound like their earlier material, so as it stands there are people that do think it sounds like any other girlband which is what it is. All Saints are older and been in the business longer, surely they would have been able to come up with a better put down than that! It just makes them sound like the silly girls'.


Jessie Where View member profile	13th October 2006, 06:42 PM Post #64
Break the tension Joined: 7 March 2006 Posts: 89,024 User: 51	I personally LOVE the new All Saints track, but I disagree with Cheryl when she says it rips off rom the Girls Aloud sound, if anything 'Rock Steady' has a more Sugababes-esque vibe to it. I for one am very impressed with the All Saints comeback single, and it's better than I could have possibly imagined it would be.


Tim View member profile	14th October 2006, 12:23 AM Post #65
BuzzJack Platinum Member Joined: 7 March 2006 Posts: 5,504 User: 61	QUOTE(Aly @ Oct 13 2006, 08:00 PM) I for one am very impressed with the All Saints comeback single, and it's better than I could have possibly imagined it would be. Well I agree with that.


Tim View member profile	14th October 2006, 12:25 AM Post #66
BuzzJack Platinum Member Joined: 7 March 2006 Posts: 5,504 User: 61	QUOTE(Davidyay @ Oct 13 2006, 07:45 PM) Exactly what I'm saying. Tim, you can go round the houses with words all you like. You're trying to make me say Rock Steady sounds like another song, it's not my opinion - I dont think that. Why should I say it is! I thought I'd at least try and answer your question. I dont even care if All Saints sound like another band, they obviously need to sell and appeal...but they dont sound like their earlier material, so as it stands there are people that do think it sounds like any other girlband which is what it is. All Saints are older and been in the business longer, surely they would have been able to come up with a better put down than that! It just makes them sound like the silly girls'. Fine. Agree to disagree then. On an internet forum 'words' are really all you have to work with. This post has been edited by Tim: 14th October 2006, 12:28 AM