Printable version of thread

Posted by: pippa 9th October 2019, 09:07 PM

It is the battle of cd1 and cd2 from Step Back in Time, The Definitive Collection.

Please highlight the song from each list that you prefer.
At the end, tally up totals you picked from each cd.

As the songs were uneven i had to add in a song to keep it level on both cds.


Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

CD1 Total:
CD 2Total:

Posted by: pippa 9th October 2019, 09:10 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

CD1 Total:11
CD 2Total: 11

Posted by: Medellíam 9th October 2019, 09:34 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

CD1 Total: 19
CD2 Total: 3

Oops. That makes it seem like I'm not a fan of her PWL stuff but that's not the case at all. A lot of my top favourite PWL songs were up against my top favourite Parlophone songs. 'Spinning' vs. 'Devil' was certainly very close.

Posted by: Hide&Seek 9th October 2019, 09:37 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

CD1 Total: 6
CD 2Total: 16

Posted by: Spiceboy 9th October 2019, 09:52 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head (cd1)
Better The Devil You Know (cd2)
Love at First Sight (cd1)
Wouldn't Change a Thing (cd2)
Shocked (cd2)
Slow (cd1)
All the Lovers (cd1)
I Believe in You (cd1)
The Loco Motion (cd2)
On a Night like This (cd1)
Never Too Late (cd2)
Please Stay (cd1)
2 Hearts (cd1)
Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai (cd2)
Red Blooded Woman (cd1)
What Do I Have To Do (cd2)
Confide In Me (cd2)
Put Yourself in my Place (cd2)
Get Outta My Way (cd1)
Where The Wild Roses Grow (cd2)
Kids (with Robbie Williams) (cd1)
Into The Blue (cd2)

cd1 - 11
cd2 - 11

It's a draw!

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 9th October 2019, 10:48 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

Its a draw for me, 11 on each although in general i prefer cd 2 but it doesnt show that way here.

Posted by: SamJudd 10th October 2019, 12:44 AM

Posted by: SmileyKylie 10th October 2019, 07:10 AM

Need to do this later with more time!

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 10th October 2019, 11:58 AM

Pitting the songs together makes it hard, I love both the one and what do i have to do but when pitted together what do I have to do easily wins. Great way to think about the songs though.

Posted by: vibe 10th October 2019, 01:31 PM

Step Back in Time
Spinning Around
Love at First Sight
Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes
Slow
All the Lovers
I Believe in You
In My Arms
On a Night like This
Never Too Late
Please Stay
Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit)
Red Blooded Woman
What Do I Have To Do
Confide In Me
Put Yourself in my Place
Chocolate
Timebomb
Kids (with Robbie Williams)
Into The Blue

Posted by: Red Blooded Man 10th October 2019, 02:24 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time (A tough choice)
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldn't Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked (A tough choice)
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do (A very tough one)
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue (Another tough one)

Posted by: pippa 10th October 2019, 02:27 PM

That is a 13 for cd1 and 9 for cd2 Red Blooded Woman based on your highlighted choices.

Posted by: Red Blooded Man 10th October 2019, 02:29 PM

Sorry, forgot to count the total !

Posted by: pippa 10th October 2019, 02:54 PM

QUOTE(Red Blooded Man @ Oct 10 2019, 03:29 PM)

Posted by: Michael Andrew 10th October 2019, 09:27 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

CD 1: 15
CD 2: 7

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 11th October 2019, 02:49 AM

Happy to see others apart from myself picking what do I have to do over the one, the one is great but what do I have to do is Brill for me.

Posted by: davidas 11th October 2019, 11:12 AM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 11th October 2019, 11:18 AM

11 on each is happening for a few which is good as its showing there is lots for both cds

Posted by: pippa 11th October 2019, 12:14 PM

Daviddas is another
Cd1 11 and Cd2 11 just for totals.

Posted by: dandy* 11th October 2019, 02:27 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

Posted by: pippa 11th October 2019, 03:07 PM

Dandy that results in
Cd 1 16 and Cd2 6

Posted by: Euphorique 11th October 2019, 04:54 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldnt Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquai
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

Posted by: Stuart25 11th October 2019, 06:50 PM

Can't Get You out of My Head vs Step Back in Time
Spinning Around vs Better The Devil You Know
Love at First Sight vs Hand On Your Heart
Dancing vs Wouldn't Change a Thing
In Your Eyes vs Shocked
Slow vs Especially For You
All the Lovers vs I Should Be So Lucky
I Believe in You vs Celebration
In My Arms vs The Loco Motion
On a Night like This vs Give Me Just A Little More Time
Your Disco Needs You vs Never Too Late
Please Stay vs Got To Be Certain
2 Hearts vs Tears on my Pillow
Breathe (Radio Edit) vs Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquoi
Red Blooded Woman vs What Kind of Fool (heard all that before)
The One vs What Do I Have To Do
Come into My World vs Confide In Me
Wow vs Put Yourself in my Place
Get Outta My Way vs Chocolate
Timebomb vs Where The Wild Roses Grow
Kids (with Robbie Williams) vs New York City
Stop Me from Falling vs Into The Blue

CD 1 - 9
CD 2 - 13

Posted by: pippa 11th October 2019, 06:50 PM

Nice to see a cd2 winning a round

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 12th October 2019, 03:26 AM

I ended up a draw despite thinking I enjoy cd 2 more.

Posted by: dandy* 12th October 2019, 01:48 PM

QUOTE(pippa @ Oct 11 2019, 04:07 PM)

Posted by: pippa 12th October 2019, 01:57 PM

Since the release of SBIT i have enjoyed the older material much more.

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 12th October 2019, 03:39 PM

I have CD 2 in far more since I bought it but CD 1 is still great aswell shame cds arent longer as in 50 songs all on 1 cd.

Posted by: pippa 13th October 2019, 11:13 AM

Through the years, the actual cds never managed to increase in songs.
I would have thought it would also be cheaper to produce an album that would contain 1 long cd.
Having SBIT all on the one cd would be wonderful.

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 13th October 2019, 02:07 PM

The one huge long CD would be great plus I'd love it when doing up my own mixed cds.

Posted by: pippa 14th October 2019, 07:29 PM

With cds on the way out, extended cds wont happen unless they make a big comeback in the years ahead.

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 15th October 2019, 11:42 PM

If it hasnt happened by now unfortunately it never will