Printable version of thread

Posted by: Dannyboy 28th August 2019, 06:09 PM

Hey everyone, over the last few months you have all been voting for your least favourite song, video and single cover and for each round points were allocated. Its now time to see just how you all voted and to find out what song is the ultimate package.

The aim is to post a minimum of 1 song per day but will post more depending on interactions from forum members.

Lets get the discussions going, there will be A LOT of surprises, lets see what you think about where your favourites appear, are songs too high or too low based on what you expected ? how did the biggest sellers do ? how did the fan favourites do ?

Time to find out

Number 71 - Gambler - 70 Points





Cover - 40 out of a possible 900
Video - 20 out of a possible 900
Song - 10 out of a possible 900


What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: dandy* 28th August 2019, 06:11 PM

We finally made it!

That’s a fair enough last placed track for me.

Posted by: Dannyboy 28th August 2019, 06:19 PM

Tell me about it, its felt like years haha

Posted by: Medellíam 28th August 2019, 07:56 PM

Aw I really like Gambler. Presumably it was at a major disadvantage by being in such a strong selection of songs, videos and covers as it doesn't deserve to place behind certain others.

Posted by: HausofF 28th August 2019, 09:18 PM

Excited to see how this pans out. The Ray of Light era has the strongest visuals and artwork for me, so hopefully they shine here.

Posted by: Dannyboy 31st August 2019, 06:52 PM

Number 70 - American Pie - 90 Points





Cover - 50 out of a possible 900
Video - 20 out of a possible 900
Song - 20 out of a possible 900


What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: dandy* 1st September 2019, 09:36 AM

Ooooops! Although again it would have been in a ridiculously strong group

Posted by: HausofF 1st September 2019, 02:23 PM

Ummm HOW is that 2nd from last

Posted by: Dannyboy 1st September 2019, 07:29 PM

Number 69 - Love don't live here anymore - 270 Points



Song - 144 out of a possible 900
Cover - 63 out of a possible 900
Video - 63 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 1st September 2019, 09:03 PM

Nice enough, but not a favourite of mine.

Posted by: dandy* 1st September 2019, 09:06 PM

I'd possibly even opt for 'too high'

Posted by: Dannyboy 4th September 2019, 07:46 PM

Number 68 - Bitch i'm Madonna - 304 Points



Video - 224 out of a possible 900
Song - 40 out of a possible 900
Cover - 40 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 4th September 2019, 08:09 PM

Delete it.

Posted by: Dannyboy 4th September 2019, 08:16 PM

Why ?

Posted by: HausofF 4th September 2019, 08:17 PM

I don't mean your post! I mean the song because I dislike it

Posted by: Dannyboy 4th September 2019, 08:22 PM

Oh right

Posted by: dandy* 4th September 2019, 10:41 PM

Again, TOO HIGH.

Posted by: Dannyboy 6th September 2019, 04:22 PM

Number 16 - MDNA (Album) - 488 Points



Cover - 326 out of a possible 1,300
Album - 131 out of a possible 1,300
Song Selection - 31 out of a possible 1,300

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 6th September 2019, 07:09 PM

Expected that to be last. The single selections in particular let it down ~

Posted by: Dannyboy 9th September 2019, 08:00 PM

Number 67 - Everybody - 337 Points



Cover - 237 out of a possible 900
Song - 55 out of a possible 900
Video - 45 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: dandy* 9th September 2019, 08:19 PM

MDNA deserved last place.

Everybody is no real loss either. I used to quite like it but it does sound really dated now.

Posted by: HausofF 9th September 2019, 08:32 PM

Everybody is a song I rarely go back to, so not fussed about it dropping out so lowly.

Posted by: Dannyboy 10th September 2019, 07:51 PM

Number 66 - Turn up the radio - 405 Points



Cover - 233 out of a possible 900
Song - 122 out of a possible 900
Video - 60 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 10th September 2019, 08:17 PM

The song is cute enough but she can do so much better. No idea why it was a single over some of the better choices on the album

Posted by: Medellíam 10th September 2019, 08:51 PM

I randomly really got into 'Everybody' last year and have loved it ever since. I love the bassline and the little synth lines and the simple hooks - the dub version really highlights the production for me. The Stuart Price mix from 2005 is fab too.

'Turn Up the Radio' being a single screamed "we can't be bothered with the era, let's just go for the most inoffensive song and what will be, will be".

Posted by: Dannyboy 13th September 2019, 05:31 PM

Number 65 - Another suitcase in another hall - 409 Points



Cover - 230 out of a possible 900
Video - 129 out of a possible 900
Song - 50 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 14th September 2019, 05:57 PM

Number 64 - This used to be my playground - 413 Points



Video - 225 out of a possible 900
Cover - 128 out of a possible 900
Song - 60 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 15th September 2019, 02:57 PM

Number 15 - Who's that girl (Album) - 644 Points



Song Selection - 427 out of a possible 1,300
Cover - 148 out of a possible 1,300
Album - 69 out of a possible 1,300

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 15th September 2019, 04:04 PM

The cover for that is actually growing on me the more I look at it. It's represents such a child-like innocence on the cusp of adulthood.

Posted by: Dannyboy 18th September 2019, 08:53 PM

Number 63 - Love Profusion - 419 Points



Song - 300 out of a possible 900
Video - 119 out of a possible 900
Cover - 0 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 19th September 2019, 07:54 PM

Number 62 - Fever - 419 Points



Cover - 222 out of a possible 900
Video - 128 out of a possible 900
Song - 105 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 20th September 2019, 07:20 PM

Fever above Love Profusion is.. a choice lmao.

Posted by: Dannyboy 20th September 2019, 07:58 PM

Number 61 - Who's that girl - 419 Points



Song - 162 out of a possible 900
Cover - 159 out of a possible 900
Video - 146 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 22nd September 2019, 03:01 PM

Number 60 - Beautiful Stranger - 503 Points



Song - 217 out of a possible 900
Video - 144 out of a possible 900
Cover - 142 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HausofF 22nd September 2019, 03:45 PM

Very low for such an iconic single and video package!

Posted by: dandy* 24th September 2019, 04:59 PM

Very low indeed! Surprised the video did so poorly

Posted by: vibe 24th September 2019, 05:37 PM

It was prob up against the music and rol videos .

Posted by: Dannyboy 24th September 2019, 06:39 PM

Or that it’s just a bad video 😂 I voted it out every round on all categories

Posted by: dandy* 24th September 2019, 07:09 PM

It's not a bad video though? It's perfect for the film!

Posted by: vibe 24th September 2019, 07:27 PM

This rates never ever made sense . I appreciate a lot of work goes into them tho.

Posted by: Dannyboy 25th September 2019, 05:36 AM

Don’t blame the rate, blame the lack of voters or the people like me not liking any aspect of this song/video/cover.

Posted by: vibe 25th September 2019, 06:22 AM

I’m so picky over little things , just a perfectionist. The way the votes in the initial round make the results invalid for me .

Posted by: Dannyboy 25th September 2019, 11:44 AM

Then why bother looking at the results if they are irrelevant and invalid to you

Posted by: vibe 25th September 2019, 12:47 PM

I thought you needed the reply's. I mean all this work your doing.

Posted by: Dannyboy 25th September 2019, 05:40 PM

I don’t “need” replies, certainly don’t “need” replies that dismiss what people vote or didn’t vote for

Posted by: Dannyboy 25th September 2019, 06:16 PM

Number 14 - Evita (Album) - 688 Points



Song Selection - 232 out of a possible 1,300
Album - 229 out of a possible 1,300
Cover - 227 out of a possible 1,300

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: vibe 25th September 2019, 07:15 PM

The only thing I’m dismissing is the way you organised it .

Posted by: Dannyboy 25th September 2019, 07:31 PM

So maybe say this months ago when it started, not now after its all finished.

And how else could it have been done ? each song was up against another song that was released at a similar time to make it fair, it's hardly hard to compare Hung Ups video for example to the video of Holiday etc.

Anyway, its irrelevant after the fact, maybe next time speak up instead of waiting months to open your mouth about how bad someone did something after they put a lot of effort into something. Don't like it ? don't bother commenting

Posted by: Dannyboy 28th September 2019, 11:14 AM

Number 59 - Me against the music - 521 Points



Video - 314 out of a possible 900
Cover - 144 out of a possible 900
Song - 63 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 29th September 2019, 04:56 PM

Number 58 - Miles Away - 525 Points



Song - 273 out of a possible 900
Video - 126 out of a possible 900
Cover - 126 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 16th November 2019, 06:18 PM

Number 57 - Burning Up - 560 Points



Cover - 270 out of a possible 900
Video - 149 out of a possible 900
Song - 141 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss




Number 56 - Holiday - 701 Points



Song - 425 out of a possible 900
Video - 212 out of a possible 900
Cover - 64 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 18th November 2019, 05:41 PM

Number 13 - I'm Breathless (Album) - 712 Points



Song Selection - 309 out of a possible 1,300
Album - 248 out of a possible 1,300
Cover - 155 out of a possible 1,300

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: dandy* 18th November 2019, 05:47 PM

I have a soft spot for I’m Breathless but it was always going to finish low down. It’s fun!

What do you think about it Danny?

Posted by: Dannyboy 18th November 2019, 05:49 PM

I'll be honest, other than the singles I have never really listened to it, I did really enjoy the film though, not watched it in years so may be worth another watch.

Posted by: dandy* 18th November 2019, 05:58 PM

You have to approach it like a stage musical soundtrack I think. It’s silly but quite unique amongst her back catalogue.

Posted by: Dannyboy 23rd November 2019, 04:43 PM

Number 55 - Dress you up - 770 Points



Video - 345 out of a possible 900
Song - 267 out of a possible 900
Cover - 158 out of a possible 900


Number 54 - You must love me - 772 Points



Cover - 434 out of a possible 900
Video - 181 out of a possible 900
Song - 157 out of a possible 900


Number 53 - What it feels like for a girl - 792 Points



Cover - 199 out of a possible 900
Video - 441 out of a possible 900
Song - 152 out of a possible 900


Number 52 - Don't cry for me Argentina - 898 Points



Cover - 350 out of a possible 900
Video - 325 out of a possible 900
Song - 223 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HauntedHaus 25th November 2019, 04:37 PM

WIFLFAG my favourite of that latest bunch.

And Holiday has been done so dirty here

Posted by: Dannyboy 29th November 2019, 09:46 PM

Number 12 - Hard Candy (Album) - 974 Points



Song Selection - 530 out of a possible 1,300
Album - 375 out of a possible 1,300
Cover - 69 out of a possible 1,300

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 2nd December 2019, 06:28 PM

Number 51 - Dear Jessie - 916 Points



Cover - 653 out of a possible 900
Song - 213 out of a possible 900
Video - 50 out of a possible 900

Number 50 - Jump - 922 Points



Song - 482 out of a possible 900
Video - 242 out of a possible 900
Cover - 198 out of a possible 900

Number 49 - You'll See - 949 Points



Video - 456 out of a possible 900
Song - 336 out of a possible 900
Cover - 157 out of a possible 900

Number 48 Cherish - 1,010 Points



Video - 431 out of a possible 900
Cover - 320 out of a possible 900
Song - 259 out of a possible 900

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: HauntedHaus 2nd December 2019, 06:39 PM

Jump is W A Y too low but it was up against tough competition so understandable ~

Posted by: Dannyboy 8th December 2019, 05:08 PM

Number 11 - Rebel Heart (Album) - 1,154 Points



Cover - 529 out of a possible 1,300
Album - 492 out of a possible 1,300
Song Selection - 133 out of a possible 1,300

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Posted by: Dannyboy 21st December 2019, 06:25 PM

Number 10 - American Life (Album) - 1,928 Points

Number 9 - Bedtime Stories (Album) - 2,025 Points

Number 8 - Madonna (Album) - 2,141 Points

Number 7 - Erotica (Album) - 2,379 Points

Number 6 - Music (Album) - 2,414 Points

Number 5 - Like a virgin (Album) - 2,440 Points

Number 4 - Like a prayer (Album) - 3,118 Points

Number 3 - True Blue (Album) - 3,480 Points

Number 2 - Confessions on a Dance Floor (Album) - 3,515 Points

Number 1 - Ray of light (Album) - 3,672 Points

Posted by: FKA Twiglets 22nd December 2019, 11:50 AM

Correct winner!

Posted by: Dannyboy 18th April 2020, 12:42 PM

For those interested -

1 Vogue - 2440
2 Frozen - 2419
3 Ray of light - 2293
4 Medellín - 2231
5 Like a prayer - 2226
6 Hung Up - 2156
7 Girl gone wild - 2117
8 Ghostown - 2098
9 Papa don't preach - 2077
10 Human Nature - 1951
11 Secret - 1910
12 Take a bow - 1897
13 Celebration - 1880
14 Sorry - 1870
15 Oh Father - 1826
16 Borderline - 1799
17 Material Girl - 1744
18 Like a virgin - 1729
19 Into the groove - 1710
20 Bad Girl - 1680
21 Music - 1660
22 Justify my love - 1630
23 La isla Bonita - 1621
24 Crave - 1621
25 Die another day - 1581
26 Open your heart - 1544
27 Bedtime Stories - 1529
28 Give it 2 me - 1511
29 Don't tell me - 1453
30 I'll Remember - 1426
31 Express Yourself - 1417
32 Erotica - 1413
33 American Life - 1409
34 Drowned World - 1387
35 The power of goodbye - 1357
36 Living for love - 1336
37 Lucky Star - 1295
38 Crazy for you - 1264
39 True Blue - 1251
40 Deeper and Deeper - 1204
41 Nothing really matters - 1154
42 Give me all your lovin - 1144
43 4 Minutes - 1071
44 Rain - 1045
45 Hollywood - 1040
46 Live to tell - 1033
47 Get Together - 1025