Printable version of thread

Posted by: Maurice! 20th August 2019, 02:38 PM

Hello all and welcome to Spice Rate 2019!!

Over the course of this summer, we will be conducting the Spice Girls 2019 rate. People who were on DenDen know this from the past.

This year we decided to do it in a different format because all together our girls have released a lot of songs to do it in one bunch. There will be a 90s edition, a 2000-2004 edition and a 2005-2019 edition. So 3 times more fun. The 3 editions + results will keep us entertained for the summer.

This is the 2005-2019 edition.

The rules are just like any other rate One 11, one -1. should be easy.

We will do the same with the other eras and then put all results together to determine which is Buzzjack’s favorite Spice/solo spice song!

Get rating!

A Spotify playlist of this rate is here so you can listen if you want to remember a song!


There are some singles missing on Spotify (also some singles for people outside the UK like me )
Emma:



Melanie C:




Geri:



Spice Girls:
xx Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
xx Today
xx For Once In My Life

Emma:
xx Downtown
xx All I Need to Know
xx Baby Please Don't Stop
xx You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
xx Next Best Superstar
xx Better Alone
xx First Day of My Life
xx The Moment You Believe
xx I Want Candy
xx Carolyna
xx This Time
xx Understand
xx Rock Me
xx Think About It
xx Weak
xx Let There Be Love
xx I Know Him So Well
xx Loving You
xx Cool as You
xx Numb
xx Anymore
xx Dear Life
xx Hold On
xx Room for Love

Geri:
xx Desire
xx Half of Me
xx Angels in Chains

Posted by: Maurice! 20th August 2019, 02:42 PM

Spice Girls:
09 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
06 Today
09 For Once In My Life

Emma:
09 Downtown
10 All I Need to Know
11 Baby Please Don't Stop
09 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
06 Next Best Superstar
06 Better Alone
07 First Day of My Life
06 The Moment You Believe
06 I Want Candy
04 Carolyna
07 This Time
03 Understand
06 Rock Me
08 Think About It
07 Weak
06 Let There Be Love
09 I Know Him So Well
08 Loving You
05 Cool as You
06 Numb
07 Anymore
02 Dear Life
02 Hold On
05 Room for Love

Geri:
09 Desire
06 Half of Me
07 Angels in Chains

Posted by: engineer 20th August 2019, 03:55 PM

Spice Girls:
08 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
07 Today
07 For Once In My Life

Emma:
08 Downtown
06 All I Need to Know
08 Baby Please Don't Stop
06 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
02 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
07 First Day of My Life
07 The Moment You Believe
01 I Want Candy
02 Carolyna
05 This Time
01 Understand
05 Rock Me
09 Think About It
05 Weak
07 Let There Be Love
07 I Know Him So Well
08 Loving You
06 Cool as You
05 Numb
10 Anymore
08 Dear Life
06 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
06 Desire
01 Half of Me
09 Angels in Chains

Posted by: vibe 20th August 2019, 04:11 PM

Spice Girls:
07 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
06 Today
06 For Once In My Life

Emma:
07 Downtown
06 All I Need to Know
07 Baby Please Don't Stop
05 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
10 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
10 First Day of My Life
08 The Moment You Believe
05 I Want Candy
08 Carolyna
06 This Time
07 Understand
07 Rock Me
11 Think About It
09 Weak
04 Let There Be Love
07 I Know Him So Well
10 Loving You
03 Cool as You
08 Numb
10 Anymore
07 Dear Life
04 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
04 Desire
01 Half of Me
05 Angels in Chains

Posted by: blacksquare 20th August 2019, 04:13 PM

I want to give Half of Me 11 for being iconically terrible

Posted by: Mr.X 20th August 2019, 05:44 PM

QUOTE(blacksquare @ Aug 20 2019, 05:13 PM)

Posted by: Spiceboy 21st August 2019, 12:50 PM

Headlines (Rate never ends) haha!

Posted by: Spiceboy 21st August 2019, 12:54 PM

Spice Girls:
06 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) - this has grown on me over time, it's a beautiful song just not single (comeback at that) material.

Mel B:
05 Today
07 For Once In My Life

Emma:
05 Downtown
07 All I Need to Know
10 Baby Please Don't Stop
03 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
08 Next Best Superstar
04 Better Alone
07 First Day of My Life
08 The Moment You Believe
01 I Want Candy
10 Carolyna
-1 This Time
09 Understand
07 Rock Me
11 Think About It
10 Weak
06 Let There Be Love
05 I Know Him So Well
10 Loving You
01 Cool as You
09 Numb
09 Anymore
03 Dear Life
05 Hold On
08 Room for Love

Geri:
07 Desire
03 Half of Me
04 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Mr.X 21st August 2019, 07:54 PM

Spice Girls:
04 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
04 Today
00 For Once In My Life

Emma:
05 Downtown
11 All I Need to Know
10 Baby Please Don't Stop
10 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
02 First Day of My Life
05 The Moment You Believe
01 I Want Candy
02 Carolyna
02 This Time
03 Understand
00 Rock Me
04 Think About It
03 Weak
03 Let There Be Love
06 I Know Him So Well (purely cos Emma and Mel sound amazing - the song itself is pish)
05 Loving You
01 Cool as You
01 Numb
06 Anymore
02 Dear Life
02 Hold On
02 Room for Love

Geri:
00 Desire
00 Half of Me
-01 Angels in Chains

GOD the amount of really terrible songs they released since 2005 is quite staggering hey? Even Emma released some contemporary duds

Posted by: SouthernStar88 21st August 2019, 09:28 PM

Spice Girls:
08 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
07 Today
09 For Once In My Life

Emma:
08 Downtown
10 All I Need to Know
08 Baby Please Don't Stop
08 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
08 Next Best Superstar
07 Better Alone
07 First Day of My Life
06 The Moment You Believe
06 I Want Candy
06 Carolyna
11 This Time
09 Understand
10 Rock Me
10 Think About It
09 Weak
09 Let There Be Love
06 I Know Him So Well
07 Loving You
09 Cool as You
10 Numb
07 Anymore
08 Dear Life
07 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
06 Desire
07 Half of Me
07 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Babyboy 23rd August 2019, 09:10 AM

Spice Girls
07 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B
06 Today
08 For Once In My Life

Emma:
05 Downtown
09 All I Need to Know
07 Baby Please Don't Stop
07 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07 Next Best Superstar
08 Better Alone
07 First Day of My Life
08 The Moment You Believe
07 I Want Candy
08 Carolyna
07 This Time
07 Understand
06 Rock Me
10 Think About It
08 Weak
07 Let There Be Love
07 I Know Him So Well
10 Loving You
07 Cool as You
06 Numb
09 Anymore
10 Dear Life
08 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
07 Desire
06 Half of Me
05 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Jay ☆ 23rd August 2019, 10:29 AM

Spice Girls:
09.0 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
06.5 Today
09.0 For Once In My Life

Emma:
06.5 Downtown
11.0 All I Need to Know
10.0 Baby Please Don't Stop
05.0 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
08.0 Next Best Superstar
04.0 Better Alone
06.0 First Day of My Life
05.0 The Moment You Believe
05.0 I Want Candy
07.0 Carolyna
05.0 This Time
06.0 Understand
06.5 Rock Me
10.0 Think About It
07.5 Weak
05.0 Let There Be Love
05.0 I Know Him So Well
08.0 Loving You
03.0 Cool as You
07.0 Numb
08.5 Anymore
08.5 Dear Life
05.5 Hold On
07.5 Room for Love

Geri:
08.0 Desire
01.0 Half of Me
05.5 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Jay ☆ 27th August 2019, 05:17 PM

More rates please

Posted by: jakewild 27th August 2019, 05:56 PM

Spice Girls:
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
02 Today
05 For Once In My Life

Emma:
09 Downtown
06 All I Need to Know
05 Baby Please Don't Stop
07 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
10 Next Best Superstar
01 Better Alone
00 First Day of My Life
05 The Moment You Believe
00 I Want Candy
00 Carolyna
00 This Time
01 Understand
03 Rock Me
00 Think About It
06 Weak
00 Let There Be Love
00 I Know Him So Well
01 Loving You
04 Cool as You
03 Numb
xx Anymore
xx Dear Life
xx Hold On
xx Room for Love

Geri:
07 Desire
03 Half of Me
02 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Jay ☆ 29th August 2019, 06:25 PM

Thanks for the rates so far! Hope we can get some more?

Posted by: Jay ☆ 29th August 2019, 06:26 PM

QUOTE(jakewild @ Aug 27 2019, 06:56 PM)

Posted by: JosephStyles 29th August 2019, 10:50 PM

Spice Girls:
08.0 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
08.0 Today
11.0 For Once In My Life

Emma:
09.0 Downtown
08.0 All I Need to Know
09.0 Baby Please Don't Stop
07.0 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07.5 Next Best Superstar
07.0 Better Alone
09.5 First Day of My Life
08.5 The Moment You Believe
06.5 I Want Candy
08.0 Carolyna
10.0 This Time
07.5 Understand
09.0 Rock Me
09.0 Think About It
08.0 Weak
10.0 Let There Be Love
07.0 I Know Him So Well
07.5 Loving You
07.0 Cool as You
08.5 Numb
09.0 Anymore
09.0 Dear Life
06.0 Hold On
08.0 Room for Love

Geri:
06.0 Desire
07.0 Half of Me
08.0 Angels in Chains

Posted by: vibe 30th August 2019, 11:04 AM

How can anyone score half of me above a 3 ?
Taste people

Posted by: Jade 30th August 2019, 12:11 PM

Completely forgot that I hadn't done this one yet! There's a few songs I need to re-listen to, will make sure to get it done this weekend.

Posted by: Jay ☆ 9th September 2019, 01:21 AM

Any more rates?

Posted by: TheJüpreme 10th September 2019, 11:20 AM

Yikes I'll have to relisten & come back to a bunch of these.

Spice Girls:
04 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
03 Today
05 For Once In My Life

Emma:
08 Downtown
06 All I Need to Know
06 Baby Please Don't Stop
05 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
06 First Day of My Life
05 The Moment You Believe
04 I Want Candy
07 Carolyna
05 This Time
05 Understand
04 Rock Me
06 Think About It
05 Weak
07 Let There Be Love
04 I Know Him So Well
05 Loving You
06 Cool as You
07 Numb
07 Anymore
07 Dear Life
07 Hold On
09 Room for Love

Geri:
01 Desire
-1 Half of Me
05 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Algernon Monqueef 10th September 2019, 11:29 AM

Omg I didn't even see this was happening till you pmed me!!!!


Spice Girls:
10 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
09 Today
11 For Once In My Life

Emma:
06 Downtown
04 All I Need to Know
02 Baby Please Don't Stop
01 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07 Next Best Superstar
02 Better Alone
03 First Day of My Life
00 The Moment You Believe
08 I Want Candy - loool at this being a thing!! The super cheesy Latin sounds too! An 8 just for being excellent novelty.
07 Carolyna
02 This Time
04 Understand
05 Rock Me
04 Think About It
Xx Weak
Xx Let There Be Love
-1 I Know Him So Well
Xx Loving You
Xx Cool as You
05 Numb
Xx Anymore
xx Dear Life
xx Hold On
xx Room for Love

Geri:
03 Desire
00 Half of Me
00 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Algernon Monqueef 10th September 2019, 11:30 AM

Omg you totally should listen to Next Best Superstar

Omg, all their output but Mel B's got so so sooo much WORSE

Posted by: Jay ☆ 10th September 2019, 11:40 AM

Thank you both

Hope you fill in those xx's soon Michael! Only a 4 for Think About It??

Posted by: isanka 10th September 2019, 12:16 PM

Spice Girls:
05 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
03 Today
10 For Once In My Life

Emma:
09 Downtown
08 All I Need to Know
03 Baby Please Don't Stop
01 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
05 Next Best Superstar
07 Better Alone
11 First Day of My Life
09 The Moment You Believe
02 I Want Candy
06 Carolyna
08 This Time
02 Understand
09 Rock Me
10 Think About It
08 Weak
10 Let There Be Love
02 I Know Him So Well
09 Loving You
08 Cool as You
05 Numb
09 Anymore
10 Dear Life
07 Hold On
05 Room for Love

Geri:
03 Desire
00 Half of Me
-01 Angels in Chains

Posted by: pippa 10th September 2019, 01:38 PM

Spice Girls:
06 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
05 Today
05 For Once In My Life

Emma:
06 Downtown
07 All I Need to Know
06 Baby Please Don't Stop
06 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
09 Next Best Superstar
08 Better Alone
08 First Day of My Life
07 The Moment You Believe
05 I Want Candy
10 Carolyna
08 This Time
08 Understand
10 Rock Me
09 Think About It
09 Weak
09 Let There Be Love
05 I Know Him So Well
11 Loving You
08 Cool as You
08 Numb
07 Anymore
07 Dear Life
07 Hold On
08 Room for Love

Geri:
02 Desire
02 Half of Me
01 Angels in Chains

Posted by: letloverule 10th September 2019, 02:29 PM

Spice Girls:
06 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
06 Today
05 For Once In My Life

Emma:
08 Downtown
07 All I Need to Know
08 Baby Please Don't Stop
07 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
06 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
06 First Day of My Life
06 The Moment You Believe
04 I Want Candy
08 Carolyna
06 This Time
08 Understand
06 Rock Me
08 Think About It
06 Weak
07 Let There Be Love
08 I Know Him So Well
08 Loving You
06 Cool as You
04 Numb
09 Anymore
08 Dear Life
05 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
06 Desire
03 Half of Me
05 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Algernon Monqueef 10th September 2019, 02:33 PM

QUOTE(Jay ☆ @ Sep 10 2019, 12:40 PM)

Thank you both

Hope you fill in those xx's soon Michael! Only a 4 for Think About It??

Posted by: Nick F1 10th September 2019, 03:54 PM

Spice Girls:
6.5 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
5 Today
7 For Once In My Life

Emma:
7 Downtown
6 All I Need to Know
8 Baby Please Don't Stop
6.5 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
6 Next Best Superstar
5 Better Alone
7 First Day of My Life
4.5 The Moment You Believe
7 I Want Candy
5.5 Carolyna
5 This Time
5.5 Understand
6 Rock Me
6 Think About It
5 Weak
5 Let There Be Love
5.5 I Know Him So Well
6 Loving You
5 Cool as You
7 Numb
7 Anymore
6.5 Dear Life
5 Hold On
4.5 Room for Love

Geri:
11 Desire
6 Half of Me
5.5 Angels in Chains

Posted by: HausofF 10th September 2019, 07:43 PM

Spice Girls:
08 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
02 Today
08 For Once In My Life

Emma:
04 Downtown
05 All I Need to Know
07 Baby Please Don't Stop
04 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
05 Next Best Superstar
04 Better Alone
07 First Day of My Life
07 The Moment You Believe
02 I Want Candy
06 Carolyna
06 This Time
05 Understand
03 Rock Me
08 Think About It
07 Weak
06 Let There Be Love
05 I Know Him So Well
09 Loving You
03 Cool as You
07 Numb
06 Anymore
06 Dear Life
04 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
04 Desire
02 Half of Me
08 Angels in Chains

Posted by: ...ready for it 10th September 2019, 11:48 PM

Spice Girls:
11 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
08 Today
07 For Once In My Life

Emma:
06 Downtown
06 All I Need to Know
08 Baby Please Don't Stop
07 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
06 First Day of My Life
07 The Moment You Believe
03 I Want Candy
08 Carolyna
08 This Time
06 Understand
08 Rock Me
08 Think About It
08 Weak
06 Let There Be Love
07 I Know Him So Well
06 Loving You
06 Cool as You
06 Numb
08 Anymore
08 Dear Life
06 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
07 Desire
05 Half of Me
07 Angels in Chains

Posted by: GLOBALFUNQ 👣 12th September 2019, 10:18 PM

Spice Girls:
07.0 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
04.0 Today
07.0 For Once In My Life

Emma:
05.5 Downtown
07.0 All I Need to Know
07.5 Baby Please Don't Stop
04.0 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
07.0 Next Best Superstar
04.0 Better Alone
06.5 First Day of My Life
05.0 The Moment You Believe
02.0 I Want Candy
06.0 Carolyna
05.0 This Time
06.0 Understand
06.5 Rock Me
07.5 Think About It
06.0 Weak
05.0 Let There Be Love
04.0 I Know Him So Well
06.5 Loving You
04.0 Cool as You
07.0 Numb
08.0 Anymore
4.5 Dear Life
04.5 Hold On
06.0 Room for Love

Geri:
05.0 Desire
-1 Half of Me
06.0 Angels in Chains

Posted by: Michael Andrew 15th September 2019, 08:50 AM

Spice Girls:
06 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
01 Today
04 For Once In My Life

Emma:
06 Downtown
09 All I Need to Know
10 Baby Please Don't Stop
06 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
06 Next Best Superstar
05 Better Alone
04 First Day of My Life
08 The Moment You Believe
05 I Want Candy
05 Carolyna
04 This Time
07 Understand
07 Rock Me
09 Think About It
08 Weak
03 Let There Be Love
04 I Know Him So Well
10 Loving You
00 Cool as You
05 Numb
10 Anymore
06 Dear Life
06 Hold On
07 Room for Love

Geri:
06 Desire
01 Half of Me
05 Angels in Chains

Posted by: SamJudd 15th September 2019, 11:56 AM

Posted by: TheJüpreme 16th September 2019, 11:46 PM

Updated all my scores now!

Posted by: Jay ☆ 17th September 2019, 12:57 AM

^ Thank you!

Final few days now - is there anyone else who would like to rate?

Posted by: Lukuzz 17th September 2019, 06:31 AM

Spice Girls:
8.5 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Mel B:
4.0 Today
10 For Once In My Life

Emma:
5.0 Downtown
10 All I Need to Know
8.0 Baby Please Don't Stop
3.0 You're All I Need to Get By

Melanie C
9.0 Next Best Superstar
11 Better Alone
7.5 First Day of My Life
6.5 The Moment You Believe
4.0 I Want Candy
6.5 Carolyna
6.0 This Time
5.5 Understand
6.0 Rock Me
9.0 Think About It
7.0 Weak
7.0 Let There Be Love
7.5 I Know Him So Well
7.5 Loving You
5.0 Cool as You
7.0 Numb
10 Anymore
8.5 Dear Life
6.0 Hold On
8.0 Room for Love

Geri:
8.0 Desire
3.0 Half of Me
6.0 Angels in Chains