Printable version of thread

Posted by: Joe. May 16 2016, 08:53 AM

With Civil War just having just been released to tremendous reception , UV asked me to do a film/character rate, which I thought was an exciting idea.

Here's the rate, which you can use 1 -1 and 1 11, everything else between 1 - 10. Please do not rate films you have not seen. Either, xx them, or better yet xx them, watch them and fill in the score later.

Phase One
xx Iron Man
xx The Incredible Hulk
xx Iron Man 2
xx Thor
xx Captain America: The First Avenger
xx Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
xx Iron Man 3
xx Thor: The Dark World
xx Captain America: The Winter Soldier
xx Guardians of the Galaxy
xx Avengers: Age of Ultron
xx Ant-Man
Phase Three
xx Captain America: Civil War

Character rank/rate.


Please do between 10 - 15 characters, no more and no less. And do make it easier for me working out the scores please use this format when posting them

You can use any of the super-heroes/supporting characters, so long as they are from the MCU, which means characters from any of the spin off TV shows can be included. Just please don't include any non-canon characters, like Wolverine from the Brian Singer universe or worse, DC characters.

Posted by: Josh. May 16 2016, 09:13 AM

Phase One
05 Iron Man
06 The Incredible Hulk
xx Iron Man 2
09 Thor
06 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers

Phase Two
xx Iron Man 3
07 Thor: The Dark World
10 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
10 Guardians of the Galaxy
10 Avengers: Age of Ultron
08 Ant-Man

Phase Three
11 Captain America: Civil War

Found the first Iron Man dreadfully boring and I hate the character of Tony Stark too so just never watched the other two.

Will edit the characters in soon!

EDIT:
15 Black Widow
14 Antman
13 Thor
12 Scarlet Witch
11 Captain America
10 Star Lord
09 Hawkeye
08 Rocket
07 Falcon
06 Gamora
05 Quicksilver
04 Loki
03 Bucky
02 Hulk
01 Spiderman

Posted by: Joe. May 16 2016, 09:27 AM

Films:
Phase One
07 Iron Man
08 The Incredible Hulk
05 Iron Man 2
08 Thor
07 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
08 Iron Man 3
9.5 Thor: The Dark World
11 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
08 Guardians of the Galaxy
7.5 Avengers: Age of Ultron
9.5 Ant-Man
Phase Three
10 Captain America: Civil War

----
Characters:

15: Black Widow
14: Scarlet Witch
13: Thor
12: Captain America
11: Ant Man
10: Rocket
09: Loki
08: Gamora
07: Hawkeye
06: Spider-Man
05: Maria Hill
04: Agent 13
03: Bucky with the good hair
02: Falcon
01: Groot

Posted by: Joe. May 16 2016, 09:40 AM

Josh, slay at us having the same top 5 characters (differently ordered)!

Commiserations to Nick Fury and The Wasp who just missed my top 15!

Posted by: Jimmy Jam May 16 2016, 11:02 AM

Phase One
08 Iron Man
-1 The Incredible Hulk
05 Iron Man 2
10 Thor
08 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
04 Iron Man 3
09 Thor: The Dark World
09 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
10 Guardians of the Galaxy
06 Avengers: Age of Ultron
06 Ant-Man
Phase Three
11 Captain America: Civil War

15 Black Widow
14 Thor
13 Spiderman
12 Captain America
11 Wasp
10 Hawkeye
09 Groot
08 Scarlet Witch
07 Loki
06 Quicksilver
05 Iron Man
04 Star Lord
03 Hulk
02 Gamora
01 Ant Man

Posted by: Severin May 16 2016, 11:06 AM

Phase One
08 Iron Man
xx The Incredible Hulk
05 Iron Man 2
03 Thor
07 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
04 Iron Man 3
xx Thor: The Dark World
07 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
11 Guardians of the Galaxy
07 Avengers: Age of Ultron
06 Ant-Man
Phase Three
09 Captain America: Civil War


15: Loki
14: Jessica Jones
13: Tony Stark/Iron Man
12: Killgrave
11: Rocket
10: Black Widow
09: Scarlet Witch
08: The Winter Soldier (Specifically as opposed to when he's Bucky)
07: Bruce Banner (Specifically as opposed to The Hulk)
06: Kingpin
05: Red Skull
04: Nebula
03: Gamora
02: Hawkeye
01: Groot

I'm not asking for special treatment with Banner and Winter Soldier but I do find them a damn sight more interesting than in their other personas

Posted by: Joe. May 16 2016, 11:20 AM

I'm not 100%, has Storm appeared in the MCU? Can anyone help?

Posted by: Regina May 16 2016, 11:25 AM

No I don't think so. She's only been in the Xmen movies and I don't think they are MCU canon.

Posted by: Jimmy Jam May 16 2016, 03:09 PM

OOOPS! flop, i'll edit!! Sorry queen Storm

Edit: Edited!

Posted by: Chez Wombat May 16 2016, 03:41 PM

Phase One
09 Iron Man
07 The Incredible Hulk
08 Iron Man 2
10 Thor
xx Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
08 Iron Man 3
09 Thor: The Dark World
10 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
11 Guardians of the Galaxy
xx Avengers: Age of Ultron
xx Ant-Man
Phase Three
10 Captain America: Civil War

Character rank/rate.

15: Groot
14: Iron Man
13: Spider Man
12: Loki
11: Thor
10: Peter Quill
09: The Hulk
08: Rocket
07: Captain America
06: Gamora

Hopefully, I'll be able to edit in Civil War before the end of the rate!

Posted by: Regina May 16 2016, 04:33 PM

Phase One
03 Iron Man
07 The Incredible Hulk
00 Iron Man 2
10 Thor
10 Captain America: The First Avenger
9.5 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
00 Iron Man 3
08 Thor: The Dark World
11 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
05 Guardians of the Galaxy
08 Avengers: Age of Ultron
07 Ant-Man
Phase Three
xx Captain America: Civil War

15: Bucky
14: Black Widow
13: Captain America
12: Maria Hill
11: Thor
10: Scarlet Witch
09: Hawkeye
08: Loki
07: Ant Man
06: Groot

Posted by: Joe. May 16 2016, 04:41 PM

Regina and Chez, it'll probably be open for about 2 weeks. If you do see Civil War and add in a score, let me know on here in case I miss it (same goes to everyone else)

Posted by: RobinJuanPersie May 16 2016, 04:46 PM

Phase One
07 Iron Man
07 The Incredible Hulk
07 Iron Man 2
07 Thor
07 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
08 Iron Man 3
07 Thor: The Dark World
09 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
11 Guardians of the Galaxy
08 Avengers: Age of Ultron
09 Ant-Man
Phase Three
10 Captain America: Civil War

Character rank/rate.
15: Black Widow
14: Groot
13: Spider-Man
12: Rocket Racoon
11: Ant-Man
10: Nick Fury
09: Scarlet Witch
08: Iron Man
07: Starlord
06: Loki
05: Peggy Carter
04: War Machine
03: Falcon
02: Black Panther
01: Vision

I wanted to put Howard The Duck but his cameo is so small in Guardians

Posted by: SamJudd May 16 2016, 04:57 PM

Phase One
10 Iron Man
05 The Incredible Hulk
07 Iron Man 2
08 Thor
08 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
07 Iron Man 3
06 Thor: The Dark World
10 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
10 Guardians of the Galaxy
09 Avengers: Age of Ultron
09 Ant-Man
Phase Three
11 Captain America: Civil War


CODE

15: Captain America
14: Black Widow
13: Iron Man
12: Peter Quill
11: Ant Man
10: Thor
09: Bucky
08: Rocket
07: Loki
06: Scarlet Witch
05: Nick Fury
04: Hawkeye
03: Hulk
02: Peggy Carter
01: Groot

Posted by: Jonjo May 16 2016, 05:49 PM

Phase One
09.0 Iron Man
07.0 The Incredible Hulk
06.5 Iron Man 2
06.0 Thor
08.0 Captain America: The First Avenger >> This is probably my favourite origin movie. <<
10.0 Marvel's The Avengers

Phase Two
07.5 Iron Man 3
09.0 Thor: The Dark World >> This is RIDICULOUSLY under appreciated. <<
10.0 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
11.0 Guardians of the Galaxy
09.0 Avengers: Age of Ultron >> Haters. BE QUIET. <<
08.5 Ant-Man >> I get the feeling that once I've watched this again, this will rise! <<

Phase Three
10.0 Captain America: Civil War

SLAY ME.

Character Rank:
15. Captain America
14. Groot
13. Ant-Man
12. Rocket Raccoon
11. Hulk
---
10. Star Lord
09. Black Widow
08. Drax
07. Spider-Man >> This could obviously rise. He was the highlight of CW for me! <<
06. Bucky
---
05. Gamora
04. Thanos
03. Ultron
02. Iron Man
01. Loki

Ugh. I'm not even happy with this rank tbh.

Posted by: Joe. May 17 2016, 10:49 AM

9 voters in and Loki is the only character to have made a big enough impression to have been pointed by everyone so far!

Poor underrated Agent 13 only getting points from moi.

Some quite iconic characters seem to be under-performing somewhat

Posted by: DJHazey May 17 2016, 01:18 PM

Phase One
10 Iron Man
xx The Incredible Hulk
09 Iron Man 2
10 Thor
10 Captain America: The First Avenger
08 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
09 Iron Man 3
10 Thor: The Dark World
10 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
11 Guardians of the Galaxy
07 Avengers: Age of Ultron
04 Ant-Man
Phase Three
10 Captain America: Civil War

---

15: Black Widow
14: Pepper Potts
13: Thor
12: Rocket
11: Bucky
10: Nebula
09: Groot
08: The Falcon
07: Loki
06: Nick Fury
05: Star Lord
04: Gamora
03: Vision
02: Darcy Lewis
01: Peggy Carter

Posted by: Ultraviolence1989 May 17 2016, 10:00 PM

Phase One
10 Iron Man
05.5 The Incredible Hulk
02 Iron Man 2
05 Thor
05 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers

Phase Two
08 Iron Man 3
05 Thor: The Dark World
08.5 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
11 Guardians of the Galaxy
07 Avengers: Age of Ultron
09 Ant-Man

Phase Three
10 Captain America: Civil War

CHARACTERS:
15 Black Widow
14 Spiderman
13 Scarlett Witch
12 Iron Man
11 Gamora

10 Captain America
09 Loki
08 Groot
07 Agent 13
06 Rocket Raccoon

05 Hulk
04 Star Lord
03 Bucky
02 Ant-Man
01 Nebula

Posted by: Iz~ May 18 2016, 12:09 AM

Phase One
07 Iron Man
xx The Incredible Hulk
02 Iron Man 2 (this put me off superhero films for a good few years)
xx Thor
07 Captain America: The First Avenger
07 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
xx Iron Man 3
xx Thor: The Dark World
06 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
xx Guardians of the Galaxy
xx Avengers: Age of Ultron
08 Ant-Man
Phase Three
09 Captain America: Civil War

CODE
15: Iron Man (I didn't dislike Iron Man 2 because of him, he's awesome in most of these but it was just a poor movie)
14: Nick Fury
13: Black Widow
12: Captain America
11: Hawkeye
10: Loki (bear in mind this is solely off of the Avengers)
09: Ant-Man
08: Peggy Carter
07: Hank Pym
06: Black Panther
05: Spiderman

Yeah, I haven't seen half of them, I'm not in any huge rush to go for the rest even if I'm slowly getting back into this sort of thing. I know I need to at least see Guardians at some point though.

Posted by: Joe. May 21 2016, 09:55 AM

Bump.

Posted by: Scherz May 21 2016, 11:37 AM

Phase One
06 Iron Man
xx The Incredible Hulk
05 Iron Man 2
08 Thor
09 Captain America: The First Avenger
09 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
05 Iron Man 3
07 Thor: The Dark World
09 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
08 Guardians of the Galaxy
09 Avengers: Age of Ultron
09 Ant-Man
Phase Three
10 Captain America: Civil War

- -

Character rate
15: Black Widow
14: Thor
13: Scarlet Witch
12: Captain America
11: Jessica Jones
10: Ant-Man
09: Bucky
08: Star-Lord
07: Hawkeye
06: Spider-Man
05: Falcon
04: Nick Fury
03: Darcy Lewis
02: Jane Foster
01: Pepper Potts

Posted by: Froot. May 21 2016, 12:31 PM

Phase One
08 Iron Man
xx The Incredible Hulk
04 Iron Man 2
09 Thor
08 Captain America: The First Avenger
10 Marvel's The Avengers
Phase Two
06 Iron Man 3
02 Thor: The Dark World
10 Captain America: The Winter Soldier
10 Guardians of the Galaxy
09 Avengers: Age of Ultron
09.5 Ant-Man
Phase Three
11 Captain America: Civil War

Character rate
16: Baby Groot
15: Ant-Man
14: Iron Man
13: Kilgrave
12: Black Widow
11: Peter Quill
10: Jessica Jones
09: Loki
08: Rocket
07: Gemma Simmons
06: Captain America
05: Nebula
04: Hulk
03: Nick Fury
02: Thor
01: Spiderman - will most likely be higher after Homecoming is released

-1: War Machine

Posted by: Joe. May 24 2016, 09:09 AM

If we've got all these in, I'll proceed with the results in the next couple of days, so get any last ones in.

Posted by: Chez Wombat May 24 2016, 03:59 PM

I've now seen it so edited in my score for Civil War (and already supporting it do very well in this)

Posted by: Joe. May 26 2016, 03:10 PM

Thanks, added!

Results starting tomorrow, so any last rates get them in ASAP