When Radio 1 moves the top 40 to Fridays as of next month, the shorter slot that will go with it will mean they will only have time to play a select number of entries in the lower bracket alongside the full top 20 but which method do you prefer? I think the concept of playing all forty entries is now old hat considering the impact of streaming has seen several long runners in the lower end although it did work back in the 90s and early 2000s when you would regularly get 15-20 new entries.
Currently I prefer the idea of playing all the tracks, especially as some songs grow on me over time and I won't otherwise hear them outside of the chart. However, as streaming becomes more and more dominant, the chart will be staler and there really won't be much of a point playing the entire top 40 so in time I'll prefer the latter. Right now though, I like the idea of playing all 40 songs.
Skipping entries definitely. There's so much deadwood in the chart right now which makes the chart less interesting to listen to. Glad it's being reduced to 2 hours, that should be good.
There won't be much time to play a top 40 anyway, and the show is less than 2 hours, with newsbeat slotted at 5:45pm
It'll be option 2 because of the time anyway but I'd also favour playing the top 20 with Greg going through all the 40-21 positions first with only playing the new entries/any re entries and songs climbing to new peaks or climbing with less than 10/5 weeks top 40. Which is probably what will happen anyway so option 2!
Used to like them playing the entire top 40 for so many years but it's a chore to listen to nowadays with all the staleness!
Playing all 40, don't like the fact the Chart will be shortened by an hour.
We all know there will be a week soon enough where Britney or the like peak at 28 or something and radio 1 don't play it and instead play TOL again instead because they playlisted the later and BJ will go nuts!!
Also, people mentioning the lower bracket is stale nowadays well actually that's where most of the new entries tend to initially chart these days, both ones that peak there (like Geronimo) & the eventual climbers (Cheerleader).
If anything, the top half will be the stale bracket from now on with the likes of Cheerleader & Lean On looking set to camp there for eternity - luckily in this case they are both good tracks but it won't be long before we get another Stay With Me.
The way the chart is now, listening to the full 40 every week is just too tedious. I can't put myself through it every week. I listen once a month max. I'm glad they're changing the show.
I would like to see them play all new entries and climbers outside the top 20. I know they've said they want to play the full top 20 as well, but I think with the 1hr45 time slot, occasionally they might have to skip one or two tracks lower down that they would have usually played so that they can fit in the full top 20. I'd rather they cut down or skipped one or two in the top 20 to accommodate.
It'd also be good that in really quiet weeks they played a new entry or two from outside the top 40. For instance for last week's chart, I would have played:
56 The Weeknd
51 Leona Lewis
34 Ed Sheeran
30 Rudimental
24 Ariana Grande
21 Rixton
+ full top 20
It'd be nice if they made a rule to play all new entries in the top 60. I expect what will actually happen is we'll get a maximum of 3 songs played in 21-40, and skipping any new entries that aren't R1 friendly!
I'd be surprised if they skip non-Radio 1 friendly new entries actually. They don't pick and choose what to play on the chart update and instead play all new entries, or if there's not enough time to play them all, they'll snub the lowest ones which is the fairest way. I really can't see them snubbing a new entry from, say, Leona Lewis, just because she's not supported by Radio 1.
Highlights (40-21) and full Top 20.
Back when they used to skip records, it used to annoy me as it was kinda biased to their playlist and they used to skip (and play) the same songs every week. So I enjoyed that they played the whole top 40, BUT now with on average 3-4 new entries a week, most of which dropping out instantly and others going to spend weeks and weeks in the chart, I think skipping the odd record that's been around for a millennium is for the best and this new format fits quite well, just as long as they play ALL the new entries and not skip ones that they haven't been supporting. It'd be even better if they played some sales-only top 40 hits but I doubt they'd have time.
Out of this week's chart, this is what would likely be played in the 21-40 bracket under the new format.
(22) Ed Sheeran - Photograph (new peak)
(29) Rudimental - Never Let You Go (new peak)
(34) The Weeknd - Can't Feel My Face (New Entry)
(38) Kygo - Stole The Show (New Entry)
(39) Flo Rida feat. Sage The Gemini - GDFR (Re-entry)
Powered by Invision Power Board
© Invision Power Services