Printable version of thread

Posted by: MrIndependent 14th April 2016, 06:52 PM

http://jesseepinkman.tumblr.com/madonnasong

Anybody done this? Does it give you an accurate representation of your favourite and least favourite Madonna songs?

Posted by: liamk97 14th April 2016, 07:14 PM

I'm at 30% and I'm bored, I just keep clicking with whatever my immediate thought is. It's a great idea though and thank you for posting!

Posted by: Qween 14th April 2016, 07:35 PM

Oh this sounds like a great idea but surely an entire EVENINGS worth of activity.

Posted by: Joe. 14th April 2016, 07:36 PM

Can one be made for singles? That takes sooooooooooo long.

Posted by: MrIndependent 14th April 2016, 07:40 PM

It took me forever to do.

My whole list:

1 Deeper And Deeper
2 Sky Fits Heaven
3 Impressive Instant
4 Don't Tell Me
5 Waiting
6 Bedtime Story
7 Sanctuary
8 Take A Bow
9 Nothing Fails
10 Paradise (Not For Me)
11 Erotica
12 Drowned World / Substitute For Love
13 Bad Girl
14 Intervention
15 Hollywood
16 Ray Of Light
17 Rain
18 Secret
19 The Power Of Good-Bye
20 Words
21 You'll See
22 X-Static Process
23 Love Tried To Welcome Me
24 Devil Pray
25 Secret Garden
26 Frozen
27 Ghosttown
28 Human Nature
29 Where Life Begins
30 Express Yourself
31 Vogue
32 Music
33 Till Death Do Us Part
34 Promise To Try
35 Holy Water
36 Skin
37 Thief Of Hearts
38 Oh Father
39 Easy Ride
40 Like A Prayer
41 Inside Of Me
42 Isaac
43 Live To Tell
44 Veni Vedi Vici
45 Die Another Day
46 Gone
47 Best Night
48 Body Shop
49 What It feels Like For A Girl
50 Wash All Over Me
51 La Isla Bonita
52 Love Profusion
53 Messiah
54 Mer Girl
55 Burning Up
56 I'll Remember
57 I Want You
58 Inside Out
59 Nobody's Perfect
60 Open Your Heart
61 I Deserve It
62 I Don't Give A
63 Rebel Heart
64 Papa Don't Preach
65 Nobody Knows Me
66 Swim
67 Nothing Really Matters
68 Spanish Eyes
69 This Used To Be My Playground
70 To Have And Not To Hold
71 Joan Of Arc
72 Borderline
73 Candy Perfume Girl
74 Borrowed Time
75 Beautiful Scars
76 Cherish
77 Falling Free
78 Dress You Up
79 Get Together
80 Bye Bye Baby
81 Forbidden Love
82 Hung Up
83 Holiday
84 Mother And Father
85 I'm So Stupid
86 I f***ed Up
87 American Life
88 Illuminati
89 Hold Tight
90 Runaway Lover
91 Gang Bang
92 Physical Attraction
93 Survival
94 Beat Goes On
95 Give It 2 Me
96 Bitch I'm Madonna
97 Fever
98 Everybody
99 Living For Love
100 Keep It Together
101 Sorry
102 Something To Remember
103 Miles Away
104 Lucky Star
105 Why's It So Hard
106 Shanti / Ashtangi
107 In This Life
108 I'd Rather Be Your Lover
109 How High
110 Sooner Or Later
111 Jump
112 Beautiful Killer
113 Devil Wouldn't Recognize You
114 4 Minutes
115 Amazing
116 Dance 2night
117 Little Star
118 Love Don't Live Here Anymore
119 Masterpiece
120 Love Spent
121 Let It Will Be
122 Cyberraga
123 One More Chance
124 Like It Or Not
125 Material Girl
126 Like A Virgin
127 Don't Stop
128 Dear Jessie
129 Hanky Panky
130 Has To Be
131 I'm Addicted
132 Iconic
133 Love Song
134 I Love New York
135 S.E.X.
136 Unapologetic Bitch
137 White Heat
138 Voices
139 Stay
140 True Blue
141 She's Not Me
142 Some Girls
143 Where's The Party
144 Girl Gone Wild
145 He's A Man
146 Heartbeat
147 Candy Shop
148 Fighting Spirit
149 HeartBreakCity
150 Incredible
151 I'm A Sinner
152 Cry Baby
153 Superstar
154 I Know It
155 Think Of Me
156 Shoo-Bee-Doo
157 I'm Going Bananas
158 Did You Do It?
159 Back In Business
160 Act Of Contrition
161 Angel
162 Best Friend
163 Crimes Of Passion
164 Don't You Know?
165 Now I'm Following You (Part I)
166 Now I'm Following You (Part II)
167 Push
168 Over And Over
169 Pretender
170 More
171 Laugh To Keep From Crying
172 Autotune Baby
173 Future Lovers
174 Give Me All Your Luvin'
175 Spanish Lesson
176 Jimmy Jimmy
177 What Can You Lose
178 Ring My Bell
179 B-Day Song
180 Love Makes The World Go Round
180 Turn Up The Radio

I never could've arranged 180+ songs on my own , but I think the general structure of my list is accurate. The top and bottom sections all contain what I would've considered my favourite and least favourite Madonna tracks.

(On another note, if this post is too long a moderator can feel free to edit it down. )

Posted by: liamk97 14th April 2016, 07:41 PM

I got through it!

01. Hung Up
02. Ray of Light
03. Sorry
04. Vogue
05. You'll See
06. Isaac
07. Take a Bow (joint 7th)
07. The Power of Goodbye (joint 7th)
09. Skin
10. Sky Fits Heaven
11. How High
12. Paradise (Not for Me)
13. Oh Father
14. Like a Prayer
15. Jump
16. Let It Will Be
17. Live to Tell
18. Nothing Really Matters
19. Papa Don't Preach
20. Ghosttown

...

180. Spanish Lesson
181. Autotune Baby

Not sure if that would be the exact order but all of those songs in the Top 20 are really good shouts for being in my actual Top 20. Can't argue with that Top 3.

Posted by: Qween 14th April 2016, 08:17 PM

Rank Song
1 Hung Up
2 Vogue
3 Ghosttown
4 Express Yourself
5 Wash All Over Me
6 Deeper And Deeper
7 Skin
8 The Power Of Good-Bye
9 Future Lovers
10 I'm Addicted
11 Paradise (Not For Me)
12 I Know It
13 Ray Of Light
14 Drowned World / Substitute For Love
15 Sorry
16 Devil Wouldn't Recognize You
17 Oh Father
18 Nobody Knows Me
19 Spanish Eyes
20 How High
21 Over And Over
21 Rain
23 Easy Ride
24 Nothing Really Matters
25 Nobody's Perfect
26 Open Your Heart
26 Rebel Heart
28 Mother And Father
29 Papa Don't Preach
29 Promise To Try
31 Runaway Lover
32 Messiah
33 Live To Tell
34 Love Don't Live Here Anymore
35 La Isla Bonita
36 Let It Will Be
37 Jump
38 Like A Prayer
39 Love Spent
40 Lucky Star
41 Voices
42 Words
43 You'll See
44 Joan Of Arc
45 Impressive Instant
46 Bedtime Story
47 Burning Up
48 Borderline
49 American Life
50 Bad Girl
51 HeartBreakCity
52 Inside Out
53 Stay
54 Gang Bang
55 Give It 2 Me
56 Get Together
57 Gone
58 Sky Fits Heaven
59 Beat Goes On
60 Shanti / Ashtangi
61 Swim
62 She's Not Me
63 Angel
64 Dress You Up
65 Devil Pray
65 Die Another Day
67 Erotica
68 Amazing
69 Bye Bye Baby
70 Something To Remember
71 Sooner Or Later
72 Like A Virgin
73 Material Girl
74 Masterpiece
75 Like It Or Not
76 Cyberraga
77 I'll Remember
78 Till Death Do Us Part
79 Hanky Panky
80 Has To Be
81 I'm A Sinner
82 I'm So Stupid
83 I f***ed Up
84 I Deserve It
85 I Don't Give A
86 I Want You
87 He's A Man
88 Hollywood
89 Fighting Spirit
90 Pretender
91 Love Makes The World Go Round
92 Spanish Lesson
92 Take A Bow
94 One More Chance
95 Little Star
96 Cherish
96 Dear Jessie
96 Don't Stop
99 Waiting
100 True Blue
101 More
101 Music
103 Miles Away
104 Now I'm Following You (Part II)
105 Keep It Together
106 Nothing Fails
107 Now I'm Following You (Part I)
108 Intervention
109 Forbidden Love
110 Girl Gone Wild
111 Frozen
112 Human Nature
113 Holiday
114 Heartbeat
115 Hold Tight
116 4 Minutes
117 Candy Perfume Girl
118 Don't Tell Me
119 Falling Free
120 Candy Shop
121 Shoo-Bee-Doo
122 To Have And Not To Hold
123 Think Of Me
124 What Can You Lose
125 Sanctuary
126 Turn Up The Radio
127 Cry Baby
128 Survival
129 Back In Business
130 Everybody
130 Fever
132 Physical Attraction
132 Push
134 X-Static Process
135 Where's The Party
136 Ring My Bell
136 Some Girls
138 I'm Going Bananas
139 Isaac
140 Secret
140 Superstar
142 Why's It So Hard
143 This Used To Be My Playground
144 Thief Of Hearts
145 Unapologetic Bitch
145 Veni Vedi Vici
145 What It feels Like For A Girl
145 Where Life Begins
149 Living For Love
149 Love Tried To Welcome Me
151 Give Me All Your Luvin'
152 White Heat
153 Borrowed Time
154 Act Of Contrition
154 Autotune Baby
156 Best Friend
156 Best Night
156 Bitch I'm Madonna
156 Body Shop
156 Iconic
156 Illuminati
156 I Love New York
156 Jimmy Jimmy
156 Laugh To Keep From Crying
156 Love Profusion
156 Love Song
156 Mer Girl
168 In This Life
169 Inside Of Me
170 Crimes Of Passion
170 Dance 2night
170 Did You Do It?
173 Don't You Know?
174 B-Day Song
174 Beautiful Killer
176 Beautiful Scars
177 Holy Water
177 I'd Rather Be Your Lover
179 S.E.X.
179 Secret Garden
181 Incredible

Posted by: HausofKubrick 14th April 2016, 08:19 PM

Oh GOSH what a mammoth task She'll have released another 6 albums by the time I finish this but I will endeavor to do it at some point ~

Posted by: Qween 14th April 2016, 08:19 PM

That's pretty much my exact top 20, not quite the same order but the top 3 are bang on. They got the right bottom song as well, though Secret Garden is less offensive than a good 10 or so above it I don't think I actually picked it over anything.

Posted by: liamk97 14th April 2016, 08:28 PM

Really interesting Top 10! Several songs I don't usually see be so highly regarded. Yes for 'Sky Fits Heaven', 'Take a Bow' and 'Paradise'!


'Ghosttown' in your Top 3? I don't know why but it surprises me that you regarded it quite so well (no complaints though, it's certainly already cemented itself as one of her greats for me also).

Posted by: Qween 14th April 2016, 08:59 PM

I mean I'd say recency definitely helps it a bit, but i can certainly see it settling into my all time top 5 over time. My favourite from MDNA (I'm Addicted) would never have been top 10 at any point, even when I was full on living for it, it's probably about 10 places too high on that list.

Posted by: SamJudd 14th April 2016, 11:48 PM

Here's mine =

Rank Song
1 Like A Prayer
2 Vogue
3 Material Girl
4 Like A Virgin
5 Hung Up
6 Borderline
7 La Isla Bonita
8 4 Minutes
9 Dress You Up
10 Express Yourself
11 Cherish
12 Holiday
13 Frozen
14 Ghosttown
15 True Blue
16 Living For Love
17 Open Your Heart
18 Papa Don't Preach
19 Ray Of Light
20 Music
21 Deeper And Deeper
22 Sorry
23 Die Another Day
24 Devil Pray
25 Don't Tell Me
26 Rain
27 Live To Tell
28 The Power Of Good-Bye
29 Till Death Do Us Part
30 Lucky Star
31 Jump
32 Where's The Party
33 Take A Bow
34 Secret
35 Sky Fits Heaven
36 Dear Jessie
37 Burning Up
38 Bedtime Story
39 Get Together
40 Hold Tight
41 Candy Perfume Girl
42 Human Nature
43 Impressive Instant
44 Runaway Lover
45 This Used To Be My Playground
46 Where Life Begins
47 What It feels Like For A Girl
48 Thief Of Hearts
49 White Heat
50 You'll See
51 Why's It So Hard
52 Gang Bang
53 Give It 2 Me
54 Devil Wouldn't Recognize You
55 Everybody
56 Drowned World / Substitute For Love
57 Act Of Contrition
58 Erotica
59 Fever
60 Angel
61 Amazing
62 How High
63 Hollywood
64 Forbidden Love
65 I'd Rather Be Your Lover
66 Future Lovers
67 Heartbeat
68 In This Life
69 Joan Of Arc
70 I'll Remember
71 I'm Addicted
72 Iconic
73 Think Of Me
74 Sanctuary
75 Secret Garden
76 Skin
77 Keep It Together
78 Oh Father
79 Nothing Really Matters
80 Nothing Fails
81 Over And Over
82 Physical Attraction
83 Pretender
84 Paradise (Not For Me)
85 Push
86 Promise To Try
87 Rebel Heart
88 Mother And Father
89 Nobody Knows Me
90 Nobody's Perfect
91 Dance 2night
92 Bad Girl
93 Love Makes The World Go Round
94 Masterpiece
95 Let It Will Be
96 Love Don't Live Here Anymore
97 Like It Or Not
98 Little Star
99 Unapologetic Bitch
100 Stay
101 Waiting
102 I Know It
103 Words
104 X-Static Process
105 Cry Baby
106 Beat Goes On
107 Beautiful Killer
108 Bye Bye Baby
109 Wash All Over Me
110 American Life
111 I'm A Sinner
112 I Deserve It
113 To Have And Not To Hold
114 I Don't Give A
115 I Want You
116 She's Not Me
117 Swim
118 Survival
119 Sooner Or Later
120 Spanish Eyes
121 Something To Remember
122 I f***ed Up
123 Illuminati
124 I'm Going Bananas
125 I'm So Stupid
126 Isaac
127 Holy Water
128 I Love New York
129 Inside Of Me
130 Incredible
131 Inside Out
132 Intervention
133 Jimmy Jimmy
134 HeartBreakCity
135 Beautiful Scars
136 He's A Man
137 Give Me All Your Luvin'
138 Gone
139 Hanky Panky
140 Girl Gone Wild
141 Has To Be
142 Best Friend
143 Back In Business
144 Candy Shop
145 Spanish Lesson
146 Superstar
147 Some Girls
148 Shanti / Ashtangi
149 Best Night
150 S.E.X.
151 Borrowed Time
152 What Can You Lose
153 Body Shop
154 Voices
155 Turn Up The Radio
156 Veni Vedi Vici
157 Laugh To Keep From Crying
158 Love Spent
159 Love Tried To Welcome Me
160 Mer Girl
161 Miles Away
162 Love Song
163 Messiah
164 Now I'm Following You (Part I)
165 Now I'm Following You (Part II)
166 One More Chance
167 More
168 Love Profusion
169 Shoo-Bee-Doo
170 Ring My Bell
171 Autotune Baby
172 Bitch I'm Madonna
173 B-Day Song
174 Did You Do It?
175 Don't Stop
176 Cyberraga
177 Easy Ride
178 Falling Free
179 Don't You Know?
180 Crimes Of Passion
181 Fighting Spirit

Posted by: liamk97 17th April 2016, 01:25 PM

Just goes to show she can still deliver the classics in amongst her more... outrageous tracks. Such a shame the two surrounding singles and their respective talking points overshadow it, as well as Madonna's insanity of blanking her supposed "favourite from the album" on her tour.


Very classic singles heavy at the top but all really strong tracks nonetheless! Great to see 'Devil Pray' and 'Til Death Us Do Part' as your top album tracks; easily among the highlights of both albums despite, in my opinion, a lot of highlights on each!