Hello y'all and welcome to the official Ultimate Video Rate from the saturdays' universe! After much controversy, God-lee allowed me to host the rate for y'all to love and treasure
Please forgive me if I make an inevitable mistake but I will make sure my loyal and trust-worthy henchman, Totto, keep you guys calm.
Rules:
- You must rate each music video done by the Saturdays from 0-10 (with ten being the highest and zerp being the lowest)
- You are allowed to give only one 11 to the music video of your choice.
- It is COMPULSORY to give ONE music video a -1
- You may NOT change your score after it has been submitted. It will most likely already have been counted.
- You may NOT give What About Us more than a 3
This is Round 1 of 3 rounds for this rate where you guys will give your initial rates on which video you think is the best. The deadline is on the 20th October with results announced the following day. Rate wisely as your score may affect the success of a music video in the long-run.
Schedule
Initial Rate - Ends 20th October / announced on 21st october
Quarantine Zone - Begins 1st November / results announced 14th November
Head-to-head eliminations - Begins 29th November / results announced 13th December
Final results / announced 20th December
e.g. Save:
-Ego
-Up
-What About Us
Quarantine:
-Forever is Over
-30 Days
This means that Ego, Up And What About Us will not gain any points whilst Forever is Over and 30 days will gain 5 points each (the lowest scores win).[/color]
xx | If This is Love
xx | Up
xx | Issues
xx | Just Can't Get Enough
xx | Work
xx | Forever is Over
xx | Ego
xx | Missing You
xx | Higher
xx | Notorious
xx | All Fired Up
xx | My Heart Takes Over
xx | 30 Days
xx | What About Us
xx | Gentleman
xx | Disco Love
xx | Not Giving Up
xx | What Are You Waiting For?
08 | If This is Love
10 | Up = Iconic video - the tights definitely gave them an image!
04 | Issues
02 | Just Can't Get Enough
03 | Work
10 | Forever is Over
10 | Ego = Perfect - it was fun and funky!
07 | Missing You = Love the solo shots of each of the girls and then the dance routine + video location, definitely one of their best!
10 | Higher
11 | Notorious = Perfect video, love the styling, the video moves in time with the song and just progressively gets better!
10 | All Fired Up
09 | My Heart Takes Over
05 | 30 Days
06 | What About Us
06 | Gentleman
07 | Disco Love = Again, would mark this better had they done something better for the 90's - SPICE GIRLS!
08 | Not Giving Up = Would mark it higher had Foden not fudged her dancing up.
-1 | What Are You Waiting For? = The video drags for me. Say this all the time, they only picked this as a single so they could get a holiday. 808 filmed in a resort? Nah.
06 | If This is Love
-1 | Up
06 | Issues
07 | Just Can't Get Enough
07 | Work
08 | Forever is Over
09 | Ego
08 | Missing You
10 | Higher
09 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
08 | My Heart Takes Over
11 | 30 Days
07 | What About Us
04 | Gentleman
08 | Disco Love
10 | Not Giving Up
09 | What Are You Waiting For?
07 | If This is Love
10 | Up
04 | Issues
10 | Just Can't Get Enough
05 | Work
11 | Forever is Over
10 | Ego
09 | Missing You
06 | Higher
08 | Notorious
07 | All Fired Up
04 | My Heart Takes Over
-1 | 30 Days
08 | What About Us
06 | Gentleman
08 | Disco Love
03 | Not Giving Up
06 | What Are You Waiting For?
I love how you both gave polar opposites nearly for Up and 30 Days!
04 - If This Is Love
07 - Up
-1 - Issues
10 - Just Can't Get Enough
10 - Work
02 - Forever Is Over
11- Ego
06 - Missing You
09 - Higher
10 - Notorious
09 - All Fired Up
05 - My Heart Takes Over
03 - 30 Days
08 - What About Us
09 - Gentleman
10 - Disco Love
08 - Not Giving Up
04 - What Are You Waiting For
05 | If This is Love Good debut video and there isn't anything awkward going on. Shame there's nothing special in it either
04 | Up I just didn't like the video for this.
06 | Issues This marks a significant step-up for the girls for me It's cute and very nice!
07 | Just Can't Get Enough
05 | Work
08 | Forever is Over The video made this song tbh
09 | Ego One of their more higher budget music videos for sure. It works very well and I loved the concept
05 | Missing You
06 | Higher All they did was dance in the video tbh, I didn't see a lot special in it but it had a nice atmosphere to it
11 | Notorious By far my favorite music video done by them! So colorful and entertaining to watch
10 | All Fired Up The dancing and everything was executed so well imo!
07 | My Heart Takes Over
08 | 30 Days
-1 | What About Us As much as I love to watch the girls walk down the street and sing in various places, I don't think it should make up an entire video. Except for the baseball break-in, everything else was very dull and meh. I think I'm the only one thinking this though
07 | Gentleman
06 | Disco Love
08 | Not Giving Up
06 | What Are You Waiting For?
07 If This Is Love
09 Up
07 Issues
09 Just Can't Get Enough
05 Work
08 Forever Is Over
10 Ego
09 Missing You
10 Higher
10 Notorious
10 All Fired Up
10 My Heart Takes Over
09 30 Days
10 What About Us
03 Gentleman
07 Disco Love
08 Not Giving Up
09 What Are You Waiting For
Ego - What About Us was the golden era of The Saturdays IMO.
Disco Love is my fave Sats single but the video was a bit bland and lacked extra sparkle
Work was far too slutty
Gentleman was just pure trash and it wasn't very likeable
Not Giving Up lost a mark for the lack of colour and the bloody Citroen
Pfft. Shade. *rolls eyes*
07 | If This is Love
07 | Up
08 | Issues
10 | Just Can't Get Enough
06 | Work
08 | Forever is Over
11 | Ego - ***FLAWLESS..."like MJ doctor, they killing me"!
08 | Missing You
10 | Higher
10 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
10 | My Heart Takes Over - Rochessa are FLAWLESS in this. In fact they all are - even Frankie!
07 | 30 Days - bit bland, but a good concept - it just wasn't right for this song.
09 | What About Us - A have a soft spot for this, but it could've been better with different editing
-1 | Gentleman - So cheap and cheesy
10 | Disco Love - so fun and very Saturdays
05 | Not Giving Up - not enough going on or enough colour. It would've been better to have more set ups, better choreography and changing colours of the lights.
06 | What Are You Waiting For? - ok, but just a bit meh and too much product placement.
The run of videos from Ego to My Heart Takes Over is pretty amazing.
Poor snubbed Alaia-Maisus!
04 | If This is Love - Pretty boring music video & the weird lighting puts me off
-1 | Up - Just so cringeworthy these days. At the time it was fine, but now..
06 | Issues - It fits the song really nicely imo
06 | Just Can't Get Enough - A very fun music video and the first one where the girls personalities are really shown off
05 | Work - An all round ok music video, but its so different to everything else the band have done/their normal style
07 | Forever is Over - Lots of different and interesting set ups
10 | Ego - The best concept for any of their music videos and I love how there is a plot
05 | Missing You - Sort of bland, but the solo shots of the girls are amazing (Especially Mollie on the bike and Frankie)
09 | Higher - Nothing too spectacular going on but I love the atmosphere of the video
07 | Notorious - A very solid music video, not a massive fan of the secretary aspect but everything else is great
11 | All Fired Up - Their best music video for me. The costumes, dancing, atmosphere, set and sleek look are all on point
09 | My Heart Takes Over - The location is stunning
05 | 30 Days - Another rather bland video, but it earns a mark for having a sense of humour to it
07 | What About Us - The girls all look amazing, the dancing is pretty good and it captures the summer vibe of the song
06 | Gentleman - Kind of cheap looking but I can't help but like it (even if the song is awful)
09 | Disco Love - Fun, cheesy and just a good time
07 | Not Giving Up - I love the sleek look the video has, and the tube light idea, but it loses some marks for the out of sync dancing and the citron
06 | What Are You Waiting For? - Nothing too exciting, they've done better summer videos (Higher/WAU), and the karaoke is pretty stupid, but plus points for different locations
05 | If This is Love
10 | Up (their most iconic video and despite looking cheap as chips I still love watching the video, it does every the Gentleman video wished it could)
07 | Issues
08 | Just Can't Get Enough
09 | Work (I love this video, Vanessa looks amazing)
07 | Forever is Over
10 | Ego (probably their 2nd best video. The last shot is my favourite video moment by them tbh)
08 | Missing You
08 | Higher
10 | Notorious (when they strip in the elevator and Una sings "boy beware..." just yes)
11 | All Fired Up (they all just look flawless in the video, they're dancing, their solo shots are great and I think the song and video fit really well)
04 | My Heart Takes Over (it's nice but there's not much too it zzzz)
-1 | 30 Days ( I think I've watched this video five times in my life and been bored each time)
06 | What About Us (Daisy Dukes & Dance Routine ...apart from that it's pretty meh although I did used to try and replicate the dance routine everytime it was on tv lmfao)
03 | Gentleman (as tacky as it is it's f***ing hilarious to watch sometimes)
07 | Disco Love (wish they had went through the eras/history of girl bands and not decades, would have made for a much more intresting video)
08 | Not Giving Up (I remember being so excited for this video! not their best but Mollie's solo shots are gorgeous)
06 | What Are You Waiting For (Una's hair flip is the only important thing apart from that the video is pretty boring, a Greek version of the What About Us video)
-1 | If This is Love
02 | Up
02 | Issues
04 | Just Can't Get Enough
07 | Work
06 | Forever is Over
08 | Ego
04 | Missing You
07 | Higher
09 | Notorious
07 | All Fired Up
07 | My Heart Takes Over
11 | 30 Days
07 | What About Us
04 | Gentleman
07 | Disco Love
08 | Not Giving Up
08 | What Are You Waiting For?
30 days is actually evening out quite well with the 11s
#30DaysShade
-1 | If This is Love - Boring, boring, boring. Una and Mollie look so bad looking back. Boring video for boring song.
06 | Up - Probably their most recognizable video and the "coloured tights" is often associated with them so I'm glad for that.
05 | Issues - Nice scenery and the girls looked beautiful.
04 | Just Can't Get Enough - Boring.
06 | Work - The last chorus is pretty good. Shame about the video version of the song being so weak.
05 | Forever is Over - Nothing stands out about it.
09 | Ego - If only they done something else for the last chorus instead of sitting on cars...
05 | Missing You - Awful dance routine but some nice scenery.
09 | Higher - Again, I wish they done something more interesting for the second chorus instead of sitting on the steps.
07 | Notorious - First half is amazing then it's generic.
08 | All Fired Up - Always liked this. Very slick and professional looking. Makes them look very badass.
04 | My Heart Takes Over - Boring, although I like Vanessa's little middle 8 walking through the snow.
05 | 30 Days - Some funny moments but Vanessa's styling was AWFUL and it was very cheap looking.
10 | What About Us - Love everything about it. I remember sitting in college when it premiered and couldn't stop watching it. Love the slow motion hairflips at the end, the "breaking into" the baseball field, the street shots, even Sean Paul's section.
05 | Gentleman - Could have been brilliant but was very messy.
05 | Disco Love - Not a video that I watch alot. Again a brilliant concept but poor and boring execution.
09 | Not Giving Up - Watched this so many times. I love the hip shakes for the "got me, got me" parts, Vanessa is stunning, Mollie's verse slays, Rochelle looks like a superstar, Una kills it at the end with her light swinging and Frankie's section was probably the best of her career. Just let down by the fact the same shots are repeated, there's some sync problems and the lighting on Vanessa's verse was horrible.
07 | What Are You Waiting For? - Sums up their friendship pretty well. Not an amazing video but nice to see them just having fun and it definitely suits the song.
07 | If This is Love
08 | Up
09 | Issues
10 | Just Can't Get Enough
05 | Work - No colour for a 'Chasing Lights' era video? Idiotic.
07 | Forever is Over
10 | Ego
08 | Missing You
10 | Higher
09 | Notorious
11 | All Fired Up So slick and just GORGEOUS
06 | My Heart Takes Over
10 | 30 Days
-1 | What About Us Boooring
10 | Gentleman So bad it's marvellous
10 | Disco Love
09 | Not Giving Up
06 | What Are You Waiting For?
5 | If This is Love
8 | Up
8 | Issues
6 | Just Can't Get Enough
-1 | Work
6 | Forever is Over
9 | Ego
6 | Missing You
10 | Higher
9 | Notorious
9 | All Fired Up
11 | My Heart Takes Over
10 | 30 Days
8 | What About Us
2 | Gentleman
7 | Disco Love
10 | Not Giving Up
8 | What Are You Waiting For?
Predictions for last place? I have a feeling it will be poor Gentleman
It'll be Issues which is a shame, I love the video (Una and Frankie's glamour shots!) and that BONFIRE SCENE!
Lemme give it a 10 to help it achieve a positive score
05 | If This is Love
06 | Up
05 | Issues
04 | Just Can't Get Enough
08 | Work
04 | Forever is Over
11 | Ego
06 | Missing You
07 | Higher
08 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
09 | My Heart Takes Over
07 | 30 Days
08 | What About Us
-1.| Gentleman
08 | Disco Love
10 | Not Giving Up
08 | What Are You Waiting For?
Hyping up this rate by putting a few (unoriginal) spins on it by the way. There are gonna be some stages through the weeks:
Initial Rate (this)
Quarantine Zone
Head-to-head eliminations
Final.
Details to be published
2 | If This is Love
9 | Up
-1 | Issues
3 | Just Can't Get Enough
6 | Work
4 | Forever is Over
11 | Ego
8 | Missing You
9 | Higher
9 | Notorious
8 | All Fired Up
10 | My Heart Takes Over
6 | 30 Days
7 | What About Us
1 | Gentleman
8 | Disco Love
5 | Not Giving Up
7 | What Are You Waiting For?
No, I shall not allow Notorious to win this ish
09 | If This is Love
11 | Up
01 | Issues
07 | Just Can't Get Enough
02 | Work
02 | Forever is Over
09 | Ego
09 | Missing You
00 | Higher
10 | Notorious
07 | All Fired Up
02 | My Heart Takes Over
05 | 30 Days
00 | What About Us
06 | Gentleman
02 | Disco Love
05 | Not Giving Up
-1 | What Are You Waiting For?
-1 | If This is Love
07 | Up
10 | Issues
09 | Just Can't Get Enough
07 | Work
05 | Forever is Over
10 | Ego
07 | Missing You
10 | Higher
05 | Notorious
11 | All Fired Up
10 | My Heart Takes Over
07 | 30 Days
08 | What About Us
09 | Gentleman
10 | Disco Love
10 | Not Giving Up
08 | What Are You Waiting For?
If This Is Love was so messy!
Most of their videos are simple yet effective imo
02 | If This is Love
04 | Up
07 | Issues
06 | Just Can't Get Enough
08 | Work
06 | Forever is Over
07 | Ego
05 | Missing You
11 | Higher
07 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
10 | My Heart Takes Over
08 | 30 Days
07 | What About Us
-1.| Gentleman
07 | Disco Love
10 | Not Giving Up
08 | What Are You Waiting For?
#JusticeForGentleman continuing into the videos it seems.
06 | If This is Love
07 | Up
08 | Issues
07 | Just Can't Get Enough
08 | Work
07 | Forever is Over
08 | Ego
08 | Missing You
07 | Higher
09 | Notorious
08 | All Fired Up
08 | My Heart Takes Over
-1 | 30 Days
07 | What About Us
05 | Gentleman
06 | Disco Love
07 | Not Giving Up
07 | What Are You Waiting For?
Forgot about the minus 1!
I don't understand the low scores for 30 Days. It's one of the few videos that actually has a concept/storyline and it's a fun video without looking totally cheap. Ranking it lower than the likes of Gentleman and If This Is Love
I'm perfectly together, thanks.
As much as I love the song Higher, I hope the video doesn't win this again, just because their is some really awful editing in it, in that we get the same scene replayed in a few places, and their a whole chorus of them just sitting on some steps.
07 | If This is Love
06 | Up
05 | Issues
09 | Just Can't Get Enough
-1 | Work
06 | Forever is Over
10 | Ego
08 | Missing You
08 | Higher
10 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
10 | My Heart Takes Over
08 | 30 Days
07 | What About Us
11 | Gentleman
06 | Disco Love
03 | Not Giving Up
05 | What Are You Waiting For?
What is with the Gentleman Video shade!
The video is damn hilarious! I love it
The concept was good, but poorly executed as you would expect from them. Such a shame.
The video gets really shitty especially towards the end, but the start is good despite the cheapness of it all.
SPOILER
James may have just saved Gentleman from the bottom spot
#RateHype
I really like Gentlemen's video
06 | If This is Love
05 | Up
05 | Issues
03 | Just Can't Get Enough
04 | Work
05 | Forever is Over
11 | Ego (They look so hot in this one <3 )
10 | Missing You
09 | Higher
09 | Notorious
08 | All Fired Up
07 | My Heart Takes Over
-1 | 30 Days (would have given it a 3 but the rules state having to give a -1 so bleh )
06 | What About Us
10 | Gentleman
08 | Disco Love
07 | Not Giving Up
07 | What Are You Waiting For?
Much rather see Issues, or 30 Days gone first tbh
A little summary of round 2 which is called 'QUARANTINE!' which will commence on the 1st November (maybe earlier if my results for this round don't take too long)
And just like that it became the Gentleman rate.
Just by looking at Gentleman's score I can tell it will even out to about 4/5ish unless it suddenly gets more positive or more negative scores
05 | If This is Love
08 | Up
06 | Issues
04 | Just Can't Get Enough
02 | Work
07 | Forever is Over
09 | Ego
03 | Missing You
07 | Higher
08 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
06 | My Heart Takes Over
05 | 30 Days
07 | What About Us
-1 | Gentleman
08 | Disco Love
03 | Not Giving Up
05 | What Are You Waiting For?
06 | If This is Love
07 | Up
06 | Issues
01 | Just Can't Get Enough
04 | Work
09 | Forever is Over
07 | Ego
08 | Missing You
07 | Higher
07 | Notorious
11 | All Fired Up
09 | My Heart Takes Over
05 | 30 Days
05 | What About Us
-1 | Gentleman
06 | Disco Love
10 | Not Giving Up
08 | What Are You Waiting For?
One more day guys! Although I think everyone has voted haha
Nope
I almost forgot. Doing this today though.
08 | If This is Love
07 | Up
06 | Issues
08 | Just Can't Get Enough
08 | Work
08 | Forever is Over
08 | Ego
06 | Missing You
08 | Higher
10 | Notorious
10| All Fired Up
07 | My Heart Takes Over
08 | 30 Days
05 | What About Us ( I love this video very much, but it's a 08 till the Honkbal scene, it goes downhill from there. I love Rochelle looking backwards followed by blushing face during her second "suffocatin" part)
-1 | Gentleman
04 | Disco Love (It's no secret I love Rochelle, but her 1989 is horror scary. Also the video is a bit boring.)
08 | Not Giving Up (A nine if the flaws weren't so obvious)
11 | What Are You Waiting For? (The pool scene is unnecessary, But their solo shots are amazing, they're really beautiful they almost need to stop. Their weird rhythmless bending knees dance when they're doing Karaoke is even amazing. Everything! A shame it only has 1.3 Million views.)
07 | If This Is Love
08 | Up
07 | Issues
07 | Just Can't Get Enough
08 | Work
~
03 | Forever Is Over
08 | Ego
~
07 | Missing You
08 | Higher
~
11 | Notorious
10 | All Fired Up
09 | My Heart Takes Over
~
06 | 30 Days
09 | What About Us
09 | Gentleman
08 | Disco Love
09 | Not Giving Up
~
08 | What Are You Waiting For?
I can tell you guys now, Gentleman is winning by a mile. What About Us is clearly last.
#NoRiggingHere
If 30 Days isn't #1 I'm deleting my account, idc
Let's keep it at that
Yay I knew I could trust Totto to down-score What About Us Such a meh video.
Anyways, thank ya'll for voting! Results will commence tomorrow. Let the best video win.
Also, I said honkbal, I meant baseball.
There's only one Totto.
Oh mess
He woke up like this.
Resluts start at 19:30 today and will be released through the week.
Powered by Invision Power Board
© Invision Power Services