Printable version of thread

Posted by: UltraReputation 23rd October 2017, 11:05 PM

Welcome to the Red Rate where in celebration of the album being 5 years old (omg at it already being that long ago eek), we have decided to hold a rate for the iconic album. As with most rates, you can give the songs any score from 0 to 10, .5's are allowed but no other decimals. One 11 (which you will allocate to All Too Well x) and one -1 are also allowed.

The album is easy to access now Taylor's music is on spotify so for people who haven't heard the album, use the next two weeks to get familiar with this! Every song must be rated for your rate to be void.

Deadline: 7th November so this gives you just over two weeks to rate and allows us to have this finished just before the best album of 2017 drops *.*

Track-list:
xx.x State of Grace
xx.x Red
xx.x Treacherous
xx.x I Knew You Were Trouble
xx.x All Too Well
xx.x 22
xx.x I Almost Do
xx.x We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
xx.x Stay Stay Stay
xx.x The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
xx.x Holy Ground
xx.x Sad Beautiful Tragic
xx.x The Lucky One
xx.x Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
xx.x Starlight
xx.x Begin Again
xx.x The Moment I Knew
xx.x Come Back... Be Here
xx.x Girl At Home

Posted by: UltraReputation 23rd October 2017, 11:07 PM

I'm gonna re-listen to this later tonight and will rate then! All Too Well ftw <3

Posted by: Liаm 23rd October 2017, 11:10 PM

10 State of Grace
10 Red
09 Treacherous
10 I Knew You Were Trouble
11 All Too Well
08.5 22
09 I Almost Do
10 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
09 Stay Stay Stay
02 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
xx.x Holy Ground
-1 Tragic
08 The Lucky One
08.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
09 Starlight
09.5 Begin Again
08.5The Moment I Knew
07.5 Come Back... Be Here
08 Girl At Home

All Too Well is quite possibly the best song ever recorded, not even just from her discography or this album.

Posted by: Spun's Labyrinth 25th October 2017, 04:55 PM

I’ll either do the rest tonight or on the weekend as it’s a pain in the ass to do this sort of thing on phone

9 State of Grace
8.5 Red
6.5 Treacherous
9.5 I Knew You Were Trouble
10 All Too Well
10 22
7 I Almost Do
11 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
8.5 Stay Stay Stay
6 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
7.5 Holy Ground
7 Sad Beautiful Tragic
7 The Lucky One
8.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
8 Starlight
9 Begin Again
7 The Moment I Knew
7.5 Come Back... Be Here
7.5 Girl At Home

Posted by: Sonia Fowler 25th October 2017, 05:05 PM

I will have to re-listen to this at some point then

Posted by: UltraReputation 25th October 2017, 09:57 PM

omg messT I forgot Treacherous! Liam/Spun plz can you edit it in thx <3

Posted by: THEO. 25th October 2017, 09:58 PM

I'll give this another listen at the weekend and rate then

Whatever happened to the '1989'/'Teenage Dream' rate?

Posted by: SamJudd 25th October 2017, 10:25 PM

Track-list:
10.0 State of Grace
10.0 Red
08.5 Treacherous
11.0 I Knew You Were Trouble
10.0 All Too Well
10.0 22
09.0 I Almost Do
10.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
10.0 Stay Stay Stay
07.5 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
08.0 Holy Ground
07.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
09.0 The Lucky One
06.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
10.0 Starlight
10.0 Begin Again
08.5 The Moment I Knew
08.0 Come Back... Be Here
09.0 Girl At Home

Posted by: UltraReputation 25th October 2017, 11:02 PM

I've tried to be a bit subjective get rid of the 4 filler songs and this would be one of the best albums of all time!

10.0 State of Grace
10.0 Red
08.5 Treacherous - I always underrate this until I hear it
10.0 I Knew You Were Trouble
11.0 All Too Well
10.0 22
05.5 I Almost Do
10.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
09.0 Stay Stay Stay
00.0 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
09.0 Holy Ground
00.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
05.0 The Lucky One
08.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
10.0 Starlight
07.5 Begin Again
10.0 The Moment I Knew
08.5 Come Back... Be Here
10.0 Girl At Home

Posted by: UltraReputation 25th October 2017, 11:03 PM

omfg I forgot all about that messT!!! I'll sort that out over the next few days

Posted by: JosephStyles 26th October 2017, 09:22 AM

I need to give this another listen, it's been ages since I've played the whole thing - Jan 2014 apparently

Posted by: Liаm 26th October 2017, 04:05 PM

Oops edited in Treacherous

Posted by: Spun's Labyrinth 27th October 2017, 06:22 PM

done and I rated the others as well

Posted by: Atonement 28th October 2017, 12:23 PM

08.5 State of Grace
08.0 Red
06.5 Treacherous
07.0 I Knew You Were Trouble
10.0 All Too Well
07.0 22
06.0 I Almost Do
05.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
05.0 Stay Stay Stay
09.0 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
05.0 Holy Ground
09.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
08.5 The Lucky One
07.0 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
03.0 Starlight
06.5 Begin Again

I hate Taylor Swift's music and persona so much but I have to admit I even bought this album and it's pretty good. 'All Too Well' is a masterpiece. The teenybopper songs (4, 6 and 8) are so annoying but also too catchy to really hate them. Although obviously they are gonna do way too well in this rate and will overstay their welcome so I was very tempted to rate them a 0 but I'm in a good mood so...

Posted by: Good Old Days 28th October 2017, 03:54 PM

^ How you (or anybody else) can hate Taylor as person ?

Posted by: all is vanity. 30th October 2017, 02:29 AM

07 State of Grace
08 Red
07 Treacherous
09 I Knew You Were Trouble
09 All Too Well
08 22
06 I Almost Do
11 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
06 Stay Stay Stay
05 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
05 Holy Ground
03 Sad Beautiful Tragic
04 The Lucky One
05 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
08 Starlight
07 Begin Again
08 The Moment I Knew
06 Come Back... Be Here
06 Girl At Home

Posted by: HarryApa 1st November 2017, 03:01 PM

Track-list:
07.5 State of Grace
10.0 Red
07.0 Treacherous
09.5 I Knew You Were Trouble
09.0 All Too Well
08.0 22
09.0 I Almost Do
11.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
10.0 Stay Stay Stay
09.5 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
07.0 Holy Ground
07.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
09.5 The Lucky One
08.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
08.0 Starlight
06.5 Begin Again
05.5 The Moment I Knew
08.0 Come Back... Be Here
07.0 Girl At Home

Easily my favourite Taylor album and could be one of my favourite albums of the 2010's so so good

Posted by: UltraReputation 7th November 2017, 04:23 PM

Just over a day left to rate! (Will be starting results tomorrow evening so you have until then <3)

Posted by: John-James 7th November 2017, 04:38 PM

11.0 State of Grace
10.0 Red
07.0 Treacherous
09.5 I Knew You Were Trouble
10.0 All Too Well
09.0 22
07.5 I Almost Do
09.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
09.0 Stay Stay Stay
08.5 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
08.0 Holy Ground
10.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
08.5 The Lucky One
-1 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
9.0 Starlight
10.0 Begin Again
10.0 The Moment I Knew
09.5 Come Back... Be Here
09.0 Girl At Home

Posted by: Sceryl_Streep 7th November 2017, 04:44 PM

11.0 State of Grace
09.0 Red
07.0 Treacherous
02. I Knew You Were Trouble
06.0 All Too Well
07.5 22
07.5 I Almost Do
02.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
06.0 Stay Stay Stay
07.5 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
07.0 Holy Ground
08.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
06.5 The Lucky One
00.0 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
08.0 Starlight
08.0 Begin Again
08.0 The Moment I Knew
07.5 Come Back... Be Here
06.0 Girl At Home

Posted by: THEO. 7th November 2017, 06:22 PM

9 State of Grace
8 Red
8.5 Treacherous
11 I Knew You Were Trouble
9 All Too Well
10 22
5 I Almost Do
9 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
6 Stay Stay Stay
10 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
6 Holy Ground
3 Sad Beautiful Tragic
5 The Lucky One
5.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
10 Starlight
4 Begin Again
3 The Moment I Knew
5 Come Back... Be Here
6.5 Girl At Home

A very patchy album. A 10- or 12-track album with a little rearranging of some of the tracks would have worked a lot better.

Posted by: Buttered Muffin 7th November 2017, 08:46 PM

Her last good album

Posted by: Buttered Muffin 7th November 2017, 08:57 PM

11 State of Grace
10 Red
08 Treacherous
10 I Knew You Were Trouble
09 All Too Well
09.5 22
09 I Almost Do
10 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
07 Stay Stay Stay
06.5 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
10 Holy Ground
05 Sad Beautiful Tragic
06 The Lucky One
08.5 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
07 Starlight
08.5 Begin Again
06 The Moment I Knew
04 Come Back... Be Here
01 Girl At Home

Posted by: Josh-tice League 7th November 2017, 09:05 PM

07.5 State of Grace
10.0 Red
08.0 Treacherous
09.5 I Knew You Were Trouble
07.0 All Too Well
11.0 22
06.5 I Almost Do
10.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
09.0 Stay Stay Stay
06.0 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
06.0 Holy Ground
04.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
08.0 The Lucky One
09.0 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
08.0 Starlight
06.0 Begin Again
07.0 The Moment I Knew
05.0 Come Back... Be Here
08.5 Girl At Home

Posted by: JosephStyles 7th November 2017, 09:25 PM

08.0 State of Grace
10.0 Red
07.0 Treacherous
10.0 I Knew You Were Trouble
09.0 All Too Well
08.5 22
08.0 I Almost Do
11.0 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together
09.5 Stay Stay Stay
07.5 The Last Time (feat. Gary Lightbody)
08.0 Holy Ground
06.0 Sad Beautiful Tragic
07.0 The Lucky One
08.0 Everything Has Changed (feat. Ed Sheeran)
10.0 Starlight
08.0 Begin Again
06.0 The Moment I Knew
06.0 Come Back... Be Here
08.0 Girl At Home