Printable version of thread

Posted by: Jay* 16th June 2020, 07:55 PM

When voting, take into account a number of things if possible! What you like the best, and what you feel you'd most likely vote for - both very important factors, of course! Also try and think of it in terms of what you believe the best choice for the forum could be. No sabotage please

Mel B when she sees this poll and sees that neither Word Up or Lullaby made the cut


If you don't know all the songs... have a listen if you can!








Your feedback is welcomed

Posted by: JosephStyles 16th June 2020, 07:59 PM

On the Horizon to slay

Posted by: Jonjo 16th June 2020, 08:00 PM

'On The Horizon' is my favourite, but I think 'Loving You' would be the best option of the 3!

If OTH gets a chance though *.*

Posted by: Nick F1 16th June 2020, 08:42 PM

Desire.

Posted by: Spiceboy 16th June 2020, 08:43 PM

I actually really like Desire but love that you said one that's not here.

Posted by: Nick F1 16th June 2020, 08:45 PM

Desire is only option IMO.

Posted by: Maz! 16th June 2020, 08:51 PM

On The Horizon

Posted by: JaneJ 16th June 2020, 08:51 PM

Loving you but I saw some comments it's so dull. I feel old liking this song and the song is not even that old.
May I request all five spice emojis?

Posted by: Jay* 16th June 2020, 10:07 PM

I'd love for them to all have one

~

I'm going to listen to all 3 songs imminently. Obviously I'm very familiar with all 3, but maybe I need a fresh listen.

Posted by: Spiceboy 16th June 2020, 10:10 PM

I genuinely cannot choose.

Loving you is my favourite.
On the horizon feels like the most upbeat and instant for a listen.
Headlines is the Spice Girls track so may get more than a solo one.

Posted by: Jay* 16th June 2020, 10:58 PM

Taking the rates into account:

Spice Rate 2019:
6.648 - 39. On the Horizon MELANIE C
6.727 - 38. Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) SPICE GIRLS
7.690 - 21. Loving You MELANIE C

Solo Rate (obviously doesn't include Headlines):
13. Melanie C (Ft Matt Cardle) = 7.518
26. Melanie C - On The Horizon = 6.574


On the Horizon would be a bit of a curve ball considering it often doesn't fare too well in rates. Loving You does decently, on paper it seems like the song that would be generally most liked.

Posted by: Jonjo 16th June 2020, 11:10 PM

Those averages aren't even close enough to make you think "maybe we'll risk the other"...

Just send LY It's a recent-ish chart hit. So may get more casual interest than OTH. And Headlines is widely regarded as an awful comeback for one of the most successful groups of all time, so I don't think it'll resonate well at all and I think it'd be a similar fate to Katy going with a 'Witness' track last round... people will immediately dismiss it.

Posted by: Jay* 17th June 2020, 12:38 AM

You're probably right I suppose nothing is guaranteed at this point, even those voting Headlines or On the Horizon might not go for them when confronted with what Rihanna, Madonna and Gaga are sending. It would be nice to feel like we're somewhat in contention in the next round and not be a distant last, if we're going to be last!

If we do go with Loving You, hopefully it could surprise in the same way that it surprised most people when it became a Top 20 hit in 2013!

Posted by: T Boy 17th June 2020, 08:43 AM

I’m a massive Matt Cardle fan and think that Loving You would easily rank first for me if it was chosen.

Posted by: J🐠hq 17th June 2020, 10:08 AM

I love "Loving You"! I've not checked what the Madonna options are, but I'd rank it higher than what Rihanna and Gaga are likely to send personally

Posted by: Mr.X 17th June 2020, 10:43 AM

This might be the first time Im not keen on any of the entries from this sub forum...

Voted for Headlines because it is the best out of a terrible list of songs.

Posted by: Rush 17th June 2020, 11:31 AM

I only know 'Loving You' (I like it and remember it well but it wouldn't make my vote) so I can't comment, but omg if Melanie C gets her fourth solo entry while none of the others have had any :')

Melanie C taking after Nicole Scherzinger

Posted by: JosephStyles 17th June 2020, 11:52 AM

It's what the queen deserves

The other members finding out they haven't been sent once

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 17th June 2020, 02:54 PM

I adore loving you but i also really like on the horizon aswell, headlines is my least fave from the 3 but loving you gets my vote

Posted by: Feel_The_Fever 17th June 2020, 03:58 PM

Great to see loving you gone through and I've voted for it, hopefully it gets the votes needed to go through now.