Hey everyone, over the last few months you have all been voting for your least favourite song, video and single cover and for each round points were allocated. Its now time to see just how you all voted and to find out what song is the ultimate package.
The aim is to post a minimum of 1 song per day but will post more depending on interactions from forum members.
Lets get the discussions going, there will be A LOT of surprises, lets see what you think about where your favourites appear, are songs too high or too low based on what you expected ? how did the biggest sellers do ? how did the fan favourites do ?
Time to find out
! Excited to see how these results pan out!
Number 23 - The lady is a tramp - 27 Points
Points Breakdown
Song - 0 out of a possible 500
Video - 9 out of a possible 500
Cover - 18 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
This whole era was such a none event for me, I can only assume the hardcore fans liked it, she lost me with Artpop but killed me with this. The next era is make or break for me musicwise. Obviously its a great vocal, it is Gaga afterall but still very meh overal
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
You know we're dealing with TALENT when such a gorgeous cover comes in last.
Meh. No real opinions on this!
Number 22 - Chillin - 53 Points
Points Breakdown
Song - 21 out of a possible 500
Video - 16 out of a possible 500
Cover - 16 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
I actually forgot all this and expected it too be last. I don't think I ever listened it since the first day it came out, very forgettable and not really Gaga for me
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Cute song but quite forgettable in the grand scheme of things ~
Number 21 - Til it happens to you - 90 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 27 out of a possible 500
Song - 27 out of a possible 500
Video - 36 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
This song totally passed me by when it came out, I love its message and what it stands for but I just never really thought it was a stand out song and still don't.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Til It Happens To You deserved better
Number 7 - Cheek to cheek (Album) - 83 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 58 out of a possible 600
Song Selection - 17 out of a possible 600
Album - 8 out of a possible 600
Personal Opinion
No shock here regarding the Lady Gaga album to come last, if i'm honest, I have not even listened to this album so I cant comment on the quality but based on what I have heard, a lot of fan disregard it, the cover is though.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
No surprises so far.
Yep no losses at all!
Number 20 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say) - 334 Points
Points Breakdown
Song - 119 out of a possible 500
Cover - 111 out of a possible 500
Video - 104 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
So yeah the single cover isn't that great and the video isn't out there like most of her videos at the time but I have always really liked the song and its a shame we didn't get it as a release in the UK.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
"Eh Eh" is so cute and summery and just adorable
Cute song but it really got overshadowed by the singles on the album being so in your face. I still enjoy it when I hear it though
Number 19 - Joanne - 401 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 146 out of a possible 500
Video - 146 out of a possible 500
Song - 109 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
This whole era was lost of me, I don't even think I gave the album more than a few listens, you can fault gaga as at talent vocally or performance wise, I just like my gaga more poppy/dance and just upbeat in general.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Beautiful song. Not a fave but for what it stands for, we appreciate and respect.
I never return to it but it's a gorgeous song
Number 18 - Alejandro - 434 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 222 out of a possible 500
Video - 157 out of a possible 500
Song - 55 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
Its hard to fault pretty much anything within the Fame to the Born this way era and this is no exception, its not my favourite Gaga song but its certainly more than average and as usual, the video is as entertaining as they always are.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Deserves to be higher! The artwork is STUNNING and the song is incredible too. I like the video artistically but it doesn't fit with the song at all really.
Whoa @ Alejandro being so low An absolute TUNE and the video is one of her best.
I'm shocked too tbh! Just shows how loved her other songs are I guess.
Number 6 - Artpop (Album) - 530 Points
Points Breakdown
Album - 208 out of a possible 600
Song Selection - 193 out of a possible 600
Cover - 129 out of a possible 600
Personal Opinion
This is were it all went wrong for me, its not a terrible album but its not a great one either, horrendous album cover too Applause just isn't a strong 1st single and ones that followed were that great either.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Ugh. ARTPOP is underrated af
Aura/Sexxx Dreams/Manicure/Do What U Want/ARTPOP/Swine/Gypsy all say f*** off to being 6th
The cover letting it down
Number 17 - You and I - 523 Points
Points Breakdown
Video - 208 out of a possible 500
Song - 163 out of a possible 500
Cover - 153 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
I was never a big fan of this, there were so many better options on the album in my opinion and I always thought the video was a bit too excessive for the song, even for gaga.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
You & I beating Alejandro 🤣
One of my fave Gaga songs. Holds a lot of memories for me
Screaming "SIX WHOLE YEARS" back at her while she performed it on tour was always a highlight too
Artpop coming in low is no suprise
You and I song, video and single cover are all weaker than Alejandro's so I don't know how it beat it!
Number 16 - Judas - 538 Points
Points Breakdown
Video - 318 out of a possible 500
Song - 205 out of a possible 500
Cover - 18 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
I know this lost a lot of votes due the single cover but I remember at the time of its release, a lot of people considered this to be her weakest single which I don't get, I have always loved it and its still one of my favourites.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Awful cover but incredible video. Song is good ~
SO. LOW.
Brilliant song. THAT is how you do cheesy bubblegum pop. The bridge is f'n incredible too <3
Artpop is such a good album!!!!!
Number 15 - Born this way - 644 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 340 out of a possible 500
Song - 240 out of a possible 500
Video - 64 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
I thought this would be higher but as a video its not her best and the same goes for the single cover, still a great song though.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Wow! Another shock.
I guess the video isn't really loved by many and the artwork is either love or hate. Still I expected this much closer (or within!) the top 10
Video is fabulous, cover is iconic, and the song is one of her best. 15th? Absolute JOKE.
Number 5 - Joanne (Album) - 535 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 278 out of a possible 600
Album - 133 out of a possible 600
Song Selection - 124 out of a possible 600
Personal Opinion
I think I only listened to this album only a few times but it simply just didn't work for me, songs album, boring singles, boring visuals.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
I’m surprised Joanne is higher than Artpop
Number 14 - Telephone - 679 Points
Points Breakdown
Video - 397 out of a possible 500
Song - 155 out of a possible 500
Cover - 127 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
If it wasn't for the terrible cover this would and should have been higher, could have been worse, she could have released "Videophone"
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
These results are full of shocks! It's one of her most popular songs so to see it at #14 is surprising. I love it but I wouldn't put it up there with the likes of Dance In The Dark and Bad Romance tbh.
Telephone video is a masterpiece and still her best. The song is good but not an absolute favourite of mine!
Number 13 - Love Game - 700 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 247 out of a possible 500
Video - 233 out of a possible 500
Song - 220 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
This should have done so much better in the UK, I seem to remember the other singles were still doing well at the time but that could be wrong, doesn't make sense why this couldn't get top 10
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Underrated! But it's done well here
Number 12 - Perfect Illusion - 711 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 237 out of a possible 500
Video - 237 out of a possible 500
Song - 237 out of a possible 500
Personal Opinion
First single material ? really ? I find this song so hard to listen too, especially the chorus, the points spread is very interesting though.
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Love Game i now enjoy despite not liking it for sometime.
Perfect Illusion i really liked initially but don't like it now.
PI has done well! Helped by having such an electric video and unique single cover.
Number 4 - A star is born (Album) - 1,019 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 397 out of a possible 600
Song Selection - 314 out of a possible 600
Album - 308 out of a possible 600
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
L O V E
Number 11 - Do what you want - 765 Points
Points Breakdown
Song - 361 out of a possible 500
Cover - 273 out of a possible 500
Video - 131 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Amazing song, let down by single cover and... of course, the video :/
I just watched the clip from the video again and just...no.
Excellent song tho.
Number 10 - Million Reasons - 778 Points
Points Breakdown
Cover - 324 out of a possible 500
Song - 236 out of a possible 500
Video - 218 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
The highlight from "Joanne". I don't return to it often but it's an incredible song.
I don't return to it much either but it's always a delight when I do.
Number 9 - Shallow - 823 Points
Points Breakdown
Song - 391 out of a possible 500
Cover - 268 out of a possible 500
Video - 164 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Only #09 One of her best songs. Modern day classic.
TOO LOW
Number 3 - Born this way (Album) - 1,106 Points
Points Breakdown
Album - 491 out of a possible 600
Song Selection - 388 out of a possible 600
Cover - 227 out of a possible 600
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Should be #01. My favourite album of all tme.
Yep, denied a #1 spot!
Number 8 - G.U.Y - 844 Points
Video - 389 out of a possible 500
Song - 237 out of a possible 500
Cover - 218 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Everything about G.U.Y. is amazing. Song, video and cover, we STAN!
I don't think G.U.Y. has aged very well
Number 7 - The edge of glory - 881 Points
Song - 390 out of a possible 500
Cover - 373 out of a possible 500
Video - 118 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
The Edgy of Glory is a solid single with a catchy hook in the chorus.
Her best single in my opinion! The video making it fail slightly here RIP x
Number 6 - Just Dance - 925 Points
Cover - 343 out of a possible 500
Song - 309 out of a possible 500
Video - 273 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Just Dance, great debut that help set her career up but she has since delivered so much stronger tracks.
Not going Top 5 is fair on this poll result.
TEOG shoulda been top 5. One of her absolute best
Just Dance hasn't aged one bit for me. Where it all began...
A classic! The memories
You're not a true Gaga fan if you don't sing RED WINE instead of REDONE x
Yay G.U.Y is amazing
Number 2 - The Fame (Album) - 1,365 Points
Points Breakdown
Song Selection - 503 out of a possible 600
Cover - 470 out of a possible 600
Album - 392 out of a possible 600
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
I think there's 4 Gaga albums I now prefer over The Fame :') but the cover art is iconic and the single selection was FLAWLESS, no denying that - just a fair few fillers.
Yeah, the singles were incredible but there is a bit of filler. Not in my top 3 fave Gaga albums.
There's only about 5 songs on the fame that I can still listen to, the rest I've always found to be complete filler. It's nowhere near her 2nd best!
I think The Fame is possibly slightly romanticized because the singles were SO strong and iconic and memorable
Number 5 - Applause - 1,049 Points
Cover - 431 out of a possible 500
Video - 316 out of a possible 500
Song - 302 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Her worst single ;o
Applause being higher than The Edge of Glory is...bizarre.
5th?!!! Ridic!
The cover clearly saved it
Number 4 - Poker Face - 1,129 Points
Song - 451 out of a possible 500
Video - 431 out of a possible 500
Cover - 247 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
ICONIC. Pop perfection.
Still 10/10!
Number 3 - Paparazzi - 1,159 Points
Video - 443 out of a possible 500
Song - 379 out of a possible 500
Cover - 337 out of a possible 500
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
One of her earliest songs which I still constantly play. Her best video for me and it easily deserves its top 3 placing
Incredible video! Her first 'masterpiece' ~
Number 1 - The Fame monster (Album) - 1,663 Points
Points Breakdown
Album - 561 out of a possible 600
Song Selection - 561 out of a possible 600
Cover - 541 out of a possible 600
What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss
Wouldn't be #1 as album alone for me, but I guess when considering the incredible artwork and single selection.. yeah I can accept that!
Number 2 - Marry the night - 1,293 Points
Video - 447 out of a possible 500
Song - 439 out of a possible 500
Cover - 407 out of a possible 500
Number 1 - Bad Romance - 1,327 Points
Song - 457 out of a possible 500
Video - 450 out of a possible 500
Cover - 420 out of a possible 500
Marry The Night getting success!!!! Deserved.
Bad Romance really is the complete package in every single way, so its win here is obviously warranted.
Thanks for running this Dannyboy
SO F'N HAPPY about MTN being top 2. It's an underrated masterpiece and one of my favourite all time songs.
Bad Romance being #01 was always going to happen. The definition of a modern day classic
Points Breakdown
Final Positions
1 - Bad Romance
2 - Marry the night
3 - Paparazzi
4 - Poker Face
5 - Applause
6 - Just Dance
7 - The edge of glory
8 - G.U.Y
9 - Shallow
10 - Million Reasons
11 - Do what you want
12 - Perfect Illusion
13 - Love Game
14 - Telephone
15 - Born this way
16 - Judas
17 - You and I
18 - Alejandro
19 - Joanne
20 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say)
21 - Til it happens to you
22 - Chillin
23 - The lady is a tramp
Final Positions (based on video points)
1 - Bad Romance ( Non Mover )
2 - Marry the night ( Non Mover )
3 - Paparazzi ( Non Mover )
4 - Poker Face (Non mover)
5 - Telephone ( UP 9 )
6 - G.U.Y ( UP 2 )
7 - Applause ( DOWN 2 )
8 - Judas ( UP 8 )
9 - Just Dance ( DOWN 3 )
10 - Perfect Illusion ( UP 2 )
11 - Love Game ( UP 2 )
12 - Million Reasons ( DOWN 2 )
13 - You and I ( UP 4 )
14 - Shallow ( UP 5 )
15 - Alejandro ( UP 3 )
16 - Joanne ( UP 3 )
17 - Do what you want ( DOWN 6 )
18 - The edge of glory ( DOWN 11 )
19 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say) ( UP 1 )
20 - Born this way ( DOWN 5 )
21 - Til it happens to you ( Non Mover )
22 - Chillin ( Non Mover )
23 - The lady is a tramp ( Non Mover )
Points Breakdown
Final Positions
1 - Bad Romance
2 - Marry the night
3 - Paparazzi
4 - Poker Face
5 - Applause
6 - Just Dance
7 - The edge of glory
8 - G.U.Y
9 - Shallow
10 - Million Reasons
11 - Do what you want
12 - Perfect Illusion
13 - Love Game
14 - Telephone
15 - Born this way
16 - Judas
17 - You and I
18 - Alejandro
19 - Joanne
20 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say)
21 - Til it happens to you
22 - Chillin
23 - The lady is a tramp
Final Positions (based on single cover points)
1 - Applause ( UP 4 )
2 - Bad Romance ( DOWN 1 )
3 - Marry the night ( DOWN 1 )
4 - The edge of glory ( UP 3 )
5 - Just Dance ( UP 1 )
6 - Born this way ( UP 9 )
7 - Paparazzi ( DOWN 4 )
8 - Million Reasons ( UP 2 )
9 - Do what you want ( UP 2 )
10 - Shallow ( DOWN 1 )
11 - Poker Face ( DOWN 7 )
12 - Love Game ( UP 1 )
13 - Perfect Illusion ( DOWN 1 )
14 - Alejandro ( UP 4 )
15 - G.U.Y ( DOWN 7 )
16 - You and I ( UP 1 )
17 - Joanne ( UP 2 )
18 - Telephone ( DOWN 4 )
19 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say) ( UP 1 )
20 - Til it happens to you ( UP 1 )
21 - Judas ( DOWN 5 )
22 - The lady is a tramp ( UP 1 )
23 - Chillin ( DOWN 1 )
Points Breakdown
Final Positions
1 - Bad Romance
2 - Marry the night
3 - Paparazzi
4 - Poker Face
5 - Applause
6 - Just Dance
7 - The edge of glory
8 - G.U.Y
9 - Shallow
10 - Million Reasons
11 - Do what you want
12 - Perfect Illusion
13 - Love Game
14 - Telephone
15 - Born this way
16 - Judas
17 - You and I
18 - Alejandro
19 - Joanne
20 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say)
21 - Til it happens to you
22 - Chillin
23 - The lady is a tramp
Final Positions (based on song points)
1 - Bad Romance ( Non mover )
2 - Poker Face ( UP 2 )
3 - Marry the night ( DOWN 1 )
4 - Shallow ( UP 5 )
5 - The edge of glory ( UP 2 )
6 - Paparazzi ( DOWN 3 )
7 - Do what you want ( DOWN 4 )
8 - Just Dance ( DOWN 2 )
9 - Applause ( DOWN 4 )
10 - Born this way ( UP 5 )
11 - G.U.Y ( DOWN 3 )
12 - Perfect Illusion ( Non mover )
13 - Million Reasons ( DOWN 3 )
14 - Love Game ( DOWN 1 )
15 - Judas ( UP 1 )
16 - You and I ( UP 1 )
17 - Telephone ( DOWN 3 )
18 - Eh Eh (nothing else I can say) ( UP 2 )
19 - Joanne ( Non mover )
20 - Alejandro ( DOWN 2 )
21 - Til it happens to you ( Non mover )
22 - Chillin ( Non mover )
23 - The lady is a tramp ( Non mover )
Yeah, thanks Danny! Much appreciated.
Applause single cover beating Bad Romance's single cover Didn't see that one coming!
It’s been a pleasure, thank you for everyones contributions
Make sure you stick around in the forum Dannyboy and keep posting!
What an excellent Top 2 in the end.
Powered by Invision Power Board
© Invision Power Services