Printable version of thread

Click here to view this topic in its original format

BuzzJack Music Forum _ Reality TV _ Dream X Factor all stars line-up

Posted by: Liаm Oct 17 2017, 03:39 PM

If hypothetically X Factor did a best of or all stars series, who would you put in each category? Imagine everyone is available and willing

Posted by: TheGhostPensmith Oct 17 2017, 03:43 PM

Oooh...good question! Do we assign them according to their category they were in when they were on the show? If so, then I think these would be in mine:

BOYS
Shayne Ward
Marcus Collins
Jahmene Douglas

GROUPS
JLS
Little Mix
Jedward (completely so they could do their version of Oops I Did it Again. Again)

GIRLS
Alexandra Burke
Leona Lewis
Diana Vickers

OVERS
Olly Murs
Ruth Lorenzo
Wagner (again, for the lols. She Bangs, anyone?)

Posted by: Sonia Fowler Oct 17 2017, 03:47 PM

Boys
Leon Jackson (controversial opinion but I was a stan of his )
Matt Terry
Llyod Daniels
Sam Callahan

(I just choose the 4 guys I stanned the most )

Girls
Diana Vickers
Misha B
Alexandra Burke
Louisa Johnson

Groups
Little Mix
1D (relucent add since well one of the biggest X factor exports)
Union J
Jedward (HEY it wouldnt be X factor without a Joke act and this was the creme de la creme of joke act)

Overs
Matt Cardle
Leona Lewis
Olly Murs
Saara Alto

Posted by: Liаm Oct 17 2017, 03:48 PM

Girls
Leona Lewis
Alexandra Burke
Louisa Johnson
Wildcard: Rebecca Ferguson

Boys
Matt Cardle
Andrea Faustini
Shayne Ward
Wildcard: Seann Miley Moore

Overs:
Olly Murs
Saara Aalto
Fleur East
Wildcard: Ruth Lorenzo

Groups:
Little Mix
JLS
Same Difference (f*** it x)
and idk for a wildcard, I guess 1D as like LM they are a quintessential XF act

Posted by: Sonia Fowler Oct 17 2017, 03:49 PM

Oh wait was Matt Carlde in the boys category?

Posted by: PeteFromLeeds Oct 17 2017, 03:54 PM

Overs:
Beverley Trotman
Danyl Johnson
Relley C
Carolynne Poole
(Saara and Wagner next in line)

Groups:
Same Difference
Reggie 'n' Bollie
MK1
Only The Young

Boys:
Eoghan Quigg
Rikki Loney
Paije Richardson
Craig Colton

Girls:
Janet Devlin
Lucy Spraggan
Emily Middlemas
Monica Michael

(sorry for the 'obscure' choices, just went for the people I was mad about in their respective contests)

Posted by: Jack Oct 19 2017, 03:51 PM

I'd like no winners to be included / people who didn't get a chance to properly shine involved so;

BOYS
Seann Miley Moore
Sam Callahan
Jack Walton
(Marcus Collins)

GIRLS
Rachel Adedeji
Laura White
Misha B
(Cher Lloyd)

GROUPS
Only The Young
Alien Uncovered
Miss Dynamix
(Same Difference)

OVERS
Ruth Lorenzo
Fleur East
Relley C
(Saara Aalto)

Posted by: HobDoblin Oct 19 2017, 06:49 PM

Boys:
Mason Noize
Matt Terry
Rhydian Roberts
Tabby Callaghan

Girls:
Cher Lloyd
Sophie Habibis
Lucie Jones
Lauren Murray

Overs:
Wagner
Honey G
Olly Murs
Ruth Lorenzo

Groups:
G4
Little Mix
Reggie N Bollie
4Tune

Posted by: RobBob Oct 20 2017, 12:19 AM

Yeah, I'm gonna treat it the same way of NO WINNERS or people who have had a successful career (which is largely just JLS, Olly Murs and One Direction) but inclusive of artists who may have had one or two hits but would be in need of a career reboot.

BOYS:
* Aiden Grimshaw
* Rhydian Roberts
* Seann Miley Moore
* Andrea Faustini

GIRLS:
* Diana Vickers
* Misha B
* Stacey Solomon
* Cher Lloyd

GROUPS:
* Same Difference
* Union J
* Reggie N Bollie
* Hope

OVERS:
* Saara Aalto
* Fleur East
* Ruth Lorenzo
* Wagner

Posted by: Jack Oct 20 2017, 08:54 AM

I actually want this to be a real thing

I think it'd re-ignite people's interest in X Factor as well!

Posted by: Liаm Oct 20 2017, 01:35 PM

Yeah It'd be so good with the reboot career angle actually! Like ages ago on ITV when they did that thing I think called Baby One More Time it had 80s and 90s singers who had long since faded trying to get another chance at a career That didn't do that well but if they did it properly it'd be such a good idea, especially to capitalise on the old days of XF when people actually cared. Then again they can't handle the actual XF winners, let alone the second chancers who'd win this

Posted by: jafetsigfinns Oct 20 2017, 01:50 PM

Basing this on current age and for an all-star season I think a cast of 16 would only be fitting so I'm choosing the following.

GIRLS
Alexandra Burke
Louisa Johnson
Cher Lloyd
Ella Henderson

BOYS
Joe McElderry
Aiden Grimshaw
James Arthur
Luke Friend

GROUPS
JLS
5 After Midnight
One Direction
Little Mix

OVER 30S
Fleur East
Leona Lewis
Olly Murs
Matt Cardle

Posted by: Spiceboy Oct 21 2017, 10:20 PM

This is such a cool idea, I'd actually watch X-Factor again for this.

Boys
Joe McElderry
James Arthur
Ray Quinn
Andre Faustini or Marcus Collins

Girls
Alexandra Burke
Elle Henderson
Cher Lloyd
Stacey Solomon or Louisa Johnson

Over 30
Leona Lewis
Olly Murs
Shayne Ward
Matt Cardle

Groups
One Direction
Little Mix
JLS
G4

I've mainly gone for acts who performed well on the show originally and who had careers recording, on stage or in the public eye, away from the show as this would be much more of a draw than the 'failed' contestants coming back which would appear more 'desperate.'