Printable version of thread

Posted by: Acidburn 14th December 2015, 06:49 PM

I think One Direction have now had enough singles to make a rate, with 18 in total and plus they are about to take a long break. So now is the time for you all to rate all of they're back catalogue. From 2011 to 2015, they achieved a lot during these short years, 5 albums and millions sold worldwide, making them one of the most successful boy bands of all time.

Usual rules apply rate each track between 0 and 10. You can rate use one 11 and one -1, but that's optional and also half marks are allowed, but please no 10.5's or 0.5's. You can however use as many 10's as you want.




xx.x What Makes You Beautiful
xx.x Gotta Be You
xx.x One Thing
xx.x More Than This
xx.x Live While We're Young
xx.x Little Things
xx.x Kiss You
xx.x One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
xx.x Best Song Ever
xx.x Story Of My Life
xx.x Midnight Memories
xx.x You And I
xx.x Steal My Girl
xx.x Night Changes
xx.x Drag Me Down
xx.x Perfect
xx.x History


I'll be keeping this open for a couple of weeks, haven't quite decided yet so there's plenty of time for everybody to vote.

Posted by: Adam's Satsuma🙁 14th December 2015, 06:57 PM

9.5 What Makes You Beautiful
7.5 Gotta Be You
11 One Thing (I love this one for some reason!)
xx.x More Than This
10 Live While We're Young
6 Little Things kind of nice but kind of boring at the same time...
8.5 Kiss You guilty pleashh
-1 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks) sorry but this should never have happened imo
4 Best Song Ever kind of catchy but the video is so cringy and this song is certainly not the best song ever also I was in agony seeing this had a potential to knock off KingVicii from the top :/
9 Story Of My Life
7 Midnight Memories
8 You And I
8 Steal My Girl
6.5 Night Changes
6 Drag Me Down
7.5 Perfect
xx.x Infinity
xx.x History

Posted by: JosephCarey 14th December 2015, 07:14 PM

The next single is definitely History, they've said so themselves Might be best to remove that one ~

YAY for this happening though *.*

11.0 What Makes You Beautiful
06.0 Gotta Be You
08.0 One Thing
10.0 More Than This
09.0 Live While We're Young
09.0 Little Things
10.0 Kiss You
09.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10.0 Best Song Ever
09.0 Story Of My Life
07.5 Midnight Memories
08.5 You And I
08.5 Steal My Girl
10.0 Night Changes
10.0 Drag Me Down
09.0 Perfect
(08.5 Infinity)
09.0 History

Incredible.

Posted by: TheGrinch 14th December 2015, 07:19 PM

10.0 What Makes You Beautiful
-1.0 Gotta Be You
11.0 One Thing
10.0 More Than This
10.0 Live While We're Young
10.0 Little Things
07.0 Kiss You
08.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
08.0 Best Song Ever
08.0 Story Of My Life
02.0 Midnight Memories
03.0 You And I
07.0 Steal My Girl
08.0 Night Changes
08.0 Drag Me Down
07.5 Perfect
08.0 History

Posted by: Acidburn 14th December 2015, 07:55 PM

11.0 What Makes You Beautiful
06.5 Gotta Be You
10.0 One Thing
08.0 More Than This
10.0 Live While We're Young
09.0 Little Things
10.0 Kiss You
07.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10.0 Best Song Ever
10.0 Story Of My Life
07.5 Midnight Memories
09.5 You And I
08.0 Steal My Girl
10.0 Night Changes
10.0 Drag Me Down
10.0 Perfect
09.0 History


I have removed Infinity, as History is definitely confirmed as their latest single.

Posted by: Qween 14th December 2015, 10:01 PM

11.0 What Makes You Beautiful
08.0 Gotta Be You
09.0 One Thing
09.0 More Than This
08.0 Live While We're Young
-1.0 Little Things
08.0 Kiss You
06.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
08.0 Best Song Ever
07.0 Story Of My Life
08.5 Midnight Memories
08.5 You And I
09.0 Steal My Girl
07.0 Night Changes
06.5 Drag Me Down
08.5 Perfect
05.5 History

Posted by: Jimmy Jam 15th December 2015, 12:21 AM

10.0 - What Makes You Beautiful
-1.0 - Gotta Be You
10.0 - One Thing
04.5 - More Than This
07.5 - Live While We're Young
03.5 - Little Things
11.0 - Kiss You
08.0 - One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10.0 - Best Song Ever
09.0 - Story of My Life
01.0 - Midnight Memories
10.0 - You & I
08.0 - Steal My Girl
09.5 - Night Changes
10.0 - Drag Me Down
10.0 - Perfect
08.0 - History

Posted by: Aled. 15th December 2015, 04:45 PM

08.0 What Makes You Beautiful
05.0 Gotta Be You
07.5 One Thing
05.5 More Than This
07.0 Live While We're Young
00.0 Little Things
08.0 Kiss You
03.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
07.0 Best Song Ever
09.0 Story Of My Life
02.0 Midnight Memories
06.5 You And I
07.0 Steal My Girl
08.0 Night Changes
07.0 Drag Me Down
06.5 Perfect
06.5 History

Posted by: Liаm 15th December 2015, 05:09 PM

11 What Makes You Beautiful
-1 Gotta Be You
08 One Thing
06 More Than This
07 Live While We're Young
03 Little Things
08 Kiss You
02 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
09 Story Of My Life
07 Midnight Memories
04 You And I
08 Steal My Girl
07 Night Changes
06 Drag Me Down
03 Perfect
04 History

Posted by: Beatrix Kiddo 16th December 2015, 10:47 PM

10.0 What Makes You Beautiful
06.0 Gotta Be You
09.0 One Thing
08.0 More Than This
08.5 Live While We're Young
10.0 Little Things
09.0 Kiss You
07.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10.0 Best Song Ever
11.0 Story Of My Life
05.0 Midnight Memories
08.0 You And I
08.0 Steal My Girl
10.0 Night Changes
08.5 Drag Me Down
09.0 Perfect
07.5 History

Posted by: mr_pmt 17th December 2015, 01:52 AM

08 What Makes You Beautiful
-1 Gotta Be You
09 One Thing
07 More Than This
06 Live While We're Young
05 Little Things
11 Kiss You
04 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
09 Story Of My Life
08 Midnight Memories
06 You And I
08 Steal My Girl
09 Night Changes
08 Drag Me Down
09 Perfect
07 History

Some cracking singles in their back catalogue, seeing them all here really makes me realise it.

Posted by: J▲hq 17th December 2015, 10:19 AM

11.0 What Makes You Beautiful
01.0 Gotta Be You
09.0 One Thing
05.0 More Than This
07.0 Live While We're Young
09.0 Little Things
06.0 Kiss You
09.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
09.0 Best Song Ever
10.0 Story Of My Life
02.0 Midnight Memories
07.0 You And I
07.5 Steal My Girl
09.5 Night Changes
09.0 Drag Me Down
09.0 Perfect
08.5 History

Posted by: Maurince Pie 17th December 2015, 12:50 PM

09.5 What Makes You Beautiful
06.0 Gotta Be You
11.0 One Thing
07.0 More Than This
08.0 Live While We're Young
06.5 Little Things
09.0 Kiss You
07.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10.0 Best Song Ever
09.0 Story Of My Life
06.0 Midnight Memories
06.5 You And I
09.0 Steal My Girl
07.0 Night Changes
10.0 Drag Me Down
09.5 Perfect
10.0 History

Posted by: 🌚🌚🌚 17th December 2015, 12:59 PM

oh my god the zayn pics! the tru swan

00 What Makes You Beautiful
02 Gotta Be You
05 One Thing
00 More Than This
04 Live While We're Young
09 Little Things
04 Kiss You
-1 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
00 Best Song Ever
02 Story Of My Life
00 Midnight Memories
11 You And I
08 Steal My Girl
08 Night Changes
10 Drag Me Down
09 Perfect
06 History

well they're definitely improved

Posted by: 🌚🌚🌚 17th December 2015, 01:07 PM

larry comin to haunt y'all you and I haters in ya dreams

Posted by: TheGrinch 17th December 2015, 01:15 PM

maurice knowing one thing is the best thing they've ever done.

Posted by: Kylie Jackson 17th December 2015, 01:39 PM

10 What Makes You Beautiful
5 Gotta Be You
6 One Thing
7 More Than This
9.5 Live While We're Young
8.5 Little Things
10 Kiss You
7.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
11 Story Of My Life
5.5 Midnight Memories
9 You And I
8.5 Steal My Girl
10 Night Changes
9 Drag Me Down
10 Perfect
7.5 History

Posted by: J▲hq 17th December 2015, 02:20 PM

QUOTE(🌚🌚🌚 @ Dec 17 2015, 12:59 PM)

QUOTE(🌚🌚🌚 @ Dec 16 2015, 02:43 PM)

Posted by: Doboggan 17th December 2015, 03:16 PM

10 What Makes You Beautiful
05 Gotta Be You
10 One Thing
04 More Than This
07 Live While We're Young
11 Little Things
09 Kiss You
06 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
08 Best Song Ever
04 Story Of My Life
09 Midnight Memories
-1 You And I
07 Steal My Girl
06 Night Changes
09 Drag Me Down
07 Perfect
08 History

Posted by: AdventAloud 17th December 2015, 05:38 PM

09.0 What Makes You Beautiful
-1.0 Gotta Be You
08.0 One Thing
08.5 More Than This
08.5 Live While We're Young
06.0 Little Things
10.0 Kiss You
06.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
09.0 Best Song Ever
09.0 Story Of My Life
08.0 Midnight Memories
11.0 You And I
10.0 Steal My Girl
09.0 Night Changes
03.0 Drag Me Down
08.0 Perfect
05.0 History

Posted by: Davidson 17th December 2015, 05:42 PM

08.0 What Makes You Beautiful
-01.0 Gotta Be You
10.0 One Thing
09.5 More Than This
07.5 Live While We're Young
03.0 Little Things
08.5 Kiss You
02.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
09.0 Best Song Ever
07.5 Story Of My Life
07.0 Midnight Memories
05.0 You And I
07.0 Steal My Girl
07.5 Night Changes
06.0 Drag Me Down
09.0 Perfect
05.0 History

Posted by: 🌚🌚🌚 17th December 2015, 05:43 PM

eheheh

usually like the cheese but with 1D I definitely prefer their newer less cheesy stuff

Posted by: Acidburn 18th December 2015, 03:41 PM

I will be keeping this open until December 28th

Posted by: bartsimpson 19th December 2015, 09:51 PM

11 What Makes You Beautiful
4.5 Gotta Be You
08 One Thing
07 More Than This
8.5 Live While We're Young
09 Little Things
10 Kiss You
5.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
10 Story Of My Life
09 Midnight Memories
9.5 You And I
6.5 Steal My Girl
8.5 Night Changes
08 Drag Me Down
9.5 Perfect
8.5 History

Posted by: Slick 20th December 2015, 12:34 AM

10 What Makes You Beautiful
06 Gotta Be You
07 One Thing
05 More Than This
09 Live While We're Young
08 Little Things
09 Kiss You
07 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
09 Story Of My Life
07 Midnight Memories
06 You And I
08 Steal My Girl
07 Night Changes
08 Drag Me Down
07 Perfect
06 History

Posted by: Fgiboy2511 20th December 2015, 03:49 AM

8 What Makes You Beautiful
4 Gotta Be You
6 One Thing
3 More Than This
8 Live While We're Young
5 Little Things
6 Kiss You
9 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
10 Story Of My Life
-1 Midnight Memories
2 You And I
9 Steal My Girl
11 Night Changes
7 Drag Me Down
8 Perfect
8 History

Posted by: MIKEMYER 25th December 2015, 09:19 PM

10 What Makes You Beautiful
04 Gotta Be You
06 One Thing
05 More Than This
09 Live While We're Young
08 Little Things
11 Kiss You
7.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
10 Story Of My Life
08 Midnight Memories
09 You And I
07 Steal My Girl
10 Night Changes
09 Drag Me Down
09 Perfect
08 History

Posted by: Acidburn 27th December 2015, 10:21 PM

Right then I have freed up some time and decided to close this a bit earlier, so sorry guys, but the new date that this will be closing on is December 30th 2015.

So thanks for all your votes so far, so any more will be more than welcome.

Posted by: MerryFlynnmas 28th December 2015, 06:06 PM

00.0 What Makes You Beautiful
-1.0 Gotta Be You
08.5 One Thing
xx.x More Than This
02.5 Live While We're Young
10.0 Little Things
07.0 Kiss You
00.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
05.0 Best Song Ever
11.0 Story Of My Life
00.0 Midnight Memories
07.0 You And I
01.0 Steal My Girl
06.5 Night Changes
05.0 Drag Me Down
04.0 Perfect
10.0 History

Posted by: James Silkstone 29th December 2015, 06:11 PM

09 What Makes You Beautiful
01 Gotta Be You
09 One Thing
07 More Than This
06 Live While We're Young
-1 Little Things
10 Kiss You
04 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
11 Story Of My Life
03 Midnight Memories
09 You And I
07 Steal My Girl
08 Night Changes
09 Drag Me Down
08 Perfect
07 History

Posted by: Mackenzie 29th December 2015, 07:41 PM

00 What Makes You Beautiful
00 Gotta Be You
00 One Thing
00 More Than This
02 Live While We're Young
03 Little Things
07 Kiss You
05 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
07 Best Song Ever
11 Story Of My Life
-1 Midnight Memories
05 You And I
04 Steal My Girl
08 Night Changes
07 Drag Me Down
04 Perfect
06 History

Posted by: J▲hq 29th December 2015, 08:07 PM

Acidburn is under strict instructions to fix this in favour of What Makes You Beautiful so we can stop with the zero marks now x

Posted by: KWEEN_DEE 29th December 2015, 09:22 PM

08 What Makes You Beautiful
04 Gotta Be You
04 One Thing
04 More Than This
11 Live While We're Young
09 Little Things
08 Kiss You
04 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10 Best Song Ever
07 Story Of My Life
05 Midnight Memories
09 You And I
06 Steal My Girl
08 Night Changes
09 Drag Me Down
07 Perfect
06 History

Posted by: Riser 30th December 2015, 01:14 PM

09.0 What Makes You Beautiful
06.0 Gotta Be You
11.0 One Thing
08.5 More Than This
05.5 Live While We're Young
08.0 Little Things
07.0 Kiss You
07.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
07.5 Best Song Ever
11.0 Story Of My Life
07.0 Midnight Memories
10.0 You And I
09.0 Steal My Girl
09.0 Night Changes
07.5 Drag Me Down
09.0 Perfect
06.5 History

I might get a chance to listen to More Than This later and if so I'll edit it in ASAP!
Edit: all done!

Posted by: UltraChristmas 30th December 2015, 01:24 PM

07 What Makes You Beautiful
08 Gotta Be You
00 One Thing
04 More Than This
04 Live While We're Young
10 Little Things
-1 Kiss You
00 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
00 Best Song Ever
03 Story Of My Life
01 Midnight Memories
02 You And I
06 Steal My Girl
11 Night Changes
08 Drag Me Down
08 Perfect
01 History

Posted by: Snowbot 30th December 2015, 01:43 PM

09.5 What Makes You Beautiful
06.5 Gotta Be You
08.5 One Thing
07.0 More Than This
07.5 Live While We're Young
-01.0 Little Things
09.5 Kiss You
06.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
11.0 Best Song Ever
07.0 Story Of My Life
08.0 Midnight Memories
05.0 You And I
09.0 Steal My Girl
07.0 Night Changes
04.0 Drag Me Down
08.0 Perfect
06.5 History

Best Song Ever ISN'T an 11, but it's their best song. I don't usually give a -1 unless there's an absolute horror in the discography, but Little Things really is one of the worst songs of the century. They're mostly quite good though.

Posted by: Taylor Jago 30th December 2015, 04:28 PM

11.0 What Makes You Beautiful
07.5 Gotta Be You
09.0 One Thing
07.0 More Than This
10.0 Live While We're Young
10.0 Little Things
09.5 Kiss You
09.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
10.0 Best Song Ever
08.0 Story Of My Life
07.0 Midnight Memories
06.5 You And I
07.5 Steal My Girl
03.5 Night Changes
04.0 Drag Me Down
10.0 Perfect
06.5 History

Posted by: HausofTroye 30th December 2015, 04:36 PM

10.0 What Makes You Beautiful
04.0 Gotta Be You
07.0 One Thing
07.0 More Than This
09.0 Live While We're Young
00.0 Little Things
08.0 Kiss You
00.0 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
09.0 Best Song Ever
09.0 Story Of My Life
06.0 Midnight Memories
11.0 You And I
09.0 Steal My Girl
10.0 Night Changes
08.0 Drag Me Down
08.0 Perfect
06.0 History

Posted by: Acidburn 30th December 2015, 08:08 PM

Voting closed, I will start the results tomorrow, but any last minute votes will be welcome.

Posted by: Joe. 30th December 2015, 08:24 PM

10 What Makes You Beautiful
08 Gotta Be You
06 One Thing
06 More Than This
09 Live While We're Young
02 Little Things
06 Kiss You
02 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
07 Best Song Ever
07 Story Of My Life
01 Midnight Memories
05 You And I
11 Steal My Girl
10 Night Changes
01 Drag Me Down
09 Perfect
06 History

LAST MINUTE

Posted by: Riser 30th December 2015, 09:45 PM

I've edited my scores if that's all right, just realized I'd meant to give an 11.

Posted by: Acidburn 30th December 2015, 11:53 PM

QUOTE(Riser @ Dec 30 2015, 09:45 PM)

Posted by: Christmas Jay 30th December 2015, 11:58 PM

09.0 What Makes You Beautiful
05.5 Gotta Be You
08.5 One Thing
06.5 More Than This
08.0 Live While We're Young
08.5 Little Things
10.0 Kiss You
07.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks)
09.0 Best Song Ever
11.0 Story Of My Life
06.0 Midnight Memories
08.5 You And I
10.0 Steal My Girl
09.0 Night Changes
09.0 Drag Me Down
09.5 Perfect
07.5 History