Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

BuzzJack Music Forum _ R&B and Hip-Hop _ Kelly Rowland Singles Rate//Results

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 10 2014, 02:46 AM

Okay welcome to my Kelly Rowland singles rate, there has already been one for Beyonce and Destiny's Child, and I don't think that there has been one for Kelly yet, she's had 4 albums out and quite a lot of singles, she's sold 27 Million records worldwide as a solo artist.

Rules = Rate each track between 0 and 10, you can use one 11 and one -1 and half marks are allowed but please no 10.5's or 0.5's

Simply Deep era

xx.x Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
xx.x Stole
xx.x Can't Nobody
xx.x Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

xx.x Like This (Feat Eve)
xx.x Work (Freemason's Remix)
xx.x Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

xx.x When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
xx.x Commander (Feat David Guetta)
xx.x Rose Coloured Glasses
xx.x Forever And A Day
xx.x Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
xx.x Down For Whatever
xx.x Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

xx.x Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
xx.x Kisses Down Low
xx.x Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
xx.x Here We Go (Ft Trina)
xx.x Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
xx.x What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
xx.x Gone (Ft Nelly)
xx.x Grown Woman
xx.x Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
xx.x Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
xx.x One Life (Ft Madcon)
xx.x Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Right I have decided to only include singles that she has released in the UK and USA, so there are 26 singles to rate, so get voting

Posted by: 🌚🌚🌚 Aug 10 2014, 03:39 AM

just relistened to dilemma and is like rly bad how was that ever so big??

only really know the hits from the rest (so like 3 of em lolol 🔥) but motivation / work to winnn

Posted by: Nick F1 Aug 10 2014, 07:43 AM

Simply Deep era

08.5 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
09.0 Stole
10.0 Can't Nobody
07.5 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

08.5 Like This (Feat Eve)
11.0 Work (Freemason's Remix)
08.0 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

08.0 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
10.0 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
09.5 Rose Coloured Glasses
07.5 Forever And A Day
10.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08.5 Down For Whatever
09.0 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

08.0 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
09.0 Kisses Down Low
10.0 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations

07.0 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
06.5 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
08.0 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
06.0 Gone (Ft Nelly)
09.0 Grown Woman
07.0 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
07.5 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
07.5 One Life (Ft Madcon)
06.0 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)


such a strong discography wub.gif

Posted by: Davidson Aug 10 2014, 12:37 PM

Simply Deep era

08.0 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
11.0 Stole
09.0 Can't Nobody
07.0 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

08.0 Like This (Feat Eve)
10.0 Work (Freemason's Remix)
07.5 Daylight (Feat Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

10.0 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
10.0 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
08.5 Rose Coloured Glasses
04.0 Forever And A Day
10.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
01.0 Down For Whatever
07.5 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

06.0 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
06.5 Kisses Down Low
07.5 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations

06.0 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
06.0 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
06.0 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
03.5 Gone (Ft Nelly)
07.0 Grown Woman
02.0 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
09.0 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
04.0 One Life (Ft Madcon)
05.0 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Never realised just how much I loved so much of her solo stuff wub.gif

Posted by: vibe Aug 10 2014, 02:31 PM

Simply Deep era

09 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10 Stole
8.5 Can't Nobody
07 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

08.5 Like This (Feat Eve)
09 Work (Freemason's Remix)
08.0 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

11 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
10 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
09 Rose Coloured Glasses
06 Forever And A Day
09 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08 Down For Whatever
08.5 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

08.Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
07 Kisses Down Low
08.Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations

07 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
07 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
07.5 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
06. Gone (Ft Nelly)
08 Grown Woman
06 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
05 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
05 One Life (Ft Madcon)
05.5 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)[/color]



Posted by: vibe Aug 10 2014, 02:32 PM

You haven't included separated with avant .

Posted by: Liаm Aug 10 2014, 02:38 PM

Simply Deep era

09 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10 Stole
09 Can't Nobody
06.5 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

10 Like This (Feat Eve)
10 Work (Freemason's Remix)
07.5 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

10 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08.5 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
10 Rose Coloured Glasses
08 Forever And A Day
11 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
-1 Down For Whatever
08 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

07 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
02 Kisses Down Low
09 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations

06 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
08 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
07 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
05 Gone (Ft Nelly)
09.5 Grown Woman
04 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
10 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
04 One Life (Ft Madcon)
07 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

She has sooo many more amazing songs than I remember, also some crap but hey ho.

Posted by: JosephStyles Aug 10 2014, 02:54 PM

I shall definitely do this, always loved a bit of Kelly, more so than Beyoncé a lot of the time ph34r.gif

Posted by: Aled. Aug 10 2014, 03:18 PM

09.0 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10.0 Stole
08.5 Can't Nobody
05.0 Train On A Track

08.0 Like This (Feat Eve)
09.5 Work (Freemason's Remix)
07.0 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

11.0 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
09.5 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
05.0 Rose Coloured Glasses
03.0 Forever And A Day
08.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
06.5 Down For Whatever
06.0 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

06.0 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
04.5 Kisses Down Low
07.5 Dirty Laundry

06.0 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
02.0 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
06.5 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
05.0 Gone (Ft Nelly)
05.0 Grown Woman
xx.x Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
xx.x Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
xx.x One Life (Ft Madcon)
04.5 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

It's a stronger discography than what she's often given credit for!

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 10 2014, 08:53 PM

Simply Deep era

10.0 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10.0 Stole
08.5 Can't Nobody
06.5 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

09.5 Like This (Feat Eve)
11.0 Work (Freemason's Remix)
08.0 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

10.0 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
09.0 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
09.0 Rose Coloured Glasses
05.0 Forever And A Day
10.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08.0 Down For Whatever
06.5 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

08.5 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
10.0 Kisses Down Low
10.0 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
07.5 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
07.0 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
08.0 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
03.0 Gone (Ft Nelly)
05.0 Grown Woman
04.0 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
07.0 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
06.0 One Life (Ft Madcon)
06.0 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)


Here's my rates and I will be keeping this open for about two weeks, so thanks for all your votes so far and keep them coming

Posted by: JosephStyles Aug 10 2014, 11:26 PM

Simply Deep era
10.0 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10.0 Stole
07.0 Can't Nobody
06.0 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era
10.0 Like This (Feat Eve)
10.0 Work (Freemason's Remix)
08.0 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era
08.5 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
10.0 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
09.0 Rose Coloured Glasses
09.5 Forever And A Day
03.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
11.0 Down For Whatever
09.5 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era
xx.x Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
07.0 Kisses Down Low
05.0 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
xx.x Here We Go (Ft Trina)
xx.x Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
09.0 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
xx.x Gone (Ft Nelly)
xx.x Grown Woman
xx.x Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
xx.x Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
xx.x One Life (Ft Madcon)
09.0 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)


When she's on it, she's ON IT. I'll try and fill in what I don't know but I won't promise anything right now!

Posted by: kellyann Aug 12 2014, 10:39 PM

09.5 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10.0 Stole
09.0 Can't Nobody
07.0 Train On A Track
08.0 Like This (Feat Eve)
10.0 Work (Freemason's Remix)
07.5 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)
08.5 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
11.0 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
05.5 Rose Coloured Glasses
01.0 Forever And A Day
08.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08.0 Down For Whatever
09.0 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)
xx.x Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
07.5 Kisses Down Low
10.0 Dirty Laundry
06.0 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
04.0 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
06.0 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
08.0 Gone (Ft Nelly)
xx.x Grown Woman
xx.x Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
xx.x Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
03.0 One Life (Ft Madcon)
09.0 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 13 2014, 12:55 AM

Thanks for all your votes so far guys, I'll be keeping this open for another 2 weeks so keep voting and thanks again

Posted by: mr_aly Aug 14 2014, 08:01 PM

Simply Deep era

-1 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
04 Stole
09 Can't Nobody
05 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

04 Like This (Feat Eve)
08 Work (Freemason's Remix)
04 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

09 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
09 Rose Coloured Glasses
11 Forever And A Day
07 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
00 Down For Whatever
08 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

06 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
01 Kisses Down Low
07 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations

01 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
04 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
08 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
03 Gone (Ft Nelly)
06 Grown Woman
02 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
04 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
03 One Life (Ft Madcon)
02 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

A few decent ones, some absolute shockers.

'Forever And A Day' is ridiculously underrated, such perfection. sad.gif

Posted by: ♒ chris Aug 15 2014, 02:56 PM

Simply Deep era
10 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10 Stole
04 Can't Nobody
00 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era
07 Like This (Feat Eve)
11 Work (Freemason's Remix)
00 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era
07 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
00 Rose Coloured Glasses
-1 Forever And A Day
10 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
04 Down For Whatever
08 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era
09 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
00 Kisses Down Low
00 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
00 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
04 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
02 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
05 Gone (Ft Nelly)
06 Grown Woman
05 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
00 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
00 One Life (Ft Madcon)
03 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Posted by: Liаm Aug 15 2014, 03:24 PM

Anything lower than a 9 for Motivation is blasphemy.

Posted by: Totto Aug 15 2014, 09:05 PM

I'll definitely do this! Kelly is one of my favourite artist, when is the deadline?

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 16 2014, 10:19 PM

QUOTE(Totto @ Aug 15 2014, 10:05 PM) *
I'll definitely do this! Kelly is one of my favourite artist, when is the deadline?


I haven't fully decided yet, but it will be in about 2 weeks, so you should have plenty and time, hopefully

Posted by: MIKEMYER Aug 17 2014, 10:14 PM

10 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
09 Stole
08 Can't Nobody
07 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

10 Like This (Feat Eve)
10 Work (Freemason's Remix)
6.5 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

10 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
7.5 Rose Coloured Glasses
06 Forever And A Day
11 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
07 Down For Whatever
09 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

7.5 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
10 Kisses Down Low
10 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
06 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
3.5 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
8.5 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
0 Gone (Ft Nelly)
5.5 Grown Woman
06 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
05 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
04 One Life (Ft Madcon)
08 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Posted by: Simon. Aug 20 2014, 10:15 PM

Simply Deep era

10 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
10 Stole
07 Can't Nobody
06 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

07 Like This (Feat Eve)
11 Work (Freemason's Remix)
08 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

08 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
07 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
05 Rose Coloured Glasses
06 Forever And A Day
05 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
-1 Down For Whatever
06 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

05 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08 Kisses Down Low
07 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
08 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
06 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
05 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
05 Gone (Ft Nelly)
06 Grown Woman
06 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
05 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
05 One Life (Ft Madcon)
07 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Posted by: Cremey Aug 24 2014, 07:38 PM

Simply Deep era
08.0 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
07.5 Stole
07.0 Can't Nobody
06.0 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly era
08.0 Like This (Feat Eve)
08.0 Work (Freemason's Remix)
06.5 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am era
-1.0 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08.0 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
06.0 Rose Coloured Glasses
04.0 Forever And A Day
11.0 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
01.0 Down For Whatever
07.0 Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game era
09.0 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
02.0 Kisses Down Low
09.0 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
04.0 Here We Go (Ft Trina)
07.0 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
04.0 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
06.0 Gone (Ft Nelly)
08.0 Grown Woman
06.5 Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
06.0 Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
04.0 One Life (Ft Madcon)
06.5 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 28 2014, 08:55 PM

Voting closed I'll start posting the results in this thread soon

Posted by: ✖ ketalina ✖ Aug 28 2014, 11:08 PM

ik i'm late, sorry!

Simply Deep Era

08 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
09 Stole
04 Can't Nobody
05 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

07 Like This (Feat Eve)
11 Work (Freemason's Remix)
03 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

09 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
xx Rose Coloured Glasses
xx Forever And A Day
10 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
09 Down For Whatever
xx Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

08 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08 Kisses Down Low
05 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
xx.x Here We Go (Ft Trina)
00 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
07 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
xx.x Gone (Ft Nelly)
xx Grown Woman
xx Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
xx Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
xx One Life (Ft Madcon)
08 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 30 2014, 07:01 PM

QUOTE(✖ ketalina ✖ @ Aug 29 2014, 12:08 AM) *
ik i'm late, sorry!

Simply Deep Era

08 Dilemma (Ft Nelly)
09 Stole
04 Can't Nobody
05 Train On A Track

Ms Kelly Era

07 Like This (Feat Eve)
11 Work (Freemason's Remix)
03 Daylight (Fr Travis McCoy)

Here I Am Era

09 When Love Takes Over (Feat David Guetta)
08 Commander (Feat David Guetta)
xx Rose Coloured Glasses
xx Forever And A Day
10 Motivation (Feat Lil' Wayne)
09 Down For Whatever
xx Lay It On Me (Feat Big Sean)

Talk A Good Game Era

08 Ice (Feat Lil' Wayne)
08 Kisses Down Low
05 Dirty Laundry

Non Album Singles & Collaborations
xx.x Here We Go (Ft Trina)
00 Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah)
07 What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino)
xx.x Gone (Ft Nelly)
xx Grown Woman
xx Neva End (Remix) (Ft Future)
xx Without Me (Ft Fantasia & Missy Elliot)
xx One Life (Ft Madcon)
08 Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce)


Don't worry I have included your scores

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 30 2014, 07:56 PM

Right Now NO more votes the results will be posted in this thread and again thanks to everyone's whose voted

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 30 2014, 08:45 PM

Kelly Rowland Singles Rate Results



26. One Life (Ft Madcon) = Avg: 4.136


Highest Rates: (7.5): Nick F1

Lowest Rates: (0) xx Chris


Coming in at last place is "One Life" which features Madcon and is taken as the 2nd single from their 2nd album Icon In May 2013. Not one of Kelly's finest moments and wasn't thought too highly off on this rate, with just one high rate of 7.5, the rest were mainly 4's and 5's, and a couple of 3's, then finally one zero. The song itself was a hit in some countries, charting top 10 in Germany, Belgium and Austria, top 20 in Norway, top 40 in Swiss and Slovakia.




25. Gone (Ft Nelly) = Avg: 4.625


Highest Rate: (8): Kellyann

Lowest Rate: (0): MIKEMYER


At #25 is another flop single which is "Gone" released in January 2011 and features Nelly, and also marks the 2nd time they have collaborated together, first time was 2001's smash hit "Dilemma". Taken as the 3rd single from Nelly's fifth album 5.0, and totally failed to repeat the former success by bombing on the US Billboard Charts peaking at #113, and not charting much better anywhere else, #55 in Australia and #58 in the UK, therefore failing to capture the magic.




24. Neva End (Ft Future) = Avg: 4.85


Highest Rates:(7):Nick F1

Lowest Rates: (2): Davidson, Mr Aly


At #24 is Future's "Neva End" and featuring Kelly Rowland and released in December 2012 and taken as the 5th single from his debut album "Pluto". Despite having a lower score than "Gone" this gained a higher average due to it having less rates. The song was also remixed from it's original form to feature Kelly Rowland on guest vocals and it was a small success on the US Billboard Top 100, by charting at #52, but it fared better on the US Hot R&B/Hip Hop Songs chart and the US Hot Rap Songs by peaking at #14 and #11 respectably.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 31 2014, 07:55 PM

23. Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah) = Avg: 5


Highest Rates: (8): Liam

Lowest Rates: (0) X Ketalina x


At #23 is "Invincible" which is sung by English rapper Tinie Tempah and features guest vocals by none other than Kelly Rowland, and is one of her many collaborations to feature in this rate. The song also serves as the 4th single from his debut album "Disc-Overy" and is seen as a tribute to miss Rowland herself to the music of her group Destiny's Child. It recieved mixed reviews and became quite successful by peaking at #11 on the UK singles chart and to date it's Kelly's 6th best selling single with over 200,000 copies sold. Elsewhere it charted best in New Zealand at #5 and earned a Gold Disc. And also made a top 20 peak in Ireland and top 40 in Swiss, Australia and Germany.




22. Down For Whatever = Avg: 5.142


Highest Rates: (11): Joseph Styles 8.5/8 (Nick F1, Vibe, Niall Minogue, Kellyann)

Lowest Rates: (-1/0) (Mr Aly, Liam, Simon)


At #22 is "Down For Whatever" which is the lowest ranking of Kelly's album release singles in this rate, despite scoring a 11, it failed to score any 10's, but did manage a few 8's, but overall really struggled with several low scores. Released in October 2011 and taken as the 6th overall single from her third album "Here I Am". The song followed the Eurodance sound of her previous hits "When Loves Takes Over" and "Commander", therefore taking a different sound for her 3rd album, moving away from the R&B and Urban sounds of her first 2 albums. It became another hit for her in the UK with a performance on X-Factor when she served as a judge and peaked at #6, and fared better on the UK Dance charts by hitting #3. Elsewhere it went top 20 in Ireland and Slovakia, then hit top 40 in Germany and finally charting in Belgium and Swiss.




21. Here We Go (Ft Trina) = Avg: 5.375


Highest Rates: (8) (Simon)

Lowest Rates: (0) xx Chris


At #21 is "Here We Go" a hip-hop R&B song by American singer Trina and taken as the 2nd single from her 3rd album "Glamorest Life". The song is Trina's most successful single in the USA by peaking at #17, as well as being one of Kelly's most successful on the US Billboard chart. Elsewhere the song was also successful in the UK and New Zealand by reaching the top 15, and also charting top 20 in Finland.






Posted by: jsilv Aug 31 2014, 07:57 PM

gone would've had my 11 but i didnt know too many, shame its so low sad.gif

Posted by: JosephStyles Aug 31 2014, 08:38 PM

WHY is Down For Whatever so low? ohmy.gif Such a great track sad.gif

Posted by: Niall Minogue Aug 31 2014, 11:50 PM

20. Forever And A Day = 5.461


Highest Rates: (11) Mr Aly 9.5 JosephStyles

Lowest Rates: (-1) xx Chris


We now head into the top 20 and lose another "Here I Am" era single "Forever And A Day" released in September 2010 as the album's 4th overall single . The single failed to become a success like the previous hits and limped into the UK charts at #49. Originally other tracks "On And On" and "Take Everything" featuring Pitbull were considered for release instead, but due to the massive successes of "WLTO" and "Commander", it was decided that the dance route was the way to go, but didn't quite work this time round. The song also charted in two other countries but neither was successful.





Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 12:05 AM

19. Train On A Track = 5.821


Highest Rates: (7.5)Nick F1 (7) (Davidson, Vibe, Kellyann, MIKEMYER)

Lowest Rates: (0) xx Chris


At #19 is "Train On A Track" which strangely ranks higher than quite a few of her singles, despite not scoring higher than a 7 or 7.5. But none the less it's score is still beats the one previous to it and gained a few more average rates. Released in August 2003 as the 4th and final single from her debut album "Simply Deep" and gained a positive reception from critics and became her 4th UK top 20 hit, peaking at #20. In Ireland it managed to crack the top 50, while also charting in Australia, Netherlands, Swiss and Germany. The track wasn't released in the USA due to the poor performance of her previous single.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 12:27 AM

18. Without Me (Ft Fantasia Barrino & Missy Elliot) = Avg: 5.85


Highest Rate: (10) Liam

Lowest Rate: 0 xx Chris


At #18 is "Without Me" and despite getting a much lower score than the previous 5 singles due to less rates, it did manage a slightly higher average. This is another song to have Kelly Rowland as a featured artist, as Fantasia Barrino is the lead artist and serves as the 2nd single from her 4th album "Side Effects Of You" and released in April 2013. Missy Elliot also features on the song and Fantasia originally wanted her to direct the music video, but the job went to Steven Gomillion and Dennis Leupold. It peaked at #74 on the US Top 100 becoming her first to do so since 2010, but fared better on the US R&B charts peaking at #26



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 12:37 AM

17. Kisses Down Low = Avg: 5.892


Highest Rates: (10) Niall Minogue, MIKEMYER

Lowest Rates: (0) xx Chris


At #17 is "Kisses Down Low" released in February 2013 as the lead single from her 4th album "Talk A Good Game". The song was only released in the USA where it peaked at #72 becoming her 8th entry on the US Top 100, while peaking at #25 on the US Hot R&B chart.



Posted by: Liаm Sep 1 2014, 01:21 AM

Down for Whatever is beyond horrendous, how it came anywhere but last is beyond me puke.gif Kisses Down Low is pretty bad too, a blatant attempt to recreate Motivation (her best song) just because that was a big hit in the US.

Forever and A Day and Without Me are too low though sad.gif

Posted by: vibe Sep 1 2014, 06:49 AM

I really like down for whatever !!! Surprised it recieves a lot of hate.

Posted by: mr_aly Sep 1 2014, 04:07 PM

'Down For Whatever' has not one single good thing about it whatsoever. 'Forever And A Day' on the other hand is criminally underrated and a perfect song. sad.gif

Posted by: ✖ ketalina ✖ Sep 1 2014, 04:47 PM

down for whatever and kisses down low... so low? :S

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 07:48 PM

16. Say Yes (Ft Michelle Williams & Beyonce) = Avg: 6.142


Highest Rates:(9) JosephStyles, Kellyann)

Lowest Rates: (2) Mr Aly


At #16 is "Say Yes" which is a single by former Destiny's Child fellow member Michelle Williams and also features Beyonce and marks the third time the trio have collaborated as solo artists since the group split in 2006. Released in June 2014 and taken as the third single from her 4th album "Journey To Freedom". The song is an uptempo gospel and pop song, with dance music influences and received a positive reception and performed well on the US hot gospel charts by hitting #1. But failed to crack the US Top 100 by peaking at #109 and also managed to chart in UK and France at #106 and #90.



Posted by: JosephStyles Sep 1 2014, 07:56 PM

I'm not religious in the slightest but I cannot deny Say Yes at all, what a bop wub.gif

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 08:10 PM

15. Daylight (Ft Travis McCoy) = Avg: 6.392


Highest Rates: (8) Nick F1, Vibe, Niall Minogue, JosephStyles, Simon

Lowest Rates: (0) xx Chris


At #16 we lose the first of the Ms Kelly era singles which is "Daylight" which features Travis McCoy from the group Gym Glass Heroes and originally sung by Bobby Womack in 1976. Kelly recorded the song in October 2007 in London, but it didn't make the first release of her 2nd album Ms Kelly, but was instead intended for the "Asterix at the Olympic Games" soundtrack, but she liked the track so much she decided to include it on the re-release of her album titled "Ms Kelly: Diva Deluxe" and released it as a single in May 2008. It failed to dent the US Top 100 but managed to reach #4 on the US Hot Dance Club Songs. Worldwide it charted best in the UK reaching #14 becoming her 8th consecutive top 20 hit and in other countries it made top 50 peaks in Japan, Australia and Ireland.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 08:23 PM

14. What A Feeling (Ft Alex Gaudino) = Avg: 6.607


Highest Rates: (9) JosephStyles

Lowest Rates: (2) xx Chris


At #14 is "What A Feeling" which is a song by Italian DJ Alex Gaudino and taken from his 2nd album "Doctor Love" and features none other than Kelly Rowland and again taking her direction further into the dance and club scene. Released in April 2011 and won rave reviews and become another successful UK hit for her by peaking at #6 becoming her 8th top 10 hit. In other countries it hit top 20 in Hungary and Spain, while also peaking top 40 in Slovakia, Belgium, Ireland and Romania.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 08:41 PM

13. Rose Coloured Glasses = Avg: 7.153


Highest Rates: (10) Liam

Lowest Rates: (0) xx Chris


At #13 is "Rose Coloured Glasses" released in June 2010 and taken from her third album "Here I Am". This song was released in the USA and some parts of Europe only and intended to be one of two lead singles, while "Commander" was chosen for the International market and won praise from critics stating it as one of her strongest and vocal and emotional performances to date, but it caused her vocals to swell. Originally the Ne-Yo penned track "Shake Them Haters Off" would be the lead single, but was replaced by two other songs, one for pop radio which was "RCG" and "Grown Woman" for the Urban market. But it failed to dent the main billboard top 100 and only managed to chart on the US Top 40 Airplay peaking at #39. The only other country it charted in was Slovakia where it peaked at #25. Therefore causing the album to be further delayed until the following year.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 1 2014, 08:57 PM

12. Grown Woman = Avg: 7.182


Highest Rates: (10) xx Chris

Lowest Rates: (5) Aled, Niall Minogue


At #12 is "Grown Woman" and despite getting a much lower score than "RCG", this did manage a slightly higher average due to it's less rates. Released in July 2010 as one of two intended lead singles for her third album "Here I Am". It was serviced to Rhythmic, Urban and Urban AC stations and also released as a digital download in some parts of Europe. Despite becoming moderately successful on the Urban stations by hitting top 40 on the Hot Urban AC Airplay Chart and Urban Contemporay Airplay chart, while peaking at #51 on the US Hot R&B/Hip Hop Songs chart, it wasn't included on the final edition of her third album "Here I Am", while the other lead single "RCG" was only included on the worldwide edition and not on the USA version. There was a music video filmed for the song in August 2010, but never got released for unknown reasons.





Posted by: mr_aly Sep 1 2014, 10:15 PM

'Rose Coloured Glasses' is SO good, I can't believe they didn't push that properly.

I hear 'Grown Woman' in my gym frequently and it is annoying as hell.

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 3 2014, 06:32 PM

11. Ice (Ft Lil' Wayne) = Avg: 7.333


Highest Rates (9) (xx Chris, Cremey)

Lowest Rates: (5) Simon


At #11 is "Ice" which features Lil' Wayne and also marks the 3rd time that they have collaborated together, first time was on Destiny's Child's "Soldier" and her 2011 hit "Motivation" which will feature later on. Released in August 2012 and it was originally intended to be the lead single from her 4th album "Talk A Good Game", but it did not make the final cut following it's quite poor performance on the US Hot 100 peaking at #88, but fared much better on the US Hot R&B/Hip Hop Songs chart peaking at #24.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 3 2014, 06:55 PM

10. Dirty Laundry = Avg: 7.5


Highest Rates: (10) Nick F1, Niall Minogue, Kellyann, MIKEMYER]

Lowest Rates: (0) (xx Chris)


At #10 and saying goodbye to one of her album era singles "Dirty Laundry" released in May 2013 and taken as the 2nd and final single from her 4th album "Talk A Good Game". This piano led ballad won critical praise and speaks of her jealously of former bandmate Beyonce and the domestic abuse she suffered during a previous relationship. The remix version features a new introduction and verses by R Kelly. The song failed to enter the US Top 100 by peaking at #113, but made the US Hot R&B/Hip Hop songs chart peaking at #47.



Posted by: mr_aly Sep 3 2014, 07:06 PM

'Dirty Laundry' is one of her better moments, I admired how brutally honest she was on it.

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 3 2014, 07:10 PM

09. Can't Nobody = Avg: 7.75


Highest Rates: (10) Nick F1

Lowest Rates: (4) xx Chris, xKetalinax


At #9 is "Can't Nobody" which gained mostly positive rates with a 10, 4 9's and several 8's, and only just 2 low rates. Released in February 2003 and taken as the third single from her debut album "Simply Deep". The song incorporates elements of Trouble Funk's 1982 hit "Let's Get Small" and was also one of the first songs recorded for the album. It didn't match the success of "Dilemma" and "Stole" by limping in the US charts at #97, but fared much better worldwide, charting best in the UK peaking at #5 becoming her third top 5 hit and reaching top 20 peaks in Australia, Ireland and Denmark, then top 40 in Netherlands, Swiss, New Zealand and Belgium. "Can't Nobody" is also her 8th most successful single worldwide behind "Dilemma", "When Love Takes Over", "Stole", "Work", "Commander", "Like This" and Invincible".




Posted by: Liаm Sep 3 2014, 07:14 PM

I love both Rose Coloured Glasses and Grown Woman, wish the former was a proper single in the UK especially.

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 3 2014, 07:25 PM

08. Lay It On Me (Ft Big Sean) = Avg: 7.846


Highest Rates: (9.5/9) Nick F1, JosephStyles, Kellyann, MIKEMYER

Lowest Rates: (6) Aled, Simon


At #8 is "Lay It On Me" which features Big Sean and first released in August 2011 as the 2nd US single from her 3rd album "Here I Am", then released worldwide in 2012 as the 4th single. It failed to match the success of "Motivation" in the USA by peaking at #109 and worldwide it charted in 2 countries Japan and UK by peaking at #69 in both countries.







Posted by: mr_aly Sep 3 2014, 07:28 PM

'Can't Nobody' is funky (MUCH preferred it to 'Stole'), 'Lay It On Me' is quite nice.

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 4 2014, 07:37 PM

07. Like This (Ft Eve) = Avg: 8.107


Highest Rates: (10) Liam, JosephStyles, MIKEMYER

Lowest Rates: (4) Mr Aly


At #7 is "Like This" which was released in March 2007 as the lead single from her 2nd album "Ms Kelly" and features guest vocals by Eve. The song was actually one of the last songs recorded for the album, originally the record company wanted "Work" for the lead single, then "Gotsta Go" was considered before she took a break and had a flash of inspiration, as it was originally titled "Wooo" or "Bump Like This". The song became her biggest success worldwide since "Stole", In the USA it was a moderate success peaking at #30, but fared much better in the UK by reaching #4 and elsewhere it charted top 5 in Ireland, top 20 in Australia and New Zealand.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 4 2014, 07:58 PM

06. Dilemma (Ft Nelly) = Avg: 8.5


Highest Rates: (10) Niall Minogue, JosephStyles, xx chris, MIKEMYER, Simon

Lowest Rates: (-1) -1 Mr Aly


At #6 is "!Dilemma" which brought Kelly Rowland to instant solo fame and featuring Nelly and released in June 2002 as the lead single from her debut album "Simply Deep" and as the 3rd single from Nelly's 2nd album "Nellyville". The song became an instant smash by topping the charts in 10 countries worldwide including UK and USA. A well known fact that the song samples Patti LaBelle's "Love Need and Want You" and she also features in the music video as Kelly's mother. Due to it's massive success it caused the other Destiny's Child members Beyonce and Michelle's solo stuff was pushed back. To date this song is still both Kelly and Nelly's biggest hit worldwide to date.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 4 2014, 08:16 PM

05. When Love Takes Over (Ft David Guetta) = Avg: 8.571


Highest Rates: (11) Vibe, Aled (10) Davidson, Liam, Niall Minogue, MIKEMYER

Lowest Rates: (-1) Cremey


At #5 is "When Love Takes Over" a song by David Guetta who after Kelly heard the music, she fell in love with it and convinced him to let her record it and therefore was Kelly's first step into dance music and inspired her to make her 3rd album into dance music. The song was released in April 2009 as the lead single from his 4th album "One Love" and later included on Kelly's 3rd album "Here I Am". The song became a massive success and helped re establish her as a solo artist by topping the charts in Belgium, Czech Republic, Hungary, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Romania, Slovakia, Swiss and UK and top 10 in 13 other countries.





Posted by: mr_aly Sep 4 2014, 11:27 PM

'Dilemma' is utterly foul, 'When Love Takes Over' is a great summer dance anthem and 'Like This' probably would have got a lot less than a 4 had I been scoring this in 2008.

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 6 2014, 09:43 PM

04. Motivation (Ft Lil' Wayne) = Avg: 8.785


Highest Rates: (11) Liam, MIKEMYER, Cremey (10) Nick F1, Davidson, Niall Minouge, xx Chris, x Ketalina x

Lowest Rates: (3) JosephStyles


At #4 is "Motivation" released in April 2011 and features Lil' Wayne and taken as the lead US single from her 3rd album "Here I Am". The song won rave reviews and became her biggest solo success in the USA by peaking at #17 and also given her highest charting hit since "Dilemma" in 2001. Also it's her first song to chart since "When Love Takes Over" in 2009 which reached #76. The previous 2 lead singles "Grown Woman" and "Rose Coloured Glasses" both failed to make an impact and so this song becoming a success was a big deal. When she performed it at the 2011 BET awards for the first time, it became the most anticipated performance of the evening thanks to the many delays of her 3rd album and even got one of the loudest ovations of the night. It sold over 2 Million units in the USA also and topped the US Hot R&B/Hip Hop Songs chart and hit top 30 on the US Mainstream top 40. "Motivation" won two awards for Best Dance Performance at the 2011 Soul Train Awards and Top R&B song at the Billboard Music Awards as well as a Grammy nomination for Best Rap/Sung collaboration, It also managed to chart in other countries, by hitting top 10 in Hungary, but in Canada failed to become a success by limping at #99. In the UK despite not being released it managed to chart at #169 due to downloads. But to be honest this would have made a much better lead single here in the UK than "Down For Whatever".




Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 6 2014, 10:03 PM

03. Commander (Ft David Guetta) = Avg: 8.928


Highest Rates: (11) Kellyann (10) Nick F1, Davidson, Vibe, JosephStyles)

Lowest Rates: (7) Simon


We now reach the top 3 and finishing at #3 is "Commander" which means we say goodbye to her third album era singles, leaving just Simply Deep and Ms Kelly remaining. Released in May 2010 as the lead worldwide single from "Here I Am" and second overall. The song also marks her 2nd collaboration with DJ David Guetta, following last years massive "When Love Takes Over". Before it's release she parted ways with her record company due to under welming sales of Ms Kelly and after WLTO release she fired her manager Matthew Knowles and decided to carry on with her newfound dance sound, while the song did get a release in the USA, but given an Urban remix which features Nelly but failed to chart over there, but managed to top the US Hot Dance Club songs chart. In the UK, there was a much better reception where it hit #9 and sold over 285,000 copies and earning a Silver disc becoming her 3rd biggest selling single and becoming her 7th top 10 hit. Elsewhere it hit #2 in Slovakia and hit top 20 peaks in Ireland, Czech Republic, Germany, New Zealand, Norway and Finland. Then top 40 positions in Austria, Denmark, Hungary, Sweden and Netherlands.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 6 2014, 10:06 PM

So that means Stole or Work is the winner, so who will win, here are the results so far =

3. Commander - 8.928
4. Motivation - 8.785
5. When Love Takes Over - 8.571
6. Dilemma (Ft Nelly) - 8.5
7. Like This - 8.107
8. Lay It On Me - 7.846
9. Can’t Nobody - 7.75
10. Dirty Laundry - 7.5
11. Ice - 7.333
12. Grown Woman - 7.182
13. Rose Coloured Glasses - 7.153
14. What A Feeling - 6.607
15. Daylight - 6.392
16. Say Yes - 6.142
17. Kisses Down Low - 5.892
18. Without Me - 5.85
19. Train On A Track - 5.821
20. Forever And A Day - 5.461
21. Here We Go (Ft Trina) - 5.375
22. Down For Whatever - 5.142
23. Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah) - 5
24. Neva End - 4.85
25. Gone (Ft Nelly) - 4.625
26. One Life - 4.136

Posted by: Davidson Sep 7 2014, 12:04 PM

'Work' will obviously win but I am so pleased my personal favourite 'Stole' made it so high. Stunning song.

Posted by: Liаm Sep 7 2014, 12:09 PM

Motivation wub.gif definitely her best. Stole is up there too for me but I agree Work will likely win, I'd be happy with that too.

Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 7 2014, 05:37 PM

02. Stole = Avg: 9.25


Highest Rates: (11) Davidson 10 Vibe, Liam, Aled, Niall Minogue, JosephStyles, Kellyann, xx Chris, Simon

Lowest Rates: (4) Mr Aly


Right then so now the wait is over and at the runner up spot is "Stole", which means "Work" is the winner, but that will be in the next post, so now let's talk about "Stole". Written and co-produced by Dane Deviller and Steve Kipner and lyrically talks about chronicle three different scenarios with young people, whose lives are drastically changed by the aftermaths of a suicide and a school shooting. Released in Australia and USA in October 2002 and Elsewhere in January 2003 as Kelly's first official solo single and lead single taken from her first album "Simply Deep". Despite the rush release by the record company of the album (which was recorded in just 3 weeks) and this was picked by Sony Music's song pool, the song became a massive success. In the USA it was released after "Dilemma" was slipping down the charts, and debuted at #76, then 9 weeks later climbed to #27, not quite the success as hoped but elsewhere it was much better received and showed that her solo career success lies internationally. Worldwide it's still to date one of her most successful singles just behind Dilemma, Work and When Love Takes Over. In the UK it peaked at #2 and sold 210,000 copies and earned a Silver disc, her 5th highest seller over. In Australia it matched the peak at #2 and also hit top 3 in Ireland and New Zealand. In other countries it hit top 10 in Norway, Denmark, Swiss and Netherlands. Top 20 in Finland, Italy, Sweden, Germany and Belgium.



Posted by: Niall Minogue Sep 7 2014, 05:57 PM

01. Work= Avg:9.964


Highest Rates: (11) Nick F1, Niall Minogue, xx Chris, Simon, x ketalina x (10) Davidson, Liam, JosephStyles, Kellyann, MIKEMYER

Lowest Rates: (8) Mr Aly, Cremey


So there you have it Buzzjack your #1 Kelly Rowland song is none other than "Work" with 5 11's and 5 10's and no rate lower than a 8, making this the clear winner from the start. Originally intended to be the lead single from her 2nd album "Ms Kelly", but when it leaked early it had negative feedback and "Like This" was chosen instead. A re-think was in order, so Freemasons was called in to remix it and give it new life and released as the 2nd single internationally in January 2008. In the USA "Ghetto" was released and bombed, so therefore never given a proper release. In the UK "Work" became a massive success by reaching #4 and spent 6 weeks in the top 10, selling over 250,000 copies. Elsewhere it hit top 5/10 in Turkey, Finland, France, Australia, Greece, Italy, Swiss and New Zealand. Top 20 in Ireland, Slovakia, Netherlands and Norway, then top 40 in Germany, Hungary, Austria and Belgium. This also caused a boost in sales for her 2nd album "Ms Kelly" and eventually led to a re-release and following the underperformance of previous singles "Like This" and "Ghetto", this song saved the era and became one of her most successful hits ever.


Results In Full

1. Work 9.964
2. Stole 9.25
3. Commander 8.928
4. Motivation 8.785
5. When Love Takes Over 8.571
6. Dilemma (Ft Nelly) 8.5
7. Like This 8.107
8. Lay It On Me 7.846
9. Can’t Nobody 7.75
10. Dirty Laundry 7.5
11. Ice 7.333
12. Grown Woman 7.182
13. Rose Coloured Glasses 7.153
14. What A Feeling 6.607
15. Daylight 6.392
16. Say Yes 6.142
17. Kisses Down Low 5.892
18. Without Me 5.85
19. Train On A Track 5.821
20. Forever And A Day 5.461
21. Here We Go (Ft Trina) 5.375
22. Down For Whatever 5.142
23. Invincible (Ft Tinie Tempah) 5
24. Neva End 4.85
25. Gone (Ft Nelly) 4.625
26. One Life 4.136


So thanks to everybody whose voted.

Posted by: mr_aly Sep 8 2014, 02:27 PM

I wouldn't say 'Work' is her best, but it's still really good (strictly the Freemasons version only, the original is unlistenable).

'Stole' is very overrated, 'Commander' is a great song but it did get very overplayed and it hasn't quite been the same since for me. sad.gif

Posted by: vibe Sep 8 2014, 06:20 PM

Can't really argue with the top 10

Powered by Invision Power Board
© Invision Power Services