Printable version of thread

Posted by: Kimberley Walsh 22nd October 2015, 06:57 PM

- Welcome to the Atomic Kitten singles rate!
- Please rate every song from 0-10. If you don't know any, Spotify/YouTube are your friends so try and utilise them!
- One 11 and one -1 are allowed.
- Half marks are allowed but no 10.5s please, they're not within the 0-10 range and will be scaled down to a 10 if used.
- I've included Right Now and Right Now 2004 separately as I feel there's a significant difference between the two. I have, however, not separated Cradle and Cradle 2005, because they're pretty similar and the former was only a single in Japan anyway.

THE SONGS

xx.x Right Now
xx.x See Ya
xx.x I Want Your Love
xx.x Follow Me
xx.x Whole Again
xx.x Eternal Flame
xx.x You Are
xx.x It's OK!
xx.x The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
xx.x The Last Goodbye
xx.x Be With You
xx.x Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
xx.x If You Come To Me
xx.x Ladies Night
xx.x Someone Like Me
xx.x Right Now 2004
xx.x Cradle (original / 2005 version)

I'll announce a deadline at some point in the future, but for now, get rating

Posted by: Kimberley Walsh 22nd October 2015, 07:04 PM

10.0 Right Now
08.0 See Ya
08.5 I Want Your Love
08.0 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
09.0 Eternal Flame
09.0 You Are
09.5 It's OK!
09.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
08.5 The Last Goodbye
10.0 Be With You
11.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt - I was very stuck on my 11 so I've gone for this cause it's always felt quite underrated in the grand scheme of things!
10.0 If You Come To Me
10.0 Ladies Night
10.0 Someone Like Me
09.0 Right Now 2004
08.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

What a discography Forgot how much I loved all these tracks until just now, some fantastic memories too!

Posted by: Nick F1 22nd October 2015, 07:19 PM

8 Right Now
6 See Ya
xx.x I Want Your Love
xx.x Follow Me
9 Whole Again
8.5 Eternal Flame
xx.x You Are
8 It's OK!
9 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10 The Last Goodbye
10 Be With You
6 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
8 If You Come To Me
10 Ladies Night
11 Someone Like Me
8.5 Right Now 2004
6.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Simon. 22nd October 2015, 08:42 PM

So underrated these days! Gutted when the reunion tour was cancelled due to poor ticket sales.

09 Right Now
08 See Ya
07 I Want Your Love
08 Follow Me
10 Whole Again
10 Eternal Flame
08 You Are
10 It's OK!
08 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
11 The Last Goodbye
07 Be With You
07 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
07 If You Come To Me
05 Ladies Night
05 Someone Like Me
10 Right Now 2004
07 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: gooddelta 22nd October 2015, 08:48 PM

I'd forgotten a reunion tour was supposed to be happening, didn't realise they'd cancelled it

09.0 Right Now
08.5 See Ya
09.0 I Want Your Love
09.0 Follow Me
08.5 Whole Again
11.0 Eternal Flame
09.5 You Are
09.5 It's OK!
09.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
09.0 The Last Goodbye
08.5 Be With You
09.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
05.0 If You Come To Me (I've always found this so monotone and plodding)
10.0 Ladies Night
08.0 Someone Like Me
09.5 Right Now 2004
09.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

<3

Posted by: Jonjoltergeist👻 22nd October 2015, 09:13 PM

08.0 Right Now
08.5 See Ya
07.5 I Want Your Love
09.0 Follow Me
09.0 Whole Again
09.0 Eternal Flame
11.0 You Are
07.5 It's OK!
09.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10.0 The Last Goodbye
10.0 Be With You
06.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
09.5 If You Come To Me
07.5 Ladies Night
08.0 Someone Like Me >> Love the song. But I can't believe how shit a single choice this was though. Should've been 'Nothing In This World', 'Always Be My Baby' or 'I Won't Be There'! <<
07.5 Right Now 2004
10.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

<3 <3 <3

Posted by: Fgiboy2511 22nd October 2015, 09:35 PM

0 Right Now
6 See Ya
7 I Want Your Love
3 Follow Me
8 Whole Again
5 Eternal Flame
9 You Are
10 It's OK!
9 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
8 The Last Goodbye
11 Be With You
8 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
7 If You Come To Me
2 Ladies Night
10 Someone Like Me
-1 Right Now 2004
0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: mr_pmt 22nd October 2015, 09:40 PM

07 Right Now
06 See Ya
08 I Want Your Love
03 Follow Me
08 Whole Again
08 Eternal Flame
11 You Are
06 It's OK!
05 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
09 The Last Goodbye
08 Be With You
06 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06 If You Come To Me
07 Ladies Night
07 Someone Like Me
07 Right Now 2004
06 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Scary Spice 22nd October 2015, 10:00 PM

07.5 Right Now
08.0 See Ya
07.5 I Want Your Love
07.0 Follow Me
11.0 Whole Again
09.0 Eternal Flame
09.5 You Are
10.0 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
09.0 The Last Goodbye
10.0 Be With You
07.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
09.5 If You Come To Me
08.0 Ladies Night
08.5 Someone Like Me
07.0 Right Now 2004
07.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

I knew I'd end up giving loony scores!

Posted by: Slick 22nd October 2015, 10:12 PM

09 Right Now
05 See Ya
07 I Want Your Love
07 Follow Me
11 Whole Again
10 Eternal Flame
05 You Are
07 It's OK!
09 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
06 The Last Goodbye
07 Be With You
08 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
07 If You Come To Me
08 Ladies Night
07 Someone Like Me
09 Right Now 2004
06 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: AaronTM 22nd October 2015, 10:24 PM

08.5 Right Now
06.5 See Ya
07.0 I Want Your Love
05.0 Follow Me
11.0 Whole Again
07.0 Eternal Flame
07.5 You Are
09.5 It's OK!
07.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
09.0 The Last Goodbye
08.0 Be With You
10.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
07.5 If You Come To Me
07.0 Ladies Night
08.0 Someone Like Me
08.0 Right Now 2004
06.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Alex! 22nd October 2015, 11:12 PM

09.0 Right Now
08.5 See Ya
07.0 I Want Your Love
06.5 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
10.0 Eternal Flame
06.5 You Are
10.0 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
07.5 The Last Goodbye
07.5 Be With You
09.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
10.0 If You Come To Me
07.0 Ladies Night
10.0 Someone Like Me
07.5 Right Now 2004
11.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Acidburn 22nd October 2015, 11:53 PM

10.0 Right Now
09.0 See Ya
10.0 I Want Your Love
08.0 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
06.0 Eternal Flame
07.0 You Are
08.0 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10.0 The Last Goodbye
11.0 Be With You
10.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
10.0 If You Come To Me
07.0 Ladies Night
10.0 Someone Like Me
04.0 Right Now 2004
06.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Aaron. 23rd October 2015, 12:39 AM

9.0 Right Now
7.5 See Ya
8.0 I Want Your Love
8.5 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
9.5 Eternal Flame
9.0 You Are
7.0 It's OK!
8.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
11.0 The Last Goodbye
9.5 Be With You
6.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
5.5 If You Come To Me
5.0 Ladies Night
5.5 Someone Like Me
7.0 Right Now 2004
4.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Martyn 23rd October 2015, 07:46 AM

Get ready for the Martyn loon rate!

Posted by: Atonement 23rd October 2015, 08:25 AM

04 Right Now
04 See Ya
06.5 I Want Your Love
03 Follow Me
06.5 Whole Again
05.5 Eternal Flame
05 You Are
08.5 It's OK!
05.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
07 The Last Goodbye
06.5 Be With You
06 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
05 If You Come To Me
04 Ladies Night
04 Someone Like Me
06 Right Now 2004
06 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

All their stuff has aged very badly. 'It's OK' is definitely my favorite and that's mostly 'cause of the lyrics.

Posted by: Sarah 23rd October 2015, 10:55 PM

9 Right Now
8 See Ya
8 I Want Your Love
8 Follow Me
11 Whole Again
9 Eternal Flame
8 You Are
10 It's OK!
10 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10 The Last Goodbye
9 Be With You
9 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
10 If You Come To Me
10 Ladies Night
10 Someone Like Me
10 Right Now 2004
10 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Euphorique 24th October 2015, 12:01 AM

07 Right Now
09 See Ya
07 I Want Your Love
07 Follow Me
08 Whole Again
06 Eternal Flame
10 You Are
11 It's OK!
03 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10 The Last Goodbye
06 Be With You
04 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
09 If You Come To Me
05 Ladies Night
07 Someone Like Me
04 Right Now 2004
05 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Aphrodite 24th October 2015, 12:38 AM

09.0 Right Now
09.0 See Ya
10.0 I Want Your Love
06.0 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
10.0 Eternal Flame
08.0 You Are
11.0 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
07.0 The Last Goodbye
06.5 Be With You
06.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06.5 If You Come To Me
06.0 Ladies Night
08.0 Someone Like Me
09.5 Right Now 2004
07.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: vibe 25th October 2015, 12:55 PM

09 Right Now
06 See Ya
06 I Want Your Love
05 Follow Me
11.0 Whole Again
08 Eternal Flame
07 You Are
07.5 It's OK!
09 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
07 The Last Goodbye
07.5 Be With You
06 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06 If You Come To Me
07.5 Ladies Night
07 Someone Like Me
10 Right Now 2004
07 Cradle

Posted by: ThePensmith 25th October 2015, 05:40 PM

How fitting given I've just finished reviewing the majority of their singles on my 00's girl group thread! Here goes...

08.0 Right Now
10.0 See Ya
11.0 I Want Your Love - BOOOM!
04.5 Follow Me
09.5 Whole Again
01.0 Eternal Flame
03.5 You Are
02.0 It's OK!
04.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
09.5 The Last Goodbye
05.0 Be With You
03.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
07.5 If You Come To Me
-1.0 Ladies Night -
08.0 Someone Like Me
01.0 Right Now 2004
07.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Chapman 25th October 2015, 05:45 PM

08 Right Now
07 See Ya
09 I Want Your Love
05 Follow Me
10 Whole Again
08 Eternal Flame
07 You Are
08 It's OK!
08 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
06 The Last Goodbye
09 Be With You
06 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06 If You Come To Me
07 Ladies Night
09 Someone Like Me
08 Right Now 2004
06 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: JosephStyles 3rd November 2015, 09:50 PM

BUMP, MORE PLEASE

Posted by: Martyn 3rd November 2015, 09:51 PM

I will do this tomorrow.

Posted by: Scherz 4th November 2015, 12:50 AM

07.0 Right Now
08.0 See Ya
08.0 I Want Your Love
07.5 Follow Me
09.0 Whole Again
09.0 Eternal Flame
07.5 You Are
08.5 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
11.0 The Last Goodbye
06.0 Be With You
08.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
08.5 If You Come To Me
06.0 Ladies Night
06.0 Someone Like Me
06.0 Right Now 2004
08.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: James1987 4th November 2015, 09:31 AM

07.0 Right Now
07.5 See Ya
11.0 I Want Your Love
04.5 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
09.5 Eternal Flame
05.5 You Are
08.5 It's OK!
09.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10.0 The Last Goodbye
06.0 Be With You
08.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06.5 If You Come To Me
-01.0 Ladies Night
06.0 Someone Like Me
05.0 Right Now 2004
06.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: gooddelta 4th November 2015, 10:58 AM

Believer too...such a great chorus, was a no.1 in my personal chart *.* The other three you mention are amazing too although I can't envisage Always Be My Baby as a single.

Posted by: Aled. 4th November 2015, 04:05 PM

08.0 Right Now
07.0 See Ya
06.5 I Want Your Love
02.0 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
05.0 Eternal Flame
07.0 You Are
07.5 It's OK!
05.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
09.5 The Last Goodbye
08.0 Be With You
05.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
07.5 If You Come To Me
03.0 Ladies Night
06.5 Someone Like Me
04.0 Right Now 2004
07.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Martyn 9th November 2015, 11:26 PM

06.5 Right Now- I was never too fussed on this
07.5 See Ya-
07.0 I Want Your Love
05.5 Follow Me
09.0 Whole Again
08.5 Eternal Flame- Better than given credit for
11.0 You Are
09.5 It's OK!
09.5 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)- I really like this
10.0 The Last Goodbye
07.0 Be With You- hasn't aged amazinly
09.0 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
08.5 If You Come To Me
06.0 Ladies Night- It's fun
07.5 Someone Like Me- the single version is better than the album version
07.0 Right Now 2004
04.0 Cradle (original / 2005 version)- bit of a meh song, the 2005 version is much better though.

Posted by: pippa 11th November 2015, 07:22 PM

08.0 Right Now
06.0 See Ya
08.0 I Want Your Love
04.0 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
09.0 Eternal Flame
06.0 You Are
11.0 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
04.0 The Last Goodbye
07.5 Be With You
07.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
05.5 If You Come To Me
03.0 Ladies Night
05.0 Someone Like Me
06.5 Right Now 2004
07.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Beatrix Kiddo 11th November 2015, 08:41 PM

09 Right Now
07 See Ya
10 I Want Your Love
04 Follow Me
10 Whole Again
03 Eternal Flame
06 You Are
07 It's OK!
06 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
11 The Last Goodbye
10 Be With You
08 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
07 If You Come To Me
05 Ladies Night
06 Someone Like Me
00 Right Now 2004
09 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: bartsimpson 12th November 2015, 06:16 PM

11.0 Right Now
10.0 See Ya
09.0 I Want Your Love
07.5 Follow Me
10.0 Whole Again
05.5 Eternal Flame
06.5 You Are
08.0 It's OK!
10.0 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10.0 The Last Goodbye
09.0 Be With You
07.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
08.0 If You Come To Me
02.0 Ladies Night
06.0 Someone Like Me
05.0 Right Now 2004
04.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Dobbo 15th November 2015, 03:37 PM

06 Right Now
06 See Ya
04 I Want Your Love
05 Follow Me
11 Whole Again
08 Eternal Flame
04 You Are
06 It's OK!
09 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
04 The Last Goodbye
05 Be With You
04 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
05 If You Come To Me
05 Ladies Night
-1 Someone Like Me
04 Right Now 2004
05 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Average.

Posted by: UltraChristmas 15th November 2015, 04:21 PM

06 Right Now
05 See Ya
05 I Want Your Love
08 Follow Me
10 Whole Again
10 Eternal Flame
06 You Are
07 It's OK!
11 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
05 The Last Goodbye
07 Be With You
05 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
04 If You Come To Me
09 Ladies Night
08 Someone Like Me
05 Right Now 2004
06 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: Gezza 15th November 2015, 04:34 PM

07 Right Now
03 See Ya
05 I Want Your Love
01 Follow Me
08 Whole Again
06 Eternal Flame
04 You Are
09 It's OK!
06 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
11 The Last Goodbye
08 Be With You
07 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06 If You Come To Me
04 Ladies Night
10 Someone Like Me
05 Right Now 2004
03 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: mr_pmt 15th November 2015, 08:42 PM

It really annoys me that 'You Are' has got consistently low scores when it's their best one for me.

Posted by: MIKEMYER 16th November 2015, 07:32 PM

9 Right Now
10 See Ya
10 I Want Your Love
7 Follow Me
11 Whole Again
7 Eternal Flame
4.5 You Are
8.5 It's OK!
9 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
10 The Last Goodbye
9.5 Be With You
6.5 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
9 If You Come To Me
3 Ladies Night
10 Someone Like Me
-1 Right Now 2004
6.5 Cradle (original / 2005 version)

Posted by: JosephStyles 24th November 2015, 08:21 PM

CLOSING THIS TOMORROW

LAST DAY FOR VOTES

Posted by: Joe. 25th November 2015, 10:54 AM

04 Right Now
08 See Ya
06 I Want Your Love
10 Follow Me
11 Whole Again
-1 Eternal Flame
05 You Are
06 It's OK!
03 The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
04 The Last Goodbye
07 Be With You
06 Love Doesn't Have To Hurt
06 If You Come To Me
03 Ladies Night
06 Someone Like Me
08 Right Now
07 Cradle

Posted by: Jaÿ 25th November 2015, 02:28 PM

The results of this seem like they're going to be very unpredictable!

Posted by: Atonement 7th December 2015, 10:22 PM

AM W8ING