Printable version of thread

Posted by: LeeWallace Apr 30 2015, 02:29 PM

00: If This Is Love
00: Up
00: Issues
00: Just Can't Get Enough
00: Work
00: Forever Is Over
00: Ego
00: Missing You
00: Higher
00: Notorious
00: All Fired Up
00: My Heart Takes Over
00: 30 Days
00: What About Us
00: Gentleman
00: Disco Love
00: Not Giving Up
00: What Are You Waiting For?

You can provide one 11 and one -1. You have until the 7th May.

Posted by: LeeWallace Apr 30 2015, 02:30 PM

It would be so much easier had i based 'What About Us' on the original routine. I'm not sure how I will rate 'Higher' because the new routine is just awful.

Posted by: Juliano Apr 30 2015, 07:31 PM

05: If This Is Love
08: Up
05: Issues
05: Just Can't Get Enough
07: Work
03: Forever Is Over
08: Ego
08: Missing You
04: Higher
09: Notorious
07: All Fired Up
05: My Heart Takes Over
06: 30 Days
10: What About Us (the original Perez after party thingy one)
06: Gentleman
11: Disco Love
07: Not Giving Up
06: What Are You Waiting For?

Have to hand it to Disco Love, that really was the closest they got to a Beyonce moment. The problem is, so many of them have multiple routines or they perform them slightly different each time and the ballads don't really have routines.

Posted by: Hurricane May 1 2015, 02:21 AM

05: If This Is Love
09: Up
01: Issues
06: Just Can't Get Enough
09: Work
04: Forever Is Over
06: Ego
08: Missing You
07: Higher
10: Notorious
08: All Fired Up
01: My Heart Takes Over
06: 30 Days
10: What About Us
08: Gentleman
11: Disco Love
07: Not Giving Up
04: What Are You Waiting For?

I rated the original routines of Up, Work, Higher and What About Us.
The ballads got a 01 because well...they don't have routines, erm?
Forever Is Over got a low score because it barely has one, but the thing with their arm at some point during the chorus is nice enough, so there you go.

No -1 for me this time. I don't think any of their routines deserve one. However, I've been really nice. I've given 11, 10, 9, and 8...but BY THEIR STANDARDS.

Posted by: Martyn May 1 2015, 04:43 PM

I think we need a consistency for the ones which have multiple routines. E.g What About Us, The Today Show would get a higher score than the UK micstand version.

Posted by: (Zach) May 4 2015, 11:05 PM

If there are multiple routines, I'd go by the better one.

7.0 If This Is Love
8.0 Up
0.0 Issues
5.0 Just Can't Get Enough
8.0 Work
0.0 Forever Is Over
3.0 Ego
9.0 Missing You
4.0 Higher
11.00 Notorious
6.0 All Fired Up
0.0 My Heart Takes Over
6.0 30 Days
10.00 What About Us
7.0 Gentleman
7.0 Disco Love
6.0 Not Giving Up
8.5 What Are You Waiting For?

Posted by: missingyou May 5 2015, 01:20 AM

Disco Love is iconic. that Baby Baby Baby arm thing gives me life. The original WAU is also one of their best. Gentleman was very good as it fits the song so well. also i'm here for the Missing You routine as they did it so many bloody times.

Not including ballads, I think one of the worst was What Are You Waiting For. It was just too fast for them to dance and sing to.

Posted by: Hurricane May 5 2015, 02:46 AM

There is a good routine somewhere in WAYWF, but it's lost with all their usual schtick Aaron gives them so they don't have to dance too much and obviously it's also heavily affected by their (lack of?) talent as dancers.

Posted by: (Zach) May 5 2015, 10:32 PM

I agree, I actually think it's one of their more interesting and complex routines but it's poorly and lazily executed.

Posted by: DJHazey May 6 2015, 12:47 PM

Does this mean their choreograph routines in their videos? Just wanted to confirm. What happens if they don't have one in a video?

Posted by: Hurricane May 6 2015, 08:00 PM

I personally ranked the routines they do live.

Posted by: (Zach) May 9 2015, 05:05 PM

Four rates is all we can manage??? You'll all be sorry when they shut down the Sats forum. Contribute!

Posted by: Totto May 9 2015, 06:29 PM

Posted by: *Tim May 9 2015, 06:30 PM

Betch dont be so desperados for them posts tho. Who even has the time to rank their dance routines?

"1D's haircut rate" teas

Posted by: (Zach) May 9 2015, 06:58 PM

*looks at Tim's signature* OK...


The same people who had time to participate in the Rihanna Pointless

Posted by: *Tim May 9 2015, 07:15 PM

Those are actual discussions about Rih ha career and pointless is just a bit of fun, like we had in the sats forum as well

My points was that this forum is doing fine without all the extra desperate rates. No shade (or maybe it is ) but this forum is so great, it's a shame we are lowering ourselves to rates like this to gain posts

Posted by: Totto May 9 2015, 08:48 PM

Well this escalated quickly

Posted by: April May 9 2015, 09:07 PM

This rate is pointless since there routines are mostly shit and changed so often.

Still waiting for the This Morning performances rate though

Posted by: Sean. May 9 2015, 10:13 PM

Scherz said I could do one and then Lee said I could as well but been one thing after another. Nine months later it will happen this week if I'm still allowed to host, mark my words!

Posted by: April May 9 2015, 10:18 PM

Mollie 'sixth album before Christmas' teas

Posted by: Sean. May 9 2015, 10:24 PM

CHOKING OMG

Posted by: (Zach) May 10 2015, 04:59 PM

I actually love Tim (even if he's in denial and thinks I'm not his fave mod anymore) and I see his point. But I did think this rate was a cool idea

Posted by: *Tim May 11 2015, 12:54 PM

Oh it's nothing personal Zachary! I think I made my point tho so I will not go on about this

Posted by: Totto May 11 2015, 07:20 PM

I don't think it's a bad idea, it's just a random timing not even a build up.

People haven't shown any interest in a 'routine rate', I feel it's just a bit to random.