Printable version of thread

Posted by: Dobbo 8th July 2017, 04:10 PM

Following the release of their latest single 'Sun Comes Up' let's look back on their singles discography & find out which is this site's favourite as of now.

For the purposes of this rate I've only included songs that charted in the UK top 200. One 11 and one -1 permitted per voter.

xx Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
xx Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
xx Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
xx Right Here (feat. Foxes)
xx Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
xx Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
xx Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
xx Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
xx Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
xx I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
xx Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
xx Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
xx Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: awardinary 8th July 2017, 04:20 PM

10 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
7 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
9 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
6 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
6 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
7 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
5 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
7 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
2 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
8 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
5 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
6 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: Dobbo 8th July 2017, 04:25 PM

08 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman) [loved it at the time, hasn't aged well but I'll be generous]
06 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
09 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
08 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
00 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
11 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill) [incredibly underrated, one of the best vocals on a dance song in the last 10 years]
07 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
07 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
10 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance) [outstanding, deserved to be a bigger hit than their current campaign single]
08 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
-1 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard) [horrific]
07 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
05 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: shattered_sanity 8th July 2017, 04:26 PM

Yay, rates are back! (I might host a Guetta discography one after if that's ok/no one else is!)

11 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
7.5 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
9.5 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
8 Right Here (feat. Foxes) (The Andy C remix would be 11 hands down tho)
7 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
6.5 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
6.5 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre) (this one doesn't really fit here imo)
8 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
5.5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
6.5 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
8 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
9 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
7 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: BridgeCow 8th July 2017, 04:48 PM

08 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
07 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
09 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
07 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
04 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
05 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
06 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
08 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
08 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
06 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
11 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
07 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
08 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Forgot how much I like rudimental, especially Rumour Mill, still sounds so amazing

Posted by: Jonjo 8th July 2017, 04:51 PM

11.0 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
07.0 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
10.0 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
08.0 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
07.5 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
07.0 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
08.0 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
08.5 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
06.5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
07.0 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
07.0 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
06.0 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
06.0 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: Dexton 8th July 2017, 05:05 PM

07.5 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
09.0 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
09.5 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
08.0 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
09.5 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
07.0 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
07.0 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)

08.5 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
08.5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
10.0 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
11.0 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
07.5 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)

06.0 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

I enjoyed most of their first era but the first 3 were extremely overplayed, Waiting All Night is the only one I don't mind revisiting. Album #2 however is amazing from beginning to end (I really enjoyed Love Ain't Just A Word, New Day, & Treading On Water too so it's a shame this is just a singles rate )

Posted by: Klaus 8th July 2017, 05:08 PM

Not standing for any Free hate.

Posted by: lewistgreen 8th July 2017, 05:37 PM

Not here for that -1 for Rumour Mill Dobbo

Posted by: Dobbo 8th July 2017, 05:52 PM

Sorry but it's awful :/ which is a bit of shame really as I Will For Love is great & I usually enjoy Anne-Marie's contributions so it SHOULD have been amazing

Posted by: Mrs. Potts 8th July 2017, 09:15 PM

07.5 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
08.5 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
11.0 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
10.0 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
08.0 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
08.0 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
07.5 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
08.0 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
07.5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
08.0 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
06.5 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
08.5 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
07.0 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Always forget how much I like them (because their songs are a bit forgettable, oops) but they have a pretty good collection of bangers here tbh! Would make a great greatest hits playlist to play during the summer

Posted by: DalekTurret32 8th July 2017, 10:46 PM

11 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman) (This is when I first discovered Rudimental, in the Top Music Videos on iTunes back in May 2012. Modern d'n'b classic ]
10.0 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
10.0 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
9.5 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
9.5 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
9.0 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill) [that was before Becky featured in one of my favourite mainsteram dance songs of the 2010's, Gecko (Overdrive) by Oliver Heldens]
8.5 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre) [Medley: Live at the BRIT Awards 2014]
10.0 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran) [Better than the original]
9.5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
9.5 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
9.5 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
9.5 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
9.0 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)




Top 5:

1. Feel The Love
2. Waiting All Night
3. Not Giving In
4. Bloodstream
5. Never Let You Go

Posted by: Davidson 10th July 2017, 11:02 PM

09.0 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
08.0 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
11.0 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
04.0 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
09.0 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
07.5 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
06.0 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
08.0 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
06.5 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
09.5 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
10.0 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
06.0 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
07.5 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: HarryEzra 10th July 2017, 11:41 PM

09 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
07 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
08 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
10 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
06 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
11 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
06 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
09 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
06 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
08 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
10 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
07 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
07 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: Liаm 11th July 2017, 12:58 AM

06 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman) (the only song with this c** on I can even slightly bear)
02 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
09 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
09 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
11 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
09 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
08 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
07 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
04 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
04 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
07 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
05 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
06 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: 360Jupiter 11th July 2017, 01:17 AM

10 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
07 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
08 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
09 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
xx Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
xx Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
xx Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
xx Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
xx Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
xx I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
10 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
11 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
08.5 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Don't know the rest so might come back and edit scores in

Posted by: Dircadirca 11th July 2017, 07:59 AM

10 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
08 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
08.5 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
06 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
05 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
08 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
06 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
07 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
05 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
05 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
05.5 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
04 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
05.5 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: gavindeejay 11th July 2017, 03:39 PM

11 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
07 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
08 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
10 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
09 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
09 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
06 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
08 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
05 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
05 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
08 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
09 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
07 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: danG 11th July 2017, 04:28 PM

10 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
07 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
09 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
06 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
05 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
07 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
05 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
05 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
04 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
03 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
06 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
05 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
05 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

they really are quite average aside from their #1s...

Posted by: Chez Wombat 11th July 2017, 05:06 PM

11 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
05 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
03 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
08 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
05 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
xx Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
07 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
09 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
05 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
xx I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
08 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
06 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
xx Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Only one really great moment (Waiting All Night I grew to hate due to overplay), but never awful at least...

Posted by: shattered_sanity 15th July 2017, 05:55 PM

Edited the rest of mine in

Posted by: Dobbo 22nd July 2017, 11:38 PM

Will be closing this tomorrow so get rating if you haven't already! Zedd rate will close next Sunday.

Posted by: SevenSees 23rd July 2017, 01:08 AM

11 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
09 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
08 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
07 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
06 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
06 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
06 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
08 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
06 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
04 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
08 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
05 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
06 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: cq(uavo)merqn 23rd July 2017, 08:04 AM

10 Feel The Love (feat. John Newman)
00 Not Giving In (feat. John Newman & Alex Clare)
11 Waiting All Night (feat. Ella Eyre)
10 Right Here (feat. Foxes)
07 Free (feat. Emeli Sandé)
03 Powerless (feat. Becky Hill)
00 Pompeii / Waiting All Night (with Bastille & Ella Eyre)
-1 Bloodstream (with Ed Sheeran)
05 Never Let You Go (feat. Foy Vance)
01 I Will For Love (feat. Will Heard)
06 Rumour Mill (feat. Anne-Marie & Will Heard)
00 Lay It All On Me (feat. Ed Sheeran)
10 Sun Comes Up (feat. James Arthur)

Posted by: Dobbo 23rd July 2017, 07:40 PM

Results:

1. Feel The Love 9.56
2. Waiting All Night 8.92
3. Right Here 7.97
4. Rumour Mill 7.69
5. Powerless 7.56
6. Bloodstream 7.35
7. Sun Comes Up 6.85
8. Not Giving In 6.78
9. Free 6.74
10. Lay It All On Me 6.53
11. Never Let You Go 6.29
12. Pompeii/Waiting All Night 6.21
13. I Will For Love 6.03

So their biggest hit & first UK #1 Feel The Love tops the list with an impressive average. Not too far behind is their other #1 Waiting All Night.

Rumour Mill & Powerless both impress finishing in the top 5 considering they're their 2 lowest peaking hits.

New single Sun Comes Up just misses the top half & a 7+ average.

I Will For Love (VERY wrongly) finishes at the bottom but all 13 songs manage a 6+ average score.


Thanks to all participants & be sure to take part in the other 4 current active Dance Forum rates under way right now!

Posted by: danG 23rd July 2017, 08:01 PM

Seems only right that their two #1 singles finish well ahead of everything else. The rest of that top five is decent too.

Posted by: සුනු# 23rd July 2017, 08:20 PM

Decent results! Lay It All On Me was robbed tho!