Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

BuzzJack Music Forum _ Spice Girls _ Spice Girls Singles Rate

Posted by: C.R. Sep 5 2010, 11:01 PM

Ok, here goes nothing...

I was thinking of ways to get our posting up here, and a rate seemed one of the better ways to do it. Plus there didn't seem to be one for at least a few pages back, so some of the forum regulars may want to do this too! happy.gif

Ok, for the rules and all that, there's a list of the Spice Girls singles below, and you need to rate them from 0-10. You can also use ONE -1 and/or 11, but only one of each. There are no other limits or maximums on the scores, so you could give all the songs 0 or 10 (but some variation would be nice.) I'll give it a week or so to let the votes come in, maybe more if not many people do vote, so I'll give a deadline of 12th September for now. If you've bothered to read this far, thanks for wanting to take part, and without further ado, here are the songs;

Wannabe
Say You'll Be There
2 Become 1
Who Do You Think You Are
Mama
Spice Up Your Life
Too Much
Stop
Viva Forever
Goodbye
Holler
Let Love Lead the Way
Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

If I've left any off, or there are any other errors, please say, thanks! I may post in here again with the videos if people want them, I'm a bit tired to do it now (sorry!).

Posted by: JakeWild Sep 6 2010, 07:48 AM

08 Wannabe
08 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
07 Who Do You Think You Are
06 Mama
08 Spice Up Your Life
10 Too Much
09 Stop
11 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
07 Holler
03 Let Love Lead the Way
05 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

i'd never even heard of let love lead the way but i've just had a listen on youtube and wasn't impressed. though like the rest of them i probably would have liked it purely for the nostalgia if i'd heard it at the time.

Posted by: Lukuzz Sep 6 2010, 07:55 AM

07 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
09 Who Do You Think You Are
07 Mama
08 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
08 Stop
11 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye
10 Holler
10 Let Love Lead the Way
08 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Nick F1 Sep 6 2010, 10:27 AM

10 Wannabe
08 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
09 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Mama
10 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
10 Stop
09 Viva Forever
08 Goodbye
09 Holler
07 Let Love Lead the Way
07 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Leonardo2505 Sep 6 2010, 01:18 PM

Wannabe (6)
Say You'll Be There (9)
2 Become 1 (8)
Who Do You Think You Are (11)
Mama (2)
Spice Up Your Life (7)
Too Much (7)
Stop (9)
Viva Forever (6)
Goodbye (4)
Holler (0)
Let Love Lead the Way (0)
Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) (-1)

Posted by: Severin Sep 6 2010, 03:36 PM

01 Wannabe
05 Say You'll Be There
02 2 Become 1
05 Who Do You Think You Are
-1 Mama
03 Spice Up Your Life
04 Too Much
05 Stop
02 Viva Forever
01 Goodbye
00 Holler
01 Let Love Lead the Way
00 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: chart wizard Sep 6 2010, 03:59 PM

Wannabe- 9
Say You'll Be There- 6
2 Become 1- 7
Who Do You Think You Are- 10
Mama- 0
Spice Up Your Life- 9
Too Much- 5
Stop- 5
Viva Forever- 7
Goodbye- 6
Holler- 2
Let Love Lead the Way- 0
Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)- 4

the 0s I haven't heard- none are good enough for an 11 though

Posted by: *Trouble* Sep 6 2010, 05:10 PM

07 Wannabe
09 Say You'll Be There
07 2 Become 1
06 Who Do You Think You Are
05 Mama
06 Spice Up Your Life
07 Too Much
09 Stop
05Viva Forever
05 Goodbye
07 Holler
04 Let Love Lead the Way
04 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Dandy* Sep 6 2010, 06:22 PM

Okay... I'm doing this on the basis of how good the song is for a Spice Girls single...

03 Wannabe
08 Say You'll Be There
11 2 Become 1
08 Who Do You Think You Are
00 Mama
04 Spice Up Your Life
05 Too Much
07 Stop
09 Viva Forever
05 Goodbye
02 Holler
03 Let Love Lead the Way
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: C.R. Sep 6 2010, 07:49 PM

Wow, I didn't realise so many people would vote! ohmy.gif Thanks to everyone so far!

Posted by: C.R. Sep 6 2010, 09:42 PM

06 Wannabe
08 Say You'll Be There
09 2 Become 1
04 Who Do You Think You Are
00 Mama
08 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
11 Stop
10 Viva Forever
06 Goodbye
03 Holler
01 Let Love Lead the Way
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Severin Sep 6 2010, 11:34 PM

When you look at how few singles they had it's quite surprising the impact they had

Posted by: Chriss_S Sep 6 2010, 11:39 PM

10 Wannabe
07 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
06 Who Do You Think You Are
06 Mama
11 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
07 Stop
10 Viva Forever
06 Goodbye
08 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
05 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: West Sep 6 2010, 11:43 PM

08 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
09 Who Do You Think You Are
07 Mama
06 Spice Up Your Life
10 Too Much
10 Stop
09 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
07 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Casey__ Sep 8 2010, 11:35 AM

09 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
09 Who Do You Think You Are
06 Mama
09 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
06 Stop
11 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye
08 Holler
05 Let Love Lead the Way
06 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Oh, I do rather love them.. wub.gif

Posted by: 152.chris Sep 8 2010, 02:21 PM

10 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
10 Who Do You Think You Are
07 Mama
08 Spice Up Your Life
05 Too Much
09 Stop
04 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
00 Holler
00 Let Love Lead the Way
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

don't care that im blue waffle i'm doing this tongue.gif

Posted by: C.R. Sep 8 2010, 07:22 PM

That's the spirit Chris!

Posted by: JakeWild Sep 9 2010, 12:23 PM

i'm so glad that viva forever is getting so many big marks. i always thought it was so underrated but obviously not smile.gif

headlines really deserves these terrible scores though. what a disappointing 'comeback'

Posted by: gooddelta Sep 9 2010, 12:35 PM

I'll be a traitor and do this, now come and do my Delta rate Toxic's!

09 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
05 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Mama
05 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
10 Stop
11 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
-1 Holler
08 Let Love Lead the Way
07 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) - 5 extra marks for Mel's second verse

Posted by: Severin Sep 9 2010, 04:37 PM

QUOTE(gooddelta @ Sep 9 2010, 01:35 PM) *
I'll be a traitor and do this, now come and do my Delta rate Toxic's!

I would but I only know about 3 songs.

Posted by: Dandy* Sep 9 2010, 06:02 PM

Me too.

But YAY for gooddelta, I'm sure he can never resist a rate. biggrin.gif

Posted by: AaronTM Sep 10 2010, 02:43 AM

QUOTE(Severin @ Sep 7 2010, 12:34 AM) *
When you look at how few singles they had it's quite surprising the impact they had

I know! Between all the albums, there's only 34 songs, you could almost fit them all into one rate really. Even with B-sides you probably couldn't make 50 songs. They had a massive impact in such a short space of time and lack of material.

Anyway, my rate is totally biased, but here goes:

08 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
07 Who Do You Think You Are
06 Mama
09 Spice Up Your Life
11 Too Much
10 Stop
10 Viva Forever
08 Goodbye
09 Holler
07 Let Love Lead the Way
09 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

And that's me trying to be strict. I'd probably rate the majority of them as 10, but I have a very definite top four so I thought I'd make it a bit fairer. Headlines gets way too much hate. sad.gif

Posted by: Theo. Sep 10 2010, 04:58 PM

DON'T TELL QUEST! ph34r.gif

09 // Wannabe
10 // Say You'll Be There
09 // 2 Become 1
11 // Who Do You Think You Are
08 // Mama
10 // Spice Up Your Life
08 // Too Much
09 // Stop
08 // Viva Forever
07 // Goodbye
06 // Holler
06 // Let Love Lead the Way
06 // Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Their discography got awful towards the end. mellow.gif

Posted by: C.R. Sep 10 2010, 10:13 PM

Thanks everyone! I think I will still close it on Sunday, so if you've yet to vote, please do so!

Posted by: C.R. Sep 12 2010, 07:31 PM

Ok, it looks like those are the only votes we're going to get. Can Aaron or someone close this then, I'll get the votes added up and present the results later.

Posted by: Dré Sep 12 2010, 10:11 PM

06 Wannabe
07 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
08 Who Do You Think You Are
09 Mama
08 Spice Up Your Life
07 Too Much
-1 Stop
11 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
09 Holler
10 Let Love Lead the Way
02 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Powered by Invision Power Board
© Invision Power Services