Printable version of thread

Posted by: Jay ☆ 13th April 2018, 06:31 PM

Posted by: Blond 2.0 13th April 2018, 06:49 PM

Rate:

10 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
08 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
11 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
08 Stop
10 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye
10 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
06 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank:

01 Spice Up Your Life
02 Say You'll Be There
03 2 Become 1
04 Wanna Be
05 Holler
06 Who Do You Think You Are
07 Too Much
08 Goodbye
09 Stop
10 Viva Forever
11 Mama
12 Let Love Lead the Way
13 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Jay ☆ 13th April 2018, 07:13 PM

^ Just one score of '11' is allowed, Blond! Could you edit?

Posted by: Mr.X 13th April 2018, 07:43 PM

YYAYAYYAYAYAYAYYAYA

Thanks for this Jay

Here are my votes:

RATE:
Wannabe - 10
Say You'll Be There - 10
2 Become 1 - 07
Mama - -1
Who Do You Think You Are - 11
Spice Up Your Life - 4
Too Much - 08
Stop - 08
Viva Forever - 10
Goodbye - 10
Holler - 10
Let Love Lead the Way - 03
Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) - 01

RANK:

1. Who Do You Think You Are (favourite)
2. Holler
3. Viva Forever
4. Say You'll Be There
5. Goodbye
6. Stop
7. Wannabe
8. Too Much
9. 2 Become 1
10. Spice Up Your Life
11. Let Love lead The Way
12. Headlines
13. Mama

Posted by: vibe 13th April 2018, 08:20 PM

Rate
Wannabe 8 (not the best video but memories of this being on the box 24/7 , the video captures the spirit of the group wonderfully).

Say You’ll Be There 8 (I would score this higher cos I love it but I do question how it matches the lyric)

2 Become 1 9

Who Do You Think You Are 7 (Emma’s Perm always makes me laugh)

Mama 5.5

Spice Up Your Life 7.5 (love the video but wish the girls got their way with the carnival video that they wanted)

Too Much 7

Stop 6.5

Viva Forever -1 (animation was a cool idea , I like the spice fairies but hate the rest of it)

Goodbye 11 (my fav)

Holler 6

Let Love Lead The Way 5

Headlines 0 (does not match the lyric at all , that bloody victoria secrets deal)

RANK
1. Goodbye
2. 2 Become 1
3. Wannabe
4. Say Youll Be There
5. Spice Up Your Life
6. Too Much
7. Who Do You Think You Are
8. Stop
9. Holler
10. Mama
11. Let Love Lead The Way
12. Headlines
13. Viva Forever

Posted by: Jade 13th April 2018, 08:22 PM

Rate

08 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
07 Become 1
06 Mama
07 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
09 Stop
08 Viva Forever
07 Goodbye
07 Holler
05 Let Love Lead the Way
-01 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank

01. Say You'll Be There
02. Spice Up Your Life
03. Stop
04. Too Much
05. Wannabe
06. Viva Forever
07. Who Do You Think You Are
08. 2 Become 1
09. Holler
10. Goodbye
11. Mama
12. Let Love Lead The Way
13. Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

'Say You'll Be There' is their best music video by miles! 'Spice Up Your Life' was fun also and very self-aware. 'Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)' felt so cold.

Posted by: schizo_spice 13th April 2018, 10:13 PM

Rate

Wannabe 09
Say You'll Be There 11
2 Become 1 10
Mama 06
Who Do You Think You Are 08
Spice Up Your Life 10
Too Much 09
Stop 10
Viva Forever 08
Goodbye 10
Holler 06
Let Love Lead the Way 07
Headlines 05

Rank

Say You'll Be There
Stop
2 Become 1
Spice Up Your Life
Goodbye
Wannabe
Too Much
Who Do You Think You Are
Viva Forever
Let Love Lead the Way
Mama
Holler
Headlines

Posted by: Maz! 14th April 2018, 08:03 AM

Rate

10 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
09 2 Become 1
08 Mama
10 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
10 Stop
07 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
09 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
-01 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank
1.Say You''ll Be There
2.Stop
3.Spice Up Your Life
4.Who Do You Think You Are
5.Wannabe
6.Too Much
7.Goodbye
8.Holler
9.2 Become 1
10.Mama
11.Viva Forever
12.Let Love Lead The Way
13.Headlines(Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Blond 2.0 14th April 2018, 02:47 PM

Ya'll don't like headlines video

Posted by: SouthernStar88 14th April 2018, 06:36 PM

08 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
09 2 Become 1
06 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
05 Spice Up Your Life
07 Too Much
10 Stop
07 Viva Forever
11 Goodbye
08 Holler
04 Let Love Lead the Way
03 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

01 Goodbye
02 Stop
03 Say You'll Be There
04 2 Become 1
05 Holler
06 Wannabe
07 Who Do You Think You Are
08 Too Much
09 Viva Forever
10 Mama
11 Spice Up Your Life
12 Let Love Lead the Way
13 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: letloverule 14th April 2018, 07:26 PM

Rate:

10 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
09 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
08 Stop
07 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye
08 Holler
07 Let Love Lead the Way
07 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank:

01 Say You'll Be There
02 Spice Up Your Life
03 2 Become 1
04 Wannabe
05 Goodbye
06 Mama
07 Who Do You Think You Are
08 Stop
09 Holler
10 Too Much
11 Viva Forever
12 Let Love Lead the Way
13 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Michael Andrew 14th April 2018, 11:01 PM

Rate:

10 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
05 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
08 Stop
09 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye
09 Holler
05 Let Love Lead the Way
03 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank:

01 Say You'll Be There
02 Spice Up Your Life
03 2 Become 1
04 Wannabe
05 Goodbye
06 Holler
07 Viva Forever
08 Too Much
09 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Stop
11 Mama
12 Let Love Lead the Way
13 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Michael Andrew 14th April 2018, 11:08 PM

'Headlines' wasn't their worst music video though...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AtVGYFeiD2A

Posted by: Spiceboy 15th April 2018, 11:46 AM

I think headlines is worse tbh. At least there group shots in the England United video... they really got the headlines video so so so wrong.

Posted by: Blond 2.0 15th April 2018, 02:40 PM

QUOTE(Jay ☆ @ Apr 13 2018, 07:13 PM)

^ Just one score of '11' is allowed, Blond! Could you edit?

Posted by: missingyou 16th April 2018, 11:49 AM

RATE

08 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
11 2 Become 1
06 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
05 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
09 Stop
07 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
08 Holler
03 Let Love Lead The Way
09 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

RANK
01 2 Become 1
02 Say You'll Be There
03 Goodbye
04 Wannabe
05 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)
06 Stop
07 Holler
08 Too Much
09 Spice Up Your Life
10 Who Do You Think You Are
11 Viva Forever
12 Mama
13 Let Love Lead The Way

Posted by: Queef of Peace 16th April 2018, 04:00 PM

Rate:

10 Wannabe
7 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
02 Mama
05 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
05 Stop
06 Viva Forever
10 Goodbye
11 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank:

01 Holler Spice Up Your Life [Favourite]
02 Spice Up Your Life
03 Goodbye
04 2 Become 1
05 Wannabe
06 Too Much
07 Say You'll be There
08 Let Love Lead The Way
09 Viva Forever
10 Who Do You Think You Are
11 Stop
12 Mama
13 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) [Least Favourite]

Posted by: Queef of Peace 16th April 2018, 04:02 PM

QUOTE(Michael Andrew @ Apr 15 2018, 12:08 AM)

'Headlines' wasn't their worst music video though...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AtVGYFeiD2A

Posted by: HarryEzra 16th April 2018, 06:09 PM

Rate

09 Wannabe
08 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
07 Mama
10 Who Do You Think You Are
11 Spice Up Your Life
07 Too Much
08 Stop
10 Viva Forever
07 Goodbye
09 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
03 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank
1. Spice Up Your Life
2. Viva Forever
3. Who Do You Think You Are
4. Holler
5. Wannabe
6. Say You'll Be There
7. 2 Become 1
8. Stop
9. Too Much
10. Goodbye
11. Mama
12. Let Love Lead The Way
13. Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Queef of Peace 16th April 2018, 06:38 PM

Anyone who isn't putting Holler up there with Goodbye/ Spice Up Yo Life just hasn't watched it

Posted by: Jay ☆ 22nd April 2018, 01:48 PM

Any more?

Posted by: Spiceboy 22nd April 2018, 05:11 PM

I'll do mine now

Posted by: Spiceboy 22nd April 2018, 05:16 PM

11 - Spice up your life
10 - Viva forever (adore this video think it fits perfectly, took the girls to a whole new level!)
10 - Who do you think you are
10 - Wannabe (iconic, fits the song perfectly, sums up the girls to a tee)
10 - Holler
10 - Stop
10 - 2 become 1
9 - Say you'll be there
8 - Goodbye
6 - Let love lead the way (only rated higher than Mama because it has a theme)
5 - Mama
-1 - Headlines (hate the video tbh, I quite like the song but the video just killed it. Not appropriate just a cheap Victoria Secrets ad and virtually no scenes with all 5 together WTF.)

Posted by: PINKFUNQ 22nd April 2018, 10:02 PM

Rate
09 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
06 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
11 Spice Up Your Life
07 Too Much
08 Stop
07 Viva Forever
08 Goodbye
09 Holler
06 Let Love Lead the Way
04 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank
01. Spice up your life
02. 2 become 1
03. Say you'll be there
04. Wannabe
05. Holler
06. Stop
07. Who do you think you are
08. Goodbye
09. Too much
10. Viva forever
11. Let love lead the way
12. Mama
13. Headlines

Posted by: Euphorique 23rd April 2018, 09:45 PM

Rate:

07 Wannabe
08 Say You'll Be There
10 2 Become 1
07 Mama
07 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
10 Too Much
05 Stop
09 Viva Forever
08 Goodbye
11 Holler
09 Let Love Lead the Way
02 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank:

01 Holler
02 Spice Up Your Life
03 2 Become 1
04 Too Much
05 Viva Forever
06 Let Love Lead The Way
07 Goodbye
08 Say You'll Be There
09 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Wannabe
11 Mama
12 Stop
13 Headlines

Posted by: Jay ☆ 23rd April 2018, 10:49 PM

Thanks everyone! I may as well keep this open a little longer, I've not submitted my own rate/rank yet! So if there's any more to come, you've still got time.

Posted by: ...ready for it 25th April 2018, 04:18 AM

Rate
10 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
11 2 Become 1
06 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are
09 Spice Up Your Life
07 Too Much
06 Stop
05 Viva Forever
06 Goodbye
09 Holler
08 Let Love Lead the Way
05 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank
1. 2 Become 1
2. Wannabe
3. Say You'll Be There
4. Spice Up Your Life
5. Holler
6. Let Love Lead the Way
7. Who Do You Think You Are
8. Too Much
9. Goodbye
10. Mama
11. Stop
12. Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)
13. Viva Forever

Posted by: Jay ☆ 26th April 2018, 01:23 AM

Rank
01 Spice Up Your Life
02 2 Become 1
03 Say You'll Be There
04 Holler
05 Wannabe
06 Who Do You Think You Are
07 Too Much
08 Stop
09 Goodbye
10 Let Love Lead the Way
11 Viva Forever
12 Mama
13 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rate
09.0 Wannabe
10.0 Say You'll Be There
10.0 2 Become 1
04.0 Mama
09.0 Who Do You Think You Are
11.0 Spice Up Your Life
08.0 Too Much
08.0 Stop
07.5 Viva Forever
07.5 Goodbye
09.5 Holler
06.5 Let Love Lead the Way
-01.0 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

--------

I'll start figuring out the results soon. Feel free to post a rate/rank if you haven't already, you can do right up until I've started the results thread.

Posted by: Jamesy 27th April 2018, 10:42 PM

11 Say You’ll Be There
10 Spice Up Your Life
09 Too Much
09 2 Become 1
09 Stop
09 Wannabe
08 Who Do You Think You Are
08 Goodbye
07 Holler
07 Let Love Lead The Way
07 Mama
05 Viva Forever
04 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: colinn 27th April 2018, 10:49 PM

Rate
10 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
09 2 Become 1
02 Mama
03 Who Do You Think You Are
09 Spice Up Your Life
06 Too Much
05 Stop
09 Viva Forever
06 Goodbye
08 Holler
02 Let Love Lead the Way
01 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Rank
1. Say You'll Be There
2. Spice Up Your Life
3. Wannabe
4. 2 Become 1
5. Viva Forever
6. Holler
7. Goodbye
8. Too Much
9. Stop
10. Who Do You Think You Are?
11. Let Love Lead The Way
12. Mama
13. Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Jay ☆ 28th April 2018, 12:39 AM

I've looked through a few of the submissions (thanks to everyone for contributing). Unfortunately it seems a few of you didn't interpret the rank & rate activity in the way I had intended it!

Your rate and rank are supposed to correlate. For example, if you gave Stop a rate score of 10 and Holler a 9, then your rank should have Stop placed above Holler!

However I'm seeing rates and ranks that don't follow this logic. For instance...

Rate Scores
08 Who Do You Think You Are
09 Too Much
10 Goodbye

Rank Positions
6th Who Do You Think You Are
7th Too Much
8th Goodbye

... so while the rate suggests Goodbye is their favourite of those three, the rank has it as their least favourite.


I PM'd a couple of you about this, but unfortunately as I've checked through more posts, it's become evident that this is a more widespread issue than I had initially feared! I think it's a bit too far gone now, unfortunately. I guess something got lost in translation. So... I've made the decision that I'm only going to work out results from your Rate scores. Therefore I'm going to disregard the Ranks. I'm sorry, I just think it'd be a flawed outcome to count contributions where an individual is saying one video is better than another in their rate, but then is saying the opposite in their rank.


Anyway, I'm sorry for any confusion caused!


I'll endeavour to start posting the rate results in May. Thanks again to those of you who contributed, I do appreciate it!

Posted by: vibe 30th April 2018, 06:45 PM

Not hard to correlate to be fair . Your opening post was clear imo .

Posted by: Spiceboy 30th April 2018, 09:00 PM

Wtf How did people rank like that!?

Posted by: Michael Andrew 1st May 2018, 12:32 PM

What a mare! Hope that wasn't me.

Anyway, seems like the best solution.

Thanks Jay :-)

Posted by: Jay ☆ 13th May 2018, 11:07 PM

This has taken a bit of a backseat to another activity I'm doing in the Lounge, but rest assured I will post the results for this asap.

If anyone hasn't taken part and would like to, that'd be great - but please only do a rate

Posted by: Sparrow 16th May 2018, 01:14 AM

Well, poll's apparently ended but I'm doing nothing right now, so...

Rate
10 Wannabe
10 Say You'll Be There
07 2 Become 1
05 Mama
08 Who Do You Think You Are (sugar lumps version)
10 Spice Up Your Life
10 Too Much
06 Stop
10 Viva Forever
08 Goodbye
10 Holler
03 Let Love Lead the Way
-1 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends) - this video is painfully ridiculous

Rank
Wannabe
Spice Up Your Life
Viva Forever
Holler
Too Much
Say You'll Be There
Who Do You Think You Are (sugar lumps version)
Goodbye
Stop
2 Become 1
Mama
Let Love Lead the Way
Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: Lukuzz 16th May 2018, 05:49 AM

7.5 Wannabe
11 Say You'll Be There
08 2 Become 1
05 Mama
09 Who Do You Think You Are
10 Spice Up Your Life
08 Too Much
07 Stop
08 Viva Forever
09 Goodbye
10 Holler
09 Let Love Lead the Way
05 Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Posted by: SamJudd 16th May 2018, 04:45 PM