Printable version of thread
Click here to view this topic in its original format
BuzzJack Music Forum _ R&B and Hip-Hop _ I Am... Sasha Fierce SURVIVOR [Round 3]
Posted by: Infludexton* Apr 24 2020, 03:29 AM
If I Were A Boy 0 votes [0.00%]
Halo 0 votes [0.00%]
Disappear 2 votes [8.00%]
Broken-Hearted Girl 0 votes [0.00%]
Ava Maria 1 vote [4.00%]
Smash Into You 0 votes [0.00%]
That's Why You're Beautiful 2 votes[8.00%]
Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) 8 votes [32.00%]
Radio 2 votes [8.00%]
Sweet Dreams 0 votes [0.00%]
Video Phone (Standard or feat. Lady Gaga) 7 votes [28.00%]
Hello 0 votes [0.00%]
Ego 1 vote [4.00%]
Scared Of Lonely 2 votes [8.00%]
Round 2 is over and it's Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) eliminated this time! It gets a lot of flack on Buzzjack so I'm not too surprised but it should've been a couple of spaces higher at least tbh.
14 Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) [8/25]
=15 Diva [6/23]
=15 Satellites [6/23]
Posted by: Infludexton* Apr 24 2020, 03:30 AM
Shame to see Single Ladies out oh well, hopefully Radio or Video Phone are out next! Then it starts to get a bit trickier 
Posted by: Jay ☆ Apr 24 2020, 03:41 AM
Oh BuzzJack 
Voting Video Phone again!
Posted by: WinterFreeze Apr 24 2020, 05:26 AM
Video Phone is average with or without Lady Gaga. I’m voting for that.
Posted by: Scene Apr 24 2020, 05:30 AM
That's Why You're Beautiful
Posted by: Hauspital* Apr 24 2020, 09:39 AM
Also That's Why You're Beautiful!
Posted by: Condebola* Apr 24 2020, 09:50 AM
Diva and Single Ladies were probably both in the Top 3 so this got really dark really fast. Especially with some WHO???? songs still in here. :/ :/
Posted by: Infludexton* Apr 24 2020, 10:55 AM
You spelled If I Were A Boy and Halo wrong x
Posted by: LMLou Apr 24 2020, 10:56 AM
That's Why You're Beautiful, most forgetful song on the album
Posted by: Jay ☆ Apr 24 2020, 12:52 PM
I consider 'Disappear' to be the most forgettable song from Disc 1, although 'That's Why You're Beautiful' is probably my second least favourite from it (for me, both of them are better than half of what Disc 2 has to offer though). I still think 'Satellites' going first was an injustice! 
Posted by: Gerald Apr 25 2020, 01:47 PM
Voting for Disappear!
Posted by: Feel_The_Fever Apr 25 2020, 02:50 PM
Video phone
Posted by: Tawdry Hepburn Apr 25 2020, 09:54 PM
Video Phone
SO pleased 'Single Ladies' is out that soon, worst song ever!
Posted by: Jay ☆ Apr 26 2020, 04:35 AM
This has to be hyperbole, surely?
Posted by: Jay ☆ Apr 26 2020, 05:35 AM
Just to drive the point home about how different~ BuzzJack is towards Single Ladies, it placed 3rd out of all the I Am... Sasha Fierce tracks in a Popjustice rate of Beyoncé's entire discography. Interestingly Diva is better regarded there too. Judging by the fact that Sweet Dreams only came 30th, it seems this album isn't her most highly regarded on Popjustice.
30. Sweet Dreams - 8.190
32. Halo - 8.095
40. Single Ladies (Put a Ring On It) - 7.908
54. Smash Into You - 7.278
57. If I Were A Boy - 7.158
62. Diva - 7.051
66. Scared of Lonely - 6.896
72. Disappear - 6.718
74. Radio - 6.465
78. Broken-Hearted Girl - 6.239
89. Video Phone - 5.886
90. Ego - 5.813
91. Hello - 5.782
92. Ave Maria - 5.731
98. Satellites - 5.358
105. That's Why You're Beautiful - 4.677
70. Why Don't You Love Me - 6.753 [Bonus]
99. Poison - 5.307 [Bonus]
106. Save The Hero - 4.639 [Bonus]
110. Honesty - 4.199 [Bonus]
I looked at BuzzJack's own Beyoncé full discography rate (from 2013) and Single Ladies came 9th out of the original 16 tracks.
1 Halo 9.320
5 Sweet Dreams 8.820
12 Broken-Hearted Girl 8.200
13 If I Were A Boy 8.140
18 Radio 7.750
29 (more tens) Smash Into You 7.146
30 Scared Of Lonely 7.146
40 Ave Maria 6.896
42 Single Ladies (Put A Ring On it) 6.820
43 Hello 6.792
46 Disappear 6.417
54 Diva 6.220
56 Satellites 6.146
71 Video Phone 5.250
73 (more eights) That's Why You're Beautiful 5.167
77 Ego 5.080
14 Why Don't You Love Me? 8.042 [Bonus]
44 Save The Hero 6.667 [Bonus]
62 Poison 5.833 [Bonus]
64 (more nines) Honesty 5.750 [Bonus]
I suppose in a survivor it's easier to get a divisive song out earlier.
It would be interesting to do another full Beyoncé discography rate at some point!
Posted by: Infludexton* Apr 26 2020, 06:53 AM
That's true, survivors aren't typically the most accurate 
I'm shocked that only Sweet Dreams was Top 30 for them though.
Posted by: Scene Apr 26 2020, 08:27 AM
Yes! Especially if the last one was 7 years ago.
Posted by: Hauspital* Apr 26 2020, 12:08 PM
In a survivor, haters of a track can easily pick it out over tracks that they are indifferent on. That surely explains why it's out so early - because it's divisive. People either love it or find it irritating and in a poll like this those that are irritated by it have a louder voice.
Posted by: Infludexton* Apr 26 2020, 02:12 PM
More pleasssseeee 
Posted by: fl00zy* Apr 26 2020, 03:50 PM
Single Ladies & Diva out already over the ballads?
Welcome to PopJack
Posted by: Infludexton* Apr 27 2020, 05:18 AM
Closed now while I have time, thanks
Powered by Invision Power Board
© Invision Power Services