Printable version of thread

Posted by: Cremey 10th October 2014, 03:14 PM

Seems an appropriate time to rate this solid discography.
Usual rules of one 11 and one -1 (not expecting to see any of these though..) allowed per album blah blah.
Have just included the albums plus the Robert Smith version of 'Not in Love' – any more people want to add?



xx Untrust Us
xx Alice Practice
xx Crimewave
xx Magic Spells
xx Xxzxcuzx Me
xx Air War
xx Courtship Dating
xx Good Time
xx 1991
xx Vanished
xx Knights
xx Love and Caring
xx Through the Hosiery
xx Reckless
xx Black Panther
xx Tell Me What to Swallow




xx Fainting Spells
xx Celestica
xx Doe Deer
xx Baptism
xx Year of Silence
xx Empathy
xx Suffocation
xx Violent Dreams
xx Vietnam
xx Birds
xx Pap Smear
xx Not in Love
xx Intimate
xx I Am Made of Chalk

xx Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith)




xx Plague
xx Kerosene
xx Wrath of God
xx Affection
xx Pale Flesh
xx Sad Eyes
xx Insulin
xx Transgender
xx Violent Youth
xx Telepath
xx Mercenary
xx Child I Will Hurt You

Posted by: AntoineTTe 10th October 2014, 03:47 PM

This might force me to listen to III

Posted by: ϑЃεβϘ 10th October 2014, 08:33 PM

I have to listen to I more. Never got into it at the time although listened to II this afternoon and still sounds great.

Posted by: Cremey 10th October 2014, 09:16 PM

Yes Tony, you definitely need to listen to III if you haven't yet! It's actually my favourite of the three, although there's not much to separate them as they're all great. I'd say it's III>I>II for me but that seems so wrong as I love II!

Posted by: Conderella 10th October 2014, 09:29 PM

I think I'll give all of the albums a listen before I rate because a few songs are not as fresh in my memory as the others.

Posted by: Conderella 13th October 2014, 08:14 AM

Relistening to the entire discography in one sit made me feel so stupidly emotional that Ethan + Alice are no more and we probably won't get anything as perfect as this from either of them separately.

Posted by: Conderella 13th October 2014, 08:15 AM

_____ † † †

I
__________ just because we don't feel flesh doesn't mean we don't fear death

08 Untrust Us
10 Alice Practice
10 Crimewave
07 Magic Spells
11 xxzxcuzx me
09 Air War
10 Courtship Dating
06 Good Time
06 1991
08 Vanished
07 Knights
10 Love and Caring
08 Through the Hosiery
07 Reckless
09 Black Panther
09 Tell Me What to Swallow

II
__________ i suffocate and promise me you won't resuscitate

08 Fainting Spells
09 Celestica
10 Doe Deer
10 Baptism
05 Year of Silence
08 Empathy
11 Suffocation
09 Violent Dreams
08 Vietnam
08 Birds
10 Pap Smear
09 Not in Love
10 Intimate
07 I Am Made of Chalk
10 Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith)

III
__________ i'll protect you from all the things i've seen

10 Plague
10 Kerosene
09 Wrath of God
11 Affection
09 Pale Flesh
10 Sad Eyes
10 Insulin
08 Transgender
08 Violent Youth
08 Telepath
09 Mercenary
10 Child I Will Hurt You

_____ † † †

Posted by: 152chris 13th October 2014, 09:56 AM

legit think my rate is gonna be identical to pavel's lol. will have a cc day tomo and then vote 💟💖💟

(can't even rank them tho. think iii is my fav but then what about ii? AND I?? nope can't bye)

Posted by: Conderella 13th October 2014, 10:08 AM

omg S A M E

i'd rather listen to Cheryl's discography than decide on whether I prefer I to II or the other way round.

Posted by: Heezus Froot 13th October 2014, 12:15 PM

I think you should go for the one that you heard first, then. Extra points for nostalgia . I love I and II equally, but it was II that got me into CC

Posted by: Conderella 15th October 2014, 05:46 AM

french fries french LIES

Posted by: ✖ ketalina ✖ 15th October 2014, 08:32 AM

08 Untrust Us
07 Alice Practice
10 Crimewave
08 Magic Spells
08 Xxzxcuzx Me
09 Air War
11 Courtship Dating
08 Good Time
09 1991
09 Vanished
10 Knights
07 Love and Caring
07 Through the Hosiery
09 Reckless
10 Black Panther
09 Tell Me What to Swallow



10 Fainting Spells
10 Celestica
11 Doe Deer
07 Baptism
08 Year of Silence
09 Empathy
10 Suffocation
09 Violent Dreams
07 Vietnam
07 Birds
08 Pap Smear
09 Not in Love
10 Intimate
10 I Am Made of Chalk

10 Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith)



10 Plague
10 Kerosene
11 Wrath of God
10 Affection
09 Pale Flesh
08 Sad Eyes
08 Insulin
09 Transgender
10 Violent Youth
09 Telepath
08 Mercenary
09 Child I Will Hurt You

Posted by: Heezus Froot 21st October 2014, 01:00 PM

What's the deadline for this? Should I hurry up?

Posted by: Conderella 21st October 2014, 01:14 PM

Considering only two rates have been posted over the span of like 10 days, I think you're safe for at least a couple of weeks.

Posted by: uraqt 22nd October 2014, 02:22 PM

haha yeah I'll leave it going for a while, I need to do mine too. Aiming to get 10 or so rates at least?!
Hopefully people haven't done theirs yet because they're too busy reminding themselves of the albums..

Posted by: 152chris 22nd October 2014, 02:28 PM

exactement crémé.

will probs vote tonight actually. can I put two 11s in one album and none in another? there's on that has BOTH of their huge standouts and I wanna acknowledge them (guess which one yall)

Posted by: uraqt 22nd October 2014, 02:44 PM

hmm tricky. I'm tempted to say just one for each but no one likes a bore, so go for ittt.
Ha as for the album, III is my favourite but I can imagine you being more of a II kinda guy?

Posted by: Conderella 22nd October 2014, 02:52 PM

I'd give Doe Deer and Plague my 11 as well if I could. But the three that got it in the end have a special place in my heart so there was no other way really.

It was so tough to rate thooooo.

Still playing III occasionally. That first 7 tracks is just a PERFECT little sub-album. You don't even need to make a separate playlist for songs you want to listen to i'm so lazy

Posted by: 152chris 22nd October 2014, 10:01 PM

10 Untrust Us
10 Alice Practice
09 Crimewave
09 Magic Spells
10 Xxzxcuzx Me
08 Air War
11 Courtship Dating
07 Good Time
08 1991
10 Vanished
07 Knights
06 Love and Caring
06 Through the Hosiery
09 Reckless
06 Black Panther
10 Tell Me What to Swallow


07 Fainting Spells
11 Celestica
08 Doe Deer
10 Baptism
09 Year of Silence
08 Empathy
10 Suffocation
09 Violent Dreams
10 Vietnam
09 Birds
09 Pap Smear
06 Not in Love
07 Intimate
07 I Am Made of Chalk

10 Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith)


10 Plague
10 Kerosene
10 Wrath of God
11 Affection
08 Pale Flesh
09 Sad Eyes
07 Insulin
08 Transgender
08 Violent Youth
08 Telepath
09 Mercenary
10 Child I Will Hurt You

i could quite literally write an essay about how perfect (III) is as an album; the message, the songs, the ARTWORK it's just kind of a masterclass in pulling off a concept album without having to force it on people. one of my all time bests.

the two career highlight songs tho are defo celestica and not in love robert version. would have liked to give both 11 but it doesn't look like anyone else is doing that so i won't be that guy.

s f g

Posted by: 152chris 22nd October 2014, 10:05 PM

also still the best band i've ever seen live and just died a lil inside at the realisation that will never happen again

Posted by: Harve 24th October 2014, 12:09 PM

09 Untrust Us
10 Alice Practice
07 Crimewave
09 Magic Spells
10 Xxzxcuzx Me
06 Air War
08 Courtship Dating
07 Good Time
05 1991
08 Vanished
06 Knights
10 Love and Caring
10 Through the Hosiery
04 Reckless
08 Black Panther
11 Tell Me What to Swallow


07 Fainting Spells
10 Celestica
08 Doe Deer
10 Baptism
09 Year of Silence
06 Empathy
10 Suffocation
06 Violent Dreams
03 Vietnam
07 Birds
07 Pap Smear
09 Not in Love
10 Intimate
02 I Am Made of Chalk

11 Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith)


09 Plague
06 Kerosene
09 Wrath of God
07 Affection
06 Pale Flesh
10 Sad Eyes
06 Insulin
04 Transgender
06 Violent Youth
04 Telepath
02 Mercenary
11 Child I Will Hurt You

The tracks I've rated 4/10 aren't ACTUALLY 4/10 tracks (their discography is so consistently great!) but doing so favours my faves, mathematically. That sentence makes no sense but I hope you've deduced some sort of meaning if you're still reading this far~

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 12:12 PM

Closing tracks are 11s ha!

Posted by: Harve 24th October 2014, 12:18 PM

'Tell Me What To Swallow' is a PERFECT change of pace following the chaos of the rest of the album. I love it when an album finishes like that.

Posted by: Heezus Froot 24th October 2014, 12:23 PM

10 Untrust Us AMAZING.
06 Alice Practice
10 Crimewave AMAZING.
08 Magic Spells
05 Xxzxcuzx Me
07 Air War
11 Courtship Dating AMAZING.
06 Good Time
06 1991
07 Vanished
07 Knights
05 Love and Caring
10 Through the Hosiery AMAZING.
07 Reckless
07 Black Panther
06 Tell Me What to Swallow



00 Fainting Spells
10 Celestica AMAZING.
00 Doe Deer
10 Baptism AMAZING.
10 Year of Silence AMAZING.
07 Empathy
06 Suffocation
06 Violent Dreams
08 Vietnam
10 Birds AMAZING.
11 Pap Smear THEIR BEST SONG EVER.
03 Not in Love OVERRATED.
06 Intimate
-1 I Am Made of Chalk WHAT THE F***.

02 Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith) EVEN MORE OVERRATED.



11 Plague AMAZING.
08 Kerosene
06 Wrath of God
07 Affection
05 Pale Flesh
07 Sad Eyes
06 Insulin
08 Transgender
06 Violent Youth
06 Telepath
06 Mercenary
07 Child I Will Hurt You



III is a bit of a let down, but still a great body of work.

Fainting Spells - Doe Deer - I Am Made of Chalk is the biggest WTF of their discography.

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 12:26 PM

-1 and 0s

just NO

NO NO NO NO

Posted by: Heezus Froot 24th October 2014, 12:32 PM

They Are Crap, Ya Ya Ya

I seriously hate those three with passion. One of the few times I've ever deleted a track from an album in my iTunes (I usually let them be). I don't even want to see them.

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 12:51 PM

doe deer tho

:'(

Posted by: Cremey_SZN 24th October 2014, 12:52 PM

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 12:54 PM

where is YOUR rate tho

Posted by: Cremey_SZN 24th October 2014, 01:07 PM

10 Untrust Us
09 Alice Practice
10 Crimewave
07 Magic Spells
06 Xxzxcuzx Me
07 Air War
10 Courtship Dating
07 Good Time
08 1991
09 Vanished
08 Knights
05 Love and Caring
07 Through the Hosiery
08 Reckless
10 Black Panther
11 Tell Me What to Swallow



05 Fainting Spells
10 Celestica
08 Doe Deer
10 Baptism
06 Year of Silence
08 Empathy
08 Suffocation
07 Violent Dreams
05 Vietnam
06 Birds
08 Pap Smear
09 Not in Love
07 Intimate
04 I Am Made of Chalk

11 Not in Love (feat. Robert Smith)



11 Plague
10 Kerosene
08 Wrath of God
10 Affection
07 Pale Flesh
10 Sad Eyes
10 Insulin
08 Transgender
06 Violent Youth
06 Telepath
08 Mercenary
10 Child I Will Hurt You



everything was so good

oh and my hitler face was to the guy above you.. 'music for the gays and drug addicted persons' haha wtf

Posted by: Outcast 24th October 2014, 01:13 PM

-

Posted by: Cremey_SZN 24th October 2014, 01:15 PM

So because you don't like their music, it must be for homosexuals and drug addicts? Good reasoning.

Posted by: Outcast 24th October 2014, 01:19 PM

-

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 01:22 PM

Yeah I know that. But it's his usual 'oh i'm so different and edgy i like inoffensive blondes with tits who sing about going to malls and buying hair products' troll-like drivel and ain't nobody got time fo' dat anymo'

Posted by: Outcast 24th October 2014, 01:26 PM

-

Posted by: Harve 24th October 2014, 01:28 PM

(prize if you remember where that special sequence of emoticons comes from/if you still remember 2009)

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 01:29 PM

Posted by: Cremey_SZN 24th October 2014, 01:29 PM

Ohhh it's AlexRange, I didn't realise with the name change. If I'd known I wouldn't have bothered replying..
But don't worry, no injuries have taken place, I can assure you!

Posted by: Conderella 24th October 2014, 01:36 PM

10 guests viewing though

we goin' viral!

are ATRL talking about us again or something?

Posted by: 152chris 24th October 2014, 02:32 PM

haaa cremey !

alex this is a verbal warning and i know it's useless but comments bordering on homophobic are not what we stand for here in the indie forum i'll have you know and i know pavel's delicate sensibilities are starting to feel personally victimised (152 layin down the law yes)

Posted by: Cremey 13th November 2014, 02:40 PM

Posted by: ♡ Heezus Froot ♡ 13th November 2014, 04:21 PM

6 rates is more than I expected this to get, to be honest Maybe you should PM people who might be fans, or just go ahead with only 6 rates in.

Posted by: Cremey 13th November 2014, 07:26 PM

I was hoping for about 10 but 6 is acceptable I guess!
I'll leave it open for a few more days but if nothing seems to be happening I'll PM a few people (hey Tony, Grebo, two Jakes and Casey (if you still even go here..))

Posted by: ϑЃεβϘ 13th November 2014, 09:11 PM

I'll do it if you keep this open til the weekend.

Posted by: AntoineTTe 14th November 2014, 04:42 PM

I will do it this evening.

Posted by: ░░░░ 14th November 2014, 07:48 PM

i'll do this over the weekend kitten lips x

Posted by: 152chris 6th February 2015, 11:18 PM

ALSO