November 7, 200915 yr I hope I'm wrong but I can see the bottom two being Stacey & Jamie with Jamie getting KO'd. As Lloyd was so poor but will gain from the rebound of the bottom two last week, especially after the mauling he took from the judges this week.
November 7, 200915 yr Joe has a lovely voice but I agree it's much more musical theatre than pop star.
November 7, 200915 yr As Lloyd was so poor but will gain from the rebound of the bottom two last week, especially after the mauling he took from the judges this week. I think everyone is really overestimating Lloyd's fanbase, I said it before and I'll say it again. I'll bet Joe and Jedward are eating into most possible votes Llyod might get. I think Stacey will still have enough support to see her through, although it wasn't one of her best performances. Edited November 7, 200915 yr by Sabrewulf238
November 7, 200915 yr I reckon Lloyd & Jamie will be bottom two with Lloyd hopefully going. Stacey is a possibility though. :(
November 7, 200915 yr Joe: I love him. With Rachel & Miss Frank gone his is my favorite. If he cant win, then we should definatly let Jedward win. In the meantime, another great performance and I do adore this song and the film it comes from. 8.5/10 Rank 1 Joe 8.5 2 John & Edward 8 3 Olly 7.5 4 Jamie 7.5 5 Lucie 7 6 Stacey 7 7 Lloyd 5.5 8 Danyl 5 ----- Interesting. Both girls have had better. Joe was on top form and Jamie improved a lot.
November 7, 200915 yr Sugababes are on Xtra Factor. Jade looks like a deer in headlights. Amelle looks spaced out.
November 7, 200915 yr My ratings: Lucie / She has TOTALLY won me over. She's finally in a zone where i can connect with her as a potentially amazing singer and I now love her. However, I'm not totally sure why she was trying to be Stacey when talking to Dermot... Jamie / Definatley his best performance by a mile, and a beautiful song choice. Simon should like him more. Olly / :wub: I love him. He's SUCH a born performer and entertainer and this was brilliant. Stacey / <33 OK we all know I want Stacey as a pet and it was nice to see her do an uptempo... I liked it but I'm not feeling it :( John & Edward / LOLOLOL <33 I want these guys to win just to see Simon Cowell leave the country. It was amusing, it was kind of in tune, I LIKE IT. Joe / Meh, im so over him. He's the same and boring every week, it was OK but meh. Danyl / UGH! So overrated, his vocal wanst even that good, nothing compared to Ruth's 'Purple Rain' last year. Trademark big ridiculous screaming note at the end :rolleyes: Lloyd / LOL. Just LOL. GET HIM OUT.
November 7, 200915 yr BJ didn't like Danyl again? what a surprise O___O considering he was GLORIOUS as usual! :wub: a good week this week. Best performances were between Danyl, Jamie & Joe.
November 7, 200915 yr BJ didn't like Danyl again? what a surprise O___O considering he was GLORIOUS as usual! :wub: a good week this week. Best performances were between Danyl, Jamie & Joe. They're called opinions. It's incredibly annoying when somebody plays the sarcastic judgmental card. People can't help it if they don't like him. That's just the way it is. -_- I'm slightly (ever so slightly) warming to Danyl, I just wish he'd stop with the big mouth because he's quite good when he's not bellowing out the song and his mouth doesn't look like he's on a rollarcoaster Edited November 7, 200915 yr by Sabrewulf238
November 7, 200915 yr No-one was really good this week I though, which isn't good seeing as it was a wide song category. 1. Lucie - Surprisingly liked this, def my fav now. 8.5 2. Jedward - One of their best performences, only act I can see safely getting to the final. 8 3. Joe - Not bad, getting a bit boring, his worst performance so far though. 7.5 =5. Stacey - Alright, she's boring me a bit though now, I can see her being in trouble. 7 =5. Jamie - Not bad actually, best performance of his so far. 7 6. Danyl - Good choice, but nothing compared to Ruth. 6 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 7. Olly - Hated this, surprised people on here quite like it. He obviously won't be bottom two though. 4 8. Lloyd - Bah! Awful, mauled one of my favourite songs. 3 Bottom two prediction is Stacey and Jamie. Edited November 7, 200915 yr by C.R.
November 7, 200915 yr i think i must be the only one on here who likes lloyd. i think he did great tonight - his best by a mile. danyl was great too as was lucie. i think lloyd and stacey in bottom two this week. anyone else think louis walsh will be getting sacked after this year?? defo~!!
November 7, 200915 yr My order of preference tonight: Jedward Stacey Ollie The rest were just plain boring! Does Lucie really have so low a personality of her own that she has to steal Stacey's. I really liked Lucie at the audition stages but ... she has the stage presence of an apostle spoon. Norma
November 7, 200915 yr So, I took a big chance, at the high school dance, with a boy he was ready to play. Stacey's accent :wub:
November 7, 200915 yr Stacey – 6 – Her best performance to date, but I fear she’s going to be in the bottom 2 this week. Olly – 5 - The Beatles – AGAIN? He’s becoming a one trick pony. Lloyd – 3 – Oh no, it wasn’t a good idea to try and cover the Sean Kingston mix-up. I liked his hair though. Jamie – 7 – A performance that was raw, authentic, and full of emotion. Lucie – 1 – Pathetic song choice, and if that really is to be her intended niche she needs to go now. Inane drivel, for the mentally redundant. Danyl – 7 - Wow loving the makeover. I think it was his best performance to date, and more understated. Jedward – 9 – Jedward FTW - that is all. Joseph - 5 - Another dodgy song choice, but at least the vocals are consistent.
November 7, 200915 yr i think i must be the only one on here who likes lloyd. i think he did great tonight - his best by a mile. danyl was great too as was lucie. i think lloyd and stacey in bottom two this week. anyone else think louis walsh will be getting sacked after this year?? defo~!! I'd be suprised if he was sacked. They've already tried it once and failed. His comments are a bit stupid sometimes, but considering he's had BY FAR the weakest catergory two years in a row he's done pretty well. If Louis went there would just be NO chemistry at all between the judges. My order of preference: John & Edward Lucie Danyl Jamie Olly Stacey Joe Lloyd Cannot believe Lucie pulled the stupid card when being interviewed. Definitely hope that was a one off as it's the reason I can't stand Stacey. Joe's got a good voice, but his performance is just boring. I honestly thought he would win, but as each week goes by I can't see it. I actually really like Danyl, and it's unfair to compare his performance to Ruth's as they're two completely different singers. Jamie's was v.good, but I can see him being near the bottom two this week. Lloyd should be going as he honestly is just plain rubbish. People can say what they like about John & Edward but they're entertaining and don't take themselves seriously at all... seriously wtf was Cheryl thinking when she put this guy through.
November 7, 200915 yr 01. Joe - Easily the best vocal tonight, thought the performance was classy. I think he would have more of a chance of winning if it were back in the Pop Idol days. He's definitely got a thing of Gareth Gates about him. 02. Lucie - I thought the song suited her and she looked comfortable, but oh dear at another girl trying to be Stacey. :mellow: I just find her really fake. 03. Stacey - I don't think it was up to the standard of her earlier performances, I'm not convinced she can move and sing. She sings beautifully when standing still, but she wobbles a bit with movement. 04. Danyl - I think this was his best performance so far and better than rubbish Ruth, love the haircut. I think people give him a hard time. I don't think he's vile or arrogant, I actually find him one of the best people on there. He's got a big smile and doesn't come across fake (Lucie) or weird. (Jamie) However, he's not this second coming as Simon seems to think. It'd annoy me if he won though as he's not the sort of artist who'd usually be big imo, he's quite similar to Bryn Christopher/Daniel Merriweather/Nate James. 05. Olly - Didn't really like the song he did this week but I still really love his voice, just needed a better song. 06. Jamie - It's weird, this seems to be everyone's least favourite Jamie performance, but it's the first one I found myself finding acceptable. I still don't like him though, so hopefully he goes. 07. Lloyd - Looks like they tried to make him more 'cute' after finishing bottom two last week. Shame they couldn't fix his voice, it was painful to listen to. Every few seconds it felt like his voice was going to give in. 08. John & Edward - Just no. Again, it felt like I was watching that Peter Kay show, it definitely had a feel of 2 Up 2 Down to it. The difference here is that it's not supposed to be a parody. What's worse is that I feel the public are now of the opinion that it'd be 'right right laugh' if they won. It really wouldn't.
November 8, 200915 yr 01. Olly - totally in his comfort zone though. I'm with Louis et all on this, it would be good to hear him try to do contemporary - I don't see why he couldn't pull it off. I was completely "meh" originally, but Olly recently strikes me as a cross between Will Young and Robbie - he's got Robbie's performer qualities but without the twattishness and with a better singing voice. 02. Lucie The last couple of weeks, it seems like Dannii is finally starting to work out where Lucie sits. The Lucie of the last couple of weeks has been much better than the fluffy karaoke pop Lucie we saw to begin with. 03. Joe I don't want Joe to win - he's far too cheesy, and I fully expect if he were to win we would see a return to the bad old days of reality winners being given any old bland tosh and covers to sing (see Steve Brookstein, Michelle McManus, HereSay etc.) 04. Danyl A bit meh to be honest. He's a talented guy, but this performance lacked the passion of the LORENZO. 05. Stacey Quite forgettable, I think she might be in trouble tomorrow. 06. Jamie Yet another MEH performance. I'm beginning to see Louis' criticisms of the "pub singer". 07. John & Edward Jaw-droppingly awful. The musical equivalent of Sunset Beach - absolute tat, but you kind of want to watch it again. 08. Lloyd Jedward aside, there really is a massive gulf between poor Lloyd and the others. Lloyd's voice just does not translate at all onto a live stage - it's too soft and weak, and he just gets totally overwhelmed. Of course he wouldn't have this problem when it comes to making records, but still...
November 8, 200915 yr I think people are being way harsh on Joe - he was very musical theatre this week, but it was movie week, if ever there's a week to be theatrical! He commanded a Journey performance last week, he was masterful on Robbie Williams - he can be a popstar for sure, and is the best male vocalist, probably the best vocalist in general, remaining. Cheryl just needs to make sure she gives him more modern songs, otherwise in the final I'm predicting (Olly v Jpe) we'll end up with retro covers vs stage school kid. This week 01. Joe - It was musical sure but he's proved contemporary relevance before. In a weak week it was the best vocal from the most consistent artist. Not his best, but THE best this week. 02. Danyl - Normally don't like him, but much better look, MUCH better attitude - much better vocals. Less screaming, stuck to the melody, good job. 03. Lucie - Like the idea of the song choice, if not the song itself. A bit empty at points, great at others. 04. Jamie - One of his best, less pub rocker, more real artist. Still think he's a cocky bugger and would like him out. 05. Lloyd - Out of his depth but his strongest vocal yet, still love his tone. 06. Stacey - Her weakest performance for me. She looked good and towards the end sounded great but in general she just didn't sell it to me. 07. Olly - The retro thing is becoming really stale, he needs to be brought up to date. Required little singing, the dancing was poor. His worst. 08. Jedward - Funny for the first 30 seconds, awful afterwards Overall 01. Joe 02. Stacey 03. Lucie 04. Lloyd (if he never performed live, I'd love his voice on a folky CD!) 05. Olly 06. Danyl 07. Jedward 08. Jamie I am predicting Lloyd to get that bounce back this week, Olly and Joe very safe, can't see Jedward going and I think Danyl is back on track with Joe Public. So bottom two between the girls and Jamie. I think Lucie will escape it, so I predict Stacey and Jamie bottom two.
Create an account or sign in to comment