Louis is more petty than contructive and for me its been very very annoying this year.

Dannii is the type judge they need. Ones that actually care about their contestants over themselves.

Yes totally and for me she does that and is genuinly interested in her contestants and trie sto do the best for them and try to help them achieve their dreams, in contrast she is everything sharon osbourne wasnt, x factor wouldnt be the same at all without dannii, she is a hige part of the show in my opinion.

Wouldn't be surprised if this is true

According to News of the World, its the other way round Cheryl wants to quit she wants to start a family. Simon wants Robbie as a 5th judge for Novelty acts to be introduced next year, but I just wait until I hear it from reliable sources.

I feel sorry for any child she bears that has to suffer her as a mother.

 

God I'm in a bitchy mood today :(

:o

It would be great if Cheryl went tbh, she's only there 'cause she's a pretty face.

I wouldn't be surprised if she did leave. At times this series she's seemed utterly disillusioned and downright depressed by the emphasis put on entertainment over actual talent.

 

Well, Jark, is this is actually how you feel, how can you then continue to defend the show itself on Rob's topic....? Surely if Dannii IS your favourite and she is leaving the show due to being "utterly disillusioned" as you put it, then, you surely, by extension, agree with how me and Rob generally feel about "X-Factor", after all, she surely feels herself that she's being forced into quitting by the continuing manipulations and machinations of Cowell, which is obviously something she herself does not like.....

 

I actually have a bit of new found respect for Dannii now... Well done to her.. Sometimes just walking away and refusing to participate in something so hideously wrong, is the best thing you can do.... I just wish she'd go out in a blaze of glory and REALLY dish the sh!t..... :rolleyes:

:o i look like cheryl and im very brainy indeed :)

I don't know how much more clearer it could be that Simon dislikes Dannii ........

X Factor: Simon Cowell ‘Dannii Minogue ruined Stacey Solomon’s chances’

December 13th, 2009 Unrealitytv.co.uk by Lisa McGarry.

 

X Factor judge Simon Cowell has blamed Dannii Minogue for ruining Stacey Solomon’s chances of winning the show.

 

Stacey narrowly missed out on being in tonight’s final and Simon says that Dannii’s big mistake was that she tried to make her too like previous winner Leona.

 

Simon told The News Of The World:

“If Stacey were to win the show, we would have to go right back to where she started from when we first saw her.

“I would take her out of those stupid ballgowns and stop her trying to sound like Leona. I think she is a really good singer but all her originality has been stripped away from her.

“Dannii is trying to make her Leona Mark II and you can’t do that.When Stacey sang Coldplay she was so good they sent her a platinum disc. She needs to do something that’s interesting.”

One i wouldnt believe evrything the new of the world says and secondly no compares people to leona more than simon does himself. Every female that has performed on x factor since Leona all we hear is you cant get th eleona notes etc. Simon needs to leave Leona out of the occasion now and move on and let the females be themselves. Stacey inno way ever attempted to be like Leona and Dannii has often said leona and stacey are 2 very different artists.

One i wouldnt believe evrything the new of the world says and secondly no compares people to leona more than simon does himself. Every female that has performed on x factor since Leona all we hear is you cant get the leona notes etc.

 

You're probably right, I mean, I dont watch The X-Factor, so I'll take you at your word...

 

BUT, why on earth are you expecting anything of any individuality to come out of this show...? The whole ethos behind it is manufactured, regimented, formulaic, they already have their idea of what they want and nothing must be allowed to deviate from it in any way, shape or form.... The most genuinely exciting Pop Artists that are around at the moment, your Pinks, your Lady Ga Gas, your Alison Goldfrapps, your Gwen Stefanis, wouldn't last five minutes on that show let's face it.... BECAUSE REGARDLESS OF THE FACT THAT THEY SELL MILLIONS, THEY DONT "FIT" COWELL'S MOLD....... :rolleyes:

 

So, in a nutshell, X-Factor is utterly worthless because is has no "flavour", there's no point in expecting the next Madonna, the next Prince, the next Bjork or the next Lennon to come out of this show...... To quote Officer Barbrady in South Park - "Move along now, there's nothing to see here"......

 

One i wouldnt believe evrything the new of the world says and secondly no compares people to leona more than simon does himself. Every female that has performed on x factor since Leona all we hear is you cant get th eleona notes etc. Simon needs to leave Leona out of the occasion now and move on and let the females be themselves. Stacey inno way ever attempted to be like Leona and Dannii has often said leona and stacey are 2 very different artists.

 

They were direct quotes from him so I would say they're true.

 

To be fair the guy has a point as well. OK maybe it's an easy comparison to make, but as the weeks went on she did (image wise) just look more and more like Leona. Dannii probably didn't intend it, but it happened. Her voice was in the same style of Leona as well - both are not good with up-tempo and thrive off ballads. Unfortunately for most female singers in that catergory they're always going to get the Leona comparisons...

Simon talks such bull$h!t if that is true, she was the best last night, doing everything she could've done to secure votes and Dannii was a great mentor to her.

 

If anything it was Simon who made her chances of making the final slim by pairing her with Michael f***ing Bublé and putting her first in the running order and not giving her as much praise as the other two. Eugh, I hate the man. I wish HE would quit The X Factor as he manipulates it far too heavily and denies it whenever someone phones in about it on Xtra Factor or doesn't properly answer it.

Mel B? I'm sorry but that's pathetic.

 

I agree - Mel B would be pathetic And what's she ever done since SG split - absolutely nothing. IMO she was always the worst Spice Girl - now Mel C would be a completely different kettle of fish.

 

Anyway it should be Louis Walsh going not Dannii. He doesn't have a clue what talent is. He gave us Westlife and said Jedward and the McDojnald Brothers are talented.

 

 

Mel b would be too loud, common and mouthy for x factor.

Mel b would be too loud, common and mouthy for x factor.

 

Yeah shes a total chav, i could just hear her mouthing off. Melanie C would be much better as she actually runs a record label and can actually sing, tho i dont think her an Louis get on and she bitched about Cheryl, tho Cheryl done a lot of bitchin about SG's so maybe mel B could sort her!!! aha

Mel b would be too loud, common and mouthy for x factor.

 

And you think that Cheryl Cole isn't "common"...? :rolleyes:

 

I'm sorry, but she's fukkin' "Chav Idol" if ever there was one.... :lol:

 

Compared to her, Dannii Minogue is the very epitome of sophistication.....

TBH i'd like to see Cheryl replaced by Lily Allen or even Keisha Buchanan and Louis replaced by Gary Barlow.