33. Melanie Blatt (All Saints) - [215 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/Melanie-Blatt.jpg

 

The 2nd highest All Saint, she was my personal fave tbh, really love her voice. Solo songs werent that good though...

 

Appearance = 75

Personality = 66

Voice = 74

Total = 215

 

 

Bootie Call, my personal fave All Saints song, just immense :wub:

I never thought Carmit looked that bad! :( Mel Blatt was such a bore.

I loved Mel Blatt - she had a couple of good solo singles too and her voice was much sweeter and more distinctive than either of the Appleton sisters - Twenty Four Seven and See Me were great :wub: the latter was so incredibly underrated :( did it even get anywhere in the charts?

 

Who on earth are Danity Kane? They look cheap. Coming higher than TLC is an OUTRAGE, although not having voted I guess I shouldn't complain.

 

 

POOR All Saints - they really were a pretty good girlgroup, the prototype for the Sugababes with their moodiness and actual credibility. The Appleton solo album was also surprisingly RATHER GOOD. 5am is a delight.

I loved Mel Blatt - she had a couple of good solo singles too and her voice was much sweeter and more distinctive than either of the Appleton sisters - Twenty Four Seven and See Me were great :wub: the latter was so incredibly underrated :( did it even get anywhere in the charts?

 

according to wikipedia #78 :huh:

Who on earth are Danity Kane? They look cheap. Coming higher than TLC is an OUTRAGE, although not having voted I guess I shouldn't complain.

POOR All Saints - they really were a pretty good girlgroup, the prototype for the Sugababes with their moodiness and actual credibility. The Appleton solo album was also surprisingly RATHER GOOD. 5am is a delight.

 

mabye I shoulda left the voting open longer but I was eager to do results, plus It didnt get this much attention..

mabye I shoulda left the voting open longer but I was eager to do results, plus It didnt get this much attention..

 

Too be fair, I probably wouldn't have voted anyway. Bar GA, Sugas, TLC and All Saints the rest would have been mostly ???s

I do not have the slightest clue who Danity Kane are, and I honestly couldn't tell you which Saturday is which.

Poor Sue-Ellise :( Even when Miss-Teeq were still going, I doubt anyone noticed her that much. Carmit was always my favourite out of PCD if only out of sympathy for people picking on her but also as she was often the least tackiest looking :lol:

 

Great to see the legend that is Shaznay is the highest of the All Saints girls, loved her and Mel Blatt. Appleton sisters were a bit meh, did adore Natalie on Im A Celeb, it just seems rather pointless that there are two of them though :lol:

32. Kimberly Wyatt (The Pussycat Dolls) - [236 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/kimberlywyatt.jpg

 

2nd lowest member of PCD (or lowest of the current line-up, although is it true she is no longer in the band?) neways the only thing I really know her for is the leg thing in the pic above, and now also being a complete hard-to-please bitch on 'Got To Dance' :lol: [should be lower imo, but her Appearance got her here I think]

 

Appearance = 100

Personality = 80

Voice = 56

Total = 236

 

Great to see the legend that is Shaznay is the highest of the All Saints girls, loved her and Mel Blatt. Appleton sisters were a bit meh, did adore Natalie on Im A Celeb, it just seems rather pointless that there are two of them though :lol:

 

:lol: I'm sure their mother didn't plan to have both

Aw I quite like Kimberley on 'Got To Dance'.

 

Ashley, Jessica & Melody were all the better members though.

31. Siobhan Donaghy (Sugababes) - [237 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/SiobhanDonaghy.jpg

 

The lowest of all past and present Sugababes, again Im not suprised about this result. I do really like her voice but looks and personality don't do alot for me. also I tried to like her solo stuff and just couldn't get myself into it, hmmm

 

Appearance = 76

Personality = 67

Voice = 94

Total = 237

 

 

And I'll start doing the top 30 tomorrow!

31. Siobhan Donaghy (Sugababes) - [237 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/SiobhanDonaghy.jpg

 

The lowest of all past and present Sugababes, again Im not suprised about this result. I do really like her voice but looks and personality don't do alot for me. also I tried to like her solo stuff and just couldn't get myself into it, hmmm

 

Appearance = 76

Personality = 67

Voice = 94

Total = 237

 

And I'll start doing the top 30 tomorrow!

 

Not surprised really, I expect to see either Mutya or Jade next from Sugababes maybe even Keisha as people may have rated her low in personality. Some of Siobhan's solo stuff is amazing but that's only a few songs.

Awww poor Siobhan, definatly not my least favourite of the six of them. Heres hoping its not too long until Mutya and Keisha turn up :)

KEISHA FTW

what would everyones personal top 5 be?

 

mine would be between -

 

Geri Halliwell

Beyonce Knowles

Nicola Roberts

Nadine Coyle

Keisha Buchanan

 

Can't decide who my actual fave is though (and I wont give any hints on how my faves did) haha

1 Una Healy

2 Kimberly Walsh

3 Vanessa White

4 Heidi Range

5 Beyonce

1 Una Healy

2 Kimberly Walsh

3 Vanessa White

4 Heidi Range

5 Beyonce

 

Nice and mixed, I :heart: Vanessa!

Amelle

Frankie

Una

Heidi

Sarah

31. Siobhan Donaghy (Sugababes) - [237 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/SiobhanDonaghy.jpg

 

The lowest of all past and present Sugababes, again Im not suprised about this result. I do really like her voice but looks and personality don't do alot for me. also I tried to like her solo stuff and just couldn't get myself into it, hmmm

 

Appearance = 76

Personality = 67

Voice = 94

Total = 237

 

 

And I'll start doing the top 30 tomorrow!

Surprised she made it this high, most people don't remember her. hell i didn't know she was a Sugababe till 2005

 

 

Mutya or Amelle ftw