oOo lots of talk :D

 

I agree with people saying Kim is quite low for PCD, although Im not a fan I expected her in front of at least Ashley

 

as for Sugas I didnt really get into them until the 2nd album either (although I did later buy the first album) so Siobhan is probs my worst member, and yeah Jade has a brill voice so thats probs why she is yet to come.

 

 

Awww poor Carmit :(

She's so fierce and has an awesome voice. I would have thought kim would be higher than ashley and jessica cos of her one trick poney leg thing.

 

I swear if Beige comes in higher than any of the other sugas or any Girl Aloud I'm going to throw a fit. Her voice during live performances is dire, she looks like shes 45, and she has no personilty. Not to mention she's an ungrateful backstabber... but that's besides the point.

 

Hoping for Kimba at number one, though i doubt it lol

and Una for top 5 please!

Edited January 23, 201015 yr by shakilover

30. Sabrina Washington (Mis-Teeq) - [253 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/sabrina_washington.jpg

 

The 2nd Mis-Teeq lady in the countdown, not suprising she came in the middle, and I reckon she would have came lower if it wasn't for the recent apperance on I'm A Celebrity...

 

Apperance = 92

Personality = 82

Voice = 79

Total = 253

 

29. Jenny Frost (Atomic Kitten) - [255 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/Jenny_Frost.jpg

 

the 2nd AK girl (if you really count Kerry Katona :lol: ) to come out in the countdown, she never really did anything for me tbh. average voice and average looks, but thats just my opinion.

 

Appearance = 94

Personality = 89

Voice = 72

Total = 255

 

28. Ashley Roberts (The Pussycat Dolls) - [256 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/AshleyRoberts.jpg

 

The 3rd (or 2nd current) member of PCD to chart, tbh I thought she would be first out as she Is the one I forget most, she is really pretty though! :lol:

 

Appearance = 115

Personality = 78

Voice = 63

Total = 256

 

 

27. Jessica Sutta (The Pussycat Dolls) - [264 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/jessicasutta.jpg

 

The 4th PCD member, I quite like her and I love the couple of solo songs she did..

 

Appearance = 108

Personality = 74

Voice = 82

Total = 264

 

26. Shaznay Lewis (All Saints) - [267 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/Shaznay_Lewis.jpg4

 

The top member of All Saints. tbh I wasn't expecting her to get this high, but she has got a great voice and is a pretty good songwriter!

 

Appearance = 86

Personality = 77

Voice = 104

Total = 267

 

Edited January 23, 201015 yr by Lukuzz

Jenny looks amazing in that photo! :o :wub: Gutted Ashley PCD finished so low, but here's hoping Melody is top 10/20. :)

Jenny looks amazing in that photo! :o :wub: Gutted Ashley PCD finished so low, but here's hoping Melody is top 10/20. :)

 

 

I :heart: Melody! soo underated, her voice is brilliant!

Would have liked to have seen Shaznay, Jenny and Sabrina higher especially Sab and Shaz who probably would have been higher if their girlbands were still active as they both had fantastic voices, personality and looks stunning. I always likked Jenny aswell, admitetly not as much as Liz and Tash.

25. Victoria Beckham (Spice Girls) - [275 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/victoriabeckham.jpg

 

The lowest of the Spice Girls, I really love Victoria and I think she should have got higher ratings on all things, especially her persinality as I think she is really funny, also her voice is alot better than what most people think (listen to 'Forever' album) anyways rant over, Mrs.Beckham is still Major in my eyes! :heart:

 

Appearance =116

Personality = 94

Voice = 65

Total = 275

 

 

Victoria owns 'Tell Me Why' :wub:

I became a AK loon when Jenny joined. I was a fan when they released Right Now but when she joined I become obsessed! I've been listening to all their albums again recently and I've become obsessed again. 'Follow Me', 'You Are' and 'Cradle' are :heart:

Edited January 23, 201015 yr by Aidan

Nah if anything she should have been much lower imo, really suprised she got this high tbh. Saying that I do love her 'they're so $h!t they're actually kinda good' solo records.

Victoria had always been my least favourite Spice Girl. She's pretty untalented imo and lacks a decent personality, but that's just me.

 

Love Jessica & Ashley. :wub:

Geri or Heidi ftw :heart:

I :wub: Victoria, was listening to her today!

 

neways I will post more tomorrow, getting ready to go out! :D

NO WAY! Victoria is probably in my top 5 overall. :wub: Okay, maybe her singing isn't great, she doesn't look great when she's stick thin and some people think she's a moody cow but they're all wrong. I love the tone of her voice so much, she usually looks lovely (particularly in 2006, with the long hair) and she's so funny, she can take a joke.

 

She's at least better than Geri, but it's the things you have to rate them in that aren't kind to her. :lol: Shocked that's she's below Natasha from Atomic Kitten and Melody. I'd say most of the Saturdays too, but we know how this forum is.

24. Rochelle Wiseman (The Saturdays) - [277 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/Rochelle-Wiseman.jpg

 

Lowest charting member of The Saturdays, think this is mainly down to the quite low personality ratings..

 

Apperance = 98

Personality = 77

Voice = 102

Total = 277

 

23. Liz McClaron (Atomic Kitten) - [286 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/lizmcclaron.jpg

 

The 3rd (out of 4) AK girls to chart, I think Liz has a really great voice!

 

Appearance = 92

Personality = 97

Voice = 97

Total = 286

 

22. Frankie Sandford (The Saturdays) - [293 points]

 

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/frankiesandford.jpg

 

The second Saturday to chart (that both ex S Clubbers out first) I dont particularly think she has a great voice but I do really like her!

 

Apperance = 117

Personality = 94

Voice = 82

Total = 293