Jump to content

Featured Replies

Cara Mia vs. The Worrying Kind. NUFF SAID.

 

Oh, but at least we got Maia Hirasawa's gorgeous cover out of the latter ^_^

  • Replies 47
  • Views 9.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS

 

 

f***ing Amazing track.

Yeah, but I think we can all agree that Fairytale was *probably* the right choice :kink:
Cara Mia vs. The Worrying Kind. NUFF SAID.

 

Oh, but at least we got Maia Hirasawa's gorgeous cover out of the latter ^_^

 

True, it was far better than Moto Boy's Hero and that rock band's cover of La Voix...I wonder what genre This Is My Life will be transformed into next year? :o Or are they too ashamed of the song never to mention it again? Keep On Walking was a bit of a massive missed opportunity :snif: I guess Manboy would have definitely done well too judging by the reaction Eric got just from presenting the votes :lol:

 

Tone was unlucky really, I wish she'd sent Butterflies to MGP 2010 to beat Didrik :( Fairytale was just too 'DEFINITE WINNER' for it not have won by a landslide. First time I heard it when the MGP songs leaked I recall thinking 'this is the Eurovision winner, let alone just MGP!'

She should have gone to MGP 2010 with I Love You :wub:

 

I reckon that may have crashed in the semis/second chance/first half of the final like Maria and Mira. It's a decent song but it does feel like a 'I'm trying to recrate Butterflies with this, but not quite getting there', imo of course :heehee: I maintain that acts should never go back to a competition like that unless they clearly have what would be perceived as a stronger song. By the same token, I don't think Alcazar should have come back straight away after Stay The Night as they were obviously not going to top it...Headlines was great but b-side quality compared to its predecessor...

 

I don't think the wrong songs went to the final. Make My Day was obviously massively inferior to most of Maria's stuff, I'll Take You High was great but clearly Mira's too marmite for every competition :lol: If they were after pure fem-pop, they couldn't have gone wrong with Venke Knutson's Jealous 'Cause I Love You but the A1 song was my clear favourite and was honestly a whole lot better than Didrik and would have got them far more than 21st or wherever they flopped in at in the ESC final :lol:

I reckon that may have crashed in the semis/second chance/first half of the final like Maria and Mira. It's a decent song but it does feel like a 'I'm trying to recrate Butterflies with this, but not quite getting there', imo of course :heehee: I maintain that acts should never go back to a competition like that unless they clearly have what would be perceived as a stronger song. By the same token, I don't think Alcazar should have come back straight away after Stay The Night as they were obviously not going to top it...Headlines was great but b-side quality compared to its predecessor...

 

I don't think the wrong songs went to the final. Make My Day was obviously massively inferior to most of Maria's stuff, I'll Take You High was great but clearly Mira's too marmite for every competition :lol: If they were after pure fem-pop, they couldn't have gone wrong with Venke Knutson's Jealous 'Cause I Love You but the A1 song was my clear favourite and was honestly a whole lot better than Didrik and would have got them far more than 21st or wherever they flopped in at in the ESC final :lol:

I'm looning over Tone right now so i'm head over heels for I Love You :lol:

 

I actually think Headlines is a sublime piece of pop music that isn't that inferior to Stay The Night :o

 

 

I haven't heard Make My Day, although i do now own Breathing. I'm looking forward to her 3rd album. If Precious To Me is anything to go by it'll blow Hold On Be Strong out the water :w00t:

I'm looning over Tone right now so i'm head over heels for I Love You :lol:

 

I actually think Headlines is a sublime piece of pop music that isn't that inferior to Stay The Night :o

I haven't heard Make My Day, although i do now own Breathing. I'm looking forward to her 3rd album. If Precious To Me is anything to go by it'll blow Hold On Be Strong out the water :w00t:

 

It's already out there, I've had it for 7 weeks now. It's far far far inferior to the brilliant Hold On Be Strong album. Precious To Me and the lovely Extra Mile are the best tracks (there are only 9! :drama:). And when the 'quite good' title track is the 3rd best track on the thing, you know it's lacking. Nothing comes within sniffing distance of Hold On Be Strong or Mine All Mine :( I'll PM you a link anyhow.

 

I was never that big on Precious To Me anyway, although I hadn't realised it was a cover until recently!

 

 

Not much different in structure but his voice is horrible...

It's already out there, I've had it for 7 weeks now. It's far far far inferior to the brilliant Hold On Be Strong album. Precious To Me and the lovely Extra Mile are the best tracks (there are only 9! :drama:). And when the 'quite good' title track is the 3rd best track on the thing, you know it's lacking. Nothing comes within sniffing distance of Hold On Be Strong or Mine All Mine :( I'll PM you a link anyhow.

 

I was never that big on Precious To Me anyway, although I hadn't realised it was a cover until recently!

 

 

Not much different in structure but his voice is horrible...

It's a cover :o

 

Wow

 

 

Thanks for the link, i'll give it a go.

 

 

Really? :( I'm in love with it. It's not Mine All Mine but imo it's still bloody good

  • 2 weeks later...

 

:cry: The wounds are still fresh.

 

Why do the best songs have a habit of finishing 5th in MF :arrr:

 

I guess it's easier to take than if it had come 2nd 1 point behind Anna or something, at least we know they were nowhere near winning :lol:

  • Author

Tbh it was good, but it doesn't hurt so bad as this never making it...

 

 

:snif:

Tbh it was good, but it doesn't hurt so bad as this never making it...

 

 

:snif:

 

4th-7th is about the area I expected for Alcazar so it was expected imo that they didn't come that close to winning. Timoteij looked like one of the easy frontrunners for a few weeks until Anna locked herself at #1 on iTunes for weeks on end and then it became pretty obvious who was going to win...

 

Not that pre-final chart success helped E.M.D. or Caroline to overhaul Malena the year before though I guess...

 

Still, Stay The Night is my favourite non winning national final entry of all time, by a mile. I remember watching that performance live, that dance breakdown was EPIC :wub:

I'm sort of glad that it didn't go to ESC in a way. I have a horrible suspicion that it would have been the fan favourite that DNQ'd :snif: I'm struggling to think of the last time an uptempo cheesy pop/dance track did well in the contest.
  • 6 months later...

Iceland's biggest mistake (Would had a great chance as there is NO female ballad so far this year........)

 

  • 4 weeks later...

I still can't forgive the Moldovan jury :( Not that it would have done that well probably but it can't have done any worse than Zdob Si Zdub, plus it would have been SO much better an entry for me personally, and that's really what they should have been thinking of!

 

 

That said, I bet it would have been a car crash live, I never got round to watching her NF performance :lol:

Iceland's biggest mistake (Would had a great chance as there is NO female ballad so far this year........)

 

THIS

 

After she came so so so close to taking ESC previously*

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

*Yes, I am well aware she got utterly hammered by Fairytale but she was comfortably second and would have won a Rybak-less ESC

That said, I bet it would have been a car crash live, I never got round to watching her NF performance :lol:

 

It wasn't bad actually :o . The promo video is also pretty slick all things considered. It really should have won, it was the people's choice, but the jury gave it 1 point. The most sensationally obvious fix I've ever seen as it's plainly obvious Moldova don't want to be sending a potential winner these days.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.