Which song is better

 

Whats Left Of Me Nick Lacheys effort

 

OR

 

Public Affair Jessica Simpsons effort

 

I personally like both of them, but I think Jessicas song is 2x better.

Although Nick is my number 1 on my charts :o

As a person, I prefer Nick (and he's probably the hottest person EVER :wub:), but I love Jessica's new song more :wub:

As a person, I prefer Nick (and he's probably the hottest person EVER :wub:), but I love Jessica's new song more :wub:

 

 

Agreed.

Hmmm tough one.

 

I have never liked any of Nicks previous material, didn't like his last album.

 

But then again I wasn't too struck on Jessica's either, but I did love 'Boots' and I loved Fired Up and Public Affair is quite good, but I prefer What's Left Of Me personally.

 

I know he's cashing in on the divorce etc, etc which is an awful thing to do, but his music is better than it ever was, even when he was in 98 Degrees.

Well on those two singles alone Nick Lachey deffinitely, i dont really like public affair its ok...

havent herad nick's song but i have hated all jessica's song to date so im sure her new one will be no different for me

I just saw the vid for Nick's one today (and he looks hot as ever), but I couldn't help noticing that minger Chrissy from Charmed in it :angry: The Passengerz remix of it is AMAZING :wub:

They are completely different songs :mellow: I so cannot compare a lovely ballad to an extremely fresh up-beat song :wacko:

i love jessica simpson way better!

public affair is such a cool song :D

Public Affair, is better, maybe because finally Jessica is doing an effort for her music career? :P xox.

Um... Well... I think that Public Affair is better but Nick's song is also amazing :wub:

as a person he comes across as an absolute horror :puke2:

 

not a fan of either musically but i think jessica's is slightly better than his :D

Jessica wins for me. Although Nick does sound amazing on 'Whats Left Of Me' and i am recording it next week. But still...

Both $HITE but if i had to back one of them for a number 1 spot it would be NICK...

 

JESS :puke2:

Whats Left Of Me by Nick Lachey, no doubt :wub:

Jessica simpson - a public affair wins for me :D I don't understand anyone who feels the need to cash in off somebody that they "loved"

Edited July 12, 200619 yr by jack89

Have either of these sold anything in the UK?

Jessuca has had 3 albums and 5 singles i think out in the uk..nick had a few singles out in the uk but they all did badly.

Jessica Simpson easily