The one who sang Sam Cooke - A Change Is Gonna Come was my favourite from tonight. I liked what she did with the song, it was different.

 

However, that girl who just sang 'Let It Be' on the Xtra Factor was amazing! :o

Some eye candy on ITV2 Sophia :heart: Great legs, not sure about the voice though, my eyes were drifting to her legs more than anything. :cool:

Chloe was WONDERFUL, and I do wonder how much of the hatred of her was actually because of her voice or just because of the fact she was a (ugh, I HATE this word) 'chav'. Some of the abuse on Twitter was really quite disgusting :/

 

She just had a vile personality, loud, obnoxious, no redeeming features, how much of it was a front I don't know but I just wanted someone to superglue her lips together so that she would shut up

 

She had a nice figure and there was potential in her voice but she was a vile vile person

Some eye candy on ITV2 Sophia :heart: Great legs, not sure about the voice though, my eyes were drifting to her legs more than anything. :cool:

:lol: It was a good melodic interpretation!

Chloe was WONDERFUL, and I do wonder how much of the hatred of her was actually because of her voice or just because of the fact she was a (ugh, I HATE this word) 'chav'. Some of the abuse on Twitter was really quite disgusting :/

 

Believe me ... for our household tonight ... it was her voice. Nothing to do with being chavvy at all. I remember being impressed by Rachel Hylton a couple of years back when she sung just one song ... you couldn't get much chavvier ... but her initial audition was quite excellent. Pity she ruined it for herself in later shows where her voice just sort of thinned out. I believe Chloe had a shot at three songs in total ... and each one worse than the last.

 

Kath

I must admit Nicole has been the best and genuine judge out of all the guest judges, I hope she gets a permanent fixture next year, far better than airhead Pixie Lott

Yeah Nicole was brilliant, best judge there has been since X Factor started bar Cowell

Rebecca's version of "A Change Is Gonna Come" wasn't as good as Beverley Knight's version. :whistle:

I found the treatment of Chloe quite horrific if I'm honest. The rent-a-mob audience booing her simply for being a bit of a 'chav' (if thats the word we have to use to describe her, not that I approve of it) was just atrocious really.

I actually thought she sang very well first time round, but of course this being the X-Factor she got stopped 10 seconds in since a girl being edited to look baddly singing well simply wouldnt do. Didnt sing the Shakira song very wel I admit.

I actually applaud Nicole Scherzinger (never though I'd be using those words) for actually showing the girl a bit of respect, which cant be said for the attrocity that is Louis Walsh.

Rebecca's version of "A Change Is Gonna Come" wasn't as good as Beverley Knight's version. :whistle:

*youtubes Beverley Knight*

 

Hmm.. it's good. :lol: Can't beat the original however <3

I found the treatment of Chloe quite horrific if I'm honest. The rent-a-mob audience booing her simply for being a bit of a 'chav' (if thats the word we have to use to describe her, not that I approve of it) was just atrocious really.

I actually thought she sang very well first time round, but of course this being the X-Factor she got stopped 10 seconds in since a girl being edited to look baddly singing well simply wouldnt do. Didnt sing the Shakira song very wel I admit.

I actually applaud Nicole Scherzinger (never though I'd be using those words) for actually showing the girl a bit of respect, which cant be said for the attrocity that is Louis Walsh.

 

She deserved the booing tbh, she was by far the most arrogant and full of herself contestant in the entire series so far, now I have nothing against arrogance if the person has something to be arrogant about but she hasn't, she just has a competent singing voice yet she was all cocky and boastful and loud and obnoxious when she hasn't got the talent to back that up

 

Was she a bad singer ? no did she deserve to get through ? probably

 

But she was acting like she was Beyonce and already some big global star

 

Was right to be booed as she had totally the wrong attitude

I found the treatment of Chloe quite horrific if I'm honest. The rent-a-mob audience booing her simply for being a bit of a 'chav' (if thats the word we have to use to describe her, not that I approve of it) was just atrocious really.

I actually thought she sang very well first time round, but of course this being the X-Factor she got stopped 10 seconds in since a girl being edited to look baddly singing well simply wouldnt do. Didnt sing the Shakira song very wel I admit.

I actually applaud Nicole Scherzinger (never though I'd be using those words) for actually showing the girl a bit of respect, which cant be said for the attrocity that is Louis Walsh.

You're only saying that because of the way she looks though.. :lol: I'm sure it hasn't bothered anyone that the crowd have been booing people like that for about the past 5 weeks now!!

 

She yelled 'Summertime', killed 'Underneath Your Clothes' and I can't even remember the third song she screeched. She wasn't a good singer, imho.

You're only saying that due to the way she looks.. :lol: I'm sure it hasn't bothered anyone for the fact that the crowd have been booing people like that for about the past 5 weeks now!!

 

She yelled 'Summertime', killed 'Underneath Your Clothes' and I can't even remember the third song she screeched. She wasn't a good singer, imho.

 

I don't think she was even that good looking

 

Hair looked like she had been dragged through a hedge or like one of these peace protesters, she looked caked in fake tan, although she did have nice legs and hips

 

But looks wise she was not a patch on that girl that did a lovely version of "Let It Be"

about the judges, Nicole was a very good judge, she gave professional comments and let contestants down gently- can see why she was there for boot camp too- and wow she is hot! :naughty: :o

 

and imo Chloe brought it on herself- her voice is average and she shouted too much, and then she starting acting like a diva and shouting- I would've booed her too personally -_-

It was all an act :rolleyes: pathetic really

 

Just been watching her in Snog, Marry, Avoid and she is a totally different person, nice and normal when she is in the "pod", seemed a really nice person, so why she has to be like that on X Factor tonight is just pathetic :rolleyes:

 

3 mins 40 in

 

Totally different girl to X Factor tonight

She deserved the booing tbh, she was by far the most arrogant and full of herself contestant in the entire series so far, now I have nothing against arrogance if the person has something to be arrogant about but she hasn't, she just has a competent singing voice yet she was all cocky and boastful and loud and obnoxious when she hasn't got the talent to back that up

 

Was she a bad singer ? no did she deserve to get through ? probably

 

But she was acting like she was Beyonce and already some big global star

 

Was right to be booed as she had totally the wrong attitude

Hardly! She wasn't arrogant - certainly nowhere near as much as, say, the Michael Jackson look-a-like a couple of weeks back, or Ablisa etc.

Hardly! She wasn't arrogant - certainly nowhere near as much as, say, the Michael Jackson look-a-like a couple of weeks back, or Ablisa etc.

 

Having seen Snog, Marry, Avoid I am warming to her a bit, I think there is a nice person outside of the vile one we saw tonight, I suspect that the producers of X Factor told her to put on all the attitude and swagger as she was a lovely girl in the Pod and the interview of Snog, Marry, Avoid

^ Ablisa were told to shout back at audience/judges when they got given negative comments or booed so I think that's probably the case.

^ Ablisa were told to shout back at audience/judges when they got given negative comments or booed so I think that's probably the case.

 

Yeah I suspect that that is the case definitely, if she had had her Snog, Marry, Avoid persona at X Factor tonight I would have really warmed to her as she seemed really sweet and genuine on that in the Pod thingy

Aiden was my big big favourite tonight, and actually of the whole season so far. Now that was star quality. And I saw a little bit of Olly Murs in him, don't know why...

 

Rebecca was really classy and interesting but she has to get a hold of her nerves otherwise she'll be absolutely run over.

 

Chloe was really frustrating to watch. I really liked her voice in Summertime, but then she tried to impersonate Shakira's voice in Underneath Your Clothes [which is clear by the ever so shaky vocals] and that was not bright at all, but I reckon the girl was panicking by then. As soon as she let her personality out (yes, she's all street and stuff, "chav" if you must) the mob just immediately discredited her, and she was laughed at, which is all obviously nervewrecking.

Being laughed at, giving a immensely bad performance, being booed, it's a hell of a rollercoaster, no wonder she went all feisty with the mob by the end of it.

I was really on the fence about her, and I make Nicole's words my own. I reckon she has potential but she was a lot to prove.

That said, she did not deserved all that stick.

 

Nicole is indeed a great judge. Ponderate and well-spoken, gracious, funny and unaffected by everyone else's opinions.

She would be great for X Factor US.

 

Overall a great show, though not really amazing. Hope tomorrow's better.

Edited September 19, 201014 yr by Vülker