March 18, 201510 yr I just watched 5x24 and it's thrown me a bit on who I think A is, I was convinced I knew and I even watched the pilot and a few of the other earlier episodes just to kinda verify what I thought but now I'm not so sure, it still could be anyone. What I will say is, I suspect Andrew was the person up at Ezra's cabin, he's always been shady but he had cuts all over his hands and bruises across his knuckles plus the whole expert scout thing, so clearly he's up to something, I'm just not sure what. I hope the big A is only one person though and they don't make it a team effort again. I'm curious to see what's caused the other liars to be arrested though :o
March 19, 201510 yr I'd be surprised if it was either of them tbh I posted my theory on tumblr earlier, I will probably add to it throughout the week though as I keep coming across little things that change or back up my thoughts even more :lol: My PLL A Theory
March 21, 201510 yr A IS NOT one of the four girls... Unless their gonna develop memory loss and that other made up disorder Mona had. My theory on who A is is far more plausible Jason http://danieljohnsado.tumblr.com/post/1142...-jason-is-big-a
March 21, 201510 yr They were both interesting reads. I'm hoping it's Lindsey's theory because I've hoped for a long time it's the person she thinks it is. Simply because they're the one out of the four girls who presents the most socio-like personality traits. Dan, you make some striking points but if it's Jason what would be the reasons for going after Emily, Hanna, Aria & Spencer? Also, what's the connection to Varjak? Edited March 21, 201510 yr by Scherz
March 21, 201510 yr Going after the girls is simple... their Alison's Frankensteins. Their her monsters and A wants them all to suffer... Remember A never actually really injures the girls? Yet nearly killed Alison in her own home their home, if Jason. Things like Varjak and Andrew are red herrings. Edited March 21, 201510 yr by barbaric_dan
March 21, 201510 yr They've never been injured but that's because they've always been 'saved'. A has set them up loads of times to get seriously hurt. Like when Spencer & Aria were trapped in that chamber and Emily had to save them.. or when A trapped them in the burning building and Ali had to rescue them. Plus, Jason was nearly killed by A in the elevator. I think it has to be a guy, given what they're supposed to be doing and even the stature of 'A' when we have seen them. Andrew is 100% a red herring but I don't think the whole Varjak thing is. I think it could actually be Ezra after all. Could he be the one with a twin? Marlene said ""There is a reason why we keep dropping these not-so-subtle clues about the twins, so I would say wait for it. Wait for it. You're not going to see Courtney, but you may see double of someone". Double of someone? Split personalities? Actual twins? This is also very interesting: https://twitter.com/lauraliejane/status/575...2927361/photo/1 It's actually ruining my life, WE NEED TO KNOW :lol:
March 21, 201510 yr I think Hanna and Alison are twins, the amount of refrences are unreal. http://tremolux.tumblr.com/post/1140093943...rime-punishment I fully believe Toby is A- as he was sent to prison for something he never done - The liars are getting sent to prison etc. The Lucas theory is also amazing. Uber = German and Lucas is the only cast member with a German second name and his second name refers to a lot of things A.
March 21, 201510 yr Yeah, that does make sense with it being Toby.. Sasha said the reveal would be sad and we know how many Spoby shippers there are. But then, it makes sense. And she also said that it would leave you wondering why he did it and it's very dark and twisted.. him doing that would make complete sense and wouldn't be dark/twisted/leave us wondering why. Edited March 21, 201510 yr by Scherz
March 21, 201510 yr You would wonder why with Spencer etc but it all makes complete sense that everything he was accused / missed / no school is something that's happening with the liars and apparently A- is very unstable right now and illness runs in his family. Maybe Toby blames Alison for his mother dying at Radley? I don't see anybody other than Toby being A- now and the CHARLES also helps my case there. Working in the police also makes him able to do anything with evidence etc. I guess it makes sense for him to be working with Mona although the thought of toby being red coat etc :lol:
March 21, 201510 yr I do hope that my theory turns out to be true in someway but at this point I'm thinking that it's too obvious now and there are a lot of PLL theories that think it's them for whatever reason. The list of hints I could make that imply this person is A is endless that I didn't include in my Tumblr post because of how many there are, but Aria's really into English right? Well there's so many references to books throughout each series, especially with To Kill A Mockingbird but I guess you could say the same thing for Ezra considering he teaches the subject, all the focus on literature has to mean something? Also in Season 1 (I think it was the pilot actually Byron talks about how attached Aria is to a pig teddy, there has been occasions where pigs have been involved like with Hanna and the cupcakes and also in Wilden's car? If you watch the promo for the next episode, and pause it when it shows the liars in the dolls house, Aria is literally dressed in a black hoodie, just like A. I think it could maybe be one of the parents but I can't think of a motive for any of them really, but it's still possible. I think I will be happy with whoever turns out to be A, if they can give a really interesting reason for why this person has done it, and from what Marlene and Sasha have said about it, I think there will be. I will literally cry if it's Caleb or Spencer though. :unsure: Edited March 21, 201510 yr by It's Lindsey
March 25, 201510 yr f*** OFF MARLENE KING. It was cracked the other week that the ritual was Charles Dilaurentis. I'm guessing Charles is Bethany or Andrew. If Charles was Andrew then maybe Andrew was in a relationship with Bethany and Andrew blames the liars for the death of Bethany. I think Charles could be Bethany and Charles wanted to be a female and that's why Jessica never wanted Alison to tell regarding the two dresses. All that we know now is that none of the liars are A-, Ezra, Toby and Caleb are also not -A.
March 25, 201510 yr I am a bit disappointed with the finale. We were told that although A won't entirely be revealed, a lot of questions will be answered. Maybe I'm missing something but the only ones that were answered for me was "what is A's name?" (even though Charles DiLaurentis was in an anagram a few episodes ago) and "who is the twin?" Jason and Charles are obviously twins, maybe Charles was put in Radley as a child and was there at the same time as Bethany and Toby's mum?
March 25, 201510 yr Is Andrew even the same age as Jason? Nope, Andrew is supposed to be 18, the same age as the liars, not sure how old Jason is but he is Alison's older brother.
March 26, 201510 yr Nope, Andrew is supposed to be 18, the same age as the liars, not sure how old Jason is but he is Alison's older brother. I think I read somewhere that Jason was slated to be 6-7 years older than Alison, which would make him 24-ish.
Create an account or sign in to comment