With the Sun unveiling a new story today, it is rumoured (but ONLY rumoured yet) that Nadine would leave the band and the other four Girls would keep on carrying the band on their shoulders.

 

So I thought I would start this poll to know everyone's opinion about it. Fan or not, feel free to share your opinion in here !

no, call it a day, as a five piece

no, call it a day, as a five piece

 

Yes, continue as a four-piece without Nadine.

 

Seems I'm the only one who thinks that...

Yes, continue as a four-piece without Nadine.

 

Seems I'm the only one who thinks that...

 

I'm with you.

Nadine is the best singer in the group - hands down!

Although it's the same as the Spice Girls, as Cheryl is by far the most popular member. I wouldn't want them carry on without Nadine.

 

 

I dunno really, I guess I'd want them to continue.

 

Sarah = certainly continue, I don't like her anyway

Cheryl/Kimberly = Kimberly is my favourite, and Cheryl is the most famous one, so call it a day & split

Nadine/Nicola = Don't really have an opinion

As long as girls aloud continue im not bothered, the uk public hasn't seen nadine for ages do you think she will be missed? i dont think so and the other members are way more famous than nadine in the uk now so i think they can continue :)

I hope they continue as a five piece and also get back together soon and record new material,the way its left now is a very boyzone finish,

It's unfair on the other girls if they call the break a split as they probably want to stay together.

No, Call it a day, five piece.

No, call it a day, as a five-piece. :P For me GA without Nadine are NOT GA.

yes, call it a day, as a five piece

No, continue, five piece.

 

Nadine's loss would be a big blow to the group, they still have enough talent between them to make a few decent records.

No

Call It A Day

5 piece

 

Nadine is the best singer. Plus, if GA do come back I get the feeling it may become "the Cheryl show"

I mean I wouldn't want Nuhdeen out of the group. But I'd rather have a four-piece Girls Aloud than get no new material.

While she is the best singer I think they other four can make it without her as long as the material is strong. And if they'd be working with xenomania I doubt it'd be anything but.