Jump to content

Featured Replies

I like Get Sexy - Keisha version. Jade version is... bad.

 

If it was the Keisha version I would think it's the 2nd best song on the album. Jade version... I don't really know.

  • Replies 74
  • Views 12.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

i never listen jade's version, when i listen sweet 7 i always put keisha's gs, and the rest of jade... it's not that bad her version, but i don;y like that "now"
I've had a bit of a complicated rlationship with Get Sexy, at various points I've thought of it as a complete abominaiton of a song whilst at other times I've equally loved it to bits. A happy medium is really the best place to be, it's nowhere neat their best and it is horribly trashy, but a bit of a guilty pleasure really.
  • Author

5. No More You - 7.48 pts

 

 

Lovers: Aled., Rossco, Marina Hurts, Silas, Mike Sugafan, Doug, Theo, Marc., David

Haters: Pavel, Kay.

Aled said about "Give It To Me Now" that it fully represents what is wrong with the album. For me this type of the song is "No More You". Keisha was always telling how great it was to work with all those big producers, Rihanna this, Lady GaGa that... They were hyping to the heaven "No More You" too admiring the Ne-Yo's writing skills. Instead we got a quite nice ballad, yes. But it is very generic and it's not really different to any other Ne-Yo ballad. Yes, the lyrics are nice, the song is nice - but we need more from the epic group which Sugababes used to be. After Mutya's departure the quality of material has lowered down quite a bit, the falling interest in group just proved that. Maybe she was indeed the main songwriter of Sugababes? But "No More You" still got relatively high rates, so maybe I'm wrong.

I kinda like No More You. It's one of the songs that Jade uses her vocals to full potential (other is Sweet and Amazing).
The only reason GS didn't get a 10 from me was because i rated it as the Jade version

 

same goes here I rated Jade version too, which is really poor. Keisha's version is f***ing good. A TEN!

Not that impressed with the results, Thank You For The Heartbreak is by far my best!

 

Still I'm glad 'About A Girl' is still to come..

 

Also my average score 8.21, I reckon that score would be quite a bit lower now tbh..

No More You is alright. I'm pleased Crash & Burn is higher though, deffinately the better ballad.
I quite like No More You, nothing groundbreaking and again like the majority of the album it did feel awfully generic in places. Probably my least favourites of the albums ballads and if we rated this album again, I'd probably rate it lower in all honesty.
  • Author

4. Crash & Burn - 7.67 pts

 

 

Lovers: Gaga for Glee!, Aled., Rossco, Steve D, Jonjo, Liam Gleek., Crowan, Silas, Mike Sugafan, Aidan, Marc., Sweet 7, Steven.

Haters: XXXO, Pavel

Oh, how many jokes we heard when it was going to be a single! It indeed would be funny if it was released and indeed was their last single, but I would like to change the record and say something else. So... This is the only pure Sugababes 4.0 song we have heard (we won't properly count Rabbit Heart, Santa Baby and err... Grow a Girl?) and it showed pretty good results being higher than whole other 8 songs on the album, including 2 singles. I can say that they are off to a good start, but personally I'd love them to distance from this song as far as they can. The song is essentially the Saturdays' "Here Standing" part 2, the melodies in the "That's when we crashed and burned" / "You're the reason I'm here" parts are pretty much identical! And I can't say that I'm keen on "Here Standing" either. And I don't think it fits the other songs on the album really, it's a bit in a different style. To the song's defense I need to say that it's a grower. It's really a grower as now I quite like it while when I first heard it - I was like "WTF?"

Edited by Arrs

  • Author

Yes, these songs have made the top-3:

3. About a Girl

4. Wait For You

7. She's a Mess

 

Finally it's out. I'm so glad I'm a hater. If She's a Mess would've been out my least fav. songs woulda been top3 :puke2:. I'm not happy with the results :P.

'Crash & Burn' is f***ing awful! :lol:

 

'Wait For You' is by far my favourite out of the remaining songs so I hope it wins.

  • Author

3. Wait for You - 7.79 pts

 

 

Lovers: Chris-2k10, Rossco, Steve D, Jonjo, Cremey, Mike Sugafan, Aidan, Kuki Sanban, Doug, Marc., Sweet 7, J-o-e, Arrs

Haters: Pavel, Silas

It is funny how somebody mentiones here the song which he wants to go to #1 and I need to announce that it is the next to be revealed in the countdown. Firstly Mike Sugafan and "Crash & Burn", now Cremey and "Wait For You"... Maybe someone wants to "predict" the winner this way?

This is the last and the highest song from this utterly close 3-11 region. The top-2 is well above 8 points at the same time. I think this song could be the best on the album if the Jade's version was produced well, but her voice was a bit messed up there, and it definitely didn't fit as well as Keisha's. Overall, the song is very romantic and makes you feel a bit happier if you are in the right mood. It is at #3 - and deservedly so.

 

And now, these songs have made the top-2:

3. About a Girl

vs

7. She's a Mess

 

Unlike the number 3-11, the top-2 is very clear: #1 got 8.72 points, #2 got 8.31 points.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.