October 18, 201014 yr Car Wash for me as its Christina and she outsings most people never mind Britney Spears :lol:, although My Progative has always been on of my favourite Britney songs.
October 18, 201014 yr What rot! Car Wash was a bit of fun - never intended to be an important release in the context of Christina's career, and it was actually a decent cover - it added a new spin to the original and Missy's presence was fun if random too. The original My Prerogative was before my time and I don't think much to it but Britney's cover is an incredibly lush and sexy song - if only the quality of her music today matched that song, back when she was relatively unpredictable and daring and not churning out poop like Womawomawoma and 3. My favourite is My Prerog though, just because Car Wash, good as it is, is nothing more than a bit of fun. Jark in speaking sense outrage! On another note, all these 'omgz BEST COVER EVER' people need to take off the loon glasses. My Prerogative is NO No Doubt - It's My Life http://www.moopy.org.uk/forums/images/icons/disco.gif
October 18, 201014 yr I'm sorry but I think both are dreadful. How anyone can listen to either makes my head spin round. I see nothing redeeming about either song and both artists have produced FAR better.
October 18, 201014 yr My Prerogative, although I think I prefered Car Wash at the time it was released. I don't really like Car Wash anymore, it's nowhere near Christina's best songs while My Prerogative is still amazing.
October 18, 201014 yr I'm sorry but I think both are dreadful. How anyone can listen to either makes my head spin round. I see nothing redeeming about either song and both artists have produced FAR better. Oh, I can definitely understand why people would hate My Prerogative. It truly is a FILTHY sounding song with little in the way of melody. But that doesn't phase me, the sleazy mood of it is just everything.
October 18, 201014 yr I am so shocked that Britney is winning!! Car Was was a lot more fun/GOOD than My Prerogative, she didn't put any effort in the song - she sung-talked it and relied heavily on her backing vocals to carry off the chorus. Xtina put more effort into her cover
October 18, 201014 yr Yeah but Chrissy's out of favour with Buzzjack/the whole world at the minute anyway so she was always going to be at a disadvantage. And 95% of people are likely to prefer a 'serious' song to a novelty one anyway.
October 18, 201014 yr Yeah but Chrissy's out of favour with Buzzjack/the whole world at the minute anyway so she was always going to be at a disadvantage. And 95% of people are likely to prefer a 'serious' song to a novelty one anyway. If Christina released something like Circus (or Back to Basics Pt. 2) she'd probably win this.. I hate that Britney has become more of a legend when she doesn't have a proper vocal range, unless Robots have a range? And, the Macerena is probably more serious than her version of 'My Prerogative' which was just to fill in the gap that Overprotected and Piece of Me had. Now Car Wash & Lady Marmalade are perfect covers, nicely produced, nicely sung and keeps it's close to original with a few GOOD twists Edited October 18, 201014 yr by Spiral
October 18, 201014 yr Ok first I'd like to say. I bought Bionic and I love the album, I am out of Christina hating period. I will also admit I kinda love her now. So no "SO BIASED!". I love both covers tbh! My Prerogative is MY favorite cover ever. I think she made it her own and the video is amazing. I love the production as well. And she did write the intro for those questioning, she has writing credits on the remake. And alsom Bobby Brown now has to pay her small royalties now because he now uses the intro when he performs it. lol. "People can take everything away from you, but they can never take away your truth, but the question is, can you handle mine". OBVIOUSLY WE CAN. Please bring back that fire and take your throne back. And lol at Jark "womawomawoma". Edited October 18, 201014 yr by Tyler
Create an account or sign in to comment