October 23, 201014 yr TreyC- 5/10- amazing voice, but that performance didnt work at all, it didnt suit her well and of course they dont say anything about the ridiculous song choice! :angry:
October 23, 201014 yr TreyC - Good performance, her vocals seemed improved from before, but I feel the dancers and the guitarist was quite a distraction from her.
October 23, 201014 yr Treyc Cohen: Great song choice for her. Another solid performance from her. - 8.0/10
October 23, 201014 yr Wow TreyC's best performance so far. :wub: Amazing!! Really? It wasn't a patch on Purple Rain for me. Too rocky for TreyC, she needs to be more about the power-ballad/power-house soul numbers. Disappointing.
October 23, 201014 yr Treyc - I'm really unsure if it worked for me or not, there was so much action going on my head was spinning. Maybe it's something I need to look back over. However I loved her voice and Treyc on a bad day is still better than 1 Direction and Paije. 7/10 Matt - 9/10 Rebecca - 9/10 Cher - 7.5/10 Treyc - 7/10 Paije - 7/10 1 Direction - 6.5/10 John - 6/10
October 23, 201014 yr Treyc was pretty good.....another WTF song choice though. Led Zepellin a guilty pleasure?? She pulled it off, though. Edited October 23, 201014 yr by Word Life
October 23, 201014 yr Mary: Now that's what I call it a performance, best of the night 9/10 along with Matt
October 23, 201014 yr Mary = 8.0 Oh my! This song again? Why? Great performance again but Why don't sing something new? Matt = 9.0 TreyC = 8.5 One Direction = 8.0 Mary = 8.0 Cher = 7.5 Rebecca = 6.5 Paije = 5.5 John = 4.5
October 23, 201014 yr Oh my! This song again? Why? Great performance again but Why don't sing something new? Did you watch her VT? :huh:
October 23, 201014 yr Mary- 7/10- she is undeniably a great singer, but this is the same thing again- plus she's sang this before, solid, but thats it Edited October 23, 201014 yr by chart wizard
October 23, 201014 yr How the hell is Led Zeppelin a guilty pleasure? Bloody muppets. and yet they say nothing to Cheryl :angry:
October 23, 201014 yr Hang on! Just last week Simon was telling Mary to keep doing what she's doing. Now he's telling her to change her songs? :huh: Mary - I really enjoyed that song, maybe it was because we had already heard her sing it there wasn't as much of the surprise factor to hear her sing it, but still great. 8.5/10 Matt - 9/10 Rebecca - 9/10 Mary - 8.5/10 Cher - 7.5/10 Treyc - 7/10 Paije - 7/10 1 Direction - 6.5/10 John - 6/10
October 23, 201014 yr Mary Bryne: Still love Mary & her vocals were perfect. I do agree with Simon though, its basically been 3 very similar songs since the live shows started and we have heard her do this before. - 8.5/10
October 23, 201014 yr Treyc was good, I wasn't that keen on the song choice, but she gave a good performance. Not as great as her 'One' performance, but better than the screechy 'Purple Rain'. Mary was alright, although I think it's unfair that she got to do a song she'd already performed, so early into the competition. 01. Matt Cardle 02. Rebecca Ferguson 03. Treyc Cohen 04. Cher Lloyd 05. One Direction 06. Mary Byrne --- 07. Paije Richardson 08. John Adeleye
October 23, 201014 yr Mary - Her performance was stunning as always, but I was quite annoyed that it was a song she has already performed.
Create an account or sign in to comment