To be fair, this list is awful, by far the worst yet. Apart from 'Nasty Girl and 'JCB' everything that's gone so far I think its rubbish, and there are still another ten songs left which I think are dreadful. It's not usually quite that bad.

Yeah, I can count 9 songs on that list that I don't really like.

 

Although I think Smack That, Nasty Girl and Everytime We Touch are awesome, and they've all been voted out. :(

I have 12 that I really don't like. 8 of these I'm pretty sure won't go far, but 4 of these will probably be in the top 10.

 

What happened to all the Chasing Cars haters, btw? Brayfish must be fuming right now. If it lasts much longer chart_wizard people can start using it as an excuse not to take songs out that have already featured/ing in another game :cry: Get it out for the sake of Hole in the Head being in the 2003 game, people!!

lol. It doesn't make sense to remove songs from certain polls just because it happened to be popular in another year aswell.

 

Just think of all those people, when they see the poll from a year, and they think "Oh, I loved that song that year, I hope it wins", and then BAM!!!!!, it's not there!!!!! :o :cry: How do you think they'd feel!?!?

lol. It doesn't make sense to remove songs from certain polls just because it happened to be popular in another year aswell.

 

Just think of all those people, when they see the poll from a year, and they think "Oh, I loved that song that year, I hope it wins", and then BAM!!!!!, it's not there!!!!! :o :cry: How do you think they'd feel!?!?

Not as bad as I'd feel having to put up with f***ing Daniel Bedingfield's utter dreck If You're Not The One (which I remember Simon Cowell said was one of the greatest songs in recent years, ENOUGH SAID there :nocheer:) in both 2002 and 2003 when I could be watching a storming pop single by Sugababes romp home to victory instead!!

 

Anyway, I thought Dannyboy had already decided he would take them out from now on. But I'm worried if Chasing Cars gets much further he'll change his mind.

What happened to all the Chasing Cars haters, btw? Brayfish must be fuming right now. If it lasts much longer chart_wizard people can start using it as an excuse not to take songs out that have already featured/ing in another game :cry: Get it out for the sake of Hole in the Head being in the 2003 game, people!!

 

I see you've noticed! :P if it does somehow make the top 20, I think that proves that songs can do better under different circumstances, admittedly, I'm not expecting it too, still, I still would prefer it if the format was kept the same for all the years (although obviously its Dannyboy's choice :P )

 

and Its not just you thats frustrated about songs just missing out in favour of songs in the same game - in 2005's game, Coldplay- Speed of Sound is 41st so won't be there :cry:

Edited February 18, 201114 yr by chart wizard

What happened to all the Chasing Cars haters, btw? Brayfish must be fuming right now. If it lasts much longer chart_wizard people can start using it as an excuse not to take songs out that have already featured/ing in another game :cry: Get it out for the sake of Hole in the Head being in the 2003 game, people!!

 

<_<

 

You can stop calling me 'Brayfish' by the way :kink: That's a chapter of my history that is now forever erased, I'm just Bray again now

Look guys, I think we need to take a step back, and apply some LOGIC to the whole situation.

 

Okay. Having done so, I think we should use the year-end top 40 in each poll.

 

Have a good evening. :)

I honestly see more LOGIC in taking them out, and that's not just because I'm loony over the Sugababes song (my last few posts here have been slightly hyperbolic, anyway, I won't break down or something if HITH is left out, it's not even my fave Sugababes song, really)... but frankly I don't want to get into this again after the last time it was discussed went on for like 2 pages. At the end of the day it's up to Dannyboy, and I'll honestly be okay if he leaves them in (although I still might have a SNIFF and wonder whether the 2003 winner really would have won if Sugababes were there :kink:)

 

And sorry, Bray. For some reason I always think of you as Brayfish. I think that was your name when I first 'e-met' you, so to speak, so it's kind of stuck in my head.

Edited February 18, 201114 yr by superbossanova

We could perhaps do it both ways. Like do the whole poll using the simply year-end top 40, then re-do the poll taking duplicates out.

We could perhaps do it both ways. Like do the whole poll using the simply year-end top 40, then re-do the poll taking duplicates out.

That'd be one way of ensuring this game runs into 2012, I suppose.

That'd be one way of ensuring this game runs into 2012, I suppose.

 

Or we could do them simultaneously? Like have both threads going on at the same time?

Did my vote get moved to America? because if not they should technically be in the lead now

 

(Is moving votes even possible btw? :mellow:)

And sorry, Bray. For some reason I always think of you as Brayfish. I think that was your name when I first 'e-met' you, so to speak, so it's kind of stuck in my head.

 

I did have that name for quite a while but I got bored of it, like I do with all names. I've even tired of 'BlindFaithBray' (with stars as appropriate) now. So for now I'm just back to 'Bray' but I'll probably end up changing it again before the end of February :lol: