So...after many months, we made it! Unlike the unfinished Mistaken Identity survivor, this one kept on going and Butterfly fell at the final hurdle, going out with 4 votes. Now it's up to you to pick your favourite album track from Innocent Eyes. The fantastic Aus 5th single and 5th #1 Predictable (which would have EASILY given her a 5th UK top 20 hit single if released here instead of the canned Throw It Away - I even heard Predictable on the radio a few times here :o) is up against the gorgeous heartbreaking ballad A Year Ago Today. Which is your favourite?

 

Predictable

 

 

A Year Ago Today

 

This is exceptionally hard, but I've gone for A Year Ago Today, as it's one of my all time favourite ballads. Although not the original video version where her voice sounds bizarre :lol:

 

Predictable is brilliant but I can't listen to it properly anymore since hearing it mashed up with Sweet Dreams - the original feels so slow and plodding in comparison now.

As above tbh.

 

I've gone with A Year Ago Today as Predictable has been ruined by that utterly sublime mash up.

As much as I do love 'A Year Ago Today', I had to go for 'Predictable'.

The mashup is fabulous but the original version is still brilliant from start to finish.