Misha smacked her performance big time, you just know she'll go through.

I personally thought Misha was quite shit. She could have done 'Fly' so much better. Amelia certainly wiped the floor with everyone last night, imo. I reckon she'll be the Alexandra of this year in the sense that no one will see her as a strong contender until about week 5 or 6 then she'll slowly start to walk away with it.

Yes loved Amelia too! Loved Kelly's reaction 'Katy Who'? :lol:

Edited October 2, 201113 yr by Karma

Amelia was rather excellent although I'm loving Mischa.

 

The only group I really care about is 2 Shoes though, they are epic.

 

 

Kelly Rowland gets more god like each episode. If she continues I'm going to have to set up a religion dedicated to her.

My final list of who I want through....(The leaks don't effect this list, it's who I like the most in each selection)

 

Boys

------

John Wilding

Frankie Cocozza

Marcus Collins

Joe Cox

 

 

Girls

-----

Janet Devlin

Misha Bryan

Jade Richards

Amelia Lily/Melanie Mccabe (either of these, all the girls are quite strong)

 

Groups

--------

2Shoes

The Keys

The Lovettes

Girl V Boy

 

Groups are pretty dodgy, my favouries Girl V Boy were a bit blah last night. So now the only group I'm interested in his 2Shoes.

 

Overs

-------

Samantha Brookes

Carolynne Poole

Johnny Robinson

Kitty Brucknell (Well we're going to need the token clown right?)

 

Terry was in there at first, but his performance last night was pretty bland.

 

 

(I'm still catching up on last night here)

 

 

The thing that really annoys me about the boys is most of them look like their are having seizures when they sing. Seriously shit dancing/swaying.

 

That Frankie reminds me of GabCilmi, not vocally she absolutely wipes the floor with it, coz she has about 4 dance moves that she uses repeatedly as well.

 

 

 

 

That John deserves to go home for inflicting The Promise on me. Vile song.

To add to that point, Joe is by far the worst offender of the seizure dancing.

 

It looks like he is attempting to shit a bowling ball. He just looks in pain and he looks simple.

Watching the Xtra Factor at the moment, I bet Kitty was copying Goldie when she jumped in the pool. (Goldie did it too)

I personally thought Misha was quite shit. She could have done 'Fly' so much better. Amelia certainly wiped the floor with everyone last night, imo. I reckon she'll be the Alexandra of this year in the sense that no one will see her as a strong contender until about week 5 or 6 then she'll slowly start to walk away with it.

Me too actually, Misha was quite disappointing. When I watched it first, I thought 'ooh! She's quite good!' but I think it was just the amazement of someone singing (well and rapping :P) a Nicki song on X-Factor! Because I watched it back and I just thought 'OK, actually she's one of the weaker girls...' I agree on Amelia too, she's been my favourite since her audition and has stayed there since - and last night she slayed it. The only other contestant who came close to her was Sophie and even then Amelia was quite a lot better than her. I'd be shocked if she wasn't top 2 at least, but atm I can only see her and Janet as contenders and Janet will blatantly be this year's Cher/Diana, so tbh this is Amelia's to lose.

It looks like he is attempting to shit a bowling ball. He just looks in pain and he looks simple.

 

:rofl: Love it!

Because I watched it back and I just thought 'OK, actually she's one of the weaker girls...'

 

I thought you said Misha's audition was one of the best you have ever seen? She is most certainly not one of the weaker girls, this proves it:

 

 

Outstanding. If she doesn't get through tonight I will not be happy.

I thought you said Misha's audition was one of the best you have ever seen? She is most certainly not one of the weaker girls, this proves it:

 

 

Outstanding. If she doesn't get through tonight I will not be happy.

That was a bit of looning at the time too, I maintain it was brilliant (probably the 3rd best audition this year behind Amelia and Jade) but not quite 'top 5 auditions ever' material. Watching it back a few times I just realised she wasn't quite as life-changing as I thought, but I wouldn't mind her through because I do like her.

 

Imo, if I ranked the girls:

1. Amelia

2. Sophie

3. Melanie

4. Jade

5. Misha

6. Holly

7. Janet

8. Sarah

 

So by one of the weaker girls, I mean in the bottom half. And that's just because through bootcamp and JH we've not heard anything to replicate her great audition.

I thought Mischa was great last night! It's only because Fly doesn't have any big notes that people are thinking she isn't 'that' good; it would've been over-the-top to add them in anyway. Jade's in a similar situation too, maybe because it wasn't a 'big' song that Kelly and Jennifer weren't that impressed and

didn't put her through

I thought Mischa was great last night! It's only because Fly doesn't have any big notes that people are thinking she isn't 'that' good; it would've been over-the-top to add them in anyway.

Not at all. Misha has just shown she's just style over substance really. There's definitely potential there, but she falls short and it becomes a little flat. That 'Ave Maria' performance is rubbish! It's so monotonous and she has a limited range to her vocal. It's one of my favourite Beyoncé songs and I just think her voice is not suited to it at all. Her voice SHOULD have been suited to 'Fly' better, but she failed imo. Shame really as her audition IS very good.

Janet absolutely murdered Beautiful last night. Awful. I'm still gutted that Louis is going to screw up the overs but I suppose if at least 1 of Sammi, Jonjo, Joseph or Carolynne get through I shall be happy. With the boys it's all about Marcus and Craig, the others were shite. For the girls, Amelia, Sophie and Melanie were my faves. For the groups, 2 Shoes are the only ones worth mentioning. They're so getting their own reality show or something after all this is over because of hilarity.

Girls ranking for me are:

 

1. Sophie

2. Misha

3. Amelia

4. Jade

5. Melanie

6. Holly

7. Sarah

8. Janet

I'll go for a girls rank too :kink:

 

1. Janet

2. Amelia

-------------------

3. Misha

4. Sophie

5. Melanie

-------------------

6. Jade

7. Holly

8. Sarah

 

I'm personally feeling a bit underwhelmed by Jade now but after her Fly performance, I like Misha a bit more :) Hopefully 4 from my top 5 go through :)

 

Ooh, I fancy an overs rate too :D

 

1. Carolynne

--------------------

2. Kitty

3. Sami

4. Jonjo

--------------------

5. Joseph

6. Terry

7. Goldie

8. Johnny

Edited October 2, 201113 yr by RC741

I've only just noticed why Frankie has that daft hairstyle over the top of his face! Have you caught a look at his eyebrows? Wow! They're really bushy!

 

Oh his voice is sh/te too! I only really like Marcus and Craig from the boys. I have to admit that Robbie Williams was very entertaining as guest judge.

 

At the Overs JH - how obvious was it that Louis had utter contempt for being lumbered with Sinitta?

 

Kath

So one of the spoiler girls was WRONG!

 

They said

Melanie McCabe

but she didn't

Sophie

is through :)

 

 

http://xfactor-updates.com/x-factor-2011-judges-houses-contestants/

 

Alright pet, calm it. No need for the block caps there.