I know, but did you really expect anything less? :(

I missed this but I am gutted 'Fantasy' and 'Always Be My Baby' are not even top 5? Both are the best in her back catalogue for me :(

I love both of the top 2, so I'm happy with either tbh. Obsessed though :wub:

I gave "Obsessed" a 10!!1! I love both songs but "All I Want For Christmas Is You" just IS Mariah. It has to win!

02 | We Belong Together | Average: 9.11764



Highest Scores
11 rafik4u
11 Slick
10 Jack
10 Liam
10 Stewie
10 AaronTM
10 Simon
10 kenukcsfant2012
10 Mikal
10 Jonjo

Lowest Scores
03 JakeWild

01 | All I Want For Christmas Is You | Average: 9.941176



Highest Scores
11 Liam
11 kenukcsfant2012
11 Silver Rocket
11 JakeWild
10 rafik4u
10 Jack
10 JohnKM
10 Ryan
10 Stewie
10 Simon
10 CianS
10 Mikal
10 Jonjo
10 Slick


Lowest Scores
08 Euphorique
08 AaronTM

So we have come to an end! The most successful Emancipation Of Mimi single, We Belong Together which sees her go back to classic Mariah ballad territory with an updated production is at #02. It was always a favourite of mine, and seems rather forgotten within the general public these days which is a shame (in the UK at least anyway). Absolutely stunning song but I have overplayed it just a little. And the winner is by far and away her most successful song ever and probably always will be, the classic that is All I Want For Christmas Is You. I personally would not have it the winner myself, but it is such a classic and imo, the best christmas song ever. Thanks to all who took part and it is finally done over a year later! :D

Pretty much THE perfect top 2 imo <3

It's weird how WBT was far bigger than ILT when they were released yet ILT is the one still getting played today (well in clubs at least although WBT wouldn't exactly sound good there :lol:).

"Obsessed" and "It's Like That" are incredible songs, obv, in fact both right up there with the very best from a woman whose back cat is astonishing enough already, BUT it seems a shame these results were so focused on the '00s material. I mean "Get Your Number" top 10? It's fun but come on. That said, "We Belong Together" never fails to wow and it really should have won. Simply the pinnacle of a great career. The actual winner can do one anytime it's not December!

 

Wunderbar countdown Jack!