Posted September 9, 201311 yr Discuss all spoiler items here including who's got what category, who's made it to lives and what songs they'll be singing. I hereby give y'all permission to ditch the spoiler tags in this thread and anyone not wishing to read any spoilers should stay in the discussion thread.
September 9, 201311 yr Barclay (yodel boy) and Melanie's twitter convo makes it sound like he hasn't made the live shows but Melanie has! @MelanieMcCabe nah but your actually stunning ! You better win the show for me !!!! Your titanium was on another world !!! and this @MelanieMcCabe well thats good !!! Generally can't believe that you haven't made it before ! #beautiful #DoItForMe https://twitter.com/BarclayBeales
September 9, 201311 yr Yay if she has made it, definitely deserves to be there after all those failed attempts! :cheer: And Jade betta be there too or Fife will protest EN MASS.
September 10, 201311 yr Melanie McCabe Bootcamp audition (Katy Perry - The One That Got Away) https://soundcloud.com/fribblet/x-factor-bo...mp-2013-melanie Jade Richards bootcamp audition (Emeli Sande - Clown) https://soundcloud.com/fribblet/x-factor-bootcamp-jade Abi Alton bootcamp audition (Whitney Houston - I Wanna Dance With Somebody) https://soundcloud.com/fribblet/x-factor-bootcamp-2013-abi Tamera Foster bootcamp audition (Rihanna - Stay) https://soundcloud.com/fribblet/x-factor-bo...amp-2013-tamera Few of the girls bootcamp audio's! Love Jades & Melanie's but I think only one will go to live shows! And judging by the airtime they both had so far it looks like producers want Melanie to be the "comeback kid" this year. Edited September 10, 201311 yr by BrookeOlivia
September 10, 201311 yr YES! 'The One That Got Away' to FINALLY get that top 10 peak please! Criminal it's her only song from that era not to make it! :( I wish Tamera knew her vocal range! :( She really isn't too good when she's trying to go for the big notes. She sounds a lot better in a more lower tone and reigning it in! :(
September 10, 201311 yr Jade knows what song'll get her to Judges' Houses! Amazing. :wub: LOL. If she did, she wouldn't be out in 2011.
September 10, 201311 yr Jade knows what song'll get her to Judges' Houses! Amazing. :wub: She knows which song will prove that she has absolutely NO versatility more like. :lol: If she got to the live shows it'd just be the same old type of song every week (they'll do dance week and she'll still find a way to sing an Emeli piano ballad or something). Edited September 10, 201311 yr by JosephStyles
September 10, 201311 yr She knows which song will prove that she has absolutely NO versatility more like. :lol: If she got to the live shows it'd just be the same old type of song every week (they'll do dance week and she'll still find a way to sing an Emeli piano ballad or something). lolno Think she actually proved in 2011 that she was very worthy of going to live shows. Just a shame she had the shittest judge going.
September 10, 201311 yr The problem with Melanie is she has the VOX but not the personality or dare I say the X FACTOR, as that clip proves.
September 10, 201311 yr Sam Bailey did Clown at bootcamp, I think it suited her more than Jade. That was on Digital Spy somewhere (on the forums not the main site).
September 10, 201311 yr Sam Bailey did Clown at bootcamp, I think it suited her more than Jade. That was on Digital Spy somewhere (on the forums not the main site). And Carolynne slayed all performances of Clown with her audition last year. :kink:
September 10, 201311 yr lolno Think she actually proved in 2011 that she was very worthy of going to live shows. Just a shame she had the shittest judge going. I think she proved in 2011 that she wasn't very versatile tbh, she's decent enough but will she really present anything that we don't already have? I don't think she will, she'll go down the Adele/Emeli Sande route and we really don't need another of either of them. Emeli or not, it's nothing that different to what she's sang before.
September 10, 201311 yr I think she proved in 2011 that she wasn't very versatile tbh, she's decent enough but will she really present anything that we don't already have? I don't think she will, she'll go down the Adele/Emeli Sande route and we really don't need another of either of them. Emeli or not, it's nothing that different to what she's sang before. I don't think she proved that at all. Just because she sung two very near-similar songs, doesn't mean she doesn't have any versatility about her. Those were two opportunities to sell herself as the type of artist she could see herself being, and why shouldn't she have taken them? Likewise at Boot Camp, she wasn't exactly in full control of the song she chose to sing. She really does present a different type of soulful voice that is different to Adele (I don't know where the comparisons to Emeli are coming from just because she's chosen to sing Clown? LMAO). But on the topic of versatility (not that it's important when an artist has a style and wants to further establish that), if she gets to live shows, I have every faith she'd be perfectly capable of doing so, and adapting her voice to different genres of music. Edited September 10, 201311 yr by Calum Sandé
September 10, 201311 yr It's a bit stupid for me to try and fight this battle as you're not gonna see my point regardless, but she's shown in three series that she only seems to be able to do piano ballads, have we seen her do anything else? That's what I'm trying to say. And she is pretty similar to Adele and would just be marketed like her I think.
September 10, 201311 yr I don't think you actually have a point, though, that's the problem. She's not been given a chance to show how diverse she may or may not be, so you can't exactly write her off. When people audition, they audition with a song that they think sells their style, and will get them further in the show, they don't go in with the attitude that says "OMFG I HAVE TO BE DIVERSE JUST TO PLEASE THE VIEWERZZ !!!!!1"
September 10, 201311 yr Didn't Jade get asked to do another song ('Someone Like You') at her VERY first audition a couple of years ago, because it wasn't very good, but they thought she had potential? Jade has not shown diversity. She would have been far better suited to 'The Voice'. The 'X Factor' is about showing versatility AND having the voice to match. Wasn't she also slating XF to the press saying stuff like "they forced me to do SLY etc... but that's not who I want to be" but here she comes again, for the 3rd time singing the same sort of songs. But anyway I'm not a fan of her at all. She's very cold and unlikeable to me and her voice really isn't all that. I'm fairly confident she won't make it past judge's houses this year.
September 10, 201311 yr Apparently... http://s18.postimg.org/w4e9mn1rd/X_Factor_2013_Girls.jpg They did the bootcamp results in front of a live audience. So basically everybody knows everything. Groups Brick City Rough Copy Kingsland Xyra Code 4 Girlband, 3 piece (put together by judges) Boys Sam Callahan Paul Akister Ryan Mathie Luke Friend Giles Potter Nicholas McDonald Girls Melanie McCabe Abi Alton Rielle Carrington Jade Richards Tamera Foster Hannah Barrett Overs Joseph Whelan Sam Bailey Shelley Lewis Lorna Zoe Andrea
September 10, 201311 yr Didn't Jade get asked to do another song ('Someone Like You') at her VERY first audition a couple of years ago, because it wasn't very good, but they thought she had potential? Jade has not shown diversity. She would have been far better suited to 'The Voice'. The 'X Factor' is about showing versatility AND having the voice to match. Wasn't she also slating XF to the press saying stuff like "they forced me to do SLY etc... but that's not who I want to be" but here she comes again, for the 3rd time singing the same sort of songs. But anyway I'm not a fan of her at all. She's very cold and unlikeable to me and her voice really isn't all that. I'm fairly confident she won't make it past judge's houses this year. If she did, it wasn't shown, but I doubt she did anyway. They were blown away with her at the auditions in 2011. And OMFG at that final 6 for the girls *.* That's a phenomenal line-up, and AMAZING to see Jade and Melanie both going to judges' houses again (if true) :wub: But the Boys category... SAM CALLAHAN?! He's auditioned? :lol:
Create an account or sign in to comment