Rate of all stars to come out of X Factor, Pop Idol, Popstars and Fame Academy.

Let us rejoice at how many flop packages we have actually had to endure since Hear'say rocketed to #1 with 'Pure & Simple' back in March 2001. Rate each act out of 10. You can give a -1 and an 11 even though these are not compulsory. Oh and if I've missed anyone tough.

 

Hear'say

Liberty X

Will Young

Gareth Gates

Darius

Zoe Birkett

Rik Waller

Sarah Whatmore

Rosie Ribbons

Jessica Garlick

Girls Aloud

One True Voice

Kym Marsh

Clea

Phixx

David Sneddon

Sinead Quinn

Lemar

Ainsle Henderson

Alex Parks

Alistar Griffin

Michelle Mcmanus

Sam & Mark

Steve Brookstein

G4

Shayne Ward

Andy Abraham

Journey South

Chico

Cheeky Girls

Maria Lawson

08 Hear'say

08 Liberty X

09 Will Young

06 Gareth Gates

05 Darius

07 Zoe Birkett

00 Rik Waller

06 Sarah Whatmore

04 Rosie Ribbons

07 Jessica Garlick

10 Girls Aloud

01 One True Voice

07 Kym Marsh

07 Clea

09 Phixx

10 David Sneddon

11 Sinead Quinn :wub:

08 Lemar

07 Ainsle Henderson

06 Alex Parks

06 Alistar Griffin

05 Michelle Mcmanus

02 Sam & Mark

00 Steve Brookstein

02 G4

07 Shayne Ward

03 Andy Abraham

03 Journey South

-1 Chico

10 Cheeky Girls - LEGENDSSSSSSSSSS

08 Maria Lawson

Hear'say- 9

Liberty X- 10

Will Young- 10

Gareth Gates- 04

Darius- 04

Zoe Birkett- 02

Rik Waller- 00

Sarah Whatmore- 03

Rosie Ribbons- 05

Jessica Garlick- 07

Girls Aloud- 11

One True Voice- 02

Kym Marsh- 03

Clea- 04

Phixx- 07

David Sneddon- 04

Sinead Quinn- 09

Lemar- 10

Ainsle Henderson- 06

Alex Parks- 07

Alistar Griffin- 04

Michelle Mcmanus- 08

Sam & Mark- 01

Steve Brookstein- 01

G4- 04

Shayne Ward- 07

Andy Abraham- 06

Journey South- 04

Chico- 01

Cheeky Girls- 03

Maria Lawson- 06

Fab! :kink:

 

10 Hear'say

09 Liberty X

11 Will Young

04 Gareth Gates

04 Darius

05 Zoe Birkett

00 Rik Waller

06 Sarah Whatmore

05 Rosie Ribbons

06 Jessica Garlick

10 Girls Aloud

00 One True Voice

09 Kym Marsh

00 Clea

07 Phixx

08 David Sneddon

05 Sinead Quinn

08 Lemar

08 Ainsle Henderson

07 Alex Parks

04 Alistar Griffin

05 Michelle Mcmanus

-1 Sam & Mark

00 Steve Brookstein

00 G4

01 Shayne Ward

00 Andy Abraham

00 Journey South

00 Chico

10 Cheeky Girls

08 Maria Lawson

Hear'say 6

Liberty X 7

Will Young 5

Gareth Gates 4

Darius 2

Zoe Birkett 8

Rik Waller 0

Sarah Whatmore 9 (for Automatic alone :wub: )

Rosie Ribbons 7

Jessica Garlick 5

Girls Aloud 11 :wub:

One True Voice 0

Kym Marsh 6

Clea 2

Phixx 9

David Sneddon 4

Sinead Quinn 7

Lemar 0

Ainsle Henderson 4

Alex Parks 6

Alistar Griffin 5

Michelle Mcmanus 5

Sam & Mark -1 :puke2:

Steve Brookstein 0

G4 0

Shayne Ward 5

Andy Abraham 3

Journey South 1

Chico 3

Cheeky Girls 9

Maria Lawson 5

Hear'say 0

Liberty X 7

Will Young 10

Gareth Gates 5

Darius 5

Zoe Birkett 0

Rik Waller 0 :lol:

Sarah Whatmore 0

Rosie Ribbons 0

Jessica Garlick 0

Girls Aloud 4

One True Voice 0

Kym Marsh 3

Clea 0

Phixx 0

David Sneddon 1

Sinead Quinn 3

Lemar 7

Ainsle Henderson 0

Alex Parks 4

Alistar Griffin 2

Michelle Mcmanus 0

Sam & Mark 0

Steve Brookstein 0

G4 0

Shayne Ward 6

Andy Abraham 6

Journey South 6

Chico 0

Cheeky Girls 0

Maria Lawson 5

 

Hear'say 8 with kym

Liberty X 11 - they were the best

Will Young 8

Gareth Gates 3

Darius 4

Zoe Birkett 9

Rik Waller-1

Sarah Whatmore9

Rosie Ribbons 9 blink was fab i must download

Jessica Garlick 10 come back was it fabness!

Girls Aloud 10

One True Voice 1

Kym Marsh 9

Clea 10

Phixx 3

David Sneddon 7

Sinead Quinn 10 bring her back now :angry:

Lemar 7

Ainsle Henderson 2 t wat

Alex Parks 5

Alistar Griffin 2

Michelle Mcmanus 8

Sam & Mark 2

Steve Brookstein 1

G4 4

Shayne Ward 4

Andy Abraham 3

Journey South 2

Chico 2

Cheeky Girls7

Maria Lawson 8

Hear'say with kym 8

Liberty X 11

Will Young 6

Gareth Gates 7

Darius 1

Zoe Birkett 6

Rik Waller-1

Sarah Whatmore 9

Rosie Ribbons 5

Jessica Garlick 8

Girls Aloud 11

One True Voice 1

Kym Marsh 10

Clea 5

Phixx 2

David Sneddon 7

Sinead Quinn 6

Lemar 8

Ainsle Henderson 1

Alex Parks 5

Alistar Griffin 2

Michelle Mcmanus 9

Sam & Mark 2

Steve Brookstein 3

G4 4

Shayne Ward 6

Andy Abraham 3

Journey South 5

Chico -1 and i stress minus

Cheeky Girls 3

Maria Lawson 5

02 Hear'say

06 Liberty X

07 Will Young

00 Gareth Gates

01 Darius

01 Zoe Birkett

02 Rik Waller

03 Sarah Whatmore

02 Rosie Ribbons

03 Jessica Garlick

01 Girls Aloud

03 One True Voice

06 Kym Marsh

04 Clea

08 Phixx

06 David Sneddon

05 Sinead Quinn

06 Lemar

01 Ainsle Henderson

06 Alex Parks

00 Alistar Griffin

03 Michelle Mcmanus

01 Sam & Mark

00 Steve Brookstein

03 G4

02 Shayne Ward

04 Andy Abraham

03 Journey South

00 Chico

10 Cheeky Girls -for they MUST win

03 Maria Lawson

05 Hear'say

06 Liberty X

11 Will Young

03 Gareth Gates

04 Darius

05 Zoe Birkett

02 Rik Waller

04 Sarah Whatmore

01 Rosie Ribbons

04 Jessica Garlick

07 Girls Aloud

01 One True Voice

03 Kym Marsh

02 Clea

01 Phixx

01 David Sneddon

05 Sinead Quinn

08 Lemar

03 Ainsle Henderson

02 Alex Parks

02 Alistar Griffin

02 Michelle Mcmanus

02 Sam & Mark

02 Steve Brookstein

01 G4

05 Shayne Ward

04 Andy Abraham

04 Journey South

00 Chico

-1 Cheeky Girls

03 Maria Lawson

 

00 Hear'say

09 Liberty X

09 Will Young

07 Gareth Gates

09 Darius

06 Zoe Birkett

04 Rik Waller

10 Sarah Whatmore

00 Rosie Ribbons

00 Jessica Garlick

11 Girls Aloud

08 One True Voice

08 Kym Marsh

00 Clea

09 Phixx

00 David Sneddon

08 Sinead Quinn

09 Lemar

10 Ainsle Henderson

10 Alex Parks

05 Alistar Griffin

07 Michelle Mcmanus

06 Sam & Mark

05 Steve Brookstein

-1 G4

09 Shayne Ward

00 Andy Abraham

00 Journey South

07 Chico

07 Cheeky Girls

09 Maria Lawson

 

Hear'say 7

Liberty X 5

Will Young 4

Gareth Gates 0

Darius 0

Zoe Birkett 5

Rik Waller 0

Sarah Whatmore 9

Rosie Ribbons 4

Jessica Garlick 6

Girls Aloud 11

One True Voice 0

Kym Marsh 9

Clea 7

Phixx 1

David Sneddon 1

Sinead Quinn 10

Lemar10

Ainsle Henderson 1

Alex Parks 0

Alistar Griffin 0

Michelle Mcmanus 4

Sam & Mark 0

Steve Brookstein 0

G4 3

Shayne Ward 10

Andy Abraham 3

Journey South 7

Chico -1

Cheeky Girls 0

Maria Lawson11

Hear'say - 6

Liberty X - 9

Will Young - 11

Gareth Gates - 2

Darius - 2

Zoe Birkett - 5

Rik Waller - 0

Sarah Whatmore - 0

Rosie Ribbons - 1

Jessica Garlick - 5

Girls Aloud - 8

One True Voice - 2

Kym Marsh - 4

Clea - 6

Phixx - 6

David Sneddon - 4

Sinead Quinn - 1

Lemar - 5

Ainsle Henderson - 1

Alex Parks - 2

Alistar Griffin - 1

Michelle Mcmanus - 1

Sam & Mark - 3

Steve Brookstein - 0

G4 - -1

Shayne Ward - 6

Andy Abraham - 1

Journey South - 2

Chico - 2

Cheeky Girls - 0

Maria Lawson - 2

 

These are my scores for the talent show stars

 

Hear'say - 2

Liberty X - 5

Will Young - 11 - would give him 100 if I could :dance:

Gareth Gates - 4

Darius - 2

Zoe Birkett - 6

Rik Waller - -1

Sarah Whatmore - 4

Rosie Ribbons - 0

Jessica Garlick - 8

Girls Aloud - 3

One True Voice - 0

Kym Marsh - 2

Clea - 0

Phixx - 0

David Sneddon - 0

Sinead Quinn - 5

Lemar - 6

Ainsle Henderson - 1

Alex Parks - 0

Alistar Griffin - 2

Michelle Mcmanus - 0

Sam Nixon - 7 ) These are not a double act!

Mark Rhodes - 6 )

Steve Brookstein - 0

G4 - 5

Shayne Ward - 4

Andy Abraham - 4

Journey South - 4

Chico - 0

Cheeky Girls - 0

Maria Lawson - 5

 

And 10 for Hayley Evetts who you have left out!

Edited August 28, 200618 yr by Dot

Hear'say 7

Liberty X 5

Will Young 11

Gareth Gates 4

Darius 4

Zoe Birkett 6

Rik Waller 4

Sarah Whatmore 4

Rosie Ribbons 1

Jessica Garlick 7

Girls Aloud 3

One True Voice 1

Kym Marsh 6

Clea 3

Phixx 3

David Sneddon 6

Sinead Quinn 6

Lemar 7

Ainsle Henderson 4

Alex Parks 6

Alistar Griffin 5

Michelle Mcmanus 4

Sam & Mark 4

Steve Brookstein 6

G4 6

Shayne Ward 5

Andy Abraham 6

Journey South 6

Chico 1

Cheeky Girls 0

Maria Lawson 5

sorry couldnt get past Darius, none of the others stick in my mind

 

 

Darius 11

 

 

mind you these are talent shows not reality shows, reality shows are BB and wife swap type shows

Edited August 28, 200618 yr by prettyinpink

Hear'say: 6

Liberty X: 8

Will Young: 5

Gareth Gates: 11

Darius: 5

Zoe Birkett: 6 (loved her on the show, but one duff single makes it hard to give her anything more)

Rik Waller: 0

Sarah Whatmore: 7

Rosie Ribbons: 6 (hated her on the show, but the leaked album tracks were great)

Jessica Garlick: 7

Girls Aloud: 9

One True Voice: 1

Kym Marsh: 3

Clea: 4 (Download was quality, but their recent stuff is terrible)

Phixx: 2

David Sneddon: 3

Sinead Quinn: 8

Lemar: 5

Ainsle Henderson: 6

Alex Parks: 4

Alistar Griffin: 3

Michelle Mcmanus: 3

Sam & Mark: 4

Steve Brookstein: 3

G4: 4

Shayne Ward: 2

Andy Abraham: 3

Journey South: 3

Chico: 3 (for entertainment value)

Cheeky Girls: 4 (as above)

Maria Lawson: 3 (great singer, but her new song is dull)

Hear'say - 5

Liberty X - 9

Will Young - 6

Gareth Gates - 11

Darius - 6

Zoe Birkett - 8

Rik Waller - 1

Sarah Whatmore - 5

Rosie Ribbons - 4

Jessica Garlick - 7

Girls Aloud - 8

One True Voice - 3

Kym Marsh - 5

Clea - 6

Phixx - 3

David Sneddon - 6

Sinead Quinn - 7

Lemar - 3

Ainsle Henderson - 1

Alex Parks - 3

Alistar Griffin - 5

Michelle Mcmanus - 5

Sam & Mark - 4

Steve Brookstein - 6

G4 - 7

Shayne Ward - 6

Andy Abraham - 5

Journey South - 9

Chico - 1

Cheeky Girls - 1

Maria Lawson - 8

 

[9]Hear'say

[9]Liberty X

[9]Will Young

[6]Gareth Gates

[6]Darius

[6]Zoe Birkett

[-1]Rik Waller

[9]Sarah Whatmore

[10]Rosie Ribbons

[9]Jessica Garlick

[11]Girls Aloud

[5]One True Voice

[9]Kym Marsh

[5]Clea

[6]Phixx

[6]David Sneddon

[10]Sinead Quinn

[8]Lemar

[3]Ainsle Henderson

[10]Alex Parks

[2]Alistar Griffin

[3]Michelle Mcmanus

[4]Sam & Mark

[2]Steve Brookstein

[2]G4

[6]Shayne Ward

[3]Andy Abraham

[2]Journey South

[4]Chico

[4]Cheeky Girls

[8]Maria Lawson

Hear'say...4..

Liberty X...8..

Will Young...11.. :wub:

Gareth Gates...2

Darius...4...

Zoe Birkett...6..

Rik Waller...0..

Sarah Whatmore...3..

Rosie Ribbons...0..

Jessica Garlick..6..

Girls Aloud...4..

One True Voice..0..

Kym Marsh..2

Clea..0..

Phixx..4..

David Sneddon....3..

Sinead Quinn..5..

Lemar...7..

Ainsle Henderson..0

Alex Parks...3..

Alistar Griffin...0

Michelle Mcmanus...2..

Sam & Mark..0..

Steve Brookstein..0..

G4...0..

Shayne Ward...4..

Andy Abraham...0..

Journey South...0..

Chico...0..

Cheeky Girls...0..

Maria Lawson..3..