oh I might do that then :lol:

I went for top 20. Thought it was pretty good. It's a shame she's struggling so badly this era! :(

um..no way. lol

I think her name is such a huge liability these days, it would be an uphill battle even for an incredible pop song. As this one is average at best, I would be shocked if this doesn't become her smallest hit both here and in the US.

It's a mess.

As normal with Gaga the video needs editing. It doesn't need 2 songs shoe-horned in at the beginning or a 4 minute credits. It could have been a great 4 minute video with select great visuals.

 

Anyway G.U.Y is a bit of a non event of a song anyway. So top 30 I think.

All people thinking that the 12 minute video with 4 minutes of end credits will harm the song itself, you do realise that for TV exposure there will be an edit containing G.U.Y. only?

The hype has dropped significantly for Lady Gaga so i cant see this doing anything more than a flash top 20 hit.

I say top 20, I really like it but I can see this being one Radio 1 fails to A-list.

All people thinking that the 12 minute video with 4 minutes of end credits will harm the song itself, you do realise that for TV exposure there will be an edit containing G.U.Y. only?

 

TV airplay really isn't as important as Youtube these days and it being so long is going to put so many off watching it more than once.

Think it might bag a week or two in the lower region of the top 40 but I guess it depends on what promo she does. Still really think she blew a huge chance to get a #1 with the disastrous way DWUW was handled.

TV airplay really isn't as important as Youtube these days and it being so long is going to put so many off watching it more than once.

 

But if it does its job of persusading people to buy it, that won't matter.

But if it does its job of persusading people to buy it, that won't matter.

 

I don't understand your point? All videos jobs are to persuade people to buy the song (or album) but if it is so long that it puts people off repeat views it isn't doing it's job well.

 

I watched the video, thought some of the visuals were very good, but I'm not going to bother sitting through it again. I would think a lot of people will feel the same. The less you hear a song the less chance you have for it to 'grow' on you.

Top 40. It's not a bad song but the general public are a bit bored of Gaga atm.