March 26, 201510 yr That note is just so weird. Just realised how low it actually is???? :unsure: What happened? :lol: Robotollie had a glitch or something :lol:
March 27, 201510 yr if they were even still going..... I think Vanessa leaving would have the least impact in terms of image/publicity, plus I think towards the end Rochelle was the better singer. Her voice got stronger & stronger and Vanessa's got weaker.
March 27, 201510 yr Rochelle - shes got nothing to lose really from going and shes kinda' left anyway being under different management etc :kink: Oh wait misread the title: I don't want any of them to go! Edited March 27, 201510 yr by Sean.
March 31, 201510 yr Of course it just isn't The Saturdays without all five members, but if one was going to leave I guess Frankie would have the least impact. She has the least vocals and has missed the most performances. I've felt like she hasn't been totally "there" over the past few years anyway and the Disco Love campaign was still stellar without her. I think we sometimes overemphasize the importance of having a high profile. At this stage in their careers, they already have name recognition and a huge back catalog so Frankie leaving isn't going to make as big of a difference as it may have 4/5 years ago. Vanessa, on the other hand, still carries the group vocally. For me, her voice on a bad day is still better than Rochelle's on a good day. Mollie is the most liked member from what I can see and is the most devoted. Una has the most unique voice and their acoustic performances wouldn't work without her.
March 31, 201510 yr Of course it just isn't The Saturdays without all five members, but if one was going to leave I guess Frankie would have the least impact. She has the least vocals and has missed the most performances. I've felt like she hasn't been totally "there" over the past few years anyway and the Disco Love campaign was still stellar without her. I think we sometimes overemphasize the importance of having a high profile. At this stage in their careers, they already have name recognition and a huge back catalog so Frankie leaving isn't going to make as big of a difference as it may have 4/5 years ago. Vanessa, on the other hand, still carries the group vocally. For me, her voice on a bad day is still better than Rochelle's on a good day. Mollie is the most liked member from what I can see and is the most devoted. Una has the most unique voice and their acoustic performances wouldn't work without her. In Frankie's defense she was experiencing a lot of bad press and struggling through severe depression so obviously was going to a bit and having a baby. Not justifying the baby stuff entirely as Rochelle and Una have missed stuff as well, but I think most of this forum is in agreement that Una's pregnancies haven't been that damaging to their careers - afterall, shes the only one who performed pregnant on two tours!
March 31, 201510 yr No I completely agree Sean. I think all of Frankie's time off has been justified, I just couldn't help but notice how well the group continued to function without her.
March 31, 201510 yr No I completely agree Sean. I think all of Frankie's time off has been justified, I just couldn't help but notice how well the group continued to function without her. I think it's because her lines are easily covered! Apart from in Notorious/Not Giving Up, only she can deliver those perfectly :kink:
March 31, 201510 yr I love you Hurricane and I love Mollie, but no. She sounds like Minnie Mouse covering those lines.
March 31, 201510 yr DO YOU WANNA BE AXED THO?????? Your opinion is invalid, anyway. I mean, you like 'Missing You', like gurl bye.
March 31, 201510 yr Mollie almost sounds as bad singing Frankie's solo on Notorious as she sounds singing her own solo on Disco Love. Almost.
March 31, 201510 yr Mollie almost sounds as bad singing Frankie's solo on Notorious as she sounds singing her own solo on Disco Love. Almost. ???????????????????????? WHO IZ DIS???? CAN I GET ZACH BACK PLS????? DID LEE HACK YOUR ACCOUNT????
March 31, 201510 yr Mollie being too out of breath to sing both her and Frankie's lines during What About Us though *.*
March 31, 201510 yr Mollie almost sounds as bad singing Frankie's solo on Notorious. I agree. This I don't agree: Vanessa's voice on a bad day is still better than Rochelle's on a good day. :)
March 31, 201510 yr For me, her voice on a bad day is still better than Rochelle's on a good day. Um no. Vanessa 'Voice Crack' White says :hi:
March 31, 201510 yr OK, that is Vanessa's worst performance ever and they all sounded terrible there. There are maybe five performances where Rochelle sounded better than Vanessa and that is clearly one of them. But Rochelle's voice would do a lot more than crack if she attempted some of the vocals Vanessa has to sing on a regular basis.
Create an account or sign in to comment