I'm not entirely sure what to say of this, given that I didn't like Closer at all initially. And this sounds like a less catchy version of Closer, maybe it'll grow massively like that has, it's hard to say.

 

An initial problem is that regardless of what I thought of Closer at the time, I thought Halsey sounded strong but the guy didn't. Phoebe's voice is nowhere near as distinctive and punchy as Halsey's, so it loses a bit of the "singalong" factor that Closer has. I kinda can't imagine this being sung word for word in a club as Closer has.

 

Probably a hit but not to Closer levels, I wouldn't have thought.

 

EDIT: Already starting to love this by second listen lmao.

Well they're in such a purple patch atm that they could put literally anything out & people would lap it up. This is just so nondescript, I know I disliked Closer at first but grew to like it but can't see that happening at all with this one.

I'm really confused how but I am loving this despite hating Closer!! I love the drop and its just completely hit me!

I'm really confused how but I am loving this despite hating Closer!! I love the drop and its just completely hit me!

Ultra, the same here :lol:

I cannot listen to Closer, but I really like All We Know, although they sound so similar... weird :lol:

 

On another note, now that there's a video, will they push this as a proper single?

I'd like this to be chosen but for some reason Setting Fires has been added to rotations on music channels instead this week :(