October 24, 200618 yr they aren't bands! Bands play instruments, GA and All Saints are groups! well if ya gonna be pedantic, why didnt yoy come up with a group that does :lol:
October 26, 200618 yr Despite GA's goodness they are at the end of the day just a product of xeonomania. They would be lost without them as producers. 3 albums on and they have not progressed in the least. They're just a bit better dressed now then they were when they first started. And they still look like a couple of girls "tarted" up for a night out. All Saints on the other hand, are just better. lol
October 26, 200618 yr All Saints Tough call though - they've both produced some great songs. I've based it on their new single as a tiebreaker - I love 'Rock Steady' and I like enough 'Something Kinda Ooh'. I have two Girls Aloud albums and only like the singles on it. Whereas I only have the All Saints 'Best Of' so I don't know whether they're a stronger albums act. Edited October 26, 200618 yr by Tim
October 27, 200618 yr Im getting a bit tired of the topics and people saying Girls Aloud can never be as good as All Saints. All Girls Aloud songs have done well & their last album was very fantastic for a pop album. I know of musicians and real hardcore Indie people who like Chemistry. All Saints just appeal to the people who like Urban pop...which is fine but it's hardly doing something different which is what the product of Girls Aloud does... So Im going Girls Aloud...all judged on the music as All Saints music doesnt do much for me...I had their 1st album and gave it away.
October 27, 200618 yr Girls Aloud for me. i do like All Saints but theres no competition for me , lol Edited October 27, 200618 yr by Lukuzz
October 27, 200618 yr give me the girls who invented Girl Power anyday - Bananarama. then again it might have been the runaways. well the band who had joan jett, lita fors and some girl called michael from the bangles. fyi: the drummer died a few days ago.
Create an account or sign in to comment