11 number twos, 12 if you include the two versions of 'Crazy For You' - the most #2s for an artist in the UK.

 

Which should have made the top and which is a right number two?

 

Holiday

Borderline

Crazy For You

Live to Tell

Hanky Panky

Justify My Love

Ray of Light

Beautiful Stranger

American Life

Hollywood

Me Against the Music

BEST: Borderline - very very easily

WORST: Hanky Panky - very very easily

BEST: Borderline - very very easily

WORST: Hanky Panky - very very easily

 

I agree! Borderline is my fave and Hanky Panky my least fave.

 

 

Crazy For You is the best !! My fav song ever !! It reached number two twice !!

 

Least fav is hanky panky.

 

I’d love to know what songs kept these songs from reaching number 1 !!

 

I clicked on the wrong one lol! I chose Ray of light as my favourite but actually selected Beautiful stranger oops (that's my second fave anyway).

 

Hanky Panky is the worse, really really dreadful!

I clicked on the wrong one lol! I chose Ray of light as my favourite but actually selected Beautiful stranger oops (that's my second fave anyway).

 

Hanky Panky is the worse, really really dreadful!

No, you were right the first time. ;) (I'll change it for you)

Haven’t you changed that the wrong way?

Oh yeah, I read the comment wrong! I just saw "I chose Ray of Light".

 

Rechanged! :D

Awww at all the hate for Hanky Panky, it’s quite fun if you want a less than serious listen! Me Against the Music is the worst for me, there is no circumstance where I’d like to hear that again.

 

My faves are Ray of Light, Borderline, Crazy for You, Live to Tell, Justify My Love and Beautiful Stranger in that order.

I’d love to know what songs kept these songs from reaching number 1 !!

Crazy For You (1985) - Sister Sledge's Frankie

Holiday - Into the Groove!

Borderline - Billy Ocean's When the Going Gets Tough...

Live to Tell - Falco's Rock Me Amadeus

Hanky Panky - Partners in Kryme's Turtle Power

Justify My Love - Vanilla Ice's Ice Ice Baby

Craxy for You (1992) - The Simpsons' Do the Bartman / The Clash's Should I Stay...

Ray of Light - All Saints' Under the Bridge

Beautiful Stranger - S Club 7's Bring It All Back

American Life - Room 5's Make Luv

Hollywood - Beyonce's Crazy in Love

Me Against the Music - Busted's Crashed the Wedding

 

I know American Life lost out by 2k and Beautiful Stranger sold well over 100k in its first week.

 

Researching a bit more, Crazy for You missed out by an estimated 1k the first time around and lost out by an estimated 2k when against The Clash! Very unlucky. Live to Tell lost out by an estimated 4k too.

Crazy For You (1985) - Sister Sledge's Frankie

Holiday - Into the Groove!

Borderline - Billy Ocean's When the Going Gets Tough...

Live to Tell - Falco's Rock Me Amadeus

Hanky Panky - Partners in Kryme's Turtle Power

Justify My Love - Vanilla Ice's Ice Ice Baby

Craxy for You (1992) - The Simpsons' Do the Bartman / The Clash's Should I Stay...

Ray of Light - All Saints' Under the Bridge

Beautiful Stranger - S Club 7's Bring It All Back

American Life - Room 5's Make Luv

Hollywood - Beyonce's Crazy in Love

Me Against the Music - Busted's Crashed the Wedding

 

I know American Life lost out by 2k and Beautiful Stranger sold well over 100k in its first week.

 

Researching a bit more, Crazy for You missed out by an estimated 1k the first time around and lost out by an estimated 2k when against The Clash! Very unlucky. Live to Tell lost out by an estimated 4k too.

 

Thanks what terrible songs bar crazy in love . A lot of novelty records here !!!

Hanky Panky (Best)

Me Against The Music (Worst)

BEST: Beautiful Stranger (something tells me I'm holding on to this for nostalgia and this will probably change one day)

WORST: Hanky Panky (it's her absolute worst single, just so vile)

Best : Borderline

Worst : Ray Of Light

Hollywood!!!

Let’s do the same for her number 3 hits , she has 9 of them .

FAVOURITE

Ray of Light

Crazy for You

Live to Tell

Beautiful Stranger

Me Against the Music

Hollywood

American Life

Holiday

Borderline

Justify My Love

Hanky Panky

LEAST FAVOURITE

 

I actually quite like 'Hanky Panky', it's a bit of a laugh, although still has to be placed last for me.

 

That Top 3 though! :heart:

Hanky spanky best

Me against the music worst

Oh yeah, I read the comment wrong! I just saw "I chose Ray of Light".

 

Rechanged! :D

 

 

:lol: I just read your comment like 4 times trying to work out whether I chose Ray of light or not :lol:

 

ROL is her most criminal non-#1 :wub:

Awww at all the hate for Hanky Panky, it’s quite fun if you want a less than serious listen! Me Against the Music is the worst for me, there is no circumstance where I’d like to hear that again.

 

My faves are Ray of Light, Borderline, Crazy for You, Live to Tell, Justify My Love and Beautiful Stranger in that order.

 

 

Funnily I really like MATM as a Britney song but not as a Madonna song :lol: