Oasis - Stop The Clocks

http://img137.imageshack.us/img137/4127/oasisbc3.jpg

 

01: Rock n Roll Star

02: Some Might Say

03: Talk Tonight

04: Lyla

05: The Importance of Being Idle

06: Wonderwall

07: Slide Away

08: Cigarettes & Alcohol

09: The Masterplan

 

01: Live Forever

02: Acquiesce

03: Supersonic

04: Half The World Away

05: Go Let It Out

06: Songbird

07: Morning Glory

08: Champagne Supernova

09: Don't Look Back In Anger

 

U2 - U218 Singles

http://img176.imageshack.us/img176/8048/u2kg8.jpg

 

01: Beautiful Day

02: I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For

03: Pride (In The Name Of Love)

04: With Or Without You

05: Vertigo

06: New Year's Day

07: Mysterious Ways

08: Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of

09: Where The Streets Have No Name

10: Sweetest Thing

11: Sunday Bloody Sunday

12: One

13: Desire

14: Walk On

15: Elevation

16: Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own

17: The Saints Are Coming

18: Window In The Skies

19: I Will Follow (bonus track)

 

Which of the 2 would you prefer to own

Don't include the fact that U2 had a Greatest Hits little over 5(?) years ago, just which is the better collection....

 

I'm genuinely hard-pressed as to which one I'd perfer to own. I thought Oasis at first but might now get U2 instead :(

Tigerboy is going to kill you :lol: He set up a thread similar to this a few weeks back :P

 

 

I simply cannot choose. They are my two favourite bands of all time. I Mod both forums :lol:

 

However, Oasis were at their amazing best with their first two albums and then went downhill, but their last album was definatly a return to form with the exception to the god awful 'Lyla' :puke2:

 

U2 however, during the mid 90's went all electro which I was'nt overly impressed with however both 'pop & Zoorophra are both vastly superior to quite a few Oasis albums IMO.

 

U2 are far more consistant imo, they have been together for 30 years and their last two albums were both amazing so overall I think their collection is better ^_^

 

u218 is packed with 5 star tracks, Stop the clocks have a good few but also alot of songs that should be replaced such as 'Go Let it out, Lyla :puke2: Neither albums contain all of their best songs by far. U2's should contain more of their 80's material and should be a 2 disc collection. Oasis should have FAR more songs on their's including many of the 11 singles left off <_<

 

 

Oasis must die, so I choose U2.

Neither, I hate them both. Not my type of music at all, I find the vocals of both Liam and Bono strictly unbareable.

I settled on U2

 

However will probably get Oasis for Christmas anyways :lol:

Neither, I hate them both. Not my type of music at all, I find the vocals of both Liam and Bono strictly unbareable.

 

Each to their own I suppose but although I can understand people finding Liam's voice unbearable, I think Bono is one of the very few people in Rock music who can actually really sing ^_^

tbh i dont want either :lol:

But personally I cant stand Oasis but Bono is an AMAZING artist :wub: So I'd rather buy U2

Looking at Artist's Collection albums out on November 20th the answer is:

 

http://www.thebeatles.com/hub/love/ecard/

 

Why do you need to "Stop The Clocks" or pretend that you are "18" when all you need is LOVE.

 

http://images.play.com/covers/1611443m.jpg

 

The Beatles : LOVE

 

Track List (All Digitally Remastered & enhanced in 5:1 surround sound)

 

Because

Get Back

Glass Onion

Eleanor Rigby/Julia

I Am The Walrus

I Want To Hold Your Hand

Drive My Car/The Word/What You're Doing

Gnik Nus

Something/Blue Jay Way

Being For The Benefit Of Mr Kite!/I Want You (She's So Heavy)/Helter Skelter

Help!

Blackbird/Yesterday

Strawberry Fields Forever

Within You Without You/Tomorrow Never Knows

Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds

Octopus's Garden

Lady Madonna

Here Comes The Sun/The Inner Light

Come Together/Dear Prudence/Cry Baby Cry

Revolution

Back In The USSR

While My Guitar Gently Weeps

A Day In The Life

Hey Jude

Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)

All You Need Is Love

 

:wub: :wub: :wub:

Neither U2 or Oasis have ever been my favourite bands but I think both these greatest hits are very strong. :D

 

I dunno whether i'll buy them both though. :unsure: Probably not, but if I had to buy one it would probably be Oasis. ^_^

I will be getting Oasis, as I already own 2 U2 greatest hits, and havent been fond of their songs since....

Won't get Oasis as I have all the albums.Have the two U2 Best Ofs but will still buy U2 18 as it's a strong tracklist.

I will be getting Oasis, as I already own 2 U2 greatest hits, and havent been fond of their songs since....

 

Really :o Not even the amazing 'Sometimes you can't make it on you own' :wub:

Really :o Not even the amazing 'Sometimes you can't make it on you own' :wub:

Well, its Ok, but if im honest, U2 havent janked my chain for years. The last song of theirs I really liked was Sweetest Thing back in '98.

Well, its Ok, but if im honest, U2 havent janked my chain for years. The last song of theirs I really liked was Sweetest Thing back in '98.

 

:o Just goes to show how everyone is different :lol:

 

The think the Sweetest Thing is one of the worst songs they have ever made. It's far to pop imo.

 

Their last 2 albums have been absolutelly amazing IMO. 2 of the best albums this decade. Extremly diverce as well. Packed with brilliant songs and very few fillers apart from one on 'Atomic Bomb' (One step close) and on ATYCLB (Grace and New York) but other than that I adore both albums and think U2 are still despite being together 30 years, the best band on the planet. And on a live stage they simply cannot be touched :wub:

well im a fan of both bands but when i read the sun today and noel was saying he is positive they will beat u2 to number 1 in the uk i was like hmm i really hope u2 put you in your place so i hope u2 get to number 1.

 

the one thing against u2 is that all the song bar 2 are on the previous greatest hits they have released so that might damage sales where this is oasis first greatest hits and will go in there favour

well im a fan of both bands but when i read the sun today and noel was saying he is positive they will beat u2 to number 1 in the uk i was like hmm i really hope u2 put you in your place so i hope u2 get to number 1.

 

the one thing against u2 is that all the song bar 2 are on the previous greatest hits they have released so that might damage sales where this is oasis first greatest hits and will go in there favour

 

Oasis, will probebly beat U2 in the UK as Noel said in todays Sun with U2 beating them in Ireland and pretty much ever other country on planet earth :lol:

 

Both U2's and Oasis's last studio albums both sold about the same as far as I know in the UK. Neither passed a million altough HTDAAB may have done but I am not sure :unsure: However worlwide their is simply no comparision. Sales over HTDAAB are heading towards 10 million while DBTT is only about 2.5 million ^_^

ya in terms of world sales im sure u2 will hammer oasis,its very hard to know who will get the uk number1 when they both clash,maybe neither will!

ya in terms of world sales im sure u2 will hammer oasis,its very hard to know who will get the uk number1 when they both clash,maybe neither will!

 

You may be right actually :o I mean the Beatles new album is out on the 20th as well :o

maybe im wrong i dontthink the beatles album will do that well,it will sell ok but nothing major,maybe snow patrol,scissor sisters or killers could be in with a shout of number 1 aagin as they all have new singles out which will boost album sales

maybe im wrong i dontthink the beatles album will do that well,it will sell ok but nothing major,maybe snow patrol,scissor sisters or killers could be in with a shout of number 1 aagin as they all have new singles out which will boost album sales

 

Nah, The Beatles will sell hugely. They're last 'Best of' from 2001 sold an unbeliable amount. It will definatly be between U2/Oasis and the Beatles if you ask me ^_^