I used to love Girls Aloud but the plasticness and fame going to their heads has set in, unlike All Saints which are more down to earth i remember when Natalie went on Im A Celeb.. that was hilarious.

Appleton were better than All Saints, Nat and Nice should do it again. :D

 

And if writing your own songs brings out an album as bad as Studio 1, I think I'd rather listen to covers from GA...

All saints old songs were really good, whereas all of GA stuff has been dire

"Never Ever" is better than any song Girls Aloud have ever done. <_<

 

I don't like All Saints, but that I would agree with... If my life actually depended on listening to either a track by AS or GA, I'd pick All Saints without hesitation, because in general terms, they have more musical talent and actually involve themselves in the creative process to a far greater degree....

Well tbh I've never liked All Saints untill this year, because I liked Rockstady. Although, I listened to there album it's one of the worst I've heard this year

"Never Ever" is better than any song Girls Aloud have ever done. <_<

 

Amen :)

 

oh nasty! will they ever be friends?

Just because Sugababes are friends with Girls Aloud doesn't mean that Sugababes are against All Saints.

 

All Saints won't be bothered either way as they made the majority of the cash they needed to when they were at their career peak and it was a lot more than Girls Aloud have made.

It's the music that counts. All Saints BORE me. I bought their first album as a nieve kid and it was c**p. Never Ever was a good song...and a few more have been good but I'd never again buy an album from them.

 

Girls Aloud music is well produced, innovative and has lastability - up yours S Club/Steps/Atomic Kitten.

 

They've made the history books so they'll never be forgotten, yeah they'e a bit arrogant here but if you were in a band who had hits and records to your name, maybe you'd say something when you get called 'silly little girls' and attacked for having ginger hair.

 

All Saints should have had a go at their music like Cheryl did to them.

I can't wait to see if All Saints respond.

Edited December 29, 200618 yr by Davidyay

Just because Sugababes are friends with Girls Aloud doesn't mean that Sugababes are against All Saints.

 

Nope but the babes said that they agree with GA coz they think that "Rock steady" does sound like a GA song! It was few weeks ago in a TV interview, I think it was on MTV or summit.

 

 

I like new All Saints album, but they've got big ego now coz they had success in the past and coz they are mums... they think they could treat GA like lil girls, that was stupid so now they don't have to complain when GA hit back.

I mean that when you have an album that missed the top40 it can't make any good to be against the two bitish favourite girl bands.

Only Lily Allen can do it :wub: lol

Okay first off, Studio 1 didn't miss the Top40. ;)

 

How are they "against" the Sugababes as well? Do they have a feud going on with them as well? Because I highly doubt that Sugababes would hate All Saints just because Girls Aloud do. -_-

Nope but the babes said that they agree with GA coz they think that "Rock steady" does sound like a GA song! It was few weeks ago in a TV interview, I think it was on MTV or summit.

I like new All Saints album, but they've got big ego now coz they had success in the past and coz they are mums... they think they could treat GA like lil girls, that was stupid so now they don't have to complain when GA hit back.

To be honest I think all this "parody" shows is that All Saints were right, Girls Aloud ARE just stupid little girls. How childish honestly. Now this is coming from someone who is a new All Saints fan (I never liked them before Rock Steady) and a lifelong Girls Aloud fan (I have every single, every album and every DVD) so I obviously love them both, but it's just plain childish and it's put me off them in all honesty.

Oh come on, if someone here had written that parody everyone would be laughing at it.

 

They do come across as arogant but so were All Saints when they slagged off Jump and Nicola when Cheryl simply had a go at the song.

Well Cheryl should have kept her mouth shut then really. All Saints were doing electronic pop long before they emerged in the music scene

and it's put me off them in all honesty.

 

If a few stupid quotes, elaborated by the press can effect the music that they produce, then thats pretty sad.

Girls Aloud are truly awful. As if they have the right to slag off anyone else. They just "sing" tacky $h!t which is given to them on a plate.

"Never Ever" is better than any song Girls Aloud have ever done. <_<

 

I agree. Girls Aloud may have had more hits, but they've yet to make a song as good as that.

 

I wouldn't say I was a "fan" of either act, but Girls Aloud may end up eating their words. They'll be has-beens one day, maybe very soon.

Girls Aloud are truly awful. As if they have the right to slag off anyone else. They just "sing" tacky $h!t which is given to them on a plate.

 

At the beginning, Cheryl only said that "Rock steady" sounds like a GA song, nothing more! That's not what I call slaging off someone!! That's not nasty, just her point of view about a song, she didn't say it's $h!t or summirt, she only said it sounds like a GA song, that's all.

Then the AllSaints responded by insulting the girls and childish stuff like that. So calm down about the girls please...

That is very childish... I prefer Girls Aloud but that is just pointless!