The only way Leona's live version is better is if you are comparing it to Whitney awful performance from the WMA's in 2004. I'm sure if you compare a live performance of when Whitney was at her best in the early 90's there would be no comparision.

i agree with you in the fact that whitneys old perofrmances are better, the grammy one definetly. but comparing these videos here, leona is better.

 

can we compare some of the other videos now lol. get off the leona vs. whitney. :P

i agree with you in the fact that whitneys old perofrmances are better, the grammy one definetly. but comparing these videos here, leona is better.

 

can we compare some of the other videos now lol. get off the leona vs. whitney. :P

lol ok :P

1-0 to Leona though :smoke:

 

Leona sung Without You very good, BUT Mariah has to suprerior voice!

I seriously doubt Leona, will sell half as many records as Whitney.

 

Maybe Leona's voice is better now.

 

But Leona could never beat Whitney when her voice was at peak -_-

she has a job ahead of her to sell near as much as whitney

 

1-0 to Leona though :smoke:

 

 

My arse :lol:

 

She's better than Mariah though. :lol: :P

My arse :lol:

 

She's better than Mariah though. :lol: :P

Oh for fucks sake! :rofl: :rofl:

Oh for fucks sake! :rofl: :rofl:

 

What? :huh:

 

Saying she's better than Whitney is FAR FAR more ridiculous than saying she's better than Mariah if you ask me :P She is not as good as either of them were at their peak and never will be. -_-

Anyway, the only performance that is better than the original is 'A Moment like this' imo. -_-

What? :huh:

 

Saying she's better than Whitney is FAR FAR more ridiculous than saying she's better than Mariah if you ask me :P She is not as good as either of them were at their peak and never will be. -_-

Mariah has a better voice then whitney :P

Leona has a better voice then whitney :P

But Leona does NOT have a better voice then Mariah! :P

Mariah has a better voice then whitney :P

Leona has a better voice then whitney :P

But Leona does NOT have a better voice then Mariah! :P

 

Bless you Josh :(

 

:lol: :lol: :lol: :smoke:

 

 

 

 

Bless you Josh :(

 

:lol: :lol: :lol: :smoke:

Yes I have been blessed :smoke: :lol:

fukin hell, why did i start this forum lol. were not talking about whos gonna sell more records lol. i just want you to rate the videos/pefrmances and give your opinion on which is better. :)

fukin hell, why did i start this forum lol. were not talking about whos gonna sell more records lol. i just want you to rate the videos/pefrmances and give your opinion on which is better. :)

 

Ok, we'll stop comparing her and Mariah and Whitney :P

 

As I said I think 'A Moment like this' is the only song she did a better version to the original. ^_^

The best one on "Without you"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jRINKdQ_qI :wub: :cheer: :wub: :cheer: :wub:

You have to watch this performance, this is the French Leona/Kelly Clarkson

 

 

The best one on "I will always love you"...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nhkca7Wsepk :wub:

Edited January 1, 200718 yr by Poprocks87

Ok, we'll stop comparing her and Mariah and Whitney :P

 

As I said I think 'A Moment like this' is the only song she did a better version to the original. ^_^

hooray. judging without mariah and whitney lol. can evryone let me know what they think about the celine- all by myself. i love leonas big note at the end. i think it is one of the best notes ever in pop history lol. i love it. and her big note in sorry seems to be the hardest word... :D all her big notes and high ntoes are fantastic. her vocal range is great and she can go as high as mariah live. NOT touched up lol. :lol:

The Without You performance of Mariah's is a breath taking performance, and as much as I love Leona, she could only dream of equaling those notes.

I much prefer leona's version to whitneys.. whitney really is overrated

KELLY ****ING CLARKSON WINS. :angry:

I prefer the originals, I know I'll be hated by saying this, but Leona doesn't have any attitude at all.

She sings like you played a CD, and at the end, people will get bored of that, cause she won't be able to deliver something fresh and new.

Yes thats right, WAS :P

I dont want to hear Dolly Partons lol, isn't she some country singer? -_-

 

 

She's the "some country singer" who actually wrote the bloody song and actully manages an interpretation that doesn't assault the eardrums with it's volume of decibels.