Posted February 10, 200718 yr Im liking Beyonce a lot more than Christina at the mo just seems shes putting in more of a effort than Christina is. ANOM was alot better than "Deja Vu" but come on Irreplaceable and Listen beat Hurt & Candyman hands down! Think Christina needs to start making more of a effort before she starts losing fans to Beyonce... Also Beyonce got a hit film as well, Bday is stcking around the charts while B2Bs is slipping! What does everyone think?? Edited February 10, 200718 yr by AndyB
February 10, 200718 yr Hmm the problem I have with Beyonce is that she is very clever about what songs she releases. I found both Dangerously In Love and BDay to have about 5 good songs and about a gazillion fillers, whereas there is not (in my honest opinion) one bad song on either Stripped or Back To Basics. Can't see many people wanting to trade in Xtina for Beyonce to be fair. Oh and by the way I walked out of the cinema before the end of Dreamgirls today - I would by no means call it a hit film.
February 10, 200718 yr I'm undecided on what is better - ANOM or Deja Vu. But I do think Irreplaceable is better than hurt, but LOL at Listen being better than Candyman. I like them equally and when I go see Beyonce in June I will be able to make my mind up on who is the better performer :P
February 10, 200718 yr I love both, but Prefer Christina overall Listen is my fave song of Beyonces and i think its better than the 3 singles christina has released/releasing. but i do adore anom,candyman and hurt irreplaceable and deja vu are good but nowhere near as good as candyman,anom and hurt. Edited February 10, 200718 yr by Lukuzz
February 10, 200718 yr Tbh I've only just stopped like Aint No Other Man :P Tbh I really hate it :lol: Candyman and Hurt however = :wub: Beyonce is :wub: Although I can neither put one above the other, but Christina is working harder then Beyonce, BDay was made in a matter of weeks, Back To Basics took Christina a while :P
February 11, 200718 yr i like them both equally! why do we have to compare them though? everythings not about whos better etc. in the end of the day there just doing what they love doing.
February 11, 200718 yr Christina is much more talented than that animal-killing whore. That was uncalled for. Beyonce is talented and some people think she has a better voice than Christina, it really is a matter of opinion. I think she has leart her lesson by wearing fur, I haven't seen her do it in ages which is a good thing. And also, I don't know where the 'whore' thing came from, cus she's certainly not that.
February 11, 200718 yr I can't believe you think that "Irreplaceable" (horrible song, when you hear it twice) beats "Hurt". I mean, we are talking about the song right, not the video? Anyways, Christina gives much more emotion than Beyonce does (or has in ANY of her songs). As for "Listen", that may be one of Beyonce's good songs, but it definetely doesn't beat either Candyman or Hurt.
February 11, 200718 yr beyonce releases a single and two weeks later another, and then another...to keep the sales high.Christina is only in her second single
February 11, 200718 yr Author I think "Hurt" is a good ballad its just a bit much if you get me, whereas I've still not tired of "Irreplaceable". I dont really know Candyman V Listen is hard at the moment Id probably say Listen but once the vid for Candyman is out ill probs go with Candyman. Its probs because I havent really heard much from Xtina since "Hurt" and Beyonce is EVERYWHERE at the moment e.g. Dreamgirls,Bday,Shakira Duet,Jay Z Duet. Its going to backfire on Beyonce I think people will get sick of her.
February 11, 200718 yr what a load of c**p to post in a christina forum... :lol: christina rocks, she pisses all over beyonce imo!! so what if 'irreplaceable' is bigger... its the only decent song on the album tbh!! the production on 'back to basics' is 100 times better than 'b-days'... beyonce didnt even have input on her biggest single off it, big credits to ne*yo eh?? bring on 'candyman'!! :wub:
February 11, 200718 yr Author ^ I feel a bit a tw@t for making this thread. I forgot how much time Xtina spent on B2Bs and she did actually co-write all the songs! still im a Beyonce fan as I've always been but Xtina is sill my fave :wub:
Create an account or sign in to comment